main index




Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
Kickstarter Message
TV Tropes Needs Your Help
Big things are happening on TV Tropes! New admins, new designs, fewer ads, mobile versions, beta testing opportunities, thematic discovery engine, fun trope tools and toys, and much more - Learn how to help here and discuss here.
View Kickstarter Project
Quotes: Fanon Discontinuity
Of all sad words of tongue and pen, the saddest are these: "It might have been."
John Greenleaf Whittier

More sad are those we daily see: "It is, but hadn't ought to be."
Bret Harte

Quotes from works:

Gwen Stacy isn't dead, she's only sleeping,
And Elektra isn't evil insane.
And those bastards in the Pentagon can't really kill Sue Dibny,
No more than they could kill off Lois Lane"
Four-Color Love Story by the Metasciences

— Graffiti on an alley wall, Wreck-It Ralph

Wolverine: What about Onslaught?
Beast: We just pretend that never happened... for the Professor's sake.

Keroro: Now, do you have any questions?
Tamama: I don't know... this sounds a lot like that Wet-traman operation from the other day...
(Keroro gets an weird look on his face and pauses whilst an image of Wet-traman appears in the background)
Keroro: Okay!! Men... let's go recruit some beasts!!...
Tamama: I knew it... he's going to pretend it didn't happen...
Keroro Gunsou, Encounter 67 — The Charge of The Animal Brigade

Cashier: Okay, that's the Rocky giftset. That's going to be $49.99.
Sports Guy: Uh... we have a question.
Cashier: Sure.
Sports Guy: I don't want to pay for Rocky V. I like to pretend that Rocky V never happened.

Miss Cackle: Now come along Miss Harbroom, I've declared this an afternoon out, and you know what that means.
Miss Hardbroom: A holiday?
Miss Cackle: More than that. Tomorrow, we will forget that we were here together. An afternoon that never happened!
The Worst Witch, Season 1, Episode 11 — Let Them Eat Cake

Quotes on works:

Yahtzee: Bioshock Infinite is a retread, but it's the good kind of retread that uses a formula that works to explore new ideas, and it's a worthy sequel to the original!
Fan: Don't you mean second sequel, Yahtzee?
Yahtzee: [in an unusually raspy voice] Get out.

"'Dimensions in Time'... we don't like to talk about that."

"That War of the Daleks is a mind-wrenchingly awful book at least mostly goes without saying... Whatís surprising and relatively transformative, though, is that it was rejected almost completely. Essentially nobody took it seriously. Sure, lots of people rejected previous bits of Doctor Who in the Wilderness Years, but this was basically the first time that a book had the unanimous response of 'thanks but no thanks.' It wasnít some active campaign or a conscious, authoritative decision or anything like that. It was just a moment where the breaking point of Doctor Who fandom became clear. This was a bridge too far. Official license and BBC logo on the book or not, this was clearly not canon."

"[Hillary] Swank had a brief run on Beverly Hills 90210 and starred in The Next Karate Kid, a film that we're pretty sure doesn't actually exist. (Except that there's evidence.)"

"At least we can live with the comfort that, someday, our sun will swell into a red giant and suck up the earth and burn it into a crisp. I mean, humanity will be gone, and every possible accomplishment of humanity will be burned into an ash in a millisecond but, y'know, at least the Star Wars prequels will be gone."

"You will believe a man can fly after watching the first movie. You will enjoy Kryptonian villainy in the second movie. You will shrug at everything in the third movie except the toothsome Annette O'Toole as Lana Lang. They didn't make a fourth one. No, they didn't. No, that was a dream. (I like Batman better anyway.)"
Truth & Justice bibliography entry, by Chad Underkoffler.

"They told us that Returns just skipped over Superman III and IV, but I prefer to think of it as the movie that wouldíve happened if Superman never got over being a douchebag in this one."
Chris Sims, David Uzumeri, and Matt Wilson on Superman III

Sage: How was the damage?
Mark the Engineer: I don't know what you're talking about. It never happened.
Sage: Mark, if this didn't happen, then what the hell am I holding? (gestures to video of the movie)
Mark: Well it's certainly not the Sonic the Hedgehog movie, because it didn't happen.
Sage: Mark, I don't know what you're—
Mark: IT DIDN'T HAPPEN! Listen, lunchbox, I don't expect you to understand it, so let me give it to you like this: Sonic Heroes happened. Sonic the Hedgehog (2006) happened. (Mark goes on to list off dozens of Sonic games, including the less popular ones, and stating how they all "happened".) THAT—
Sage: (Gesturing to the movie) This?
Sage: So Sonic fans handled this... through denial.
Mark: YES! Well—err—no. Well... It was either living a lie or booze.

Which brings us to the Karate Kid trilogy. Sure, there was allegedly a fourth installment ("The Next Karate Kid," featuring Hillary Swank as Mr. Miyagi's new student), but as far as I'm concerned, that movie never happened. You hear me? Just like "Rocky V," "Another Forty Eight Hours," "Caddyshack II," "Another Midnight Run," "Fletch 2," "Made," "Slap Shot II: Breaking the Ice," the final season of "90210" and everything else, "The Next Karate Kid" never happened.

This film is such a misstep all around that you can pick it up and remove it from the franchise without consequence. Moving from 4 to 6 without 5 still flows naturally. In fact, it arguably works better to ignore it altogether, since 6 carries on the themes of the previous trilogy, and it removes a number of things that contradict established Trek lore, and/or common sense.

"Also Hermione and Ginny were both 25 years old and NOT married to Ron and Harry because the epilogue at the end of the last book is STUPID and NEVER HAPPENED."

JdG: And if you happen to be a young one not having seen [the Indiana Jones movies] yet, then just give up on this video and go watch them right now, I authorize you, it's really one of the best ever trilogy of cinema.
Seb: Quadrilogy.
(JdG fires a hand cannon)
JdG: You'll have to cut my balls with rusty shears drenched in vinegar before I'd admit that the fourth movie is part of the saga!

"Need I remind you that the APC and 1990s versions of Ren are NOT the same character?"
Duckyworth on Ren's portrayal in the Ren and Stimpy Adult Party Cartoon episode, 'Ren Seeks Help' note 

TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from
Privacy Policy