YMMV / The Legends of Treasure Island

  • Iron Woobie: Jane
  • Nightmare Fuel: The opening theme music, plain and simple. It opens with a hollow, despairing groan, and culminates in the sound of people screaming and wailing like damned souls. Fitting, given the existence of an Evil Sorceror and Satan himself as the Big Bads. Listen for yourself.
    • Though Season Two botches it by replacing it with an upbeat vocal theme due to change of music team.
    • Pew himself is considered this. The series took a very minor character and made him very threatening!
  • Vocal Dissonance: Dawn French doesn't even attempt to make Jim sound masculine. This was fixed in season 2, replacing French with John Hasler.