Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / OnceUponATimeInChina

Go To

OR

Added: 92

Changed: 9

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Vincent Zhao's turn as Wong Fei-hong in the fourth and fifth was not well received by audiences, despite giving decent performance. Jet Li was brought back in the sixth and final film as a result.

to:

** Vincent Zhao's Creator/VincentZhao's turn as Wong Fei-hong in the fourth and fifth was not well received by audiences, despite giving decent performance. Jet Li was brought back in the sixth and final film as a result.


Added DiffLines:

** Averted by Creator/MaxMok who replaced Creator/YuenBiao as Leung Fu after the first film.

Added: 2348

Changed: 3931

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent ear worm.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic:
**
[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent ear worm.worm.
** Aunt 13's motif, a combination of Chinese and Western instruments and musical styles, pretty much sums up the series.



** [[BigBad Jackson]], an American dignitary in the first film, is a corrupt sociopath who runs a side business selling the Chinese as slaves, especially selling attractive women as prostitutes. Using the Shaho Gang as his personal army of thugs, Jackson orders an attack on the province's governor and hero Wong Fei-Hung at an opera, having his men fire into the crowd of civilians. When confronted by Fei-Hung at the end, Jackson attempts to use the Governor as a hostage while trying to kill Fei-Hung and his friends.
** Jackson's corrupt partner, the [[NoNameGiven unnamed leader]] of the Shaho Gang [[note]]Jackson calls him Hung in one scene, but it is very brief and near the end of the movie[[/note]], participates in the massacre at the opera house and abducts innocents to be sold in Jackson's slave trade. Terrorizing the province and murdering at will, the Shaho Leader also kidnaps Wong Fei-Hung's LoveInterest, Aunt 13, and makes clear his intention to rape her. When she fights back, he attempts to drag her to a boiler to burn her face off.
** ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': High Priest Kau-Kung, master of the White Lotus sect, [[AbsoluteXenophobe leads a crusade against anything even vaguely Western]]. Having his followers burn every Western item they can find, Kau-Kung even has [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals Western dogs burnt alive]] before sending his men into the streets to attack and murder those with Western items, technology or clothing. Kau-Kung has his followers attack multiple institutions, [[WouldHurtAChild including a school for children]] to learn foreign languages, with Fei-Hung barely saving the lives of the children. He then has the foreign embassies besieged, intending to have every Westerner within massacred along with any Chinese citizen seen as a "collaborator."
* EnsembleDarkhorse: "Club Foot" Qi, a deliberately {{gonk}}ish character who turns out to be a LightningBruiser ExtremityExtremist, whom after his HeelFaceTurn enjoys an elevated role by the final movie. Basically, he's the [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] of the franchise.
%%* EvenBetterSequel: Part 2.

to:

** [[BigBad Jackson]], an American dignitary in the first film, is a corrupt sociopath who runs a side business selling the Chinese as slaves, especially selling attractive women as prostitutes. Using the Shaho Gang as his personal army of thugs, Jackson orders an attack on the province's governor and hero Wong Fei-Hung Fei-hung at an opera, having his men fire into the crowd of civilians. When confronted by Fei-Hung Fei-hung at the end, Jackson attempts to use the Governor as a hostage while trying to kill Fei-Hung Fei-hung and his friends.
** Jackson's corrupt partner, the [[NoNameGiven unnamed leader]] of the Shaho Gang [[note]]Jackson calls him Hung in one scene, but it is very brief and near the end of the movie[[/note]], participates in the massacre at the opera house and abducts innocents to be sold in Jackson's slave trade. Terrorizing the province and murdering at will, the Shaho Leader leader also kidnaps Wong Fei-Hung's Fei-hung's LoveInterest, Aunt 13, and makes clear his intention to rape her. When she fights back, he attempts to drag her to a boiler to burn her face off.
** ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': In the second film, High Priest Kau-Kung, Kau-hung, master of the White Lotus sect, Society, [[AbsoluteXenophobe leads a crusade against anything even vaguely Western]]. Having his followers burn every Western item they can find, Kau-Kung Kau-hung even has [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals Western dogs burnt alive]] before sending his men into the streets to attack and murder those with Western items, technology or clothing. Kau-Kung Kau-hung has his followers attack multiple institutions, [[WouldHurtAChild including a school for children]] to learn foreign languages, with Fei-Hung Fei-hung barely saving the lives of the children. He then has the foreign embassies besieged, intending to have every Westerner within massacred along with any Chinese citizen seen as a "collaborator."
"collaborator".
** In the third film, Chiu Tin-bak, a local gangster who is a DirtyCoward and tries everything to win the upcoming lion dance tournament, picks fights with Wong's family and friends, and casts out his henchman Clubfoot Qi into the streets after he injures his leg, in spite of his loyal service.
* EnsembleDarkhorse: "Club Foot" "Clubfoot" Qi, a deliberately {{gonk}}ish character who turns out to be a LightningBruiser ExtremityExtremist, whom after his HeelFaceTurn enjoys an elevated role by the final movie. Basically, he's the [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] of the franchise.
%%* * EvenBetterSequel: Part 2.Many fans consider the second movie to be just as good as the first, if not better, largely due to the presence of ''Creator/DonnieYen'' as the main villain and delivers the message that not all Westerner are bad.



