This is based on opinion. Please don't list it on a work's trope example list.
Nightmare Fuel / The Transformers
In "Countdown to Extinction", the evil mad scientist Dr. Arkeville gets electrocuted and is treated for his injuries by being made into a cyborg. The result is this◊ delectable bit of Body Horror.
In "Dark Awakening", Zombie Optimus Prime and his Heroic Sacrifice that involved bits of him being blown apart, he ends up without an eye and an arm before his death. The first act had Optimus Prime terrify young Daniel after the lights go out.
Webworld, the Torkuli in general. They are not above lobotomisation to cure their patients of their insanity and speak in a Creepy Monotone. The fact that Cyclonus (who signed all those forms to have Galvatron committed) couldn't do anything to stop them from them implementing Maximal Intervention (by use of the Ayla, insects that have a symbiotic relationship with the planet) on his leader.
The Energy Vampires (which other than the name, are pretty much a robotic version of the classic Romero zombie) from "Dweller in the Depths" are really creepy. They lose all their coloration, their eyes glow, and they advance slowly but utterly implacably.
The Hate Plague from "Return of Optimus Prime" spreads across the entire planet, so everyone has to see everyone they love go insane and start attacking them, knowing that just a touch means they will lose their minds as well...
It says a lot that even Galvatron is horrified by the plague.
Planet? It spread across the galaxy.
The eponymous disease from "Cosmic Rust". It's leprosy for robots. The Autobots even call up video archive footage of a 'bot collapsing to the ground and crumbling to dust from it.
Rodimus' vision quest into the Matrix in "Five Faces of Darkness, Part 2".
Galvatron, the first one, especially after he goes completely insane. As his earliest appearance demonstrates, he can shrug off enough firepower to level a whole city.
The Demons, Primus' first failed creations, are all kinds of unsettling.
Shockwave's first appearance in the comics, casually shooting every Autobot present. No warning, no announcement, he just shows up almost completely out of the blue and BLAM!
The corrupted Matrix. Especially once it starts taking over Thunderwing, growing into a large demonic shade...
Its reappearance in Regeneration One is so much worse, though.
"Rhythms of Darkness". All of it. Unicron has won. Cybertron is gone. The Matrix is gone. The war is long over, and the Decepticons have won, and taken over America. The rest of the world is planning to nuke the Decepticons, unaware it'll just make them stronger...
Buzzsaw. True, he's a walking version of The Worf Effect, but his method of fighting is disturbing; slicing his enemies to pieces with his beak. And it takes fifty issues for him to go down for good.
What's done to poor Spanner. He's not just part of the Space Bridge, he is the Space Bridge. Bob Budiansky later suggested that what was done to him was so painful it destroyed his mind.