Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / Good Luck Girl!
aka: Binbo Gami Ga

Go To

  • Fan-Preferred Couple: The Pixiv fanartists are very much in favor of Ichiko and Momiji over the former's canonical love interest Keita.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: The 2011 extra chapter (later featured in volume 10) features the girls doing competitive boob sumo. This was a good two years before Keijo!!!!!!!! began serialization, and while the former was more gag and fanservice oriented, the latter took itself far more seriously.
  • Informed Wrongness: Ichiko is the one considered at fault by the story for not wanting anything to do with her parents after they ditched her for almost her entire life with some weak excuses from her dad's band about how they pressured him to keep touring with them. For fifteen years? And he didn't care enough to change his plans to be there for her despite it supposedly being his greatest dream? Small wonder she wants nothing to do with him. However, as their neglect was actually the result of Ichiko's extreme good fortune rubbing off on them, it's not like they could do anything to remedy the problem in the first place; the abundance of fortune in one area of their lives left them unable to spread it to their family life, just as Ichiko's good looks, riches and body had her set for life but horribly lonely.
  • Jerkass Woobie: Ichiko. A Rich Bitch who's been neglected by her parents, hated by her female classmates because she's more athletic, talented and beautiful than them, manipulated by a classmate that pretended to be friends with her in order to break her, having her Parental Substitute butler and only friend suffer a heart attack due to her person absorbing all of the good energy...just goes to show that money or being really lucky really can't solve all problems.
    • She does get better anyway. Her former butler is living peacefully (with a new wife) as he writes her letters often. Later, she has become more sociable as she befriends a delinquent tomboy who vows to never betray her and probably a Cosplay Otaku Girl goddess.
    • Akane also counts in that her hate of Ichiko seems to stem only from jealousy of Ichiko's popularity. After Ranmaru saves her and her friends from a collapsing building Akane seems to actually regret going too far, if only cause Ranmaru got hurt. She and her friends call an ambulance and lead them back. Later its heavily implied that not only is Akane in love with Ranmaru but that Ranmaru may have been a Closet Key for her causing her more than a bit of angst. She still hates Ichiko, but for a different reason now.
    • And later, Ikari's revealed to have suffered a lot before. It turns out he was born the exact opposite of Ichiko, with a massive amount of bad luck, that made him a pariah even though the bad things only happened to him. The one person who was willing to be with him, like him and even eventually love him dies saving him. Made worse because she saves him by turning him into an immortal god effectively making him have to live forever without the person he loves and with the pain of her loss.
  • Les Yay: The Manga is so full of les-yay that Tsuwabuki is the only reason it's not Yuri.
    • Lampshaded in chapter 32
      Ranmaru: How dare you to make my precious Ichiko cry...!!!
      Nadeshiko: Don't say things that'll be taken the wrong way! It's bad enough that we're being mistaken as a yuri manga by some readers.
    • Momiji and Ichiko have a complicated relationship that zig-zags between With Friends Like These... and Pseudo-Romantic Friendship, at the very least it's obvious that no matter how much they deny it, both care about each other. In later chapters Momiji refers to herself as Ichiko's true partner, a term Ichiko accepts and embraces.
    • When Momiji and Ichiko are teleported to Antarctica by mistake (it's a long story) Momiji suggests huddling together for warmth which is logical under the circumstance. She then suggests that they huddle together naked which is...less so. Of course, she might have been doing that just to mess with Ichiko's head.
    • Chapter 51 ends in a way that make it seems that Ichiko and Momiji are an Official Couple.
    • After Their Fusion Dance, Momiji gets a lot of enjoyment out of feeling their combined body's bust and they sound like a arguing couple when they switch control.
    • Ichiko gets a nosebleed when Momiji's boobs grow bigger. Granted, it ended up being Momiji's dream, but what does that say about her...?
    • Ichiko is Kanna's reincarnation, while Momiji was born from half of Ikari's soul. Kanna and Ikari were lovers.
    • A special after the final chapter has the two kiss. Completely non-canon, but seems to be the author's way of making shippers happy.
    • Ichiko and Ranmaru within chapter 25. Also taken up to eleven in the omake. And then there's the final scene of Episode 8 where Ichiko finally accepts Ranmaru as her friend. While not really Les Yay, it almost looks like it. Ichiko even kinda confesses to Ranmaru at one point. To be fair, she's essentially drunk at the time. She also for some reason has a bunch of sexy pictures of Ranmaru.
    • Kuroyuri seems to be in love with Yamabuki.
    • Akane is outright in love with Ranmaru. There is even a special chapter dedicated to Akane's crush.
    • Suzuhikohime is a canon lesbian, and has a special fondness for Huguruma Youbi, who isn't but doesn't really resist her.
    • Chisha seems to have a penchant for falling for anyone who happens to be punctual or responsible.
      Chisha: 4 minutes, 17 seconds... that's exceptional! Do you mind if I fall for you!?
      Ayama: That would trouble me...
      Chisha: That's too bad!
  • Superlative Dubbing: The dub is really really hilarious. Among a great cast, Colleen Clinkenbeard and Brina Palencia are especially fantastic as Momiji and Ichiko. Bonus points for Colleen’s role as Momiji being an excellent demonstration of her vocal range.
  • Tear Jerker: Oh so much. See Woobie above. Comedy manga should not be able to make you cry.
  • Unintentionally Unsympathetic: While Ichiko's tragic backstory is supposed to explain and excuse some of her reprehensible behavior, it really doesn't excuse some of the particularly callous things she does. A prime example is when she initially refuses to save Rindou from a collapsing building, despite being fully capable of doing so quite easily. Her reasoning? She believed that if she saved her, then Rindou would continue to try to befriend her, which she still had hang ups over from her childhood betrayal. Not wanting to let people get close is one thing, but she was willing to let another person die, someone who had just saved her from almost getting raped no less, just because she didn't want to deal with the "inner turmoil" of someone being friendly to her. It's only after considerable coaxing from Momiji that she finally steps in to help, and it's never addressed how near sociopathic her initial behavior was. She's never confronted about her selfishness or blatant disregard for human life, and by the end of the episode we're supposed to forget all about this and be happy that she's grown more trusting of others.
  • Values Dissonance: Ichiko's parents essentially abandoned her from the ages of one through sixteen and constantly broke promises to her and failed to show up for anything in her life. Tired of their negligence, she gave up expecting anything from them. When her father shows up again and offers to have her move with him to America, somehow Ichiko is in the wrong for not wanting anything to do with him at this point. It's a pretty standard setup in many manga: Terrible parents get a huge free pass on their behavior, presumably thanks to assumptions of filial piety among the audience.
  • Wangst: Ichiko's endless whining about her life can cross the line into wangsty. Her spoiled nature is a plot point, though.
  • Woolseyism: Ichiko is oftentimes referred to as "Chichiko" (a nod to her impressive bust size). The anime’s English dub altered the nickname to "Titchiko", while scanlations often defaulted to "Tittyko". Admit it, this was the perfect way the joke could’ve been translated.

Alternative Title(s): Binbo Gami Ga

Top