Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / Up

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: The reason for so many failures at ornithology in the following WMG]]

It's actualy a defense mechanism by Kevin's species; in order to remain elusive, it sends psychic waves to disrupt brain functions and force people to say outdated facts about birds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Or Russel's dad made Russell go to Carl just to annoy Carl for not selling the house.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In conjunction with the [=WMG=] of Russel being Short Round's grandson, this means that Short Round himself was either a Nocker or - more likely - he too was a kinain, under the guidance of IndianaJones, Archeologist Eshu!

to:

*** In conjunction with the [=WMG=] of Russel being Short Round's grandson, this means that Short Round himself was either a Nocker or - more likely - he too was a kinain, under the guidance of IndianaJones, Franchise/IndianaJones, Archeologist Eshu!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace fixing.


[[WMG: The movie takes place in the same world as ''GirlGenius'']]

to:

[[WMG: The movie takes place in the same world as ''GirlGenius'']]''Webcomic/GirlGenius'']]



[[WMG: The film runs on [[TengenToppaGurrenLagann Spiral Energy]]]]

to:

[[WMG: The film runs on [[TengenToppaGurrenLagann [[Anime/TengenToppaGurrenLagann Spiral Energy]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Alternatively, his father is [[TheDarkKnightSaga Mr. Lau...]]

to:

** Alternatively, his father is [[TheDarkKnightSaga [[Film/TheDarkKnight Mr. Lau...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changed the namespace!!&


** Grief over Ellie's death robbed him of his powers. He probably got them back after the events of the movie, though. It explains how he got to keep the zepplin.

to:

** Grief over Ellie's death robbed him of his powers. He probably got them back after the events of the movie, though. It explains how he got to keep the zepplin.
zepplin.



-->'''Freakazoid:''' ''Do'' I!

[[WMG: Russell was a child from ''{{WALL-E}}'' who time-traveled backwards to the present.]]
Okay, this WMG was mainly built on the fact that Russell was kind of chubby. But still, a WMG's an WMG.

to:

-->'''Freakazoid:''' ''Do'' I!

''Do I''!

[[WMG: Russell was a child from ''{{WALL-E}}'' ''WesternAnimation/{{WALL-E}}'' who time-traveled backwards to the present.]]
Okay, this WMG was mainly built on the fact that Russell was kind of chubby. But still, a WMG's an WMG.
WMG.



*** This troper agrees. He could have died in the ambulance or maybe it is what Elli thinks might happen to him, heck it might even be what the kid wishes assisting the old man would end up as.

to:

*** This troper agrees. He could have died in the ambulance or maybe it is what Elli thinks might happen to him, heck it might even be what the kid wishes assisting the old man would end up as.



[[WMG: Russell's father is the {{Corrupt Corporate Executive}}]]

to:

[[WMG: Russell's father is the {{Corrupt Corporate Executive}}]]CorruptCorporateExecutive]]



** This is untrue. There is an Omega listed separately during the ending credits.

to:

** This is untrue. There is an Omega listed separately during the ending credits.



* Those were the wing bones.

to:

* Those were the wing bones.



The house instead crashed into the buildings that the CorruptCorporateExecutive wanted to complete in the first place, than accidentally killed said Executive ''a la'' Wicked Witch Of East. However, it ended with Russel severely injured, and Carl in a coma, thus dreaming up the rest of it...

to:

The house instead crashed into the buildings that the CorruptCorporateExecutive wanted to complete in the first place, than accidentally killed said Executive ''a la'' Wicked Witch Of East. However, it ended with Russel severely injured, and Carl in a coma, thus dreaming up the rest of it...



The scientific community laughed him off because the "monster of Paradise Falls" was (metaphorically) just another [[ScienceMarchesOn Brontosaurus]]. He declared that it was real, and he could prove it by finding a live specimen. However, if he'd been in his right mind, it would have been possible for him to accept Kevin's kind as being a real example of a Lost World species, instead of killing them and letting his dogs eat them as soon as he realized that an individual specimen wasn't the same "species" as the monster, and thus 1. useless in proving the existence of the monster, and 2. a worthless freak of nature [[CriticalResearchFailure that we already have the bones of]] (''aepyornis maximus''), just a colorful emu that nobody will care about.

to:

The scientific community laughed him off because the "monster of Paradise Falls" was (metaphorically) just another [[ScienceMarchesOn Brontosaurus]]. He declared that it was real, and he could prove it by finding a live specimen. However, if he'd been in his right mind, it would have been possible for him to accept Kevin's kind as being a real example of a Lost World species, instead of killing them and letting his dogs eat them as soon as he realized that an individual specimen wasn't the same "species" as the monster, and thus 1. useless in proving the existence of the monster, and 2. a worthless freak of nature [[CriticalResearchFailure that we already have the bones of]] (''aepyornis maximus''), just a colorful emu that nobody will care about.
about.



