Follow TV Tropes

Following

History SoYouWantTo / WriteAKidNovel

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Critical Research Failure is a disambiguation page


Kids will quickly know that you didn't do your homework if you screw up the portrayal of their hobbies. For example, there have been many books using video games as a plot device written by people who obviously do not play them, often running into PacManFever problems. You, reading this, probably do play them if you're under the age of 35, so you won't have that problem. But you still could easily get some other common childhood activity, especially a recent one, horribly wrong. Kids will notice immediately. They might shrug it off and just enjoy the story for what it is, they might be annoyed by your ignorance, or if it's a CriticalResearchFailure that affects the entire plot, they might tell everyone at school how much your book sucked and what an idiot you are.

to:

Kids will quickly know that you didn't do your homework if you screw up the portrayal of their hobbies. For example, there have been many books using video games as a plot device written by people who obviously do not play them, often running into PacManFever problems. You, reading this, probably do play them if you're under the age of 35, so you won't have that problem. But you still could easily get some other common childhood activity, especially a recent one, horribly wrong. Kids will notice immediately. They might shrug it off and just enjoy the story for what it is, they might be annoyed by your ignorance, or if it's a CriticalResearchFailure mistake that affects the entire plot, they might tell everyone at school how much your book sucked and what an idiot you are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


So you're thinking of all those great books you liked to read when you were a kid, with kid heroes who snooped around and stopped criminal plots, or kids just like you who handled problems much like yours but in an interesting way. And you're remembering just how much you loved those kinds of books, or maybe you [[PeripheryDemographic still do like reading them]], and you'd really like to make one of your own.

to:

So you're thinking of [[ChildrensLiterature all those great books you liked to read when you were a kid, kid]], with kid heroes who snooped around and stopped criminal plots, or kids just like you who handled problems much like yours but in an interesting way. And you're remembering just how much you loved those kinds of books, or maybe you [[PeripheryDemographic still do like reading them]], and you'd really like to make one of your own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of ChildrensLiterature tropes, including outdated and sexist ones, accompanied with rather boring writing. It is clearly inferior to its competitor ''Literature/JunieBJones'' as the result. Abby Klein may be or have been an elementary school teacher, but [[WriteWhatYouKnow having the experience for the writing]] doesn't automatically make it good; writing skills are a necessity.

to:

* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of ChildrensLiterature tropes, including outdated and sexist ones, accompanied with rather boring writing. It is clearly inferior to its competitor ''Literature/JunieBJones'' as the result. Abby Klein may be or have been an elementary school teacher, but [[WriteWhatYouKnow having the experience for to base the writing]] stories on]] doesn't automatically make it them good; writing skills are a necessity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of ChildrensLiterature tropes, including outdated and sexist ones, accompanied with rather boring writing. It is clearly inferior to its competitor ''Literature/JunieBJones'' as the result. Abby Klein may be or have been an elementary school teacher, but [[WriteWhatYouKnow having the experience for the writing]] doesn't automatically make it good; writing skills are a neccessity.

to:

* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of ChildrensLiterature tropes, including outdated and sexist ones, accompanied with rather boring writing. It is clearly inferior to its competitor ''Literature/JunieBJones'' as the result. Abby Klein may be or have been an elementary school teacher, but [[WriteWhatYouKnow having the experience for the writing]] doesn't automatically make it good; writing skills are a neccessity.necessity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of every trope used in children's literature, including some outdated and sexist UnfortunateImplications, accompanied with rather boring writing. It's a mediocre example you wouldn't want to follow if you want to write something interesting.

to:

* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of every trope used in children's literature, ChildrensLiterature tropes, including some outdated and sexist UnfortunateImplications, ones, accompanied with rather boring writing. It's a mediocre example you wouldn't want It is clearly inferior to follow if you want to write something interesting.its competitor ''Literature/JunieBJones'' as the result. Abby Klein may be or have been an elementary school teacher, but [[WriteWhatYouKnow having the experience for the writing]] doesn't automatically make it good; writing skills are a neccessity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Black Best Friend was renamed Token Black Friend in TRS. Removing examples that are low-context or don't seem to be about a black Satellite Character whose purpose is to add diversity.


