Follow TV Tropes

Live Blogs Modelland: A Blind Sporking
LadyMomus2012-03-15 19:33:55

Go To


Epilogue: Why Can't the Narrator Just Die Already?

The narrator is back. Also, the font is twice the size as the previous chapter.

Either they screwed up the text formatting for the Kindle version — something I've seen happen in other books — or it's supposed to be huge. My vision's bad, but it's not that bad. I can read stuff at arm's length just fine.


The epilogue begins with text mirroring Tookie's original introduction, talking about her mouth being "four centimeter too wide" and various other details from earlier. Except this time instead of her features being freakish, they're "unusual" and make the reader's gaze linger.

We find out that Tookie is now "kind of okay" with her hair and not okay with her large feet. She no longer looks hunched over (presumably, she grew a spine), and she doesn't look starved.

Her head's still the size of a punch bowl, with a forehead that goes on and on and on, but she holds it high, like only someone whose big brain is filled with eloquent strings of words and brave, gutsy thoughts can do.

Still not buying Tookie being smart or brave. Sorry.

Tookie is standing on top of the M building. She's allowed now that Ci~L is in charge.

She looked down at the expanse of Metopia's four distinct quadrants surrounding the mountain and prayed that Lizzie was still down there, still alive.

If Tookie is feeling guilty, she deserves to. She's friends with Ci~L, who has quite a bit of authority now. It would take less than a minute to say "can you have someone go check and see whether the friend I abandoned twice is alive or dead?" But she doesn't. Heck, Ci~L would probably leap at the chance considering how enthralled she is by Tookie and her other friends.

Tookie then thinks of something that's not ironic that she describes as ironic: the adjective of Metopia is "metopic" which means "of or pertaining to the forehead." Get it? Because Tookie's got a big forehead?

Bestosteros are trying to keep the peace while the Bellas are still having nervous breakdowns and crying because the 7Seven Tournament was cancelled. Once again, we see that the Bestosteros are useful. When are we going to see the Bellas do something useful?

"Then, from a corner of the plaza, Tookie heard a meow! followed by a scream. "Get away from me, you bitey-scratchy things! Creameeeeeee!" a ditzy voice whined.

Myrracle? Tookie thought, perking up. Was her sister still at Modelland, now trapped in Catwalk Corridor? Well, at least she's here, Tookie thought, stifling a giggle. Modelland is where she belongs, after all.

Yep, Bravo was completely right to call Tookie "pure and sweet." Because only a sweetheart would delight in their sister being clawed repeatedly.

Ci~L arrives, and we find out that she had slipped Tookie a note beforehand.

Tookie,

Meet me tonite at the south point of the M.

Princess BellaDonna (Can you flippin' believe it? I can't!)

Fierce & Love, Ci~L

The Grammar Nazi in me wants to cry when I read passages like this in a professionally published book.

Ci~L hasn't bothered to tell the panicking Bellas that she's the new BellaDonna because the Bored wants them to wait for the right time. Presumably that will be when the Bellas stop moping and start rioting.

Tookie asks what Ci~L thinks will happen to the old BellaDonna. Ci~L says that she doesn't have any authority over that, and that it's up to the Bored to decide.

"The Bored makes that decision based on a volume of rules and bylaws taller than you and thicker than me."

So what's the point of having a BellaDonna if it's the Bored that makes all the decisions?

Also, I love the fact that Tookie and Ci~L aren't going to do anything to stop their mothers from being tortured for an accident and trying to lodge a legitimate complaint. It speaks volumes about their characters.

Ci~L tells Tookie that she'll be staying in Modelland and that the Bored wants her there. She then tells Tookie that first year is easy, but second year is much harder. I can't think of a single scene where Tookie prepared for a class, studied, or did any work outside of class. I guess second year is when they start actually assigning homework.

Ci~L tells Tookie that she'll change Modelland into a place that her "sister-friends" could have gone to, but it will be an uphill battle with the Bored.

Tookie tells Ci~L that she wants to try hard to succeed next year and that she loves it at Modelland. Ci~L tells Tookie that she should dream big. Since everything has to be spelled out for the audience, the text notes that this mirrors the advice Wingtip / Ray Faye / Ci~L's father gave Tookie earlier in the book.

