Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Characters / ASongOfIceAndFireHouseTarth

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* HeroesPreferSwords: Played with. She's certainly very proficient with a sword, but when given a choice of weapons (for example when fighting [[spoiler:her third fiancé]] and at Renly's tourney) she prefers [[DropTheHammer maces]]. However, she adores [[CoolSword Oathkeeper]] and uses it whenever she can do so without attracting unwanted attention, being well aware of this trope InUniverse. It helps that Oathkeeper is a magical AbsurdlySharpBlade that can cut through plate like butter, negating the main disadvantage of longswords as a weapon in the setting.

to:

* HeroesPreferSwords: Played with. She's certainly very proficient with a sword, but when given a choice of weapons (for example when fighting [[spoiler:her third fiancé]] and at Renly's tourney) she prefers [[DropTheHammer [[CarryABigStick maces]]. However, she adores [[CoolSword Oathkeeper]] and uses it whenever she can do so without attracting unwanted attention, being well aware of this trope InUniverse. It helps that Oathkeeper is a magical AbsurdlySharpBlade that can cut through plate like butter, negating the main disadvantage of longswords as a weapon in the setting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Boobs Of Steel is no longer a trope. And aversions are not notable.


* BoobsOfSteel: Deliberately and realistically averted. Brienne is physically the strongest woman in all of Westeros, the only one big, strong and fast enough to confidently take on and beat well-conditioned adult men in a physical fight. Because of her freakishly huge, manly musculature and massive bone structure (which WordOfGod notes is physically impossible for a woman to possess), she has a broad, flat, and visibly "thick muscular chest" and what little breast tissue she actually has are "pointy little buds that would have looked more natural on some ten-year-old".

Added: 501

Changed: 313

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MeaningfulName: Her name, 'Brienne', is a variant of 'Brianne', the female form of 'Brian' - which means 'high' or 'noble'. She is also, bar none, ''the'' most noble and morally upright character in the entire series, coming closer than anyone else to being a true KnightInShiningArmor despite not technically ''being'' a knight.

to:

* MeaningfulName: MeaningfulName:
**
Her name, 'Brienne', is a variant of 'Brianne', the female form of 'Brian' - which means 'high' or 'noble'. She is also, bar none, ''the'' most noble and morally upright character in the entire series, coming closer than anyone else to being a true KnightInShiningArmor despite not technically ''being'' a knight.knight.
** The arms of the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/County_of_Brienne County of Brienne]] in France is a golden lion on a blue field, fitting Brienne's relationship with Jaime Lannister.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RuleOfSymbolism: Brienne is built like a man and fights like one, but she is also a romantic who [[IJustWantToBeLoved just wants to be loved]]. Fittingly, the Tarth arms are quartered [[PinkMeansFeminine rose]] and [[TrueBlueFemininity azure]].


Added DiffLines:

* TrueBlueFemininity: Her gentle and WideEyedIdealist nature is emphasized by her blue armor, InnocentBlueEyes, and the beautiful blue dress Jaime gifts her.


Added DiffLines:

** To Jaime Lannister, as she chooses to die [[ConflictingLoyalty than kill him for Catelyn.]] She only relented because Cat was going to [[WouldHurtAChild kill Pod as well]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no chained sinkholing


* SkilledButNaive: Her first on-screen action is defeating [[MemeticBadass Loras]] [[KnightInShiningArmor Tyrell]], and when she and Jaime duel he mentions that she's incredibly strong and tireless, though not quite as fast as he is. As of the fourth book Brienne is probably the second most capable fighter of all the POV characters (first being [[WorldsStrongestMan Victarion]] [[OneManArmy Greyjoy]]), possibly first if her magical sword is taken into account, but her status as a WideEyedIdealist is not well suited to the WorldHalfEmpty she lives in.

to:

* SkilledButNaive: Her first on-screen action is defeating [[MemeticBadass Loras]] [[KnightInShiningArmor Loras Tyrell]], and when she and Jaime duel he mentions that she's incredibly strong and tireless, though not quite as fast as he is. As of the fourth book Brienne is probably the second most capable fighter of all the POV characters (first being [[WorldsStrongestMan Victarion]] [[OneManArmy Victarion Greyjoy]]), possibly first if her magical sword is taken into account, but her status as a WideEyedIdealist is not well suited to the WorldHalfEmpty she lives in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroicBuild: Deconstructed. In terms of appearance, build and proportions, Brienne is, quite frankly, a massive, muscular and beardless man with a vagina and ''very'' mild gynecomastia. However, because she is (as far as medieval medicine can tell, and thus as far as George Martin care]) female, she is constantly mistaken for a man (Jaime at one point implying that she's a male-to-female transsexual) and inspires confusion, horror and violent disgust in everyone around her once they realize she's a woman.

to:

