Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit

Go To

OR

Added: 431

Changed: 1094

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives (mostly Stabler) can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex and the men that want to have sex with them are pedophiles, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over perfectly normal fetishes it makes this troper just want to see the bad guy win.
** In addition, the detectives have very low opinions about every other government body, including other police departments and the FBI. To the members of the SVU, they themselves are the only ones who actually care about the victims, everyone else is just looking to play the system as much as they can and don't care about the well-being of others.

to:

* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives (mostly Stabler) can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting judgmental and close-minded on sexuality, to the point that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex and the men that want to have sex with them are pedophiles, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over even perfectly normal fetishes it makes are demonized, and any other branch of law enforcement that has their hands in their case just complicates matters and has no regard for justice. For example:
** One episode features a woman who was [[YoungerThanTheyLook very young looking]] to the point she looked underage, and her boyfriend was a convicted pedophile. The detectives were disgusted with
this troper just want relationship, feeling it was unhealthy and that his only interest in her was due to see her looking like a child--however nothing illegal was being done and her appearance aside they were in a perfectly normal relationship.
** As for
the bad guy win.
** In addition,
JurisdictionFriction, the detectives have very low opinions about every often jeopardize investigations being conducted by other government body, including other police departments to further their own, even when the other department's investigation is far more important. Many times their suspects are agents working for the FBI or some other higher branch of authority, and the FBI. To detectives refuse to back off and often force the members of the SVU, they themselves are the only ones who actually care about the victims, everyone else is just looking other agency to play the system as much as they can and don't care about the well-being of others.include them. This rarely, if ever, goes well.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DesignatedHero: Stabler--he's bigoted, abusive, neglects his kids and can be borderline psychotic at times. But he's good enough at collaring criminals to keep his badge.


Added DiffLines:

* JerkassWoobie: As completely unlikeable as Elliot can be, you can really feel for him, especially when he realizes he's been a neglectful dad and tries to make ammends with his kids but is pushed away.


Added DiffLines:

** Stabler has his moments as well. The opening of one episode showed Stabler unscrewing the bottom of the leg of a chair so it wobbled, loosened a light so it flickered, and turned up the thermostat, all to unnerve a suspect he was about to interview and knew would be hard to crack.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** An earlier episode centers around a young woman with Down's Syndrome who became pregnant after being raped. Her 67 year old mother campaigns throughout most of the episode to have the fetus aborted, and the writers make it clear we're supposed to villify her at this point. YMMV on her methods, but the points made in court by the mother's attorney are valid nevertheless. The girl clearly had no idea how to properly care for a child and would likely not only fail to be a competent mother, but may endager the welfare of the potential child.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Anticlimax}}: YourMileageMayVary, but a good number of episodes end with them catching the bad guys and nothing else. The viewer doesn't get to see the trial, or, most satisfyingly, the guilty verdict. This kind of ending is even more infuriating if the suspect had been in court previously in the episode, but the case was foiled for some reason.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In addition, the detectives have very low opinions about every other government body, including other police departments and the FBI. To the members of the SVU, they themselves are the only ones who actually care about the victims, everyone else is just looking to play the system as much as they can and don't care about the well-being of others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives (mostly Stabler) can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over perfectly normal fetishes it makes this troper just want to see the bad guy win.

to:

* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives (mostly Stabler) can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex, sex and the men that want to have sex with them are pedophiles, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over perfectly normal fetishes it makes this troper just want to see the bad guy win.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over perfectly normal fetishes it makes this troper just want to see the bad guy win.

to:

* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives (mostly Stabler) can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over perfectly normal fetishes it makes this troper just want to see the bad guy win.

Added: 473

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoYay:'''And how.''' "Loss" is a virtual cornucopia of LesYay for Alex/Olivia, but there's evidence [[http://community.livejournal.com/ship_manifesto/43570.html#cutid1 well before that]]. It just breaks your heart.

to:

* HoYay:'''And how.''' "Loss" is a virtual cornucopia of LesYay for Alex/Olivia, but there's evidence [[http://community.livejournal.com/ship_manifesto/43570.html#cutid1 well before that]]. that]] It just breaks your heart.


