Needs Help: Multiple Demographic Appeal

Mix of issues here. One, quality is again poor. It's also not very succinct. I'm also not quite clear what the point is. It looks more like the result pisses off all potential audiences rather than appeals to multiple target groups. I'm also baffled that this is not YMMV yet, but that's for another thread.

It's a bit of a hard concept to picture. Perhaps the Titanic re-release◊? "Disaster and Romance. Two great tastes that taste great together."

Previous thread. I'd originally voted in favor of it, but now I'm reconsidering due to it using 3/4 of a comic strip.

edited 12th Dec '16 5:49:44 PM by Willbyr

I like the Titanic poster.

for Titanic.

Eh, not really feeling the Titanic suggestion.

OP is not at all illustrative of the trope. The caption suggestion makes it sound like it's trying to show something similar to Genre Mashup.

Current is probably bad enough to pull.

If those mashed up genres cater to different demographics, it would still qualify.

Bump. Other thoughts/suggestions?

Still leaning toward pulling the current if we can't find a replacement.

Pull the current if nothing else.

The Titanic one is just a couple of faces and a caption.

Alternatively, here's a live reaction video to Canterlot Wedding.

edited 12th Jan '17 12:36:51 PM by neoYTPism

It's really hard to make out anyone in that.

I could go for a narrower crop, then.

I'm thinking. Would a Troperiffic work be a good example of this trope? Like, it has so many elements of different nature in it, it appeals to a lot of demographics.

Pull the current, at least. If anything, it illustrates the opposite of the trope.

Maybe something from the Harry Potter fandom? 1◊, 2◊, 3◊, 4◊

The first one is the only one that seems relevant, for showing an old guy and some young people. We shouldn't be implying it's a surprise that people of different races can appreciate the same stories.

I still prefer my own for showing a spectrum of ages, rather than just two different generations. I also like the fact that it shows a crowd reaction to a TV show episode, rather than people posing for the camera. To be fair, the fact that it's about MLP might be a biasing factor in my opinion of it, though I'm a Harry Potter fan too.

With all that said, though, either image would be good for this.

edited 12th Jan '17 8:43:56 PM by neoYTPism

MLP is an example of Periphery Demographic rather than this.

They were well aware of the existence of bronies by the time they made Canterlot Wedding.

edited 12th Jan '17 8:43:38 PM by neoYTPism

Harry Potter is a bit of a weird example in that it's not so much marketed towards adults but more that the books got more mature as its initial audience grew up.

Perhaps Disney movies being watched by three generations?

That looks like a really bad Photo Shop job.

The clock's up and the only decision that has any consensus is to pull the current, so it's gone and the page is tagged. Locking up.