Please don't list this on a work's page as a trope. Examples can go on the work's YMMV tab.
Tear Jerker: Batman: Arkham Asylum
The sequence in Batman: Arkham Asylum where under the influence of the Scarecrow's fear toxin, you relive the death of Bruce Wayne's parents. Including a point where you turn into Bruce Wayne as a child and stumble past the corpses of your parents. Eight-year-old Bruce overhears a police officer that is a dick: ("Oh, he'll be fine. Kid like that, with all that money? Yeah, I'm sure he'll be just fine... His butler's coming to pick him up... Hear that? He's got a butler.") Comissioner Gordon's the only one who takes pity on Bruce, which makes it all the more heartwarming.
"Why did he do it, officer? Why?"
In a minor way, seeing Harley sobbing in her cell after Batman has subdued her kind of reminds you that for all her slavish devotion to the Joker, she's ultimately just a broken woman and another of Joker's victims.
Until you look at her in Detective Mode and realize she's faking it (and looking up at you every so often to see if you're buying it)... She's even laid a trap for you, and she WILL gloat.
That's still kinda sad. Puddin' said stop the Bat, so he'll be thrilled when he finds out she trapped him there, and gladly let her back on the party list, right?
Your first encounter with enemies with guns. An officer says "Please, I've got a wife and kids..." "You don't have to do this!" After killing the officer, the goon says "You're right, I don't have to. I just want to!"
Seeing the dozens upon dozens of corpses of innocent guards and doctors throughout the game. Easily a hundred good men and women dead, and this is just one time that the Joker will break out. Knowing that Batman will never bring himself to end his archnemesis means that this will happen again, and again, and again...
Fridge Horror and/or Fridge Brilliance is invoked once you recall this conversation from the intro sequence where you escort Joker through the asylum.
Security Officer: So, you're back. You killed three of my crew when you busted outta here.
Joker: Only three? I'll be sure to try harder next time. What say we aim for a hundred?
Both this and Nightmare Fuel. Seeing Bruce's parents after hearing them.
The cracks in Batman's voice only make this all the more depressing.
Same as above, both this and horror. While saving Dr. Young from Zsasz, she's crying with her whole heart out, even with smeared make up. After the bomb blows out on her face, her body, left on the floor, with no one attending or taking it... just left there, all burned out and charred and bloodied. It'll be normal if she just disappears, like in any other game, but in this one, just the unconscious disappear, and because they left after waking up. But the dead stay there, even if they're cops or doctors or whatever other citizen.
The first Scarecrow sequence has Batman entering the lower levels of medical seeing several people freak out, including one of the feral patients that Joker will release later on. This patient is screaming a plea for help before dying from fright. Arkham City reveals that Strange experimented on these inmates to develop the mind control techniques he used on Mayor Sharp and his Tyger guards. That patient you see? He became sane enough for one last coherent thought, but only of sheer terror.
Most of the Joker interviews are disturbing, but the third one is just sad. After the Joker plays the Multiple Choice Past card, Dr. Young tells him to focus on his real past. His response is one of the few times there's no manipulation or mockery in his voice: "What if... what if I'm too scared to remember? It hurts too much." Even the Joker was a person once.
So much happens in the Warden's office that you may miss this, but there's a plaque on the wall near his safe that has a dedication on it. "May this secret be as an oasis in a desert of insanity. —Daddy." It's not made clear who put this there, the Warden or Amadaeus, but it serves a sobering reminder that, for all their flaws, they've suffered through just as much loss as Batman has.