* MagnificentBastard: ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': Nap-lan is a military officer hunting down members of a revolutionary sect that seek to replace the dynasty with a republic. Gaining a respect for Wong Fei-hung in a sparring match, Nap-lan later fakes an attack by the fanatic White Lotus cultists to give himself an excuse to search the British consulate for rebels, murdering the consul when he sees through the ruse. Infiltrating the White Lotus to engage Fei-hung, Nap-lan even succeeds in eliminating his friend before attempting to steal a book of revolutionary names to clandestinely eliminate them.
* RetroactiveRecognition: Marvelous as Creator/DonnieYen's performance as AntiVillain General Nap-lan Yun-Suet was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''Film/IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....
%%* {{Sequelitis}}
* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the European's stranglehold over the lives of the Chinese people during the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by the positive portrayal Buck-Teeth-Soo's English in the first film and medical practitioners in the second film. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark mirror to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either Chinese or Westerners can be negative to both the practitioners and the victims.
%%* {{Tearjerker}}
* UnconventionalLearningExperience: Even if the series runs on RuleOfCool and ArtisticLicenseHistory, it still neatly covers the final years of Imperial China. Never heard about unequal treaties? Or maybe the fact that China was ruled by Manchurians? Or how Western powers tried to slice pieces of China for themselves? Then please, take a seat.

to:

* MagnificentBastard: ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': Nap-lan MagnificentBastard:
** In the second film, Narlan
is a military officer hunting down members of a revolutionary sect group that seek to replace the dynasty with a republic. Gaining a respect for Wong Fei-hung in a sparring match, Nap-lan Narlan later fakes an attack by the fanatic White Lotus cultists to give himself an excuse to search the British consulate for rebels, murdering and murders the consul when he sees through the ruse. Infiltrating the White Lotus to engage Fei-hung, Nap-lan Narlan even succeeds in eliminating his friend Luke before attempting to steal a book of revolutionary names of revolutionaries to clandestinely eliminate them.
** Pirate king Cheung Po Tsai in the fifth film.
* ReplacementScrappy:
** Vincent Zhao's turn as Wong Fei-hong in the fourth and fifth was not well received by audiences, despite giving decent performance. Jet Li was brought back in the sixth and final film as a result.
** To a lesser extent, Aunt 14 who replaced Aunt 13 in the fourth movie. Aunt 13 returned in the fifth film however.
* RetroactiveRecognition: Marvelous as Creator/DonnieYen's performance as AntiVillain General Nap-lan Yun-Suet Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' the second film (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying another famous martial artist, Wing-Chun master in the ''Film/IpMan'' series almost 15 years later.....
%%* {{Sequelitis}}
* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed series shows the European's European stranglehold over the lives of the Chinese people during the twilight of Qing Dynasty Dynasty, and Heroic the futility of romanticized Chinese ideal. ideals. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, Western imperialism is a major topic, the films--especially the second part--showed films also take a more nuanced approach in arguing that western Western people are also capable of good, and Western knowledge can also be used to aid people the Chinese people, as shown by the positive portrayal Buck-Teeth-Soo's English of the Jesuit priest in the first film and medical practitioners in the second film. Furthermore, the second film portrayed depicts the White Lotus sect's anti-western anti-Western ideals as a dark mirror to the European's Europeans' imperialism and racism; serving to show showing that CulturalPosturing by either Chinese or Westerners can be negative to both the practitioners and the victims.
%%* {{Tearjerker}}
* UnconventionalLearningExperience: Even if the series runs on RuleOfCool and ArtisticLicenseHistory, it still neatly covers the final years of Imperial China. Never heard about unequal treaties? Or maybe the fact that China was ruled by Manchurians? Manchus? Or how Western powers tried to slice carve pieces of China for themselves? Then please, take a seat.

