Suggestion: Nightmare Fuel.Si Ivagunner

The previous image of NightmareFuel.Si Ivagunner was pulled by Moments Page Image Cleanup thread, so I've decided to look for new images for the page. I originally suggested 1.4 on the Image Suggestion Thread, but I realized some time later that it would be a good idea to look for more options within the rips themselves instead of only suggesting an image from the channel's Lore Videos and there was an image from a video (1.2) uploaded a few days later that could also be a good image. Here's all of the suggestions:

• The Playboy Carti Standing Goat (Screenshot taken from Mimiga Town (Beta Mix)--Cave Story)

• Uncanny Boyfried from Super Mario Bros but its sus.

• A "personalized" Super Mario 64 Hallway from PlayStation Startup (Super Disc Version) - Console/BIOS Music

• Ju'Reshoggoth from Episode 10 of The Christmas Comeback Crisis.

I'm personally voting for 1.2 or 1.4 btw

Edited by jlvs200s on Apr 22nd 2024 at 6:23:20 PM

1.4

1.1 used to scare me like you wouldn't believe, so I personally prefer it. Although it being low quality probably makes 1.4 a better choice. 1.2 is mild in comparison, and 1.3, while eerie, feels like something that the Moments Image Cleanup Thread would go for the throat of.

1.4

1.2 is personally the creepiest to me, though that may just be that I find "uncanny" horror most disturbing than "scary" horror.

To 1.4

1.1

Bump

I personally prefer 1.1 the most, as said before. But, if the quality is too low, then we can try ripping it from "Goat Trap - Goat Simulator".

I also imagine a theoretical caption referencing the comment comment on any video featuring the goat about how predators have front-facing eyes.

bump

This should've been clocked like a week ago, doing so now.

Crowner ?

Vote bump; three in green.

Votes Bump;two in the green.

to 1.4

I've always been curious, are nightmare fuel images supposed to hit a good medium? Because I remember a bunch of nasty ones got replaced with tamer ones for several pages, for example Kirby and Ace Attorney Dual Destinies. I personally think that's pretty fair so for that reason I vote 1.3, seems to perfectly hit the balance of creepy but won't jump scare you with a scary face. 1.3

Edited by Shad0wSmoke on May 6th 2024 at 6:48:58 AM

Ideally, we should pick scary images. There are far more "jump scare" worthy images on other NF pages that were thread approved than the suggestions here (well, besides 1.1, as that one used to jump scare me back when it was still a new meme on the channel). If I remember correctly, the old Duel Destinies image was a spoiler, and the old Kirby image with 0's eye wasn't considered scary anymore due to the blood "not looking like blood" and the Dark Matter image "just being a blob with an eye"

I also find the 0 moment scarier, but the thread didn't agree. The Forgotten Land image might also have been a spoiler case as well. But this is getting rather off-topic.

Edited by KingofNightmares on May 7th 2024 at 4:47:29 AM

Oh, I guess spoilers explain it too. I see the nightmare fuel page for films is the Exorcist face now when I thought it had been changed too. I think Zero's eye scream moment is much creepier/scarier than just the simple appearance of Necrodeus. Was Forgotten Land's ever changed? I seem to recall it used to be the Forgo blob before it changed to be the possessed version but I might be misremembering.

Suggested caption.

Suggested caption

Edited by animuacid on May 7th 2024 at 7:23:33 PM

Caption in the OP works.