Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekS2E6TheDoomsdayMachine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a downright heartbreaking one when they find Decker.
-->'''Kirk:''' "Matt, where's your crew?"
-->'''Decker:''' "On the third planet."
-->'''Kirk:''' "There is no third planet."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoctorsOrders: Discussed. When [=McCoy=] protests Decker taking command of the ''Enterprise'', Spock reminds him that he has the authority as Chief Medical Officer to certify the Commodore unfit for duty. [=McCoy=] eagerly states he'll certify that right now, only for Spock to point out for it to be valid he will also need to provide medical proof (which [=McCoy=] does not have as he has not examined Decker and doesn't have the time to conduct a full examination before they have to obey Decker's orders).

to:

* DoctorsOrders: Discussed. When [=McCoy=] protests DoctorsOrders: Commodore Decker taking takes advantage of Kirk being stuck on his crippled ship to take command of the ''Enterprise'', Spock reminds Enterprise and avenge his lost crew. Bones tries, but can't relieve him that he has the authority as Chief Medical Officer because Decker refuses to certify the Commodore unfit for duty. [=McCoy=] eagerly states he'll certify that right now, only for submit to an evaluation, and holds Bones and Spock to point out for it regulations that allow him to be valid he will also need pull rank. Kirk and Spock risk a court martial to provide medical proof (which [=McCoy=] does not have as he has not examined finally force Decker to stand down and doesn't have proceed to sickbay for his evaluation, but it never gets that far as Decker gets away from his security escort and pilots a shuttlecraft into the time to conduct a full examination before they have to obey Decker's orders).maw of the machine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''Original air date:''' October 20, 1967
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Leitmotif}}: Interestingly enough, the episode's score is based on the technology instead of the characters. The planet killer, the ''Constellation'', even the transporter all have their own themes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Actually, Kirk ''does'' have the authority to order Spock to relieve Decker. He's the ''Captain of the Enterprise'' and ''Decker'' doesn't have the grounds to relieve ''him.'' Decker's plan of attacking the Planet Killer was doomed to failure, Kirk himself was stunned to see that the Enterprise was attacking something he knew their weapons couldn't scratch, Spock had to threaten Decker with being relieved for attempting suicide if he didn't break off the attack, the Chief Medical Officer is right on the bridge observing all this (as is the entire bridge crew), and he's been repeatedly informed the Enterprise's weapons are useless against the Planet-Killer. If he had survived and tried to bring charges against Kirk and Spock, it wouldn't have gone far. A senior Admiral at Star Fleet would have quietly advised him to drop the whole thing and retire, or face losing everything in a court-martial.

Added: 471

Changed: 110

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DoctorsOrders: Discussed. When [=McCoy=] protests Decker taking command of the ''Enterprise'', Spock reminds him that he has the authority as Chief Medical Officer to certify the Commodore unfit for duty. [=McCoy=] eagerly states he'll certify that right now, only for Spock to point out for it to be valid he will also need to provide medical proof (which [=McCoy=] does not have as he has not examined Decker).

to:

* DoctorsOrders: Discussed. When [=McCoy=] protests Decker taking command of the ''Enterprise'', Spock reminds him that he has the authority as Chief Medical Officer to certify the Commodore unfit for duty. [=McCoy=] eagerly states he'll certify that right now, only for Spock to point out for it to be valid he will also need to provide medical proof (which [=McCoy=] does not have as he has not examined Decker).Decker and doesn't have the time to conduct a full examination before they have to obey Decker's orders).



* FeedItABomb: And [[LudicrousPrecision 97.835 megatons]] megatons of fusion energy make for one hell of a bomb.

to:

* FeedItABomb: And [[LudicrousPrecision 97.835 megatons]] megatons of fusion energy make for one hell of a bomb.



* LargeHam: William Windom thought the story was ridiculous and [[UpToEleven purposely overacted]], not realizing he was supposed to be channeling [[MobySchtick Captain Ahab]]. [[GoneHorriblyRight Ironically, he wound up giving what is widely regarded as one of the greatest and most memorable performances of his career.]] He came to appreciate the irony of this in his later life, and he even reprised the role of Decker for ''WebVideo/StarTrekNewVoyages''.

to:

* LargeHam: William Windom thought the story was ridiculous and [[UpToEleven purposely overacted]], not realizing he was supposed to be channeling [[MobySchtick Captain Ahab]]. [[GoneHorriblyRight Ironically, he wound up giving what is widely regarded as one of the greatest and most memorable performances of his career.]] career]]. He came to appreciate the irony of this in his later life, and he even reprised the role of Decker for ''WebVideo/StarTrekNewVoyages''.