Changed: 836

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.


* MagnificentBastard: General Nap-lan Yun-Suet from ''II'' is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily the equal of Wong Fei-Hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, to which end he manipulates and exploits the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and even murders the attache and frames it on them so his orders won't be questioned]].

to:

* MagnificentBastard: General ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': Nap-lan Yun-Suet from ''II'' is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily military officer hunting down members of a revolutionary sect that seek to replace the equal of dynasty with a republic. Gaining a respect for Wong Fei-Hung Fei-hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing sparring match, Nap-lan later fakes an attack by the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, fanatic White Lotus cultists to which end give himself an excuse to search the British consulate for rebels, murdering the consul when he manipulates and exploits sees through the ruse. Infiltrating the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and engage Fei-hung, Nap-lan even murders the attache and frames it on them so succeeds in eliminating his orders won't be questioned]]. friend before attempting to steal a book of revolutionary names to clandestinely eliminate them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagnificentBastard: General Narlan Yuenshu from ''II'' is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily the equal of Wong Fei-Hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, to which end he manipulates and exploits the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and even murders the attache and frames it on them so his orders won't be questioned]].
* RetroactiveRecognition: Marvelous as Creator/DonnieYen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''Film/IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....

to:

* MagnificentBastard: General Narlan Yuenshu Nap-lan Yun-Suet from ''II'' is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily the equal of Wong Fei-Hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, to which end he manipulates and exploits the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and even murders the attache and frames it on them so his orders won't be questioned]].
* RetroactiveRecognition: Marvelous as Creator/DonnieYen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu Nap-lan Yun-Suet was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''Film/IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagnificentBastard: General Narlan Yuenshu is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily the equal of Wong Fei-Hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, to which end he manipulates and exploits the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and even murders the attache and frames it on them so his orders won't be questioned]].

to:

* MagnificentBastard: General Narlan Yuenshu from ''II'' is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily the equal of Wong Fei-Hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, to which end he manipulates and exploits the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and even murders the attache and frames it on them so his orders won't be questioned]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MagnificentBastard: General Narlan Yuenshu is a BadassNormal ArrogantKungFuGuy who is easily the equal of Wong Fei-Hung in combat, while also being a calculating and ruthless EvilReactionary, tactician and soldier tasked with crushing the revolution of Dr Sun Yat-Sen, to which end he manipulates and exploits the White Lotus Society into attacking the British Consulate in a bid to arrest Sun and his followers under the guise of arresting White Lotus members [[spoiler: and even murders the attache and frames it on them so his orders won't be questioned]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Jackson's corrupt partner, the [[NoNameGiven unnamed leader]] of the Shaho Gang, participates in the massacre at the opera house and abducts innocents to be sold in Jackson's slave trade. Terrorizing the province and murdering at will, the Shaho Leader also kidnaps Wong Fei-Hung's LoveInterest, Aunt 13, and makes clear his intention to rape her. When she fights back, he attempts to drag her to a boiler to burn her face off.

to:

** Jackson's corrupt partner, the [[NoNameGiven unnamed leader]] of the Shaho Gang, Gang [[note]]Jackson calls him Hung in one scene, but it is very brief and near the end of the movie[[/note]], participates in the massacre at the opera house and abducts innocents to be sold in Jackson's slave trade. Terrorizing the province and murdering at will, the Shaho Leader also kidnaps Wong Fei-Hung's LoveInterest, Aunt 13, and makes clear his intention to rape her. When she fights back, he attempts to drag her to a boiler to burn her face off.
Tabs MOD

Changed: -15

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.ear worm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkhorse: "Club Foot" Qi, a deliberately {{gonk}}ish character who turns out to be a LightningBruiser ExtremityExtremist, whom after his HeelFaceTurn enjoys an elevated role by the final movie. Basically he's the [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] of the franchise.

to:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: "Club Foot" Qi, a deliberately {{gonk}}ish character who turns out to be a LightningBruiser ExtremityExtremist, whom after his HeelFaceTurn enjoys an elevated role by the final movie. Basically Basically, he's the [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] of the franchise.



* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the European's stranglehold over the lives of teh Chinese during the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by the positive portrayal Buck-Teeth-Soo's English and Aunt 13's photography hobby. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either Chinese or Westerners can be negative to the practitioners and the victims.

to:

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the European's stranglehold over the lives of teh the Chinese people during the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by the positive portrayal Buck-Teeth-Soo's English in the first film and Aunt 13's photography hobby. medical practitioners in the second film. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast mirror to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either Chinese or Westerners can be negative to both the practitioners and the victims.

Changed: 240

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal as European powers began to eclipse over the lives of Chinese. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by Aunt 13's western medicine being used to help people and photography as an art. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either Chinese or Westerners can be negative to the practitioners and the victims.

to:

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the European's stranglehold over the lives of teh Chinese during the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal as European powers began to eclipse over the lives of Chinese. ideal. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by the positive portrayal Buck-Teeth-Soo's English and Aunt 13's western medicine being used to help people and photography as an art.hobby. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either Chinese or Westerners can be negative to the practitioners and the victims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMusic: [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.

to:

* AwesomeMusic: SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal as European powers began to eclipse over the lives of Chinese. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by Aunt 13's western medicine being used to help people and photography as an art. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either side can be negative to the practitioners and the victims.

to:

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal as European powers began to eclipse over the lives of Chinese. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by Aunt 13's western medicine being used to help people and photography as an art. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either side Chinese or Westerners can be negative to the practitioners and the victims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SomeAnvilsNeedToBeDropped: The central theme of the film showed the twilight of Qing Dynasty and Heroic Chinese ideal as European powers began to eclipse over the lives of Chinese. While it showed the evils of Imperialism, the films--especially the second part--showed a more nuanced approach that western knowledge can be used to aid people as shown by Aunt 13's western medicine being used to help people and photography as an art. Furthermore, the second film portrayed White Lotus sect's anti-western ideals as a dark contrast to the European's imperialism and racism; serving to show that CulturalPosturing by either side can be negative to the practitioners and the victims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnsembleDarkhorse: "Club Foot" Qi, a deliberately {{gonk}}ish character who turns out to be a LightningBruiser ExtremityExtremist, whom after his HeelFaceTurn enjoys an elevated role by the final movie. Basically he's the [[Franchise/StarWars Darth Maul]] of the franchise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition - Marvelous as Donnie Yen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''Film/IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition - RetroactiveRecognition: Marvelous as Donnie Yen's Creator/DonnieYen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''Film/IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RetroactiveRecognition - Marvelous as Donnie Yen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....

to:

* RetroactiveRecognition - Marvelous as Donnie Yen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''IpMan'' ''Film/IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....

Changed: 29

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': High Priest Kau-Kung, master of the White Lotus sect, [[AbsoluteXenophobe leads a crusade against anything even vaguely Western]]. Having his followers burn every Western item they can find, Kau-Kung even has [[KickTheDog Western dogs burnt alive]] before sending his men into the streets to attack and murder those with Western items, technology or clothing. Kau-Kung has his followers attack multiple institutions, [[WouldHurtAChild including a school for children]] to learn foreign languages, with Fei-Hung barely saving the lives of the children. He then has the foreign embassies besieged, intending to have every Westerner within massacred along with any Chinese citizen seen as a "collaborator."

to:

** ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': High Priest Kau-Kung, master of the White Lotus sect, [[AbsoluteXenophobe leads a crusade against anything even vaguely Western]]. Having his followers burn every Western item they can find, Kau-Kung even has [[KickTheDog [[BadPeopleAbuseAnimals Western dogs burnt alive]] before sending his men into the streets to attack and murder those with Western items, technology or clothing. Kau-Kung has his followers attack multiple institutions, [[WouldHurtAChild including a school for children]] to learn foreign languages, with Fei-Hung barely saving the lives of the children. He then has the foreign embassies besieged, intending to have every Westerner within massacred along with any Chinese citizen seen as a "collaborator."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FirstInstallmentWins: A mild subversion in that both the first and second films in the series are loved and highly praised. It's every film after the first two that receive more and more criticisms and accusations of {{Sequelitis}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.

Added DiffLines:

** ''Once Upon a Time in China II'': High Priest Kau-Kung, master of the White Lotus sect, [[AbsoluteXenophobe leads a crusade against anything even vaguely Western]]. Having his followers burn every Western item they can find, Kau-Kung even has [[KickTheDog Western dogs burnt alive]] before sending his men into the streets to attack and murder those with Western items, technology or clothing. Kau-Kung has his followers attack multiple institutions, [[WouldHurtAChild including a school for children]] to learn foreign languages, with Fei-Hung barely saving the lives of the children. He then has the foreign embassies besieged, intending to have every Westerner within massacred along with any Chinese citizen seen as a "collaborator."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvenBetterSequel - Part 2.

to:

* EvenBetterSequel - %%* EvenBetterSequel: Part 2.