Ci~L then asks Tookie if she wants to fly with her. Ci~L then gives Tookie back the SMIZE from ManAttack and Tookie wears it so she feels beautiful. Tookie climbs on Ci~L's back, and Ci~L begins to fly without her magic pouch.

Tookie then thinks back to a letter she wrote a few hours before. From an in-story perspective, it's supposed to be addressed towards other girls like Tookie. However, it reads exactly like you'd expect a letter to the reader would be.

She says that her journey hasn't been easy, and that she feels stronger because of all the struggles she's gone through. (What struggles? Stuff has been handed to her on a silver platter.) She mentions still not having a Lumière, which is misspelled as "Lumièe."

Maybe, like me, your father abandoned you, or perhaps you never even knew him. Maybe your mom's a terror or you have no friends. Maybe you're not the best-loved or best-looking daughter.

Nope. I got that last one covered. It's easy. The trick is to not have any sisters.

Maybe someone hurt you but you're too nervous to tell anyone. Maybe you hurt yourself and want to stop but don't know how. Maybe you give of your body freely, hoping to get love in return.

She continues on for about half a page, saying maybe the reader hates their body, or is bullied, etc. I feel kind of bad about the idea of mocking this section, since it is ATTEMPTING to deal with serious issues.

So I'm just going to say this: simply including a real-life issue in a book does not mean that book handles the issues well. I get what this section is meant to do, but the book's poor execution ruins it.

Tookie then says she hopes the reader finds their own special light.

I want to dedicate my struggle and all my time at Modelland to you.

Please don't.

Everything I've gone through, everything I'll continue to face, is all for you. And I want you to make me a promise: take all your pain, take all the hurt you're feeling and your bad memories and your darkest thoughts, and send it out to the universe ... to me. I'll be your vessel. I'll carry all of the hurt inside me so that you can be free.

Destroy this temple, and in three days, Tookie will raise it again.

She then asks the readers to send their strength and power to her, for when she's feeling scared. I'm not really sure complete strangers sending their strength to her would work. I'm not even sure how you would send memories, pain or strength to a real person, let alone a fictional character.

I believe in you with all my heart—and I hope you believe in me. I just want to get to the place where we believe in ourselves just as strongly.

You know, this letter really shouldn't have been included in the prose. It should have been Tyra speaking directly to the reader in the Afterword.

We go back to Ci~L and Tookie flying, and Ci~L announces that she's about to teleportal but she doesn't know where.

"Sometimes this happens—the universe tells me to teleportal, and even though I don't know where I'm going, I just go with it."

Translation: the dangling plot threads aren't going to be resolved. Have a sequel hook instead!

And I really don't like all these new powers that Ci~L keeps pulling out. First flight and now the mystical ability for the universe to guide her to the next book where she should teleportal?

She asks if Tookie wants to go with her, and Tookie says "hells yeah!"

They fly downward, heading towards the Muse gravestones from earlier. I'm immediately reminded of the women who had limbs torn off apart by monsters not far from there. Tookie, not knowing about this, just is excited by how much fun the flying is. It's a bit jarring.

The Intoxibella and soon-to-be Segunda Bella shot like arrows toward the earth. A black hole opened up as their bodies approached. Just as Tookie and Ci~L entered, the hole magically, seamlessly swallowed them up ... and the two of them disappeared.

The End

This doesn't feel like the ending of the first book in a trilogy. It feels like the end of a TV show where the last episode has the heroes going off into the sunset to keep having adventures. Except with a lot more loose plot threads.

Most importantly: what happened to Hunchy? You do not spend half of a book building up a character who is planning to turn one of the protagonists into an entrée and then just end the book without resolving it. Aside from the sacrifice rumors - which turned out to be total bull - the danger that Hunchy presented was the most compelling conflict in the story.

I wouldn't have minded if the book had ended with him arriving at Modelland, or with a single line hinting that he was going try to butcher Piper in her sleep. But this feels like Tyra just forgot he existed.

