YMMV / Fullmetal Alchemist: The Sacred Star of Milos

  • Complete Monster: Security Chief Atlas killed the movie's female protagonist's parents, then stole her brother Ashley's skin and used it as a disguise in order to trick the rebel group, Bats, into making a Transmutation circle for him in order to gain power to rival other nations. He then killed the Bats' leader, Miranda, for her sacrificial blood, murdered his co-conspirator to gain his blood as well, and sacrificed dozens of Amestrian soldiers by "feeding them" to Milos's machinery to create a Philosopher's Stone for himself.
  • Crazy Awesome: Ashleigh/Atlas is an evil and depraved variation. The guy manipulates an entire rebel group while wearing another man's face, breaks no sweat going head to head with the Elric brothers and Wolf chimeras, shrugs off various horrific injuries during the climax, and ultimately goes out cursing at the real Ashleigh before his head blows up.
  • Crowning Moment of Awesome: Colonel Herschel stepping in to reveal his true identity-and send Atlas straight to hell.
  • Crowning Music of Awesome/Earworm: The movie's ending theme, Good Luck My Way by L'arc-en-Ciel
  • Jerkass Woobie: The real Ashleigh Crichton.
  • Magnificent Bastard: Atlas, he had everyone fooled until the last few minutes of the film.
  • Moral Event Horizon: If Atlas using Julia and lying to her in order to create a Philosophers Stone isn't bad enough, then there's him murdering her parents and stealing her brothers face when they were both still children, whom he was supposed to be protecting.
  • The Untwist: It is pretty obvious that Atlas is the fake Ashleigh and Herschel is the real Ashleigh, Its noticeable when Atlas has a scar that looks like he is stealing a face and Herschel having no facial skin under his mask.
  • What Do You Mean, It's Not Political?: People from Milos trying to reach Table City are shot down, and the whole issue of deporting illegal immigrants and the fact that most people from Milos (at least the ones whom name we know) are named with Mexican-sounding names, like Carlos, Santos, Julia, Miranda, Raúl, Anita, Pedro and Gonzalez. Not to mention the flashback scenes of the people of Table City being conquered by one people, then another, both times being conscripted into the defender's army to try and stop them.
  • Suspiciously Similar Substitute: The officer in charge of Table City looks remarkably similar to Yoki.