* SenselessSacrifice: [[SubvertedTrope Subverted,]] actually. Decker really shouldn't have had to sacrifice himself to the machine. But the method did end up revealing a weakness they ''could'' use to destroy the machine. And really, there would have been no other more satisfying way of rounding up his emotional arc.

to:

* SenselessSacrifice: [[SubvertedTrope Subverted,]] Subverted]], actually. Decker really shouldn't have had to sacrifice himself to the machine. But the method did end up revealing a weakness they ''could'' use to destroy the machine. And really, there would have been no other more satisfying way of rounding up his emotional arc.


Added DiffLines:

** That said, the ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' novel "Vendetta" was basically a sequel to this episode when the ''Enterprise''-D has to deal with someone discovering an upgraded version of the doomsday machine, which also confirms that the machine was intended as a weapon against the Borg. Later novels would re-introduce the original Doomsday Machine and also feature the discovery of a 'proto-prototype' (a more primitive version of the machine featured here).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeathWorld: The two remaining planets in the system that the planet killer has ''not'' eaten. The innermost planet has a temperature hot enough to melt lead (327.5 degrees Celsius or 621.5 degrees Fahrenheit at standard atmospheric pressure). The other has an atmosphere poisonous to human life. It is unclear whether planets we humans would judge inhospitable are also unappetizing for the planet killer, but there isn't any other explanation as to why it is leaving them behind to move onto the next star system.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheJuggernaut: The planet killer is indestructible. Repeated attacks by the ''Enterprise'' can't scratch it.

to:

* TheJuggernaut: The planet killer is indestructible. Repeated indestructible; repeated attacks by the ''Enterprise'' can't scratch it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Clarify a misunderstanding.

Added DiffLines:

**Nowhere in the episode is it stated that the planet killer ingests the entire shattered planet, only that it digests the debris for fuel. Once the machine has taken in a sufficient amount of material it moves on.

Added: 119

Removed: 123

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoLookAtTheDistraction: Kirk uses the ''Constellation'' to divert the planet-killer from moving in on the ''Enterprise''.


Added DiffLines:

* WeNeedADistraction: Kirk uses the ''Constellation'' to divert the planet-killer from moving in on the ''Enterprise''.

Added: 168

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DamageControl: Despite the severe damage to the ''Constellation'', Scotty the Miracle Worker manages to get the ship moving on impulse, raise the DeflectorShields, and recharge a phaser bank.

to:

* DamageControl: Despite the severe damage to the ''Constellation'', Scotty the Miracle Worker [[ResurrectTheWreck manages to get the ship moving on impulse, impulse]], raise the DeflectorShields, and recharge a phaser bank.bank.
-->'''Kirk:''' If only I had some phasers...\\
'''Scotty:''' Phasers? You got 'em. I have one bank recharged.\\
'''Kirk:''' Scotty, you just earned your pay for the week.

Changed: 179

Removed: 177

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Corrected improper Example Indentation.


* JerkassHasAPoint: Decker argues that running to warn Starfleet from the planet killer will allow it to destroy more defenseless planets. Nobody denies this, the problem is that his insistence on attacking the planet killer will get the ''Enterprise'' destroy for nothing.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Decker argues that running to warn Starfleet from the planet killer will allow it to destroy more defenseless planets. Nobody denies this, the problem is that his insistence on attacking the planet killer will get the ''Enterprise'' destroy destroyed for nothing.



* MadeOfIndestructium: The planet killer's hull is composed of neutronium, which is the super-compressed material that makes up white dwarf stars (to give an idea of how dense it is, a matchbox-sized amount of neutronium weighs ''six million tons''). This allows it to easily shrug off everything both the ''Constellation'' and the ''Enterprise'' throw at it from the outside.
** Even the self destruct of the ''Constellation'', which does stop the machine, only works because its more vulnerable internal systems are destroyed. The hull isn't scratched.

to:

* MadeOfIndestructium: The planet killer's hull is composed of neutronium, which is the super-compressed material that makes up white dwarf stars (to give an idea of how dense it is, a matchbox-sized amount of neutronium weighs ''six million tons''). This allows it to easily shrug off everything both the ''Constellation'' and the ''Enterprise'' throw at it from the outside.
**
outside. Even the self destruct of the ''Constellation'', which does stop the machine, only works because its more vulnerable internal systems are destroyed. The hull isn't scratched.



* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Decker v the planet killer.

to:

* RoaringRampageOfRevenge: Decker v vs. the planet killer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Spock:''' Captain, you're getting dangerously close to the planet killer.\\
'''Kirk:''' I intend to get a lot closer. I'm going to ram her right down that thing's throat.\\
'''Spock:''' ''(stands up straight)'' Jim, you'll be killed, just like Decker.

