"My Little Community: Friendship is Awesome" is another fic by Emma Iveli of Ponies One Half fame.
The gist is after the gang was expelled, the Greendale 7 are sucked into Equestria, as they're destined to be the Elements of Life.
This is gonna be bad.
It can read here: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/8212138/1/My-Little-Community-Friendship-is-Awesome
And the Director's Cut Here: http://www.fimfiction.net/story/46670/My-Little-Community-Friendship-is-Awesome
This fanfic has examples of:
- Fisher Kingdom: Equestria turns the former Study Group into Ponies.
- Fourth Wall Observer: Deconstructed, Abed and Pinkie talk about how it is a burden when it comes to dealing with other people/ponies.
- Genre Savvy: Abed, of course.
- Gilligan Cut: Invoked in chapter 3.
- Lampshade Hanging: Abed's cutie mark.
- Running Gag: Pierce getting shocked by the Elements that reject him.
- Time Skip: Takes place during the one in season 3 of Community, after getting expelled but before meeting "Doctor" Heidi.
- Squee: Troy when he first meets Derpy.
- What an Idiot: Pierce. He calles Rainbow Dash a "filly fooler," breaks a Pinkie Promise, and gets shocked by the Elements that he doesn't fit.