History WMG / RedDeadRedemption

Thieves Landing ends up as a smaller version of Reno. Parts of Tall Trees becomes a national park, the rest is cut down or developed.

While it's day when John gets betrayed, it cuts to night time when we see them again. Why did they wait that long before attempting to kill him? Plus, no matter what outfit John was wearing he will be back in his "starter" outfit which implies they changed his clothes for some reason. [[AmbiguouslyGay[=DeSanta=]]] clearly wanted to have some fun with him first.

While it's day when John gets betrayed, it cuts to night time when we see them again. Why did they wait that long before attempting to kill him? Plus, no matter what outfit John was wearing he will be back in his "starter" outfit which implies they changed his clothes for some reason. [=DeSanta=] clearly wanted to have some fun with him first.

The next game will take place when Dutch's original Gang was still around and missions would involve robbing people, banks, and kidnapping people with John slowly questioning what they are doing as Dutch descends into madness and it has an effect on Bill and Javier. Also for a potential WhamEpisode, John's daughter will be shown and she'll be a sickly child who Abigail and Jack tends to but John can't get a doctor to see her because of his reputation. Shortly before The Epilogue, she will die and John would be so distraught over what happened that he can't concentrate thus leading up to the botched robbery where John gets shot and left for dead by his companions thus leading him wanting to walk away from the life he's lead.

This game does take place in the Wild West, and it's entirely possible that Wild West action occurs in the show.

Dead Eye would continue to be passed down, except under the name "[[RainbowSix Mark and]] [[SplinterCell Execute]]".

His motives are ambiguois and he knows evereything about John and what's going on. The Slenderman takes the appearance of an ordinary human [[RuleOfCool because he can.]] He also appears randomly, as if Slendy is stalking John.

While it's day when John gets betrayed, it cuts to night time when we see them again. Why did they wait that long before attempting to kill him? Plus, no matter what outfit he was wearing he will be back in his "starter" outfit which implies they changed his clothes for some reason. [=DeSanta=] clearly wanted to have some fun with him first.

Yeah it's just for shits and giggles, but come on, no matter what other outfit John's wearing, he will be back in his "starter" outfit which implies they changed his clothes for some reason, and while it's day when he gets betrayed, it cuts to night time when we see them again. Why did they wait that long before attempting to kill him? [=DeSanta=] clearly wanted to have some fun with him first.

Yeah it's just for shits and giggles, but come on, no matter what other outfit John's wearing, he will be back in his "starter" outfit which implies they changed his clothes for some reason, and while it's day when he gets betrayed, it cuts to night time when we see them again. Why did they wait that long before attempting to kill him? [=DeSanta=] wanted to have some fun with him first.

[[WMG: John Marston is [[TheDarkTower Roland Deschain.]] ]]

[[WMG: RDR is in continuity with the TomClancy titles.]]

[[WMG:John is the son of [[{{X-Men}} Wolverine]].]]

So famous, that many years later a toy was made in his honor. That toy was named [[WesternAnimation/ToyStory Stinky Pete]].

* ...but not famous enough to avoid becoming a [[http://tfwiki.net/wiki/Shelfwarmer shelfwarmer]], apparently, according to his behavior in ToyStory2.

Jack will become a bank-robber after getting back from WWI, and you play as a FBI agent trying to track him down through the Roarin' 20s and the Great Depression. Your exploits end up being dramatized into a series of books and movies that inspire a young Cole Phelps to become a police officer after the end of WWII.

[[WMG: Red Harlow, John Marston, and Landon Ricketts are [[AssassinsCreed Assassins]].]]

...[[MetalGearSolid Revolver Ocelot]] [[EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory in Valhalla]], living out his favourite fantasy for all eternity.

* Dead eye is John's version of Wolverine's enhanced senses

** If it is, i like to present the possibility that Irish is an ancestor of the McReary's.

* Jossed: [[spoiler: He still gets killed by Ross after he cures everyone]].

Think about how the average player would act in regards to the Homestead epilogue, after the false Everybody Lives Happily Ever After (TM) ending. Would they live on the ranch until the end of there days teaching [[TheScrappy Jack]] and doing mundane chores after having experienced the adventure the rest of the world has to offer? What choice did you make: to continue herding animals or to hunt down the train robbers?

[[WMG: John Marston is a distant relative of [[BurnNotice Michael Westen.]]]]

Is because he spent so much time talking to corpses. They probably appreciated that. Or it's just that he's not that appetising, since he's skinny and stinks worse than they do.

* Makes you wish even more now for a DLC with an alternate ending, huh?

So famous, that many years later a toy was made in his honor. That toy was named [[ToyStory Stinky Pete]].

The Red Dead series is the best Western you'll find in gaming, and McCarthy himself has stated that, at their hearts, all of his stories are Westerns.

* Think about it. The whole game, John is saying to himself, "I hope I wake up soon." What a nightmare." or "I must be dreaming." Thats why McDougal suddenly returns, Nastas is still alive (well sort of), and nobody mentions the freakin' zombie apocalypse when you play as Jack. At the beginning of the game, John listened to Jack tell a story about zombies. He went to bed with that on his mind and thus dreamed everything. Plus the title, Undead ''Nightmare''.

You play as a policeman, chasing around [[spoiler: Jack Marston]], believing him to be the mastermind behind some nefarious series of crimes, but in reality, he wants to escape his life as an outlaw [[spoiler: (much like dear old dad)]]. Depending on [[KarmaMeter how desperate for justice you are,]] you either A) spare him and find who the real BigBad is, or B) gun him down impulsively and lose a valuable ally. [[ReplacementScrappy Any rejoicing]] will quickly be squashed by the fact that [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap he's a much more appealing person in general.]]

[[WMG: John Marston is an ancestor of MaxPayne.]]

* So would that in turn make the ending of MaxPayne 2 a tragic twist [[spoiler: by having Mona die and Max live? The ancestor with the troubled life gets redeemed in death; while his descendent suffers on despite his sacfrices.]]