Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / DominicDeegan

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: The Beast is actually {{Zalgo}}]]

to:

[[WMG: The Beast is actually {{Zalgo}}]]WebOriginal/{{Zalgo}}]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC: Main/DominicDeegan]]

to:

[[AC: Main/DominicDeegan]]Webcomic/DominicDeegan]]

Added: 83

Changed: 287

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Doubtful, since Miranda's mother has black and white hair in exactly the same pattern as Jacob's.

to:

** Doubtful, Not necessarily, since Miranda's mother has black and white hair in exactly the same pattern as Jacob's.
Jacob's, although the point about black hair being genetic is a good one.
** Also note that Miranda is always the one who specifically says "you're my son" when talking to him, and Donovan is always referring to Jacob by name or reference, and does not refer to Jacob as his son.
** Jacob is the only one of his brothers with absolutely no degree of Second Sight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Look how many Americans actually live up to the American cultural ideal of the self-made man (or woman), and how many people in general actually behave in an honorable, fair, honest way all the time: just because a people have cultural ideas doesn't mean the majority are going to live up to it, especially college students, regardless of nationality or species.

Changed: 998

Removed: 425

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


First off, Karnak is the only male who could have had relations with Miranda besides Donovan.

Karnak had black hair as a human and neither Miranda nor Donovan have black hair, but Jacob always has had black hair. The gene for black hair is the most dominant trait of all hair colors. Ergo, if you have black hair, at least one of your parents HAD TO have had black hair.

Both are[[spoiler: Jacob was until recently]] power-hungry and don't care who gets hurt on their way to getting it.

Both hate Donovan's puns and react to them the same way.

Miranda's insistence on scanning to make sure Donovan didn't have children with anyone else seems like 'the lady doth protest to much.'
* Funny enough, I had actually had this first guess the first time Dominic saw that vision of Karnak embracing Miranda.

to:

First off, * Karnak is the only male who could have had relations with Miranda besides Donovan.

Karnak
Donovan. He had black hair as a human and neither Miranda nor Donovan have black hair, but Jacob always has had black hair. The gene for black hair is the most dominant trait of all hair colors. Ergo, if you have black hair, at least one of your parents HAD TO have had black hair.

Both
hair. In addition: both are[[spoiler: Jacob was until recently]] power-hungry and don't care who gets hurt on their way to getting it.

Both
it; both hate Donovan's puns and react to them the same way.

way; and Miranda's insistence on scanning to make sure Donovan didn't have children with anyone else seems like 'the lady doth protest to much.'
* ** Funny enough, I had actually had this first guess the first time Dominic saw that vision of Karnak embracing Miranda.
** Doubtful, since Miranda's mother has black and white hair in exactly the same pattern as Jacob's.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


She enchanted him, his denial about being gay made it easier then normal.

to:

She enchanted him, his denial about being gay made it easier then normal.
normal. He wanted to be attracted to her



He has convinced himself he is gay in order to distance himself from the murderer he used to be.

to:

He has convinced himself he is gay in order to distance himself from the murderer he used to be. This is also why he feels the need to constantly mention the fact he is gay.

Added: 206

Changed: 39

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
two more WMG\'s


----

to:

----[[WMG: Why Szark married Amelia. ]]
She enchanted him, his denial about being gay made it easier then normal.

[[WMG: Szark is bisexual, not gay. ]]
He has convinced himself he is gay in order to distance himself from the murderer he used to be.

Changed: 46

Removed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fixed da Namespace thing, yo+


[[WMG: Donovan is Elan from ''Webcomic/OrderOfTheStick''.]]
It was suggested on the ''Webcomic/OrderOfTheStick'' page that Elan is a Deegan. Donovan is a blond bard (well, before he went gray), and handy with a sword, as Elan is after he TookALevelInBadass. Furthermore, [[spoiler: the red-haired Oracle Hunter is Donovan's daughter. Obviously her mother was Haley, who will join the Blinders in an effort to steal money from them but balk at the mass suicide. She and Elan will break up before he knows she's pregnant, and he'll move to Callan, change his name, and take up with Miranda.]]

to:

[[WMG: Donovan is Elan from ''Webcomic/OrderOfTheStick''.''Webcomic/TheOrderOfTheStick''.]]
It was suggested on the ''Webcomic/OrderOfTheStick'' ''[[Webcomic/TheOrderOfTheStick Order of the Stick]]'' page that Elan is a Deegan. Donovan is a blond bard (well, before he went gray), and handy with a sword, as Elan is after he TookALevelInBadass. Furthermore, [[spoiler: the red-haired Oracle Hunter is Donovan's daughter. Obviously her mother was Haley, who will join the Blinders in an effort to steal money from them but balk at the mass suicide. She and Elan will break up before he knows she's pregnant, and he'll move to Callan, change his name, and take up with Miranda.]] ]]



Oh, remember when Donovan predicted that "that loony" might somehow be saved? Yeah, Mookie likes his foreshadowing.

to:

Oh, remember when Donovan predicted that "that loony" might somehow be saved? Yeah, Mookie likes his foreshadowing.