* HeroicBuild: Deconstructed. In terms of appearance, build and proportions, Brienne is, quite frankly, arguably, a massive, muscular and beardless man with a vagina and ''very'' mild gynecomastia. However, because she is (as far as medieval medicine can tell, and thus as far as George Martin care]) female, and identifies as such, she is constantly mistaken for a man (Jaime at one point implying that she's a male-to-female transsexual) and inspires confusion, horror and violent disgust in everyone around her once they realize she's a woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheTeetotaler: For practical reasons rather than any particular aversion to booze. While traveling, she always drinks cider, milk, or watered wine rather than beer or ale, to keep her wits about her.

to:

* TheTeetotaler: For practical reasons rather than any particular aversion to booze.the hard stuff. While traveling, she always drinks cider, milk, or watered wine rather than beer or ale, to keep her wits about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: She fights Rorge and Biter at the Crossroads Inn to protect some Riverlands children. During the battle, she is grievously wounded and falls unconscious, which [[spoiler:allows her to be taken into the custody of the Brotherhood Without Banners. They assume she's a Lannister collaborator due to her lion-themed sword (made from the melted-down Valyrian steel of the Starks' stolen family sword, to boot), royal order from King Tommen, and repeated muttering of Jaime's name in her sleep, and prepare to hang her]].

to:

* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: She fights Rorge and Biter at the Crossroads Inn to protect some Riverlands children. During the battle, she is grievously wounded and falls unconscious, which [[spoiler:allows her to be taken into the custody of the Brotherhood Without Banners. They assume she's a Lannister collaborator due to her lion-themed sword (made from the melted-down Valyrian steel of the Starks' stolen family sword, to boot), royal order from King Tommen, and repeated muttering of Jaime's name in her sleep, and prepare to hang her]].her as a traitor]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: She fights Rorge and Biter at the Crossroads Inn to protect some Riverlands children. During the battle, she is grievously wounded and falls unconscious, which [[spoiler:allows her to be taken into the custody of the Brotherhood Without Banners. They assume she's a Lannister collaborator due to her lion-themed sword, royal order from King Tommen, and repeated muttering of Jaime's name in her sleep, and prepare to hang her]].

to:

* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: She fights Rorge and Biter at the Crossroads Inn to protect some Riverlands children. During the battle, she is grievously wounded and falls unconscious, which [[spoiler:allows her to be taken into the custody of the Brotherhood Without Banners. They assume she's a Lannister collaborator due to her lion-themed sword (made from the melted-down Valyrian steel of the Starks' stolen family sword, to boot), royal order from King Tommen, and repeated muttering of Jaime's name in her sleep, and prepare to hang her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished: She fights Rorge and Biter at the Crossroads Inn to protect some Riverlands children. During the battle, she is grievously wounded and falls unconscious, which [[spoiler:allows her to be taken into the custody of the Brotherhood Without Banners. They assume she's a Lannister collaborator due to her lion-themed sword, royal order from King Tommen, and repeated muttering of Jaime's name in her sleep, and prepare to hang her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheTeetotaler: While traveling, she always drinks cider or watered wine rather than beer or ale, to keep her wits about her.

to:

* TheTeetotaler: For practical reasons rather than any particular aversion to booze. While traveling, she always drinks cider cider, milk, or watered wine rather than beer or ale, to keep her wits about her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TalkingInYourSleep: While severely wounded, delirious and in the custody of [[spoiler:the Brotherhood Without Banners]], she mentions Jaime's name several times in her sleep. [[spoiler:It works against her, as it convinces them she's working for the Lannisters and has bad intentions in mind.]]
-->'''[[spoiler:Jack-Be-Lucky]]''': If I had a silver stag for every time you said his name, I'd be as rich as your friends the Lannisters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CarryABigStick: The mace is her WeaponOfChoice, as it plays to her great strength and is more effective against an armored opponent. She ends up using a sword however during her quest to find Sansa Stark, which works well enough against the ill-equipped outlaws she goes up against.

to:

* CarryABigStick: The mace is her WeaponOfChoice, favored weapon, as it plays to her great strength and is more effective against an armored opponent. She ends up using a sword however during her quest to find Sansa Stark, which works well enough against the ill-equipped outlaws she goes up against.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** She also counts as one to [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen Cersei]], providing a counterpoint as the other important woman in Jaime's life. Brienne is precisely everything Cersei is not; ugly where Cersei is beautiful, honorable where Cersei is treacherous, a warrior where Cersei is a plotter. Brienne is physically grotesque but noble in spirit, while Cersei is beautiful but monstrous. The more Jaime distances himself in spirit from Cersei, the closer he becomes in spirit to Brienne.

to:

** She also counts as one to [[GodSaveUsFromTheQueen Cersei]], providing a counterpoint as the other important woman in Jaime's life. Brienne is precisely everything Cersei is not; ugly where Cersei is beautiful, honorable where Cersei is treacherous, a warrior where Cersei is a plotter. Brienne is physically grotesque but noble in spirit, while Cersei is beautiful but monstrous. They do, however, both struggle deeply with the roles and restrictions imposed on them by their gender, though again in different ways: Brienne laments that she cannot be the beautiful ProperLady her father wants her to be, while [[WorldsMostBeautifulWoman Cersei]] wishes she could be a warrior like Jaime. The more Jaime distances himself in spirit from Cersei, the closer he becomes in spirit to Brienne.