''Literature/{{Pyrates}}'', for instance, has a white male lead with a BlackBestFriend and another friend who is "the coolest girl in sixth grade". He lives in New York City, which is pretty multiracial, so the BlackBestFriend part comes in seamlessly. He appears to look up to his female friend, so we can guess that he might have sought her out. A crush, perhaps? It's not stated, but the setting and the subtle hint that he's impressed by her can drop enough hints that the reader can imagine the rest.

to:

''Literature/{{Pyrates}}'', for instance, has a white male lead with a BlackBestFriend TokenBlackFriend and another friend who is "the coolest girl in sixth grade". He lives in New York City, which is pretty multiracial, so the BlackBestFriend TokenBlackFriend part comes in seamlessly. He appears to look up to his female friend, so we can guess that he might have sought her out. A crush, perhaps? It's not stated, but the setting and the subtle hint that he's impressed by her can drop enough hints that the reader can imagine the rest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Kids will quickly know that you didn't do your homework if you screw up the portrayal of their hobbies. For example, there have been many books using video games as a plot device written by people who obviously do not play them. You, reading this, probably do play them if you're under the age of 35, so you won't have that problem. But you still could easily get some other common childhood activity, especially a recent one, horribly wrong. Kids will notice immediately. They might shrug it off and just enjoy the story for what it is, they might be annoyed by your ignorance, or if it's a CriticalResearchFailure that affects the entire plot, they might tell everyone at school how much your book sucked and what an idiot you are.

to:

Kids will quickly know that you didn't do your homework if you screw up the portrayal of their hobbies. For example, there have been many books using video games as a plot device written by people who obviously do not play them.them, often running into PacManFever problems. You, reading this, probably do play them if you're under the age of 35, so you won't have that problem. But you still could easily get some other common childhood activity, especially a recent one, horribly wrong. Kids will notice immediately. They might shrug it off and just enjoy the story for what it is, they might be annoyed by your ignorance, or if it's a CriticalResearchFailure that affects the entire plot, they might tell everyone at school how much your book sucked and what an idiot you are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Many authors have difficulty portraying kid dialog realistically. This is because MostWritersAreAdults, and also because the way kids talk changes over time. Using modern slang can quickly date your story in only a few years, so try to avoid it, and instead concentrate on using the informal language that kids tend to use and the ways they talk to each other. THAT hasn't changed through the years, as reading the old ''Literature/RamonaQuimby'' books can attest to: their dialog is, for the most part, perfectly sound even here in the 21st century.

to:

Many authors have difficulty portraying kid dialog realistically. This is because MostWritersAreAdults, and also because the way kids talk changes over time. Using modern slang can quickly date your story in only a few years, so try to avoid it, and instead concentrate on using the informal language that kids tend to use and the ways they talk to each other. THAT hasn't changed through the years, as reading the old ''Literature/RamonaQuimby'' books can attest to: their dialog is, for the most part, perfectly sound even here in the 21st century.
century. Meanwhile, ''Literature/JunieBJones'' uses broken grammar as part of its unique humor and to portray how a kindergartner would try to speak.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.

to:

* ''Literature/MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.school.
!!'''The Epic Fails'''
* The ''Literature/ReadyFreddy'' series, depicting the SliceOfLife of a first (later second) grader, is a ClicheStorm of every trope used in children's literature, including some outdated and sexist UnfortunateImplications, accompanied with rather boring writing. It's a mediocre example you wouldn't want to follow if you want to write something interesting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Many authors have difficulty portraying kid dialog realistically. This is because MostWritersAreAdults, and also because the way kids talk changes over time. Using modern slang can quickly date your story in only a few years, so try to avoid it, and instead concentrate on using the informal language that kids tend to use and the ways they talk to each other. THAT hasn't changed through the years, as reading the old ''RamonaQuimby'' books can attest to: their dialog is, for the most part, perfectly sound even here in the 21st century.

to:

Many authors have difficulty portraying kid dialog realistically. This is because MostWritersAreAdults, and also because the way kids talk changes over time. Using modern slang can quickly date your story in only a few years, so try to avoid it, and instead concentrate on using the informal language that kids tend to use and the ways they talk to each other. THAT hasn't changed through the years, as reading the old ''RamonaQuimby'' ''Literature/RamonaQuimby'' books can attest to: their dialog is, for the most part, perfectly sound even here in the 21st century.



