YMMV: Tales of the Questor

  • Alternate Character Interpretation: Is Rosad Athair Beither the Monster Maker a Well-Intentioned Extremist? After spending a good part of his lifetime aiding in the fight against monsters, he began to believe that all monsters had a single source, the Patronum Monstrum. He did terrible, unspeakable thing trying to prove that every evil unnatural monster in the world could be duplicated through the use of biomancy. His findings were so startling that when he was finally captured and put on trial, he was kept alive for a full year to collect and sort his notes. And there's been no proof that he was wrong. If he is right, and ultimately could have pointed to a single, destroyable source for the evil creatures of the world, then his work could go right into Utopia Justifies the Means, since until that source is stopped, there will always be evil monsters continuously ravaging the land, and it will be impossible for most of the world to advance out of The Dung Ages, since anyone who tries will inevitably draw dragons, giants, and other horrors down on his head. Yes, his methods were horrifying, but there's a reason why we have a trope called The Extremist Was Right...
  • Mary Sue: Fortunately very few if any of the comic's main characters fall into this trap and Quentyn himself has enough faults to balance off his awesome traits. However the entire Rac Con Daimh race in its entirety technically counts. The recent filler pages of a human scholar's travels in Antillas highlights the issues; they're a race of Persecuted Intellectuals who have built a Hidden Elf Civilization in order to practice their talents without interference from their much more numerous and belligerent neighbors. As a result, they are incredibly scientifically advanced in comparison to the other races, have a near monopoly on Lux/Magical expertise among the mortal races, are unbelievably prosperous despite not only running out of the metals necessary to maintain a technological civilization, but starting to lose entire villages to environmental damage(but a genius ends up growing a plant that can GROW metal out of Bauxite poisoned soil which very might solve both issues).
    • They do, however, have one serious problem; political corruption - perhaps even by an Ancient Conspiracy. Large cities are starting to become overrun with street gangs due to overpopulation, which is also contributing to the rise of a hawkish political faction that wishes to steal land from their neighbors. Quentyn's ruined their plans twice, perhaps even three times; first, he exposed a False Flag Operation, then foiled a plot to eliminate an entire village's worth of political opponents by revoking its stateship. He may also have destroyed one of their bioweapons programs; the "Junior Questors" end up investigating ties between the Expansionist party and "Beitherite Brotherhood."
      • However, it appears that the Beitherite Brotherhood and the Expansionist Party blew pretty much all their resources in their attempt to neutralize the Open Traders. Quentyn's self-exile has reduced the once-mighty Ancient Conspiracy to a Brotherhood of Funny Hats - "a bunch of old farts with signet rings and secret handshakes who met once a month to talk about Rosad Beither and tell each other what daring and bold revolutionary thinkers they all were.[1]"