Added DiffLines:

* HolierThanThou: See StrawmanHasAPoint below. The detectives can be extremely judgmental. Let's see, there's not [[NoBisexuals believing in bisexuals]], asserting that women who [[YoungerThanTheyLook look young]] shouldn't be allowed to have sex, and classifying every single type of porn they see as "sick and wrong" or "perverted." YMMV, but whenever the detectives express disgust over perfectly normal fetishes it makes this troper just want to see the bad guy win.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The baseball player was Jesse Palmer, who is known for being an extremely forgettable NFL Quarterback
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneSceneWonder: The high-on-PCP pedophile who rampages through the station, takes a fire extinguisher to the head, and throws Elliott through an interrogation room window before being tasered down. This troper [[{{Bring My Brown Pants}} needed her brown pants]] the first time she saw that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving Trivia trope to the Trivia page.


* FanNickname: After one too many uses of the JackBauerInterrogationTechnique, Elliot became widely known as "[=UnStabler=]."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving YMMV trope from the main page.

Added DiffLines:

* {{HSQ}}: Paranoiac kills two people, and then tries to ''gas'' Elliot and Fin!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Magnificent Bastard: Darius Parker [[spoiler: or Fin's stepson]]. Not only does he commit one of the most heinous crimes depicted on SVU [[spoiler:by murdering a woman, raping her with his KNIFE, and then burying her 14-month-old son alive]], but he walks, even after confessing to the crime. How? First [[spoiler: he mentions that he has an upcoming burglary case before he confesses to the crime while waving his right to counsel. However, because he mentions his upcoming case, it is implied that he should have counsel present, making his confession and the bodies discovered by that confession inadmissible in court. He then goes to trial and picks apart the prosecution's case while airing Fin and Stabler's dirty laundry, getting the Judge recused from the case by mention the DUI of Stabler's daughter, and getting his mother to reveal that she hates him because he was the child of her rape(by his grandfather/father)]].

to:

* Magnificent Bastard: *MagnificentBastard: Darius Parker [[spoiler: Parker[[spoiler: or Fin's stepson]]. Not only does he commit one of the most heinous crimes depicted described on SVU [[spoiler:by [[spoiler: by murdering a woman, raping her with his KNIFE, and then burying her 14-month-old son alive]], but he walks, even after confessing to the crime. How? First [[spoiler: first he mentions that he has an upcoming burglary case before he confesses to the crime while waving his right to counsel. However, because he mentions his upcoming case, it is implied that he should have counsel present, making his confession and the bodies discovered by that confession inadmissible in court. He then goes to trial and picks apart the prosecution's case while airing Fin and Stabler's dirty laundry, getting the Judge recused from the case by mention the DUI of Stabler's daughter, and getting his mother to reveal that she hates him because he was the child of her rape(by his grandfather/father)]].
[[ParentalIncest grandfather/father]]).]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving Magnificent Bastard to YMMV

Added DiffLines:

*Magnificent Bastard: Darius Parker [[spoiler: or Fin's stepson]]. Not only does he commit one of the most heinous crimes depicted on SVU [[spoiler:by murdering a woman, raping her with his KNIFE, and then burying her 14-month-old son alive]], but he walks, even after confessing to the crime. How? First [[spoiler: he mentions that he has an upcoming burglary case before he confesses to the crime while waving his right to counsel. However, because he mentions his upcoming case, it is implied that he should have counsel present, making his confession and the bodies discovered by that confession inadmissible in court. He then goes to trial and picks apart the prosecution's case while airing Fin and Stabler's dirty laundry, getting the Judge recused from the case by mention the DUI of Stabler's daughter, and getting his mother to reveal that she hates him because he was the child of her rape(by his grandfather/father)]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Particularly the arguments of several pedophile perps who claim that both homosexual and interracial relationships were both reviled and illegal at one point and that pedophilic relationships "have been part of healthy Western societies since the Greeks". Squicky? Indeed. Does it make sense? Yes.

Added: 1121

Changed: 723

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Stabler. Whether he's a hero who defends children from perverts or a borderline psychopath is debatable.



