History TheScrappy / AnimeAndManga

21st Jun '16 1:53:38 PM Willbyr
Is there an issue? Send a Message


Anime/{{Pokemon}} has its [[TheScrappy/{{Pokemon}} own page]]

to:

Anime/{{Pokemon}} has its [[TheScrappy/{{Pokemon}} own page]]page]].



** Korea and Sealand are two other early fandom scrappies and eventually got RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap over time too. For Korea, it was simply a case of fans' memories of the ugly incident with Korean MoralGuardians getting the Hetalia anime pulled from TV fading with the passage of time; for Sealand, it was the HetaliaBloodbath2010 that endeared him to many fans who had previously seen him as only a BrattyHalfPint.

to:

** Korea and Sealand are two other early fandom scrappies and eventually got RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap over time too. For Korea, it was simply a case of fans' memories of the ugly incident with Korean MoralGuardians getting the Hetalia anime pulled from TV fading with the passage of time; for Sealand, it was the HetaliaBloodbath2010 ''Manga/HetaliaBloodbath2010'' that endeared him to many fans who had previously seen him as only a BrattyHalfPint.
14th Jun '16 5:21:44 PM Yalsaris63
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''Manga/GirlsBravo'': Kirie. In the first season her regular (and rather brutal) beatings of AccidentalPervert Yukinari (sometimes for no reason at all), who's supposed to be her ''best friend'', tendency to assume the worst of him if she should find him around a half naked girl, and unwillingness to listen to him explain his actions, did ''not'' earn her any points in the fandom. Neither did her tendency to verbally berate him if she suspected he was being perverted (which he wasn't) by calling ''him'' a jerk. Not to mention Kirie knows Yukinari has a fear of women (as a result of being bullied by them all his life) and developed an allergy to them because of it. One would question why she ''still'' keeps beating the crap out of him in spite of that. In fact, some fans say it's because of {{Tsundere}}s like Kirie that they grew to hate {{Tsundere}}s in general. She becomes nicer in the second season and her number of moments beating Yukinari decrease heavily. For some fans, it worked, for many, it was too little too late.

to:

* ''Manga/GirlsBravo'': Kirie. In the first season her regular (and rather brutal) beatings of AccidentalPervert Yukinari (sometimes for no reason at all), who's supposed to be her ''best friend'', tendency to assume the worst of him if she should find him around a half naked girl, and unwillingness to listen to him explain his actions, did ''not'' earn her any points in the fandom. Neither did her tendency to verbally berate him if she suspected he was being perverted (which he wasn't) by calling ''him'' [[{{Hypocrite}} a jerk.jerk]]. Not to mention Kirie knows Yukinari has a fear of women (as a result of being bullied by them all his life) and developed an allergy to them because of it. One would question why she ''still'' keeps beating the crap out of him in spite of that. In fact, some fans say it's because of {{Tsundere}}s like Kirie that they grew to hate {{Tsundere}}s in general. She becomes nicer in the second season and her number of moments beating Yukinari decrease heavily. For some fans, it worked, for many, it was too little too late.
9th Jun '16 11:49:56 PM gewunomox
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* Creator/OsamuTezuka's ReusedCharacterDesign: Ham Egg. Whether [[Manga/AstroBoy he's a nasty circus manager]], [[KimbaTheWhiteLion a poacher who killed off the hero's parents]], [[{{Phoenix}} or an organ smuggler]], he's found to be a total SmugSnake by fans.

to:

* Creator/OsamuTezuka's ReusedCharacterDesign: Ham Egg. Whether [[Manga/AstroBoy he's a nasty circus manager]], [[KimbaTheWhiteLion [[Manga/KimbaTheWhiteLion a poacher who killed off the hero's parents]], [[{{Phoenix}} [[Manga/{{Phoenix}} or an organ smuggler]], he's found to be a total SmugSnake by fans.
31st May '16 11:48:12 PM siamesecatman444
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Anzu/Téa for either her excessive, condescending friendship speeches/lectures that bring the episode to a grinding halt every time, or for [[DieForOurShip getting in the way of Yugi/Yami]]. It should be noted that the friendship obsession was a [[AmericansHateTingle dub-addition]] -- in the original Japanese show, Anzu was still a preppy cheerleader, but was much less preachy than the dub made her and didn't go into friendship speeches/lectures every episode; male characters like Yugi and Joey actually went on about friendship more. Still Scrappy material, but to a lesser degree. She gets somewhat RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap though, thanks to [[Anime/YuGiOhZexal Kotori]] being even ''[[TheLoad worse]]'' than her.

to:

** Anzu/Téa for either her excessive, condescending friendship speeches/lectures that bring the episode to a grinding halt every time, or for [[DieForOurShip getting in the way of Yugi/Yami]]. It should be noted that the friendship obsession was a [[AmericansHateTingle dub-addition]] -- in the original Japanese show, Anzu was still a preppy cheerleader, but was much less preachy than the dub made her and didn't go into friendship speeches/lectures every episode; male characters like Yugi and Joey actually went on about friendship more. Still Scrappy material, but to a lesser degree. She gets somewhat accidentally RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap though, thanks to [[Anime/YuGiOhZexal Kotori]] being even ''[[TheLoad worse]]'' than her.