* He sold balloons for a living. He probably just still had them leftover from then.

to:

* He sold balloons for a living. He probably just still had them leftover from then.
then.



* I just assumed she was the nanny, and Carl was upset that she spent more time with Russell than either of his parents did.

to:

* I just assumed she was the nanny, and Carl was upset that she spent more time with Russell than either of his parents did.



Muntz was in his early twenties when Carl and Elle were about, let's say- ten. This is why, when Carl and Mutz meet, they can both be old- but not ''too'' old. If Carl is maybe 70 (I don't remember if they actually ''say'' his age, so I'm sorry if that's wrong. XD) Than Muntz would only be 80.

to:

Muntz was in his early twenties when Carl and Elle were about, let's say- ten. This is why, when Carl and Mutz meet, they can both be old- but not ''too'' old. If Carl is maybe 70 (I don't remember if they actually ''say'' his age, so I'm sorry if that's wrong. XD) Than Muntz would only be 80.



The JerkAss wanted Carl out so badly, so he ordered the construction workers to ''accidentally'' hit something and then told them that if should they hit anything, they should be ''aggressively'' nice, knowing that it would make Carl lose his temper and lash out. The CCE probably could have found other ways to have him evicted, but he decided to do this simply to get the message across that you don't mess with him.

to:

The JerkAss wanted Carl out so badly, so he ordered the construction workers to ''accidentally'' hit something and then told them that if should they hit anything, they should be ''aggressively'' nice, knowing that it would make Carl lose his temper and lash out. The CCE probably could have found other ways to have him evicted, but he decided to do this simply to get the message across that you don't mess with him.



He's a short, adventure-loving Asian kid. Why not?

to:

He's a short, adventure-loving Asian kid. Why not?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. [[ThisIsSparta STOP. FAILING.]] [[PunctuatedForEmphasis ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVER!]]

to:

** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. [[ThisIsSparta [[PunctuatedForEmphasis STOP. FAILING.]] [[PunctuatedForEmphasis ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVER!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
possible misuse. There\'s not enough context.


The only logical explanation for how it manages to go BeyondTheImpossible

to:

The only logical explanation for how it manages to go BeyondTheImpossibleexplanation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Russell is the grandchild of [[IndianaJones Short Round]].]]

to:

[[WMG: Russell is the grandchild of [[IndianaJones [[Film/TempleOfDoom Short Round]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed broken links- sorry!


** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. [[ThisIsSpartaSTOP. FAILING.]] [[PunctatedForEmphasis ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVER!]]

to:

** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. [[ThisIsSpartaSTOP.[[ThisIsSparta STOP. FAILING.]] [[PunctatedForEmphasis [[PunctuatedForEmphasis ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVER!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed some spelling errors and added tropes.


*** Even hoatzins have the wing bones shaped like those of regular birds. And many other birds have wing claws anyway. STOP FAILING ORNITHOLOGY!!!!

to:

*** Even hoatzins have the wing bones shaped like those of regular birds. And many other birds have wing claws anyway. STOP FAILING ORNITHOLOGY!!!!ORNITHOLOGY!



** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. STOP. FAILING. ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

to:

** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. STOP.[[ThisIsSpartaSTOP. FAILING. ]] [[PunctatedForEmphasis ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
FOREVER!]]



Because Muntz was tryign to breed a dog with extreme loyalty. Knowing that [=GR=]s are traditionally very loyal, he decided to breed them into his dogs when he finally got his hands on one. Unfortunatly, [=GR=]s are also ''extrememly'' friendly, and though Muntz may have tried to breed the "friendly" out of them.... well, let's just say, it didn't work.

to:

Because Muntz was tryign trying to breed a dog with extreme loyalty. Knowing that [=GR=]s Golden Retrievers are traditionally very loyal, he decided to breed them into his dogs when he finally got his hands on one. Unfortunatly, [=GR=]s Unfortunately, Golden Retrievers are also ''extrememly'' ''extremely'' friendly, and though Muntz may have tried to breed the "friendly" out of them.... well, let's just say, it didn't work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Yes.

to:

** Yes.
[[BluntYes Yes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
disamibig, namespacing


[[WMG: The movie takes place in the WorldOfDarkness, and it's a story about [[TabletopGame/GeniusTheTransgression Geniuses]].]]

to:

[[WMG: The movie takes place in the WorldOfDarkness, TabletopGame/NewWorldOfDarkness, and it's a story about [[TabletopGame/GeniusTheTransgression Geniuses]].]]



