History YMMV / EromangaSensei

* AuthorsSavingThrow: It contains one for ''LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}''. [[spoiler:After the ending of that series made some fans fear that Kyousuke irreparably destroyed his friendships with Kuroneko, Ayase, and Manami to be with Kirino, TheCameo in the eleventh episode shows that Kuroneko and Saori, at least, are still friends with Kyousuke and Kirino after all that happened]].

* FandomRivalry: With ''LightNovel/ASistersAllYouNeed''. Fans of that tend to call this work exactly the kind of trashy {{Fanservice}} filled [[BetterThanABareBulb faux-meta]] light novel that ''Sister'' poked fun at, while fans of ''Eromanga-sensei'' consider ''Sister'' to be a pretentious, stuck up its own ass series that's really no better than the kind of light novels it makes fun of.

** Creator/YoshitsuguMatsuoka tries more to scream and play with his voice, after his LargeHam character in ''LightNovel/ReZero'' has received tremendous recognition from the audience.

** The fact that [[Creator/AkaneFujita Sagiri's voice actress]] plays another younger {{Tsundere}} main heroine with platinum hair [[LightNovel/AkashicRecordsOfBastardMagicInstructor in the same season]].

* TastesLikeDiabetes: The relationship between Sagiri and Masamune has a lot of this as the series develops, including LoveBeforeFirstSight and ChildhoodFriendRomance.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Open hebephilia tends to do that.
** Parts of the Western audience was already not too happy about the show in general, since it came off as a FollowTheLeader of [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} the author's previous work]], which is already the source of a major BrokenBase among the Western anime fandom. Especially since BrotherSisterIncest, just like ''Oreimo'', is a major plot point; though it dodges the incest taboo by the fact that Masamune and Sagiri are NotBloodSiblings, it more than makes up for it in controversy by [[LoliconAndShotacon significantly lowering the ages of the girls from high school-age to pubescent]]. Even among those inclined towards the show, [[ItsTheSameSoItSucks a few dislike the repetition]].
** Even among Eastern audiences, opinions on the show are split. Many considered Sagiri less TheWoobie and more TheScrappy because she kept demanding Masamune's attention without showing any gratitude.

* FandomRivalry: With ''LightNovel/ASistersAllYouNeed'': fans of that tend to call this work exactly the kind of trashy {{Fanservice}} filled [[BetterThanABareBulb faux-meta]] light novel that ''Sister'' poked fun at, while fans of ''Eromanga-sensei'' consider ''Sister'' to be a pretentious, stuck up its own ass series that's really no better than the kind of light novels it makes fun of.

* FandomRivalry: With ''Imouto sae Ireba Ii'': fans of that tend to call this work exactly the kind of trashy {{Fanservice}} filled [[BetterThanABareBulb faux-meta]] light novel that ''Imouto sae Ireba Ii'' poked fun at, while fans of ''Eromanga-sensei'' consider ''Imouto sae Ireba Ii'' to be a pretentious, stuck up its own ass series that's really no better than the kind of light novels it makes fun of.

%%* FandomEnragingMisconception: Never call this work a clone of Oreimo, or claim that the relationship between Masamune and Sagiri is incest or even an implied incest.

* FridgeLogic: A 12 year old girl secretly being a successful hentai artist is one thing, [[BeyondTheImpossible but a Japanese pre-teen owning an XBox One?]]

* InternetBackdraft: A brief cameo in an early anime episode shows[[spoiler: [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} Ruri Gokou]] on the TV, which wouldn't cause much fan anger except that she was wearing the same kimono [[ShipSinking as when Kyousuke rejected her]], as well as saying she was at the festival alone. The Kyousuke/Kuroneko shippers who still haven't gotten over the novels' endings took that as [[TakeThatAudience twisting the knife]] and blew up on the web. However, a later scene showing that Kyousuke and Kirino are still friends with Kuroneko softened the blow]].