* ShockingSwerve: One episode involved rapes being committed in the same fashion as some Elliot had already put away a man for. They find the real rapist, he confesses, [[spoiler:Elliot goes to apologize to the guy he put away, then the perp falls out of the bathroom window, possibly pushed by that week's guest detective. Without the perp to alocute, they can't get the other guy out of jail. Episode ends.]]
** [[SarcasmMode Another great case of SVU being completely true to how the justice system works in real life.]]



* StrawmanHasAPoint: Crops up here and there, but the sixth year finally had an egregious case, wherein [[spoiler: the military has been giving anti-malaria meds to soldiers that cause serious psychological problems in perhaps one in every one hundred-fifty people. The Military]] points out, however, that a few people experiencing some admittedly horrible side effects is still better than thousands of people being unable to fight because of malaria, and the pill is otherwise more efficient than alternatives.

to:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: Crops up here and there, Many of the characters with a weird kink or unusual sexual orientation turn out never to have hurt anybody, but the detectives (especially Stabler) think of them as "perverts" or "sickos" who ought to be in jail and it seems like the show expects us to agree with them. A lot of those characters (pedophiles trying desperately to suppress their urges, for instance) come across as more sympathetic than they're probably intended to be.
** The
sixth year finally had an egregious case, wherein [[spoiler: the military has been giving anti-malaria meds to soldiers that cause serious psychological problems in perhaps one in every one hundred-fifty people. The Military]] points out, however, that a few people experiencing some admittedly horrible side effects is still better than thousands of people being unable to fight because of malaria, and the pill is otherwise more efficient than alternatives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TruffautWasRight: Although the show usually takes pains to point out that these crimes are horrific and carry devastating consequences, many critics have nevertheless pointed out that there is also a tendency for the show to get a lot of lurid and sensationalist entertainment mileage out of them as well.

Added: 27

Changed: 32

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** JohnMunch, TheSmartGuy

to:

** JohnMunch, TheSmartGuyTheSmartGuy . Either him, or George Huang.


Added DiffLines:

** Melinda Warner, TheChick
Camacan MOD

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Feed Me is now Chewing The Scenery.


* VillainSue: Merrit Rook, an AffablyEvil con man played by RobinWilliams, decidedly in his "funny" persona, who starts a counterculture movement that manages to draw in Munch, has a [[FeedMe scenery-chewing]] VillanousBreakdown that turns out to be an act, and [[NoOneCouldSurviveThat apparently commits suicide]], but of course they NeverFoundTheBody. Just for extra Sue points, his crime, which was RippedFromTheHeadlines, is toned down to be ''just'' behind the MoralEventHorizon (he talks a man into stripping and binding an underage girl; the person he was based on talked a man into rape).

to:

* VillainSue: Merrit Rook, an AffablyEvil con man played by RobinWilliams, decidedly in his "funny" persona, who starts a counterculture movement that manages to draw in Munch, has a [[FeedMe [[ChewingTheScenery scenery-chewing]] VillanousBreakdown that turns out to be an act, and [[NoOneCouldSurviveThat apparently commits suicide]], but of course they NeverFoundTheBody. Just for extra Sue points, his crime, which was RippedFromTheHeadlines, is toned down to be ''just'' behind the MoralEventHorizon (he talks a man into stripping and binding an underage girl; the person he was based on talked a man into rape).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed black page entry


* {{Narm}} : ''Shattered''. The scene where [[spoiler: Jo reveals she had cancer to a mother who lost her child and was holding the station hostage. Then Jo picked up the dead body of the kid and was telling her to "hold her child".]] [[LargeHam Sharon Stone's]] performance was the key factor.
** Also, and this was ''spectacular'', Kathleen Stabler's intervention with Kim Garnett in "Crush". It was Narm-''tastic''.
** How about the fact that the show always starts with the speech at the top of the main page? Yeah, that speech was thought-provoking the first 400 times you said it.
** In "Sick", while gathering information on a young boy who was most likely molested, they interview a school bully. The bully says the kid one time violently fought back and expressed surprise not in the fact that such a kid would retaliate, but that he screamed the word "rape" with every punch he threw.



