The Teen Wolf image has already been chosen. I do think 15 is a good one and should be on image links.
Wandering...
I disagree with 26, as the teeth are stark white and the canines are pronounced. I did a quick, basic search for other images, but couldn't find any better.
To make it even more clear about the teeth, though, maybe a caption like—and this sounds a bit stupid to me but I might as well propose one since it's being asked—"With canines like that, one wonders just what he is."
There is no Planet B
@26: It's usually good to have an opposing opinion. 
However, now you'd probably need to suggest another image to revert the decision, and it would have to be something really good.
Current is best. Heavy focus on eyes with obvious supernatural element. It's not outrageous and it's not too subtle. I'm not sure how anyone could miss those teeth!
There is no Planet B
I also think the image from Teen Wolf is by far the best.
No, the other one.
![[up]](https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/smiles/arrow_up.png "[up]"){kind=icon}
Third is cute, but not better than the chosen image.
Hi
I, for one, am getting very tired of these "hey, what about these" suggestions after the thread has already come to a decision on a pic. If there's not a glaring issue with the consensus decision, save them for Image Links.
Speaking of, I'll whip up one for this page. Supernatural Gold Eyes
EDIT: That's done...some of the descriptions probably need tweaking.
edited 21st May '13 6:37:14 AM by Willbyr
Good. Please end this thread before the madness continues... Unless anyone wants a caption, which I don't think we need.
edited 21st May '13 6:49:58 AM by Rethkir
Image Source. Please update whenever an image is changed.
Hi
"Clear Eyes ain't gonna help with this. Try silver iodide." [/lame]
edited 21st May '13 6:55:17 AM by Willbyr
Just throwing a cat amongst the pigeons...
Although it has the advantage that it probably doesn't need any caption.
edited 22nd May '13 6:12:09 AM by Melkior
Absent-minded professor and Neverwinter Nights DM
On caption suggestions...
"Would comparing your eyes to the moon be in bad taste?" 
Hi
Eh, not seing a consensus and it's been a few days...locking up.
I'm not really a big fan of the teen wolf image, as the only other thing that hints at supernatural in the image (the teeth) can be easily missed.