History YMMV / AskAPony

* TheScrappy: Many of them can be this, but most people debate that AskSeriousDash as one, due to the UnfortunateImplications.
** Lil Miss Rarity is this for some due to how "NSFW" the tumblr and the creator are. Ironically, the tumblr has become less and less NSFW in recent updates.
*** '''DiscordedWhooves''', mainly due to the heavy HypeBacklash and the '''intense''' crossovers that the tumblr does every time, not to mention it's in par with the ''many'' Cupcakes!Pinkie tumblrs, which results with other tumblrs being overshadowed.
**** Miss Twilight Sparkle, due to the immense UnfortunateImplications, the fact Jitters wrote Twilight from being a strong Element of Harmony to a weak and depressive character (all part of his elaborate IdiotPlot and InNameOnly parts), and flat out '''NOT KNOWING ABOUT DERPY'''. Add to the fact the tumblr ''barely'' updates unless Princess Marshmallow jumps into the crossover with Motherly Scootaloo and only exists to be in par with the tumblr. Most people see the tumblr as a TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter and instead focused on forcing in that MTS is in love with Whooves, making her one dimensional.

** FanDumb: A lot of their fans act as though the Vocational Death Cruise is an arc the artist did for no real reason and not a competition [[MassiveMultiplayerCrossover multiple Tumblr blogs have joined in.]] Even worse, none of the other fanbases of the other Tumblr blogs that also joined in are doing the same thing they are doing.

* AssPull: ''Ask Twixie Genies'', [[spoiler:TheReveal that a genie's ThouShallNotKill policy regarding wishes ''only'' applies to mortals. Not only was this never alluded to before it becomes "convenient" for [[BigBad the Sultan]], not only does it cause the series to suffer from the age old "immortals cannot kill mortals but can ''totally'' kill fellow immortals" cliche, but it honestly feels like a tacked on RetCon that was done solely for the sake of a "dramatic" DisneyDeath.]]

* AssPull: [[spoiler:Wishes suddenly being able to kill when used by the ''villains'']] in ''Ask Twixie Genies''.

** Niggertron; Does he truly believe in the low-grade racial stereotypes he's making, or is he just a Creator/MelBrooks-type comedian whose actions and character are based on [[AffectionateParody Affectionate]]-StealthParody?

** ''Ask Piny Twilight'' is beginning to falter in popularity due to the author's recent attempts at publicly slandering and shaming other popular blogs over minor/perceived slights, including ''Ask Princess Twilight'' and ''Ask Brainy Twilight''.

*** Just in case you forgot what sort of ''animal'' [[http://askthetimemaster.tumblr.com/post/22248775015/and-ill-have-to-stop-there-seems-my-tardis-has#notes The Master]] really is...
*** [[CompletelyMissingThePoint ...A pony?]]

* SugarWiki/NeedsMoreLove: Some blog authors complain of overloaded inboxes. Others have the opposite problem.

* NeedsMoreLove: Some blog authors complain of overloaded inboxes. Others have the opposite problem.

* {{Draco in Leather Pants}}: Despite being a complete {{Jerkass}} whose antics include beating Derpy to a pulp (which sent her to the hospital), sleeping with her nurse and her best friend just to spite her, and possibly being an alcoholic, Discord Whooves has both [[http://askmisstwilightsparkle.tumblr.com/ Miss Twilight Sparkle]] and [[http://asklaurastuff.tumblr.com/ Laura the Zony]] in love with him. And they're both aware of his actions. Though to be fair, this probably has more to do with the mods of both blogs being friends in real life with Discord Whoove's mod.

** Many of the darker blogs also suffer from this as they get older. It doesn't really matter what happens; nothing will ever change.

** Niggertron; Does he truly believe in the low-grade racial stereotypes he's making, or is he just a MelBrooks-type comedian whose actions and character are based on [[AffectionateParody Affectionate]]-StealthParody?

** ''Ask Piny Twilight'' is beginning to falter in popularity due to the author's recent attempts at publicly slandering and shaming other popular blogs, including ''Ask Princess Twilight'' and ''Ask Brainy Twilight''.

* CompleteMonster: Pinkamina.

*** Harpoon is, as has been revealed, capable of messing up all kinds of energy except for kinetic. Does that mean he can just disrupt the life energy of anyone he's near? He's also, as of the latest entry in Pendleton Dreadful's story, mutilated Pendleton's wife and unborn son. Some might feel it's pushing into OnlyTheAuthorCanSaveThemNow territory, especially since the reveal of Harpoon's powers.

** She eventually [[spoiler:gets her body back]], so there's that.

* Kuleco from Ask Kuleco at least so far qualifies. While most Rainbow Factory inspired blogs tend to give some kind of humanising moments or PetTheDog opportunities Kuleco is well established to have been a psychotic murderer even before he came to the Factory. The two who are responsible for his employment, Doctor HoofSing and Professor ElCee, to whom Kuleco is effectively TheDragon, can also easily count.

** Many of the Darker Blog also suffer form this as they get older, it doesn't really matter happens; nothing will ever change.

** Many of the Darker Blog also suffer form this as they get older, it doesn't really matter happens nothing will ever change.

** Ask Pun lost almost its entire reader base when the writer decided to push her (''incredibly'' negative) views on the Mane Six on the audience. The person who posted those installments to Derpibooru couldn't bring himself to do so without deconstructing them.

** Except that it is now no longer gone; the blog has returned (With a team of writers/artists, no less) with a supposedly 'improved' version of the character. He -still- has not been 'beaten', he is -still- a sadistic bastard, and he is -still- extremely overpowered; see [[http://pendletondreadful.tumblr.com/ Pendleton Dreadful's Blog]] to see what is going on with him now, as that blog's story is very much intertwined with the character.