* That certainly seems plausible, and may be true, but the explanation might not be a direct reference to anything. [[spoiler: Rilian's disguise is magical in nature, and he explains in the next breath that the Wild Edge Territories screw with magic. His "bad experience" excuse could just be a [[HandWave Hand Wave]] to protect his disguise from warping or disappearing altogether.]]

to:

* That certainly seems plausible, and may be true, but the explanation might not be a direct reference to anything. [[spoiler: Rilian's disguise is magical in nature, and he explains in the next breath that the Wild Edge Territories screw with magic. His "bad experience" excuse could just be a [[HandWave Hand Wave]] HandWave to protect his disguise from warping or disappearing altogether.]]



There is a resemblance and Celesto had a past meeting with Chance's parents. Celesto could have wooed Chance's mother and Chance got born. If the beast is after Celesto then he could go after Chance. Chance's parents might have felt embarrassed at the scandal and didn't want anyone to know. So, they keep all seers away.

to:

There is a resemblance and Celesto had a past meeting with Chance's parents. Celesto could have wooed Chance's mother and Chance got born. If the beast is after Celesto then he could go after Chance. Chance's parents might have felt embarrassed at the scandal and didn't want anyone to know. So, they keep all seers away.
away.



<<|WildMassGuessing|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Chance Masters is Calesto's son.]]
There is a resemblance and Calesto had a past meeting with Chance's parents. Calesto could have wooed Chance's mother and Chance got born. If the beast is after Calesto then he could go after Chance. Chance's parents might have felt embarrassed at the scandal and didn't want anyone to know. So, they keep all seers away.

to:

[[WMG: Chance Masters is Calesto's Celesto's son.]]
There is a resemblance and Calesto Celesto had a past meeting with Chance's parents. Calesto Celesto could have wooed Chance's mother and Chance got born. If the beast is after Calesto Celesto then he could go after Chance. Chance's parents might have felt embarrassed at the scandal and didn't want anyone to know. So, they keep all seers away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing some thinly veiled bashing, and one that says \"see another site set up by the bashers\"


[[WMG: The Encyclopedia Dominica]]
The Dominic Deegan Snarkdom comes up with Wild Mass Guesses on a daily basis, far too many have been made to list here, however a lot of it gets recorded in what is referred to as [[http://dominic-deegan.wikia.com/wiki/Encyclopedia_Dominica The Encyclopedia Dominica]].



[[WMG:Dominic Deegan is deliberately taps into BileFascination.]]
The author knows it really is that bad. The fact is that every new plot twist leaves me wondering "Am I sure this isn't just satire of bad fantasy?" I only read it because I need to use up my BileFascination somehow. Are we sure this isn't deliberately tapping into that?
* After the last panel of [[http://dominic-deegan.com/view.php?date=2008-12-08 this strip]]...seems a little more likely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Wait, check that, I'm complaining because many of these werewolf cultural ideals are only introduced when [[ShillingTheWesley Milov is telling Nimmel how awesome he is]], which is made even more aggravating on the back of an arc in which almost every werewolf is shamelessly picking on the most disenfranchised members of their society and attacking each other with minimal provocation (while the ideal that wasn't just introduced still had people shamelessly trying to drive wedges between friends and a bit more shamefully abandoning friends for poon potential). So, unless this is a setup for [[HorribleJudgeOfCharacter Milov to get some]] [[PrideBeforeAFall serious egg on his face]], or at least a way for [[CharacterDevelopment Nimmel to realize how]] [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone distasteful his reasons for going to Coldfire]], I'm feeling a bit miffed, so I snark.

to:

*** Wait, check that, I'm complaining because many of these werewolf cultural ideals are only introduced when [[ShillingTheWesley [[CreatorsPet Milov is telling Nimmel how awesome he is]], which is made even more aggravating on the back of an arc in which almost every werewolf is shamelessly picking on the most disenfranchised members of their society and attacking each other with minimal provocation (while the ideal that wasn't just introduced still had people shamelessly trying to drive wedges between friends and a bit more shamefully abandoning friends for poon potential). So, unless this is a setup for [[HorribleJudgeOfCharacter Milov to get some]] [[PrideBeforeAFall serious egg on his face]], or at least a way for [[CharacterDevelopment Nimmel to realize how]] [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone distasteful his reasons for going to Coldfire]], I'm feeling a bit miffed, so I snark.