In spite of supposedly becoming incredibly close to the Unicas, Tookie doesn't even consider bringing them along for the ride. The only people going on this adventure are Tookie and Ci~L. I'm guessing the two are Tyra's favorite characters based on this ending and the fact that a good chunk of the book was really about Ci~L and not Tookie.

There are so many things in this book that got brought up and then dropped. Maybe Tyra was saving them for the next two books, but it gives this book an unfinished feeling.


Up next time: The Acknowledgements

Comments

71.202.88.54 Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 15th 2012 at 9:35:11 PM
Atrocious. The way Tyra just dropped Hunchy... When I first read this book, I was on my toes, waiting for him to re-appear. This chapter? Nope. This chapter? Nope. Epilogue? Nope. Tyra, stop writing. Or at least get a ghost writer, anything to save Lady Momus (and us) from having to go through this again.
76.69.20.119 Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 15th 2012 at 10:42:37 PM
It's funny how Tookie's letter rants about the "moral" of the story—how beauty isn't everything—*immediately* after Tookie puts on the SMIZE so that she can feel beautiful. Not to mention the fact that the whole universe of the story as well as almost every female character is concerned only with beauty and that characters who don't try to meet the standards of beauty are described as physically repulsive.

Tyra's inability to acknowledge what is portrayed in her own story is on par with Stephenie Meyer. Modelland shares many of the horrible plot and thematic elements of Twilight: a protagonist who thinks little of her and is incredibly disrespectful to everyone around her, yet is loved by everyone and everyone who dislikes her is viewed as evil; the idea that obsessive infatuation makes a person your possession; conflicts that are resolved with little if any work on the main character's part with most if not all credit going to them; "flaws" that only serve to conveniently advance the plot when needed and never affect the story otherwise; inconsistent powers that are only used when it makes the plot go easily; and characters who are far more sympathetic and interesting being outright ignored or reviled simply because of their stance towards the protagonists.

With that in mind, it doesn't surprise me at all that the most favourable reviews online for Modelland come from people who preach about how great it is but are incapable of explaining *why* it's great, insinuate that people who dislike it don't know what they're talking about, and make it clear that they understand less about the story than the haters.
DrDahm Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 15th 2012 at 11:51:22 PM
I wish she would at least mention Hunchy. It would make a better cliffhanger then "My teleportal sense is tingling!" There had better be some kind of backstory for him in the sequel or I will be pissed. Well, more pissed.
147.253.200.11 Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 16th 2012 at 8:19:22 AM
Seriously, Hunchy became my favorite character despite the fact he had so little characterization. I guess the fact that he had a simple motivation that could mean the death of one or more of the main characters and possibly an amazing liberation of the "deformed" servants of Modelland was just awesome. Far more exciting than a group of characters I never worried about because It was clear the author would never put her pwecious, broken angels in danger, let alone explore hard-hitting issues (seriously, Tookie's "I understand your bulimia because I look gawky" moment made me want to chuck the book across the room. Then I remembered it was my Kindle....)

Ah, the acknowledgements! Have fun with those. I don't see how you can't laugh, it's got some of the most bizarre writing in there.
gekkolexicon Since: Dec, 1969
Mar 16th 2012 at 3:11:25 PM
I comepletely lost my points of what I was gonna post. But, I'll put something down. The message to the readers is stupid beyond belief. It's pointless and holds no water. also, tonite? WTF! who spells like that? Also the ending is horrible, there are plot threads that could be a potential plot for a sequel. The adventure continues thing only works when you finnish fixing the plot threads! Also, shouldn't they be holding the 7seven tournament since she's the new belladonna now?

damn there's so much shit in this.

Also I agree with you guys. Tyra shouldn't have done that Hunchy, he was interesting, he had a motive and he's mysterious.

@76.69: good comparison. both are equally stupid. I have a new category for both of them: fanfic shitfest catastrophe.
Zersk Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 26th 2013 at 1:13:51 AM
"To start with, there are already several series that involve young boys transforming with magical powers and skirts/wands/sparkles/etc."

Well it worked in Earthbound! :p
Zersk Since: Dec, 1969
Feb 26th 2013 at 1:14:32 AM
That... is not the quote I wanted!

"I'm not even sure how you would send memories, pain or strength to a real person, let alone a fictional character."

Well it worked in Earthbound. :B
Top