* Uh... Can we set it in [[TabletopGame/MageTheAscension the Old World Of Darkness]] instead? That would make Carl a Son of Ether instead, probably Awakened by contact with Ellie (who was so obviously an Adventurer-type Etherite), and he and Russel and Dug can explore a happy '50s sci-fi universe. You know, with a severely downplayed likelihood of psychosis.

to:

* Uh... Can we set it in [[TabletopGame/MageTheAscension the Old World Of of Darkness]] instead? That would make Carl a Son of Ether instead, probably Awakened by contact with Ellie (who was so obviously an Adventurer-type Etherite), and he and Russel and Dug can explore a happy '50s sci-fi universe. You know, with a severely downplayed likelihood of psychosis.



* [[ChangelingTheDreaming The Old World Of Darkness, you say?]] Gather, childlings, and hear the tale of the great nocker Carl, the kinain Russel, and the chimeras Dug and Kevin, and how they did battle with Banality by venturing forth into the Dreaming and reclaiming the lost Mobile Freehold of Adventure's Soul. Our story begins with Carl loosing his house from the Earth's bonds with a cantrip and riding the winds of mortal disbelief out of this darkened world, but it should properly start with the tales of the then-Seelie eshu Muntz he followed as a childling...

to:

* [[ChangelingTheDreaming [[TabletopGame/ChangelingTheDreaming The Old World Of of Darkness, you say?]] Gather, childlings, and hear the tale of the great nocker Carl, the kinain Russel, and the chimeras Dug and Kevin, and how they did battle with Banality by venturing forth into the Dreaming and reclaiming the lost Mobile Freehold of Adventure's Soul. Our story begins with Carl loosing his house from the Earth's bonds with a cantrip and riding the winds of mortal disbelief out of this darkened world, but it should properly start with the tales of the then-Seelie eshu Muntz he followed as a childling...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** We know Titanis turned out to not have wing claws since 2006. STOP. FAILING. ORNITHOLOGY. FOREVAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* You make a rather good case; it could very well be true.




to:

*** Damn. That is sad...and possible. But if true, there is at least one light at the end of the tunnel: if Carl did indeed imagine the adventure, and then relate it to the audience/Russell, it would show that he did still let go of the house/his past, he did know what was important. Muntz would exist as a warning of what happens when you get too stuck in the past, what Carl could have become--he's that anyway, but him appearing in Carl's imagination would be justified as either his subconscious or Carl deliberately adding him in to make a point. And he was trying to pass that insight on. Not as awesome as a real adventure, but still heartwarming in its own way.




to:

* Agreed, makes sense to me.




to:

* This seems less like WildMassGuessing and more like canon to me.

Added: 226

Changed: 1806

Removed: 504

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ah... Can we set it in [[TabletopGame/MageTheAscension the Old World Of Darkness]] instead? That would make Carl a Son of Ether instead, probably Awakened by contact with Ellie (who was so obviously an Adventurer-type Etherite), and he and Russel and Dug can explore a happy '50s sci-fi universe. You know, with a severely downplayed likelihood of psychosis.

to:

* Ah...Uh... Can we set it in [[TabletopGame/MageTheAscension the Old World Of Darkness]] instead? That would make Carl a Son of Ether instead, probably Awakened by contact with Ellie (who was so obviously an Adventurer-type Etherite), and he and Russel and Dug can explore a happy '50s sci-fi universe. You know, with a severely downplayed likelihood of psychosis.