Added: 712

Changed: 71

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[WMG: Dominic will get a working leg replacement through necromancy.]]
[[http://www.dominic-deegan.com/view.php?date=2008-05-25 Back when Dominic had his vision of suffering from Mindbreak]], you can see that instead of a metal prosthetic leg like the ones he's been using, he looks like he has a patchwork leg of flesh, not unlike Quilt. Given Dominic's desire to make amends with Jacob at that point, and his later actions of attempting to understand the better side of necromancy through Brian, not to mention his improved opinion on Rilian, I get the feeling that necromancy will at some point give Dominic a new working leg. And with Jacob's enlightenment at Maltak... the two brothers might have a reconciliation and Jacob might be the one who gives Dominic this replacement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Donovan is Elan from OrderOfTheStick.]]
It was suggested on the OrderOfTheStick page that Elan is a Deegan. Donovan is a blond bard (well, before he went gray), and handy with a sword, as Elan is after he TookALevelInBadass. Furthermore, [[spoiler: the red-haired Oracle Hunter is Donovan's daughter. Obviously her mother was Haley, who will join the Blinders in an effort to steal money from them but balk at the mass suicide. She and Elan will break up before he knows she's pregnant, and he'll move to Callan, change his name, and take up with Miranda.]]

to:

[[WMG: Donovan is Elan from OrderOfTheStick.''Webcomic/OrderOfTheStick''.]]
It was suggested on the OrderOfTheStick ''Webcomic/OrderOfTheStick'' page that Elan is a Deegan. Donovan is a blond bard (well, before he went gray), and handy with a sword, as Elan is after he TookALevelInBadass. Furthermore, [[spoiler: the red-haired Oracle Hunter is Donovan's daughter. Obviously her mother was Haley, who will join the Blinders in an effort to steal money from them but balk at the mass suicide. She and Elan will break up before he knows she's pregnant, and he'll move to Callan, change his name, and take up with Miranda.]]

Added: 89

Changed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

[[WMG: The Beast is actually {{Zalgo}}]]
Celesto's eyes become black bleeding holes whenever the Beast gets involved. Coincidence?

Changed: 67

Removed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a WMG, something that was confirmed and discussed in the comic months before this WMG was ever written.


[[WMG:Quilt was partially constructed from a peeping tom/pervert.]]
Specifically, one that had an ''unhealthy'' fascination with Pam. Why do you think his use of second sight always shows directly up her skirt?

* You're right!

to:

[[WMG:Quilt was partially constructed from a peeping tom/pervert.]]
Specifically, one that had an ''unhealthy'' fascination with Pam. Why do you think his use of second sight always shows directly up her skirt?

* You're right!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* You're right!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Quilt was partially constructed from a peeping tom/pervert.]]
Specifically, one that had an ''unhealthy'' fascination with Pam. Why do you think his use of second sight always shows directly up her skirt?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Chance Masters is Calesto's son.]]

There is a resemblance and Calesto had a past meeting with Chance's parents. Calesto could have wooed Chance's mother and Chance got born. If the beast is after Calesto then he could go after Chance. Chance's parents might have felt embarrassed at the scandal and didn't want anyone to know. So, they keep all seers away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: [LeaningOnTheFourthWall The 'viewers' are Seers]]]

to:

[[WMG: [LeaningOnTheFourthWall The 'viewers' are Seers]]]Seers]]

Added: 285

Changed: 119

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Funny enough, I had actually had this first guess the first time Dominic saw that vision of Karnak embracing Miranda.

[[WMG: [LeaningOnTheFourthWall The 'viewers' are Seers]]]
Basically, the whole comic is one big vision/scry on the tale of Dominic Deegan, and we are the seers viewing the past. How none of the other seers have detected this? There's probably some punny explanation out there somewhere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Not necessarily. When we're introduced to the planes, it's stated that the Chaos and Destruction are separate planes. Considering the circumstances under which Celesto became a Champion however (And more importantly, what the cause he was championing was trying to achieve), it seems likely that he was also a champion of destruction anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: Karnak is Jacob's real father.]]
First off, Karnak is the only male who could have had relations with Miranda besides Donovan.

Karnak had black hair as a human and neither Miranda nor Donovan have black hair, but Jacob always has had black hair. The gene for black hair is the most dominant trait of all hair colors. Ergo, if you have black hair, at least one of your parents HAD TO have had black hair.

Both are[[spoiler: Jacob was until recently]] power-hungry and don't care who gets hurt on their way to getting it.

Both hate Donovan's puns and react to them the same way.

Miranda's insistence on scanning to make sure Donovan didn't have children with anyone else seems like 'the lady doth protest to much.'

Top