The Place for Purging Porn and Pedo-Pandering (AKA P5 flag evaluations)

I propose the following rule: Unless we expressly say we want to lock a page, we want it unlocked. Thus, Baldr Sky should be reopened.

All in favor?

Edited by Ramidel on Mar 20th 2024 at 3:45:40 AM

Aye.

for that proposal.

Sure. Rather, I'd like CV threads to normalize raising this question when restoration is likely.

Reopened Baldr Sky

Thanks!

Next up would be Manga.Hen. The recent CV thread called for the restoration of the whole thing and Ramiel argued against any restrictions, but the page is still left with a lock.

Hen is supposed to be merged into Strange Love anyway, though.

No, it's not. Strange Love the OVA only adapts the first dozen or so chapters of the second part of the Hen manga: there's a whole Yaoi Genre first part that it doesn't even address, so we decided not to merge them.

Huh. In that case, yeah, it should unlock.

on the content policy page, shouldn't we move Literotica from the "lock and clean" section? since we all decided on the page being stub cut and all

Yes, it needs to be in the special cases section, with a note indicating it could be recreated in the Platform namespace.

If it is then it needs a Holler or a request at Locked Pages

So, if a NSFW webcomic does not have an SFW "Do you really want to see this content?" page but has a significant amount of Porn with Plot (high emphasis on the plot), are we allowed to remove links?

VisualNovel.Wanko To Kurasou (and its Main/ counterpart, back when work pages were allowed to be in that namespace) was cut a long time ago for "Hentai, possibly pedophilia." The page is not locked, and there's no record of it on Administrivia.The Content Policy. Do I have to make a thread for it in order to get it on the record?

I think that's borrowing trouble unless someone either remakes the page or wants to, since any ruling from that long ago would need a full review.

It might have been one of the work that got culled during the hentai purge before works got properly reviewed. IMO, I feel that in the case of works that were cut long ago for content violations; the OP should make some effort to provide a good reason on why the page should be restored. Yes, I know that not every cut page had a formal review but I still feel the burden should be on the OP to provide an argument on why the page should be restored.

Edited by MacronNotes on Mar 25th 2024 at 2:13:08 PM

By the description it seems to be some sort of Spiritual Successor to Nekopara. But looking at VNDB, the entire cast looking like kids, makes me skeptical it's worth deep analysis unless someone factually claims otherwise.

Edited by Amonimus on Mar 25th 2024 at 9:23:54 PM

I took a look at the CG gallery and it is definitely a lolicon VN. I feel a thread to confirm the cut and have it officially listed and locked would go by pretty quick with that gallery contents.

Edited by Adannor on Mar 25th 2024 at 10:03:57 PM

The description of Sad Satan strongly suggests that its content violates the policy in a big way. However, I'm a bit unsure that this isn't an Urban Legend placed in the namespace for Kayfabe purposes, much like Sonic.exe was (though that one was repeatedly Defictionalized).

Edited by Prfnoff on Mar 25th 2024 at 4:02:57 AM

^ This thread made a verdict to keep the page and exclude versions of the game that contained child pornography.

Edited by MacronNotes on Mar 25th 2024 at 7:19:35 AM

@Macron Notes: Agreed. I'm just figuring that we don't need to review the work until it comes up, so to speak.

Of course, the unofficial reviewing seems to be along the lines of "keep killed with fire, salt the ashes."

Is the CP stuff just a myth for the sake of creepypasta? The page seemed a bit unclear.

EDIT: Checking the sub and its rules I guess there are versions with illegal material.

Edited by mightymewtron on Mar 26th 2024 at 9:04:45 AM