* FandomBerserkButton: Never call this work a clone of Oreimo, or claim that the relationship between Masamune and Sagiri is incest or even an implied incest.

* InternetBackdraft: [[spoiler:A brief cameo in an early anime episode shows [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} Ruri Gokou]] on the TV, which wouldn't cause much fan anger except that she was wearing the same kimono [[ShipSinking as when Kyousuke rejected her]], as well as saying she was at the festival alone. The Kyousuke/Kuroneko shippers who still haven't gotten over the novels' endings took that as [[TakeThatAudience twisting the knife]] and blew up on the web. However, a later scene showing that Kyousuke and Kirino are still friends with Kuroneko softened the blow]].

* FandomBerserkButton: Never call this work clone Oreimo or relationship between Masamune and Sagiri incest or even an implied incest.

* BaseBreakingCharacter:
** Sagiri definitely divides the fanbase, as some seem to enjoy her [[{{Moe}} cuteness]] and CovertPervert personality, but others believe that this very much vulgarizes her as a sweet character and is completely inappropriate in such a work, as well as being an UngratefulBastard toward her brother.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: [[spoiler:It contains one for ''LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}''. After the ending of that series made some fans fear that Kyousuke irreparably destroyed his friendships with Kuroneko, Ayase, and Manami to be with Kirino, TheCameo in the eleventh episode shows that Kuroneko and Saori, at least, are still friends with Kyousuke and Kirino after all that happened]].

* CounterpartComparison:
** In a very obvious way with ''LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}'', having the same author, BrotherSisterIncest as a main storyline, the duet between NiceGuy older brother protagonist and the sister studying in middle school, etc. Moreover, both [=LNs=] have many references to Otaku culture. The main difference is that ''Eromanga Sensei'' is dedicated to unrelated siblings and an adjacent literature community plot.
** With ''Imouto sae Ireba Ii/A Sister's All You Need'', which also has a combination of Imouto with the theme light novel, however more oriented to the fanservice and the real IncestSubtext.

* FandomBerserkButton: Never call this work clone Oreimo or relationship between Masamune and Sagiri incest or even an implied incest, so as not to be blamed as HateDumb on the part of the fans.

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Many people are more aware of the harem cast and incest than the major plot about the literary community.

* AwesomeMusic: It's hard not to like the opening and ending theme, especially when combined with a rather catchy video performance.

** With ''Imouto sae Ireba Ii'', which also has a combination of Imouto with the theme light novel, however more oriented to the fanservice and the real IncestSubtext.

** The fact that [[Creator/AkaneFujita Sagiri's seiyu]] plays another younger {{Tsundere}} main heroine with platinum hair [[LightNovel/AkashicRecordsOfBastardMagicInstructor in the same season]].

* SoBadItsGood: To some western viewers, anyway. Many fans in the west view this show as being so trashy, it ends up becoming hilarious.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise:
%%** Open hebephilia tends to do that.

** Open hebephilia tends to do that.

* PeripheryHatedom: The mere fact that this series features implied BrotherSisterIncest, brings out the same people who hated [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} the author's previous work]] on principle when it was in publication, [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch no matter the actual quality of the work in question.]]

** ''[[https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/6k22p5/a_new_level_of_trash_eromanga_sensei/ This show is trash and so am I.]]''

** It may happen that the interaction between Masamune and his [[Creator/YuichiNakamura father]] in the 11th episode will be impossible to take seriously because of NarmCharm, since it looks like the Tatsuya Shiba's care of a young Kirito. Moreover, Nakamura performs three roles in this show, including the cameo of two of his older brothers from other BrotherSisterIncest series. The son clearly [[SarcasmMode followed his father's way]], lol.

* FanPreferredCouple: Although Sagiri certainly can be called the most popular character of the series and is officialy its face, the LargeHam nature of Elf and the increasing emphasis on her accent in the anime quickly brings the Elf/Masamune pairing forward, at least among Western fans.