''RamonaQuimby'', being a series taking place over multiple years, uses a believable scenario that could be taken right out of real life. Ramona and Howie are neighbors, and their parents want them to play together. They actually antagonize each other at times in kindergarten and first grade, but become friendlier over time. However, in fourth grade, Ramona grows distant from Howie and befriends a girl her age. That's what happens over the course of several books, and that's also the sort of twists and turn real-life friendships take, making it very believable.

to:

''RamonaQuimby'', ''Literature/RamonaQuimby'', being a series taking place over multiple years, uses a believable scenario that could be taken right out of real life. Ramona and Howie are neighbors, and their parents want them to play together. They actually antagonize each other at times in kindergarten and first grade, but become friendlier over time. However, in fourth grade, Ramona grows distant from Howie and befriends a girl her age. That's what happens over the course of several books, and that's also the sort of twists and turn real-life friendships take, making it very believable.



* ''RamonaQuimby'' is one of the greatest SliceOfLife kids' books ever. It portrays the life of a kid whose age is anywhere from 5 to 10 depending on the book, and portrays it very accurately, with a perfect view of how kids view the world and how they act.

to:

* ''RamonaQuimby'' ''Literature/RamonaQuimby'' is one of the greatest SliceOfLife kids' books ever. It portrays the life of a kid whose age is anywhere from 5 to 10 depending on the book, and portrays it very accurately, with a perfect view of how kids view the world and how they act.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''MyTeacherIsAnAlien'' sold over a million copies in its time, and appeals somewhat more to boys despite being first-person from a female perspective. Its suspenseful theme is based on a strong permise: what would you do if you knew your teacher was secretly a space alien who planned on abducting several students in your class -- possibly including you -- and taking them back with him for study? The result is a lot of suspense and snooping and attempts to get proof of the teacher's true nature. Unfortunately, the second and third sequels totally change genre, but the original is still considered a classic.
* ''Literature/MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.


to:

* ''MyTeacherIsAnAlien'' ''Literature/MyTeacherIsAnAlien'' sold over a million copies in its time, and appeals somewhat more to boys despite being first-person from a female perspective. Its suspenseful theme is based on a strong permise: what would you do if you knew your teacher was secretly a space alien who planned on abducting several students in your class -- possibly including you -- and taking them back with him for study? The result is a lot of suspense and snooping and attempts to get proof of the teacher's true nature. Unfortunately, the second and third sequels totally change genre, but the original is still considered a classic.
* ''Literature/MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.

school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''{{Pyrates}}'', for instance, has a white male lead with a BlackBestFriend and another friend who is "the coolest girl in sixth grade". He lives in New York City, which is pretty multiracial, so the BlackBestFriend part comes in seamlessly. He appears to look up to his female friend, so we can guess that he might have sought her out. A crush, perhaps? It's not stated, but the setting and the subtle hint that he's impressed by her can drop enough hints that the reader can imagine the rest.

to:

''{{Pyrates}}'', ''Literature/{{Pyrates}}'', for instance, has a white male lead with a BlackBestFriend and another friend who is "the coolest girl in sixth grade". He lives in New York City, which is pretty multiracial, so the BlackBestFriend part comes in seamlessly. He appears to look up to his female friend, so we can guess that he might have sought her out. A crush, perhaps? It's not stated, but the setting and the subtle hint that he's impressed by her can drop enough hints that the reader can imagine the rest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Well, you'd need a KidHero, unless you're going for historical fiction in which a kid merely witnesses famous events (which is what ''DearAmerica'' and ''Literature/DearCanada'' are about). Kids tend to want characters their age who are active and more adventurous than they are.

to:

Well, you'd need a KidHero, unless you're going for historical fiction in which a kid merely witnesses famous events (which is what ''DearAmerica'' ''Literature/DearAmerica'' and ''Literature/DearCanada'' are about). Kids tend to want characters their age who are active and more adventurous than they are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Changing Link


Well, you'd need a KidHero, unless you're going for historical fiction in which a kid merely witnesses famous events (which is what ''DearAmerica'' and ''DearCanada'' are about). Kids tend to want characters their age who are active and more adventurous than they are.

to:

Well, you'd need a KidHero, unless you're going for historical fiction in which a kid merely witnesses famous events (which is what ''DearAmerica'' and ''DearCanada'' ''Literature/DearCanada'' are about). Kids tend to want characters their age who are active and more adventurous than they are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Kids don't just have the one toy that they take everywhere, they have heaps of toys which they have varying levels of affection for. Girls will often have a collection of dolls and/or stuffed animals, and have a few favourites which they'll be unable to leave the house without - expect stress over which toy to take on camp.