* [[ChangelingTheDreaming The Old World Of Darkness, you say?]] Gather, childlings, and hear the tale of the great nocker Carl, the kinain Russel, and the chimeras Dug and Kevin, and how they did battle with Banality by venturing forth into the Dreaming and reclaiming the lost Mobile Freehold of Adventure's Soul. Our story begins with Carl loosing his house from the Earth's bonds with a cantrip and riding the winds of mortal disbelief out of this darkened world, but it should properly start with the tales of the then-Seelie eshu Muntz he followed as a childling...

to:

* [[ChangelingTheDreaming The Old World Of Darkness, you say?]] Gather, childlings, and hear the tale of the great nocker Carl, the kinain Russel, and the chimeras Dug and Kevin, and how they did battle with Banality by venturing forth into the Dreaming and reclaiming the lost Mobile Freehold of Adventure's Soul. Our story begins with Carl loosing his house from the Earth's bonds with a cantrip and riding the winds of mortal disbelief out of this darkened world, but it should properly start with the tales of the then-Seelie eshu Muntz he followed as a childling...
childling...
** You see, in the time before the Resurgence, Charles Muntz was a pioneer of Imagination-- But as time passed and the domain of Science grew, Muntz became obsessed with "proving" the Dreaming to a world that was losing interest. He vanished into the Far Dreaming while Carl was still a child; yet Carl found wonder in the True Dreamer Eleanor and her pure heart. But once his beloved was lost Carl sank quickly into a Grump's state of mind. Resolving to emulate his lost idol and bid farewell to a world nearing Endless Winter, Carl cast off from the Waking World in an explosion of mechanical Glamour... accidentally drawing young Russel, a kinain whose dreams were strong despite his mundane surroundings, along with him.
*** In conjunction with the [=WMG=] of Russel being Short Round's grandson, this means that Short Round himself was either a Nocker or - more likely - he too was a kinain, under the guidance of IndianaJones, Archeologist Eshu!







That's why it can defy physics. And why Carl scrambles to save it instead of a living, breathing being. And why it lands on the spot Elie dreamed up for it from the beginning, on its own, in the end.

Carl may or may not be aware of that, or maybe only at a subconscious level.

to:

\nThat's why it can defy physics. And why Carl scrambles to save it instead of a living, breathing being. And why it lands on the spot Elie dreamed up for it from the beginning, on its own, in the end.

end. Carl may or may not be aware of that, or maybe only at a subconscious level.




Well, both films did have the wives of the old man of the house possessed by them.

But, Elie seemed to like kids more then the monster house chick, and thus, why Rushell got to live, and why she let him grab the hose.

to:

\nWell, both films did have the wives of the old man of the house possessed by them.

them. But, Elie seemed to like kids more then the monster house chick, Monster House wouman, and thus, why Rushell got to live, and why she let him grab the hose.




The house instead crashed into the buildings that the CorruptCorporateExecutive wanted to complete in the first place, than accidentally killed said Executive ala Wicked Witch Of West style. However, it ended with Russel servilely injured, and Carl in a coma, thus dreaming up the rest of it...

to:

\nThe house instead crashed into the buildings that the CorruptCorporateExecutive wanted to complete in the first place, than accidentally killed said Executive ala ''a la'' Wicked Witch Of West style. East. However, it ended with Russel servilely severely injured, and Carl in a coma, thus dreaming up the rest of it...
it...






* If Kevin's mate was a skeleton seventy years ago, and Kevin's babies are still roughly the size of a melon, then those birds must live an [i]incredibly[/i] long time.

to:

* If Kevin's mate was a skeleton seventy years ago, and Kevin's babies are still roughly the size of a melon, then those birds must live an [i]incredibly[/i] ''incredibly'' long time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Criticizing someone\'s WMG entry because they think it\'s \"boring\" or they think \"more effort needs to be put into it\" is kind of rude.


** [[AllJustADream All in the mind of an autistic child]] can be applied to nearly anything fictional, and frankly, this troper finds that it gets boring.
*** This troper agrees but if you are going to go the dieing dream rout you can at least put some effort into it. He could have died in the ambulance or maybe it is what Elli thinks might happen to him, heck it might even be what the kid wishes assisting the old man would end up as.

to:

** [[AllJustADream All in the mind of an autistic child]] can be applied to nearly anything fictional, and frankly, this troper finds that it gets boring.
*** This troper agrees but if you are going to go the dieing dream rout you can at least put some effort into it.agrees. He could have died in the ambulance or maybe it is what Elli thinks might happen to him, heck it might even be what the kid wishes assisting the old man would end up as.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Perhaps the idea of Paradise Falls being a Land Lost in Time could be related to a labyrinthine map. The only way out of the screwy timeline or what year/day/hour it is in Paradise Falls is up. This could also explain why being away from home for three days wouldn't have worried people as much as it would have, and how they could have gotten back on the same day as the badge ceremony for Russel. This is a good theory. Headcanon forever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ah... Can we set it in [[MageTheAscension the Old World Of Darkness]] instead? That would make Carl a Son of Ether instead, probably Awakened by contact with Ellie (who was so obviously an Adventurer-type Etherite), and he and Russel and Dug can explore a happy '50s sci-fi universe. You know, with a severely downplayed likelihood of psychosis.

