main index




Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
This is a "Wild Mass Guess" entry, where we pull out all the sanity stops on theorizing. The regular entry on this topic is elsewhere. Please see this programme note.
Spring Awakening
Melchior is undiagnosed bipolar, as is his father.
Eventually he'll be driven to taking his father out of his life in the most complete way the law allows, by emigrating to Canada. Undiagnosed bipolar syndrome'll continue to run among his descendants, however, until his great-great grandson Craig finally gets a diagnosis and on medication.
  • On a related note, at some point Dylan Everett will play Moritz...
    • As will Hayden Byerly, meaning that having at one point had the numbers fudged so he could get *into* school...

Ilse will grow up to be Satine.
At some point in the 8 years between the events of the musical (1891) and the movie (1899), she ends up in Montmartre, probably following one of her artist lovers. After said lover abandons her, she ends up selling herself on the street until Zidler finds her. Though he and Marie initially take her in temporarily out of pity, they discover her latent theatrical talent and decide to make her a star. Since French was commonly taught to girls throughout Europe at the time, it wouldn't take her long to become fluent given total immersion. Upon beginning her life at the Moulin Rouge, she takes the name Satine and does her best to leave the past behind.
  • That would make both works even more of a Tear Jerker, but the only problem is that Ilse's actresses tend to have Wild Hair that's brown/dark, while Satine is an impeccably groomed redhead. Red hair is notoriously hard to maintain since you have to keep touching it up every month at the least, and if the Moulin Rouge can barely help Satine's consumption, how could they afford a fake hair color?

It WAS rape...
But Wendla didn't know what Melchior was doing, so she couldn't exactly protest to it. Essentially, Melchior committed statutory rape even though he's still under aged, because Wendila is still as naive as a child.
  • Wendla does protest it in some versions, but this still stands — Melchior knew more about sex and reproduction than she ever did, there was a huge imbalance of power there just from that even if they were technically the same age. If she literally doesn't know what sex is or what can result from it, she doesn't know enough to effectively consent, even if she desired him and he desired her too.

The Masked Figure is the Doctor!
And we're all off for a magical adventure in the TARDIS!

The Sound of MusicWMG/TheaterWilliam Shakespeare

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from
Privacy Policy