** {{Your Mileage May Vary}}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not YMMV


* DownerEnding: "Screwed..." Just "[[MeaningfulName Screwed]]." Everything goes downhill for the cast as their past mistakes come back to bite them. Not to mention the results of those mistakes become the key reason why [[spoiler:[[TheBadGuyWins Darius Parker walks away]] [[KarmaHoudini Scott free]]]].
** A significant chunk of the episodes fall under this.
** Another big example is "Unstable". Basically, a serial rapist was caught, exonerating another man falsely imprisoned for his crime. [[spoiler:However, either due to the actions of the CowboyCop or the perp escaping, the guy dies and is therefore unable to testify, meaning the wrongfully imprisoned man doesn't get released.]]
* FandomNod: in 11x13, "P.C.", [[spoiler:Kathy Griffin's lesbian character [[HoYay coming onto Liv]]. The reasons she gives for her mistake are pretty much the same ones fans have been using for their SlashFic since, oh, the start of the show.]]
** The best part being when Olivia asks, "Why does everyone think I'm a lesbian?"
*** No, the best part has to be Olivia fooling the suspect into confessing by ''pretending'' to be a lesbian, [[FetishFuel swaggering into the interrogation room in a leather jacket.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Sick", while gathering information on a young boy who was most likely molested, they interview a school bully. The bully says the kid one time violently fought back and expressed surprise not in the fact that such a kid would retaliate, but that he screamed the word "rape" with every punch he threw.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* VillainSue: Merrit Rook, an AffablyEvil con man played by RobinWilliams, decidedly in his "funny" persona, who starts a counterculture movement that manages to draw in Munch, has a [[FeedMe scenery-chewing]] VillanousBreakdown that turns out to be an act, and [[NoOneCouldSurviveThat apparently commits suicide]], but of course they NeverFoundTheBody. Just for extra Sue points, his crime, which was RippedFromTheHeadlines, is toned down to be ''just'' behind the MoralEventHorizon (he talks a man into stripping and binding an underage girl; the person he was based on talked a man into rape).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** How about the fact that the show always starts with the speech at the top of the main page? Yeah, that speech was thought-provoking the first 400 times you said it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed Wallbanger reference (should only be used in Darth Wiki)


* WallBanger: The entire series after three, or maybe five, seasons. There's a ''reason'' that Sex Crimes cops are rotated out after a few years. It's a good show, but the main cast needs to be rotated out.
** At least Benson and Stabler, Munch has plenthy of untapped potential if he wasn't just the Dale Gribble of the show.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NarrowedItDownToTheGuyIRecognize: Usually played straight, but one episode, in quick succession, had the detectives talking up a promiscuous female vic's sexual partners: Bobby Flay, Mark [=McGrath=], and some baseball player this troper can't recall the name of, all playing [[{{Expy}} Expies]] of themselves. It's not ''any'' of them; just sweeps.
** Subverted in the 2009 season finale: The killer is very quickly found to be a very paranoid [[SinCity That Yellow Bastard]] and one of his allies is Munch's paranoid ex-wife [[{{Taxi}} Simka Gravas]], however [[spoiler: most of the ''actual'' killings were done by a recurring character who was introduced ''at the beginning of the season''.]]
** Completely averted when Bill Pullman appears as a reporter who is secretly dating Benson; he only appears in one scene. The two break up at the end of the episode, and he is never seen again.
* ParanoiaFuel: Pretty much every episode if you are a woman who lives alone or who has children or who leaves the house.
** Or if you're a man involved with a woman who does any of those things.
*** Or if you're a man who does any of those things. There have certainly been enough male rape victims on this show.
*** The tactics the SVU detectives use to convict criminals or trick them into confessing, including their railroading of suspects who have only circumstantial evidence behind them, can start to give watchers rather pressing paranoia about cops.



* SpotlightStealingSquad: Elliot and Olivia have been accused of this.



