History YMMV / Supergirl2015S3E9Reign

* {{Harsher in Hindsight}} Lena telling Kara and Sam that there is no chemistry between her and James despite them saying otherwise. Lena and James get together later in the episode and begin a relationship that was very unpopular with fans and critics. One of the biggest complaints? The totally lack of onscreen chemistry between the two characters.
* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keeping Reign's identity a secret, showing most of her actions from a first-person viewpoint and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask during the third-person shots. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the antagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.
* Lena telling Kara and Sam there is no chemistry between her and James is meant to be funny as viewers are supposed to see an obvious romantic connection between the two. Sadly, there is a totally lack of any onscreen chemistry the line comes across as Lena being deadly serious

* ContinuityLockOut: Apparently the episode begins the morning after "Wake Up," making it hard to believe that Kara and Alex were able to attend Barry and Iris' wedding and take part in the ''Series/CrisisOnEarthX''. Then again time has been proven to work differently between parallel Earths, as the day [[Redap/Supergirl2015S1E18WorldsFinest Barry spent on Earth-38]] amounted to [[Recap/TheFlash2014S2E18VersusZoom less than a second on Earth-1]].

* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keeping Reign's identity a secret, showing most of her actions from a first-person viewpoint and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask during the third-person shots. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the antagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.

* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keeping Reign's identity a secret, showing most of her actions from a first-person viewpoint and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask during the third-person shots. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the anatagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.

* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keeping Reign's identity a secret, showing most of her actions from a first-person viewpoint and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask during the third-person shots. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the anatagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.
* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Kara mentioning she's never had best friends before Lena and Sam, completely ignoring Winn and James.

* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keep Reign's identity a secret, showing most of her actions from a first-person viewpoint and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask during the third-person shots. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the anatagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.

* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keep Reign's identity a secret, showing most of her actions from a first=person viewpoint and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask during the third-person shots. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the anatagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.

* {{Narm}}: The way the episode makes a big show of keep Reign's identity a secret, always showing her actions through a NecroCam and obscuring her face with close-up shots of the mask. These are the kind of techniques typically used to build mystery around who the anatagonist is, but previous episodes have outright told the audience that Samantha is Reign.

* UnintentionallyUnsympathetic: Kara mentioning she's never had best friends before Lena and Sam, poor girl never having a best fr- Oh wait, she did, his name was Winn. What the hell Kara!