Mary Sue Must Die: a call to arms:

Total posts: [164]
1 2 3 4 5 6
151 Matues26th Sep 2012 01:36:37 PM from eye on the horizon , Relationship Status: Having tea with Cthulhu

What is it?
152 Wolf106626th Sep 2012 02:46:02 PM from New Zealand , Relationship Status: In my bunk
Strange Kiwi fella
"What is a Mary Sue?" has become so clouded that the answer might as well be "42".

How's that - I found the question before the Earth got destroyed...
Dangerously Genre Savvy since ages ago...
153 JHM26th Sep 2012 02:50:43 PM from Neither Here Nor There , Relationship Status: Not war
Thunder, Perfect Mind
Everyone, please, just stop.

Particularly, I would like to address the people who want to contest the validity of the initial statement. I'll put it bluntly: You will continue to use this term whether or not anyone else makes a persuasive argument as to why it is not a valuable criticism because you have given it your own definition and it is easier for you to summarise things that way. And you know what? That's fine. Just please, don't use your personal use of the term to justify the cluttering-up of this forum with more "Is My Character A Mary Sue?!" threads. Those threads are pointless for exactly the reasons that you see illustrated here.

Stop beating this horse and let it die already.

This also goes for the other side of this argument. Continuing to engage in this debate only helps propagate further discord, and as much as watching Internet DRAMA unfold warms the cockles of my black and poisonous heart—and believe me, it's fun—I'd rather we saw some actual variation as to what the conflict is focusing upon.
154 KillerClowns26th Sep 2012 03:52:05 PM from the Midwest , Relationship Status: Healthy, deeply-felt respect for this here Shotgun
Try Indivisible! It's awesome.
You call this "Internet DRAMA™"? I do agree this debate has been going in circles, and I'd also love to see some fresh thoughts thrown into the mix. But from what I can tell, it's been very civil, and although I can tell some people feel very strongly about the topic, there's no sign of any genuine anger, personal resentment, or true discord beyond what is expected when civilized people disagree on a matter.
155 nrjxll26th Sep 2012 05:02:54 PM , Relationship Status: Not war
At least speaking personally, that's primarily because this is occurring on the internet.
156 chihuahua026th Sep 2012 06:06:25 PM from Standoff, USA , Relationship Status: I LOVE THIS DOCTOR!
Writer's Welcome Wagon
By the way, I want to write a blog post based on the idea of not using the phrase "Mary Sue", so I can present it to other writers. Is this okay?

157 nrjxll26th Sep 2012 06:10:43 PM , Relationship Status: Not war
If you're asking me, go right ahead. I'd do one myself if I had (or wanted) a blog.
158 JHM26th Sep 2012 06:10:49 PM from Neither Here Nor There , Relationship Status: Not war
Thunder, Perfect Mind
[up][up][up][up] True, but the law of entropy still applies here. Plus, this argument is exceedingly circular and repetitive, and a lack of progress in this arena can go nowhere good if left unchecked.

[up][up] If you aren't taking other people's statements and attributing them as your own, then you can really do what you want... unless you mean quoting nrjxll specifically, in which case you're probably doing the right thing in asking. Redundant...

edited 26th Sep '12 6:11:34 PM by JHM

159 nrjxll26th Sep 2012 06:12:14 PM , Relationship Status: Not war
[up]What I meant is that I would probably not be coming across as very civilized if this was occurring in real life. The nature of the internet (in multiple senses) has imposed some degree of moderation.
160 JHM26th Sep 2012 06:22:10 PM from Neither Here Nor There , Relationship Status: Not war
Thunder, Perfect Mind
I was actually addressing Killer Clowns there, but yes, that's true.
161 SnowyFoxes26th Sep 2012 08:53:02 PM from inside a snow-covered fox den , Relationship Status: Heisenberg unreliable
Eternal Screaming
I've already been drafting a blog post. It's about halfway done.

And it might be helpful to facilitate a discussion on this in writing club, especially because I know there's at least one person who regularly uses litmus tests.

I would totally give nrjxll a hug for articulating my suspicions about this.

edited 26th Sep '12 9:25:34 PM by SnowyFoxes

A lycanthrope transforms in front of their friend. "You're a wolf!" the friend exclaims.

"Yes," he replies. "I am a were."
162 chihuahua030th Sep 2012 06:58:56 AM from Standoff, USA , Relationship Status: I LOVE THIS DOCTOR!
Writer's Welcome Wagon
By the way, I'm almost done with the blog post. It's going up Monday if there aren't objections.

Thoughts on what I have so far? Note

edited 30th Sep '12 7:00:29 AM by chihuahua0

After reading various stuff on the subject matter from many sources, I do feel that Mary Sue has become both a meaningless term and a cheap argument. People just label something a Mary Sue and don't bother explaining why, giving no examples and just thinking the term speaks for itself. And that is really, really, not the case.
My name is darthnazgul and TV Tropes has ruined my life.
164 Masterofchaos1st Oct 2012 04:39:06 PM , Relationship Status: In Lesbians with you
Cute spider? Cute Spider
I'll just quote myself from Writer's Block.

I agree that the Mary Sue term should be abolished. As I said before, I never liked it in the first place. It's just a huge, poorly-disguised excuse to not like a character.
The system doesn't know you right now, so no post button for you.
You need to Get Known to get one of those.

Total posts: 164
1 2 3 4 5 6