** She's gone, thank god.

to:

** She's gone, thank god.god.
* TheWoobie: Benson did not have a happy childhood. The same could be said for Mariska Hagirtay herself, who was with [[JayneMansfield her mother]] when she died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Yes but it could just as likely started off as that had the side effects of preventing malaria while its intended effect didnt happen that often.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DieForOurShip (Kathy, Elliot's wife. Dani Beck, Olivia's SuspiciouslySimilarSubstitute [[spoiler: who actually got to ''kiss'' Elliot before departing. In their defense, Dani was a widow who had gone through quite a hard time, and Elliot was still separated from Kathy.]]. Both are reviled and bashed by Elliot x Olivia shippers, despite WordOfGod on how Stabler and Olivia will NOT hook up)
** (Likewise, Casey was often subjected to death for the Alex/Olivia ship, primarily for [[ReplacementScrappy not being Alex]].)
* DownerEnding: "Screwed..." Just "[[MeaningfulName Screwed]]." Everything goes downhill for the cast as their past mistakes come back to bite them. Not to mention the results of those mistakes become the key reason why [[spoiler:[[TheBadGuyWins Darius Parker walks away]] [[KarmaHoudini Scott free]]]].
** A significant chunk of the episodes fall under this.
** Another big example is "Unstable". Basically, a serial rapist was caught, exonerating another man falsely imprisoned for his crime. [[spoiler:However, either due to the actions of the CowboyCop or the perp escaping, the guy dies and is therefore unable to testify, meaning the wrongfully imprisoned man doesn't get released.]]
* FandomNod: in 11x13, "P.C.", [[spoiler:Kathy Griffin's lesbian character [[HoYay coming onto Liv]]. The reasons she gives for her mistake are pretty much the same ones fans have been using for their SlashFic since, oh, the start of the show.]]
** The best part being when Olivia asks, "Why does everyone think I'm a lesbian?"
*** No, the best part has to be Olivia fooling the suspect into confessing by ''pretending'' to be a lesbian, [[FetishFuel swaggering into the interrogation room in a leather jacket.]]
* FanNickname: After one too many uses of the JackBauerInterrogationTechnique, Elliot became widely known as "[=UnStabler=]."
* FiveManBand
** Elliot Stabler, Lead Detective, TheHero... [[HeroicSociopath -ish]], {{Jerkass}}
** Olivia Benson, TheLancer
** JohnMunch, TheSmartGuy
** Odafin "Fin" Tutuola, TheBigGuy
** Captain Cragen, TeamDad
** The lawyers and/or shrinks may count as {{Sixth Ranger}}s, especially the current [=ADA=] (Alex Cabot, Casey Novak, Kim Greylek, Alex Cabot, Sonya Paxton, Alex Cabot, Jo Marlowe, [[strike:hopefully, Alex Cabot]], in that order) and the psychiatrist Dr. George Huang.
** Chester Lake, SixthRangerTraitor, lasted one whole season.


Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: A popular BetaCouple in fanfiction to Elliot/Olivia had been George/Alex...[[spoiler: and then "Hardwired" gave canon confirmation that George was gay, [[{{Jossed}} jossing]] every single one of those fics.]]
** Which is, of course, particularly amusing if you ship Alex with Olivia.
** Or George and Elliot.


Added DiffLines:

* RootingForTheEmpire: With the [[IdiotBall idiocy]] and [[MoralDissonance questionable tactics]] that come from the detectives and [=ADAs=] ([[AuthorTract among]] [[WriterOnBoard other]] [[ItsPersonal things]]), sometimes you just want to see them fail. It doesn't help that some of the criminals [[UnintentionallySympathetic come off as sympathetic at times]]. Mainly, you just hate ''everyone'' on these days.
** {{Your Mileage May Vary}}
** [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation Isn't Unstabler the Empire?]]


Added DiffLines:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: Crops up here and there, but the sixth year finally had an egregious case, wherein [[spoiler: the military has been giving anti-malaria meds to soldiers that cause serious psychological problems in perhaps one in every one hundred-fifty people. The Military]] points out, however, that a few people experiencing some admittedly horrible side effects is still better than thousands of people being unable to fight because of malaria, and the pill is otherwise more efficient than alternatives.
** Then again, it's also vaguely hinted the stuff may have started out as some kinda PsychoSerum experiment that didn't pan out & the vaccine story was a cover.


Added DiffLines:

* WhatAnIdiot: Just TOO many, again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** At least Benson and Stabler, Munch has plenthy of untapped potential if he wasn't just the Dale Gribble of the show.

Top