Added: 216

Changed: 692

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SheCleansUpNicely: Nope. In armor, Brienne looks like a man. In a dress, she looks like a man wearing a dress. The very best she can hope for appearance-wise is "ugly, but not physically repulsive".

to:

* SecretKeeper: She is the ''only'' person Jaime has ever told the real reason for his assassination the Mad King: [[spoiler:to save King's Landing from being burned to ash]]. He's admitted to more people that he fucks his own sister than he has this secret. It's strongly implied Jaime never even shared this knowledge with his father, Cersei, or Tyrion, but during [[BathtubBonding their scene in the Harrenhal baths]], delerious with fever, he tells her. This also makes her possibly the only person in the entire series who ''truly'' understands [[BeneathTheMask what kind of man Jaime really is]].
* SheCleansUpNicely: Nope. [[DefiedTrope Nope.]] In armor, Brienne looks like a man. In a dress, she looks like a man wearing a dress. The very best she can hope for appearance-wise is "ugly, but not physically repulsive".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroicBuild: Deconstructed. In terms of appearance, build and proportions, Brienne is, quite frankly, a massive, muscular and beardless man with a vagina and *very* mild gynecomastia. However, because she is (as far as medieval medicine can tell, and thus [[ShrugOfGod as far as George Martin cares]]) female, she is constantly mistaken for a man (Jaime at one point implying that she's a male-to-female transsexual) and inspires confusion, horror and violent disgust in everyone around her once they realize she's a woman.

to:

* HeroicBuild: Deconstructed. In terms of appearance, build and proportions, Brienne is, quite frankly, a massive, muscular and beardless man with a vagina and *very* ''very'' mild gynecomastia. However, because she is (as far as medieval medicine can tell, and thus [[ShrugOfGod as far as George Martin cares]]) care]) female, she is constantly mistaken for a man (Jaime at one point implying that she's a male-to-female transsexual) and inspires confusion, horror and violent disgust in everyone around her once they realize she's a woman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MadnessMantra: She screams "Laugh! ''Laugh!"'' over and over while [[spoiler:stabbing Shagwell to death]].

Added: 282

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CosmicMotifs: Their sigil incorporates suns and crescent moons, their seat is Evenfall Hall and their lord is called the Evenstar. [[spoiler:And somewhere on the family tree is the legendary Ser Duncan the Tall, whose personal coat of arms was a shooting star above an elm tree.]]



* ThemeNaming: All of the Tarth women's names have "nne" at the end (Arianne, Alysanne, Brienne).

to:

* ThemeNaming: All of the Tarth women's names have "nne" "-nne" at the end (Arianne, Alysanne, Brienne).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Foils need to interact


** She's the [[GoodCounterpart Good]] ''and'' DistaffCounterpart to The Hound. They both have what it takes to be a knight but neither are for different reasons. Brienne is idealistic while Sandor is jaded. Brienne remains loyal to her dead king Renly while Sandor deserted his king Joffrey. Jaime even calls her in one of his POV chapters, "The Hound with teats."
** Brienne also reminds Cat of her daughters. She's as gritty as Arya but idealistic like Sansa.
** She's also the [[GoodCounterpart Good Counterpart]] of Pretty Meris, a member of the Windblown. They both are tall, blond, ugly female warriors with marred noses and cheeks who are given ironic nicknames referring to their "beauty", and they have both been victims of sexual violence. But while Brienne strives to follow the precept of chivalry, Meris serves as the company's torturer; while Brienne is often mocked by her small bust size, underneath Meris shirt only scars are left by the men who cut off her breasts; and while Brienne is said to have astonishing blue eyes, Meris is said to have cold dead eyes.
** Ned Stark as well, for being two characters most well known for their strict HonorBeforeReason ideals. The difference is Brienne's stubborn ideals manage to not kill her unlike Ned's because she isn't in the viper's pit known as King's Landing.
** And to Barristan Selmy, another KnightInShiningArmor who left his Kingsguard after the king he was protecting died and went on the run. Both are continually underestimated by every opponent they run into, with fatal results for many of those opponents, and both had serious issues with Jaime Lannister at their introduction, but eventually come around to his way of thinking; Brienne after travelling with him and hearing him out, Barristan after being placed in a similar situation of ToBeLawfulOrGood and being well aware of the irony. As a result, both of them gain a moral flexibility. However, Barristan is at least a well-respected knight in Westeros, which Brienne is most definitely not but strives to be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllOfTheOtherReindeer: Brienne is rejected and scorned for her ugly appearance, dreams of being a knight and inability to fit into the ideal Westerosi image of a highborn lady.

Top