Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History YMMV / Persona4

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
The Sirens are not CanonImmigrants to the show. EqG is not an adaptation, it was a spin-off, and a subset of fans have chosen to consider it non-canon for no real reason. You can't have a Canon Immigrant when they were always canon.
to:
The Sirens are not CanonImmigrant to the show. Equestria Girls is not an adaptation, it was a spin-off, and a subset of fans have chosen to consider it non-canon for no real reason but that is not the case now more than ever. You can\'t have a Canon Immigrant when they were always canon.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
That the show contradicts their comic origin is not a concern, because the comics are LooseCanon and always have been, and the show has contradicted them in numerous other places. This isn't a comics character getting into the main series, it's a spin-off character getting into the main series.
to:
That the show contradicts their comic origin is not a concern, because the comics are LooseCanon and always have been, and the show has contradicted them in numerous other places. This isn\'t a comics character getting into the main series, it\'s a spin-off character getting into the main series.
Top