Needs Help: Grimy Water

Someone changed it to this one◊. Here's the previous. Opinions?

edited 14th Dec '12 2:58:16 AM by lu127

The swap is better than the old one.

Methinks the swapped in image is better than the old - the old is just a pool of violet water. Image that was swapped in:

+1 for the swapped one.

So the purple pool, or the soup pool. I think soup is better in this case.

Yeah, no disrespect for Banjo-Kazooie, but I agree that the Portal picture is just better.

I like the Portal one since it has those funny warning signs.

One or two more votes for the Portal pic and we can call this one good.

, Another vote on the portal image.

edited 14th Dec '12 1:40:30 PM by m8e

And there we go. The page is tagged; caption or no?

EDIT: Scratch that suggestion, it's a closed room so that wouldn't work.

edited 14th Dec '12 1:57:24 PM by Willbyr

In dangerous testing environments, the Enrichment Center promises to always provide useful advice. For instance, the floor here will kill you. Try to avoid it.

"What's a little dysentery or cholera between friends?"

It's too bad the water occupies so little visual space in the pic, due to being more distant.

I'm pretty sure that's because the person who took this intentionally included the signs at the bottom as well. If that's a problem, I can get a different screenshot.

Give it a try.

That works for me.

I like the further back one better. The water is smaller, but it's clearer that's water.

I much prefer the version with the signs in the foreground.

Keep the one with the signs.

Signs.

The second shot would be better if it had more contrast or surface reflections. Otherwise, first shot's good enough.

With no consensus on a caption, let's lock up and move on.