But do keep in mind that there will be a few items that kids will have no interest in, and this is also a good way to flesh out your character. Why does your character not like this particular toy? Is it gendered? Is the character ok with that? Who gave it to them? What do they think about the gifter? Where do they keep it? Do they try to get rid of it?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing wick to Did Not Do The Research per rename at TRS.


Kids will quickly know that you DidNotDoTheResearch if you screw up the portrayal of their hobbies. For example, there have been many books using video games as a plot device written by people who obviously do not play them. You, reading this, probably do play them if you're under the age of 35, so you won't have that problem. But you still could easily get some other common childhood activity, especially a recent one, horribly wrong. Kids will notice immediately. They might shrug it off and just enjoy the story for what it is, they might be annoyed by your ignorance, or if it's a CriticalResearchFailure that affects the entire plot, they might tell everyone at school how much your book sucked and what an idiot you are.

to:

Kids will quickly know that you DidNotDoTheResearch didn't do your homework if you screw up the portrayal of their hobbies. For example, there have been many books using video games as a plot device written by people who obviously do not play them. You, reading this, probably do play them if you're under the age of 35, so you won't have that problem. But you still could easily get some other common childhood activity, especially a recent one, horribly wrong. Kids will notice immediately. They might shrug it off and just enjoy the story for what it is, they might be annoyed by your ignorance, or if it's a CriticalResearchFailure that affects the entire plot, they might tell everyone at school how much your book sucked and what an idiot you are.

Changed: 22

Removed: 592

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Save the reviews for reviews


!!'''The Epic Fails'''
* ''TheAdventuresOfArchieReynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!
.* ''BonechillersRevengeOfTheComputerPhantoms'' shows what happens when CriticalResearchFailure meets bad dialog and a dumb story. Of course, the title alone probably made you cringe, so you can imagine.

to:

!!'''The Epic Fails'''
* ''TheAdventuresOfArchieReynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!
.* ''BonechillersRevengeOfTheComputerPhantoms'' shows what happens when CriticalResearchFailure meets bad dialog and a dumb story. Of course, the title alone probably made you cringe, so you can imagine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Restoring Banned Troper Deletion

Added DiffLines:

* ''TheAdventuresOfArchieReynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!

Changed: 428

Removed: 202

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
inaccurate and defamatory


* ''TheAdventuresOfArchieReynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!
* ''BonechillersRevengeOfTheComputerPhantoms'' shows what happens when CriticalResearchFailure meets bad dialog and a dumb story. Of course, the title alone probably made you cringe, so you can imagine.

to:

* ''TheAdventuresOfArchieReynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!
.* ''BonechillersRevengeOfTheComputerPhantoms'' shows what happens when CriticalResearchFailure meets bad dialog and a dumb story. Of course, the title alone probably made you cringe, so you can imagine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.

to:

* ''MySideOfTheMountain''.''Literature/MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''The Adventures of Archie Reynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!
* ''Bonechillers: Revenge of the Computer Phantoms'' shows what happens when CriticalResearchFailure meets bad dialog and a dumb story. Of course, the title alone probably made you cringe, so you can imagine.

to:

* ''The Adventures of Archie Reynolds'' ''TheAdventuresOfArchieReynolds'' is vanity-published fail that attempts to combine SliceOfLife with an exciting adventure, but gets them both horribly wrong. The dialog is awful, the character behavior bizarre and arbitrary, and the writing repetitive. It has to be seen to be believed. Sample a random excerpt using Amazon or Google Books's "search inside" feature to see for yourself!
* ''Bonechillers: Revenge of the Computer Phantoms'' ''BonechillersRevengeOfTheComputerPhantoms'' shows what happens when CriticalResearchFailure meets bad dialog and a dumb story. Of course, the title alone probably made you cringe, so you can imagine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''MySideOfTheMountain''. The story of a city kid who ran away and lived the life of a frontiersman, and enjoyed it. You probably read this one in school.

Top