YMMV / Warrior Cats: The New Prophecy

  • Breather Episode: The second half of the arc, which is just about the settlement on the lake, and with the exception of the badger attack and final confrontation of Hawkfrost, this part is generally far lighter than Midnight, Moonrise, or Dawn
  • It Was His Sled: Hawkfrost is Tigerstar's son, Mothwing is an atheist, Tigerstar comes back, and the forest is destroyed.
  • Seasonal Rot: The second half of the series, which is arguably considered nowhere near as well written as the first half. Word of God (Vicky) has even stated Sunset was one of the worst quality ones.