* {{Sequelitis}}
* {{Tearjerker}}

to:

* %%* {{Sequelitis}}
* %%* {{Tearjerker}}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMusic: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It iss also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.

to:

* AwesomeMusic: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It iss is also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.

Added: 457

Removed: 326

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwesomeMusic: [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!" It iss also known as "男兒當自強" - [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2by2y3gkjcA A Man Should Strengthen Himself]], and is often sung in Cantonese. Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.



* CrowningMusicOfAwesome - [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDKiT3icMYM "To Be A Hero", the heart-stirring theme song of the franchise,]] based on the traditional Chinese Ballad ''Jiang Jun Ling'' (''General's Orders''). A hot-blooded song that tells you to "shine brighter than the sun!"
** Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Approved by the thread.

Added DiffLines:

*CompleteMonster:
**[[BigBad Jackson]], an American dignitary in the first film, is a corrupt sociopath who runs a side business selling the Chinese as slaves, especially selling attractive women as prostitutes. Using the Shaho Gang as his personal army of thugs, Jackson orders an attack on the province's governor and hero Wong Fei-Hung at an opera, having his men fire into the crowd of civilians. When confronted by Fei-Hung at the end, Jackson attempts to use the Governor as a hostage while trying to kill Fei-Hung and his friends.
**Jackson's corrupt partner, the [[NoNameGiven unnamed leader]] of the Shaho Gang, participates in the massacre at the opera house and abducts innocents to be sold in Jackson's slave trade. Terrorizing the province and murdering at will, the Shaho Leader also kidnaps Wong Fei-Hung's LoveInterest, Aunt 13, and makes clear his intention to rape her. When she fights back, he attempts to drag her to a boiler to burn her face off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Unfortunate Implications require citations from secondary sources.


* UnfortunateImplications - White people in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians. While this is not a totally unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time by any means, the fact that a lot of things portrayed (like the massacre in Canton) flatout did not happen does not help.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications - White people in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians. While this is not a totally unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time by any means, the fact that a lot of things portrayed (like the massacre in Canton) flatout did not happen does not help.----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnfortunateImplications - White people in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians, but frankly this is not an unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications - White people in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians, but frankly barbarians. While this is not an a totally unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time.time by any means, the fact that a lot of things portrayed (like the massacre in Canton) flatout did not happen does not help.

Added: 255

Changed: 385

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Be careful - it's a potent EarWorm.



* UnfortunateImplications - Americans in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians, but frankly this is not an unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time.

to:

* UnconventionalLearningExperience: Even if the series runs on RuleOfCool and ArtisticLicenseHistory, it still neatly covers the final years of Imperial China. Never heard about unequal treaties? Or maybe the fact that China was ruled by Manchurians? Or how Western powers tried to slice pieces of China for themselves? Then please, take a seat.
* UnfortunateImplications - Americans White people in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians, but frankly this is not an unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alas Poor Villain is being moved back to Main. Examples that don\'t describe the moment or are purely editor opinion are being deleted.


* AlasPoorVillain - The death of Master Yen Jer Dong under the gunfire of American mercenaries.

Changed: 9

Removed: 303

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
no groups


* CompleteMonster - With few exceptions, the Western invaders. Also, the Chinese people who sell out their people to the West.
** Inverted in the second movie, where the villains are a violent Chinese cult and the corrupt Chinese government. The British ambassador can even arguably be considered heroic.



* UnfortunateImplications - Americans in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians, but frankly this is not an entirely unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time.

to:

* UnfortunateImplications - Americans in this series are mostly portrayed as violent, greedy, trigger-happy barbarians, but frankly this is not an entirely unfair picture of the behaviour of Westerners in China at the time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RetroactiveRecognition - Marvelous as Donnie Yen's performance as AntiVillain General Narlan Yuenshu was in ''Once Upon A Time In China 2'' (in which he actually won the ''Best Supporting Actor Trophy'' of the Hong Kong Oscars in 1993), nobody expected him to rise to the success of portraying Wing-Chun master ''IpMan'' almost 15 years later.....
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
this page is ymmv


* EvenBetterSequel - Part 2, though YourMileageMayVary.

to:

* EvenBetterSequel - Part 2, though YourMileageMayVary.2.

Top