* ''Anime/YuGiOhGX'':
** Judai is an AmericansHateTingle case, mainly for being [[ReplacementScrappy Yugi's opposite and replacement]] as well as his original E-HERO and Neo-Spacian decks getting too much focus and being not very good. His very TotallyRadical dub portrayal didn't help matters. He gets [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap a good deal of less flak]] for his CharacterDevelopment in Season 3's second half, his manga incarnation, and his nature-themed E-HERO deck, though.

to:

* ''Anime/YuGiOhGX'':
**
''Anime/YuGiOhGX'': Judai is an AmericansHateTingle case, mainly for being [[ReplacementScrappy Yugi's opposite and replacement]] as well as his original E-HERO and Neo-Spacian decks getting too much focus and being not very good. His very TotallyRadical dub portrayal didn't help matters. He gets [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap a good deal of less flak]] for his CharacterDevelopment in Season 3's second half, his manga incarnation, and his nature-themed E-HERO deck, though.
31st May '16 7:17:54 AM siamesecatman444
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Shingetsu was originally this for his quick introduction, his annoying antics, and his relationships with Yuma and his pals. [[spoiler:Turns out that he was Vector in disguise.]]

to:

** Shingetsu was originally this for his quick introduction, his annoying antics, and his relationships with Yuma and his pals. [[spoiler:Turns out that he was Vector [[EnsembleDarkhorse Vector]] in disguise.]]
31st May '16 7:14:27 AM siamesecatman444
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** However, his BreakTheCutie moments over the course of the show could've get him RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap if he wisened up considerably. His manga counterpart is another story.

to:

*** However, his BreakTheCutie moments over the course of the show could've get him RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap if he wisened up considerably. His manga counterpart is [[AlternateContinuity another story.story]].
31st May '16 7:13:29 AM siamesecatman444
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** For [[AmericansHateTingle western fans]], Yuma gets a lot of flak for being a total goofball (in both dueling and everyday life) and a stubborn {{Hypocrite}}. The problem with him being a goofball is that he has no sense of timing; he'll regularly ruin serious scenes with his brand of comic relief, and he barely matures enough to grow out of this. His dub voice doesn't help.

to:

** For [[AmericansHateTingle western fans]], Yuma Yuma's anime incarnation gets a lot of flak for being a total goofball (in both dueling and everyday life) and a stubborn {{Hypocrite}}. The problem with him being a goofball is that he has no sense of timing; he'll regularly ruin serious scenes with his brand of comic relief, and he barely matures enough to grow out of this. His dub voice doesn't help.



*** However, his BreakTheCutie moments over the course of the show could've make him [[TheWoobie redeemable]] if he [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap wisened up]] considerably.

to:

*** However, his BreakTheCutie moments over the course of the show could've make get him [[TheWoobie redeemable]] RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap if he [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap wisened up]] up considerably. His manga counterpart is another story.



*** Kotori is the franchise's most universally despised character for being TheLoad, virtually omnipresent over the course of the series, and a {{Lolicon}} [[MsFanservice Fanservice]] (which happens in some episodes for no reason ''at all'') who repeatedly shouts [[SayMyName Yuma's name]] for many, ''many'' times. She's so reviled, she practically and retroactively made Anzu get RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap, as more fans realized that, irritating though Anzu could be, she at least did ''something''.

to:

*** Kotori is the franchise's most universally despised character in [[AmericansHateTingle America]] for being TheLoad, virtually omnipresent over the course of the series, and a {{Lolicon}} [[MsFanservice Fanservice]] (which happens in some episodes for no reason ''at all'') who repeatedly shouts [[SayMyName Yuma's name]] for many, ''many'' times. She's so reviled, she practically and retroactively made Anzu get RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap, as more fans realized that, irritating though Anzu could be, she at least did ''something''.
29th May '16 9:00:07 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''Manga/FushiggiYuugi'': The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get disliked. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom. In fact, Miaka is one of the most ''hated'' female characters in anime/manga -- to the degree when fans used a "Level of Suck" meter to measure other shoujo heroines. "At least she's not a Miaka".

to:

* ''Manga/FushiggiYuugi'': ''Manga/FushigiYuugi'': The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get disliked. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom. In fact, Miaka is one of the most ''hated'' female characters in anime/manga -- to the degree when fans used a "Level of Suck" meter to measure other shoujo heroines. "At least she's not a Miaka".
29th May '16 8:59:15 PM BatmanKalEl
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* ''Manga/FushiggiYuugi'': The anime's portrayal of Miaka tends to get disliked. The manga portrays her in a more realistic way. Ironically, [[ReplacementScrappy Mayo Sakaki]] from ''Eikoden'' actually [[RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap replaced Miaka as the Scrappy in the eyes of some fans]] with the release of ''Eikoden''. Ashitare, Yui and Tomo have also gained a degree of Scrappydom. In fact, Miaka is one of the most ''hated'' female characters in anime/manga -- to the degree when fans used a "Level of Suck" meter to measure other shoujo heroines. "At least she's not a Miaka".
18th May '16 6:50:08 PM Doug86
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* ''RozenMaiden'': Hinaichigo and Kanaria are easily the two least popular of the dolls, especially because they're seen as "less mature" than the others. Still, [[AlasPoorScrappy it's kinda sad]] [[spoiler:watching Hina slowly wind down to her inevitable death]]. The biggest reason for the hate toward Kanaria is the fact that [[spoiler: EnsembleDarkhorse Suiseiseki performs a HeroicSacrifice to let her escape, which she responds to by foolishly going back and getting killed like an idiot anyway, rendering her death pointless.]]

to:

* ''RozenMaiden'': ''Manga/RozenMaiden'': Hinaichigo and Kanaria are easily the two least popular of the dolls, especially because they're seen as "less mature" than the others. Still, [[AlasPoorScrappy it's kinda sad]] [[spoiler:watching Hina slowly wind down to her inevitable death]]. The biggest reason for the hate toward Kanaria is the fact that [[spoiler: EnsembleDarkhorse Suiseiseki performs a HeroicSacrifice to let her escape, which she responds to by foolishly going back and getting killed like an idiot anyway, rendering her death pointless.]]
This list shows the last 10 events of 529. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=TheScrappy.AnimeAndManga