History YMMV / ElevenEyes

** The most popular choices for Kakeru's LoveInterest are [[DefrostingIceQueen Misuzu]] or [[ReiAyanamiExpy Shiori]].
** Despite Yukiko being a potential love interest for Kakeru, most fans prefer her to end up with Takahisa.

* HoYay: Between Georgius and Samson in Before Story arc in Resona forma even if [[spoiler: Samson actually loved Misao ]].

** Many fans prefer Kakeru to be with [[DefrostingIceQueen Misuzu]] or [[ReiAyanamiExpy Shiori]].
** Despite Yukiko being a potential love interest for Kakeru, pairing her with Takahisa is just as, if not more, popular.

** Takahisa and Yukiko is fairly popular.

* FoeYay:
** Between Kakeru and Liselotte. In a SS, he even had a H-scene with her. There is also between Avaritia and Liselotte in the OVA.
** Kanae and Shuu in Crossover. She has apparently a kind of attraction toward him.
** A bit between Misao and Scholastica too. According to the Phantasmagoria spell, it seemed Misao was actually the person who Scholastica cared the most about. Misao lost it when [[spoiler: Scholastica is killed]].

** [[NotSoDifferent Takahisa and Yukiko]] is fairly popular.

* TheScrappy: Yuka Minase's portrayal in the anime compared to her game and manga counterparts ''really'' ups her {{Yandere}}, ClingyJealousGirl, and BitchInSheepsClothing tendencies towards Kakeru; causing a lot of viewers to despise her as the anime went on. The low point was passing the MoralEventHorizon when she attempts murder by putting a razor-blade in Misuzu's tea in episode ten.

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: The soundtrack is considered one of the highest points both of the anime and the games. The former's opening song, "Arrival of Tears" by Ayane, is particularly epic, to the point that dissers of the series claim it is better than the entire anime.

* HolyShitQuotient: For a relatively short and not too original story, the plot is surprisingly ambitious and carries some quite shocking twists, especially at the last episodes.

* TheScrappy: Yuka Minase's portrayal in the anime compared to her game and manga counterparts ''really'' ups her {{Yandere}}, ClingyJealousGirl, and BitchInSheepsClothing tendencies towards Kakeru; causing a lot of viewers to despise her as the anime went on. The low point was passing the MoralEventHorizon when she attempts murder by putting a razor-blade in Misuzu's tea in episode ten.

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: The soundtrack is considered one of the highest points both of the anime and the games. The former's opening song, "Arrival of Tears" by Ayane, is particularly epic.

* TearJerker:
** When Yukiko killed Takahisa, as much in the game than in the anime.
** It kinda applied to the episode 12, where Kakeru reminisced his past with Yuka which shows how she always supported him during their childhood and after the death of Kukuri. However, it could be subverted as Yuka had been showed as a Bitch in Sheep's Clothing during all the half of the anime.
** Lisette's past without any doubt.
** If story. The moment where Vlad saved Lisette,[[spoiler: then died]] after having fought 90,000 crusaders for her safety will make you cry like a baby. Especially the scene where Lisette confessed her love and answered his name, Vlad [[spoiler:disappears and returns in his time before to be killed. He understood his death now has a meaning.]]
*** It's a lot sadder when you realized [[spoiler:that If Story is just a fictive story made for fans. So, this story didn't really happen and Vlad didn't really save Lisette.]]
** Before Story without any doubts has a lot of TearJerker moment, as the story told the past of the Black Knights. If you played the original, you'll expect what's happened to them.
*** [[spoiler: Every deaths of the Black Knights will make you cry. Especially Irene's and Sebastianus's deaths when we understood that Irene was apparently pregnant, so their happy ending fell.]]
*** [[spoiler:Samson's death. Especially when we learnt that he loved Misao from the beginning and didn't hesitate to sacrifice himself for her safe.]]
*** [[spoiler: Even if Benedictus wasn't really a sympathetic character, you'll feel bad for him as it's the only moment where he actually cared and cried over someone, making him slowly Jerkass to JerkWithAHeartOfGold.]]
** Liselotte's defeat. Subverted in the anime.

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: Yuka Minase to a certain degree for her anime portrayal (depending on who you ask). The middle episodes brought to light her Bitch in Sheep's Clothing persona, but episode 12 attempted to calm the past viewer hate with a TearJerker flashback that showed the childhood memories between Kakeru and Yuka.

* AwesomeMusic: The soundtrack is considered one of the highest points both of the anime and the games. The former's opening song, "Arrival of Tears" by Ayane, is particularly epic.

* AwesomeMusic: The soundtrack is considered one of the highest points both of the anime and the games. The former's opening song, "Arrival of Tears" by Ayame, is particularly epic.