to:

* Ah... Can we set it in [[MageTheAscension [[TabletopGame/MageTheAscension the Old World Of Darkness]] instead? That would make Carl a Son of Ether instead, probably Awakened by contact with Ellie (who was so obviously an Adventurer-type Etherite), and he and Russel and Dug can explore a happy '50s sci-fi universe. You know, with a severely downplayed likelihood of psychosis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[http://www.dkimages.com/discover/previews/1519/11653707.JPG Meet Titanis, a terror bird with "wing bones" that could have possibly functioned like claws]]. Following the evolution WMG above, it fits in perfectly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* When the three dogs were shooting at Russell in the biplanes, two of them were Beta and Gamma. I always assumed the other one was Delta.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** ''Aepyornis'' [[SomewhereAPaleontologistIsCrying is not a real snipe]], it is actually more closely related to ostriches. Besides, [[MisplacedWildlife it only lived in Madagascar]].


Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Kevin is not a snipe.]]
He is actually a form of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terror_bird terror bird]]. To survive competition by saber-toothed cats, it turned omnivorous. What Muntz discovered was a chimera between it, a dinosaur, Phorusrhachos, and Titanis. It was dismissed as a hoax, and no proof has been found since. Then the events of Up took place. Its genus is not of any known terror bird, since none are confirmed omnivores. He was nicknamed a snipe by Russell and Carl. Kevin probably doesn't have a common name.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[WMG: Russell is the grandchild of [[IndianaJones Short Round]].]]
He's a short, adventure-loving Asian kid. Why not?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*If that were true, it'd have been awfully hard for him to go on excursions with Teddy Roosevelt, who died in 1919, a full decade before Muntz would have been born to only be 80 in 2009. And something vaguely wheelchair-ish is telling me he wasn't talking about FDR.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ...can Muntz be a dupe who got all his gear from [[WerewolfTheApocalypse Pentex]]? Paradise Falls looks like the kind of place they like to break up for parts and sell off.

to:

** ...can Muntz be a dupe who got all his gear from [[WerewolfTheApocalypse [[TabletopGame/WerewolfTheApocalypse Pentex]]? Paradise Falls looks like the kind of place they like to break up for parts and sell off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
per trs


Because Muntz was tryign to breed a dog with extreme loyalty. Knowing that [=GR=]s are traditionally very loyal, he decided to breed them into his dogs when he finally got his hands on one. Unfortunatly, [=GR=]s are also ''extrememly'' friendly, and though Muntz may have tried to breed the "friendly" out of them.... well, let's just say, [[{{Understatement}} it didn't work]].

to:

Because Muntz was tryign to breed a dog with extreme loyalty. Knowing that [=GR=]s are traditionally very loyal, he decided to breed them into his dogs when he finally got his hands on one. Unfortunatly, [=GR=]s are also ''extrememly'' friendly, and though Muntz may have tried to breed the "friendly" out of them.... well, let's just say, [[{{Understatement}} it didn't work]].
work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Russell was a child from {{WALL-E}} who time-traveled backwards to the present.]]

to:

[[WMG: Russell was a child from {{WALL-E}} ''{{WALL-E}}'' who time-traveled backwards to the present.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* He might not like his son being around Carl for personal reasons.



[[WMG: If above theory is correct, than the movie universe is the same as MonsterHouse]]

to:

[[WMG: If above theory is correct, than the movie universe is the same as MonsterHouse]]
''MonsterHouse'']]




to:

* He likely took it personally when Carl got his house to float away. To him its like a big "up yours".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Quite likely- he figured he didn't have long to live anyway, nor anything to live for with no family, so he decided to pursue the one thing he wanted in life that he could still achieve- going to Paradise Falls, even though it would be a one-way trip, and he likely wouldn't last long out there. He wanted to get there, and didn't care if it killed him, knowing full well it almost surely would.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Nope, one of the songs on the official soundtrack is listed as "The Small Mailman Returns".

Top