** [[BirdsOfAFeather Takahisa and Yukiko]] is fairly popular.

** Yukiko enjoys touching the breasts of the others girls.

* RescuedFromtheScrappyHeap: Yuka Minase to a certain degree for her anime portrayal (depending on who you ask). The middle episodes brought to light her Bitch in Sheep's Clothing persona, but episode 12 attempted to calm the past viewer hate with a TearJerker flashback that showed the childhood memories between Kakeru and Yuka.

* StoicWoobie: Yukiko could count as one. Though she is more of a [[StepFordSmiler Stepford Smiler]] than being stoic, she won't show any kinds emotions dealing with her [[DarkAndTroubledPast tragic past]] and [[DontYouDarePityMe denies any pity towards her.]]
* TheScrappy: Yuka Minase's portrayal in the anime compared to her game and manga counterparts ''really'' ups her {{Yandere}}, ClingyJealousGirl, and Bitch in Sheep's Clothing tendencies towards Kakeru; causing a lot of viewers to despise her as the anime went on. The low point was passing the MoralEventHorizon when she attempts murder by putting a razor-blade in Misuzu's tea in episode ten.

* StoicWoobie: Yukiko could count as one. Though she is more of a [[StepFordSmiler Stepford Smiler]] than being stoic, she won't show any kinds emotions dealing with her tragic past and [[DontYouDarePityMe denies any pity towards her.]]

* StoicWoobie: Yukiko could count as one. Though she is more of a [[StepFordSmiler]] than being stoic, she won't show any kinds emotions dealing with her tragic past and [[DontYouDarePityMe denies any pity towards her.]]

* StoicWoobie: Yukiko could count as one. Though she is more of a [[StepFordSmiler]] than being stoic, she won't show any kinds emotions dealing with her [[DarkAndTroubledPast]] and [[DontYouDarePityMe denies any pity towards her.]]

*** [[BirdsOfAFeather Takahisa and Yukiko]] is fairly popular.

*** The OVA had Yukiko nibbling on Yuka's ear and giving her a deep kiss. Yuka's facial expression? It [[LuminescentBlush seemed]] like she liked it!
*** Some of the official art portrays the girls in suggestive positions.

* AssPull: Rout Kukuri from the fandisс is one for some. [[spoiler: While they are certainly biological brothers and sisters, because Kukuri is a version of his sister from the alternative world, they are not related by blood, but the game never explains how it works, and why Kukuri and Kakeru themselves are completely similar to their versions in the alternative world. ]]

** Kakeru/Misuzu.
*** Kakeru/Shiori too in the game.
** Takahisa/Yukiko

** Yukiko enjoys touching the breasts of the others girls. Kukuri and Yuka are even confused about it. The OVA had Yukiko nibbling on Yuka's ear and giving her a deep kiss. Yuka's facial expression? It [[LuminescentBlush seemed]] like she liked it! She is also often showed in LesYay position with others girls 11eyes in official arts.

* BizarroEpisode: The BonusEpisode episode for the anime, which takes the main cast into the ''Pink'' Night, and perverts their powers in various ways. Kakeru now has XRayVision that can see through clothing regardless of gender; when Yukiko removes her glasses, she acts like she's on an aphrodisiac, including kissing Yuka; Takahisa now has [[MakingASplash water powers]] and can shoot a tiny stream of water from his finger; Misuzu summons ''vibrators''; the Larva are now {{Ridiculously Cute Critter}}s; and Kururi can speak, but nobody wants her to, as everything she says is [[SoundEffectBleep bleeped]] and everything she draws is [[{{Pixellation}} pixellated]]; the Black Knights are now the Pink Knights, an all-pink {{sentai}} team (with [[InTheNameOfTheMoon roll call]]) who die because of ''their own dramatic explosion'', and Liselotte is now Avaritia's dominatrix.; then it becomes a HotSpringsEpisode, revealing that Yuka's AntiMagic has turned into TheNudifier, and it also [[GenderBender turns Kakeru and Takahisa into girls]].

** And a bit between Misao and Scholastica too. According to the Phantasmagoria spell, it seemed Misao was actually the person who Scholastica cared the most about. And Misao lost it when [[spoiler: Scholastica is killed]].

* {{Moe}}: Kukuri

* {{Narm}}: Some of the in-universe fashion sense, like Kakeru's leopard-spotted eyepatch or the Kouryoukan Academy's bizarrely {{Meido}}-like crimson seifuku, can be quite jarring.

* TheScrappy: Yuka Minase's portrayal in the anime compared to her game and manga counterparts ''really'' ups her {{Yandere}}, ClingyJealousGirl, and Bitch in Sheep's Clothing tendencies towards Kakeru; causing a lot of viewers to despise her as the anime went on. The low point was passing the MoralEventHorizon when she attempts murder by putting a razor-blade in Misuzu's tea in episode ten.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: In one of the few instances this counts as a backhand compliment, the most common complaint by critics towards ''11 eyes'' was that the execution didn't do justice to the plot, as they found it surprisingly interesting and well thought for a low-tier visual novel like this.