Added: 915

Changed: 67

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TalkingDownTheSuicidal: Kirk re Decker. He fails.

to:

* TalkingDownTheSuicidal: Kirk re Decker. He fails.and Spock try to stop Decker from flying into the planet killer's maw. They fail.
-->'''Spock:''' Commodore, I must insist that you return to the ship.\\
'''Decker:''' You said it yourself, Spock. There is no way to blast through the hull of that machine, so I'm going to take this thing right down its throat.\\
'''Kirk:''' This is Kirk. Matt, you'll be killed.\\
'''Decker:''' I've been prepared for death ever since I...ever since I killed my crew.\\
'''Kirk:''' No one expects you to die for an error in judgment.\\
'''Decker:''' The commander is responsible for the lives of his crew, and for their deaths. Well, I should have died with mine.\\
'''Spock:''' You cannot succeed, Commodore. Your only logical alternative is to return to the ship.\\
'''Kirk:''' Matt. Matt, listen to me. You can't throw your life away like this. Matt, you're a starship commander. That makes you a valuable commodity. We need you, your experience, your judgment! Matt! We're stronger ''with'' you than ''without'' you!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassHasAPoint: Decker argues that running to warn Starfleet from the planet killer will allow it to destroy more defenseless planets. Nobody denies this, the problem is that his insistence on attacking the planet killer will get the Enterprise destroy for nothing.
* TheJuggernaut: The planet killer is indestructible. Repeated attacks by the Enterprise can't scratch it.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Decker argues that running to warn Starfleet from the planet killer will allow it to destroy more defenseless planets. Nobody denies this, the problem is that his insistence on attacking the planet killer will get the Enterprise ''Enterprise'' destroy for nothing.
* TheJuggernaut: The planet killer is indestructible. Repeated attacks by the Enterprise ''Enterprise'' can't scratch it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Decker argues that running to warn Starfleet from the planet killer will allow it to destroy more defenseless planets. Nobody denies this, the problem is that his insistence on attacking the planet killer will get the Enterprise destroy for nothing.
* TheJuggernaut: The planet killer is indestructible. Repeated attacks by the Enterprise can't scratch it.


Added DiffLines:

** Even the self destruct of the ''Constellation'', which does stop the machine, only works because its more vulnerable internal systems are destroyed. The hull isn't scratched.

Added: 441

Removed: 439

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EldritchAbomination: The planet killer. Let's see, it's very old, its origins and motives are unknown (Kirk's speculations about it being a doomsday machine not withstanding), it's [[WeaksauceWeakness virtually]] indestructible, and is capable of generating a jamming field preventing the ''Enterprise'' and ''Constellation'' from calling for help. Decker notes they're not even sure whether it's a living organism or a machine. Or both.


Added DiffLines:

* MechanicalAbomination: The planet killer. Let's see, it's very old, its origins and motives are unknown (Kirk's speculations about it being a doomsday machine not withstanding), it's [[WeaksauceWeakness virtually]] indestructible, and is capable of generating a jamming field preventing the ''Enterprise'' and ''Constellation'' from calling for help. Decker notes they're not even sure whether it's a living organism or a machine. Or both.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


!!Tropes for this episode include:

to:

!!Tropes for this episode include:
!!The Doomsday Tropes:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StockFootage: A shot of Scotty tossed around in engineering is recycled from "[[{{Recap/StarTrekS1E19TomorrowIsYesterday}} Tomorrow is Yesterday]]". His equipment bag disappears in this shot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Decker:''' They say there's no devil, Jim. But there is a..... Right out of hell, I ''saw it!!!''\\

to:

-->'''Decker:''' ->'''Decker:''' They say there's no devil, Jim. But there is a.....a... Right out of hell, I ''saw it!!!''\\

Added: 303

Changed: 997

Removed: 282

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbandonShip: The crew of the ''Constellation'' (save for Decker) does this prior to the episode. Turns out to be a bad move, as they evacuate to a planet that the planet killer then destroys.

to:

* AbandonShip: The crew of the ''Constellation'' (save for Decker) does did this prior to the episode. Turns out to be a bad move, as Unfortunately, not realizing what they evacuate were dealing with, they evacuated to a planet that the planet killer then destroys.destroyed.



* DamageControl: Despite the damage to the ''Constellation'', Scotty the Miracle Worker manages to get the ship moving on impulse, raise the DeflectorShields, and recharge a phaser bank.

to:

* DamageControl: Despite the severe damage to the ''Constellation'', Scotty the Miracle Worker manages to get the ship moving on impulse, raise the DeflectorShields, and recharge a phaser bank.



* DoomsdayDevice: Obviously, although any theories about the planet-killer's actual origin and purpose remain just that.

to:

* DoomsdayDevice: Obviously, although any theories about the planet-killer's planet killer's actual origin and purpose remain just that.



* FeedItABomb: And 97 megatons of fusion energy make for one hell of a bomb.
** [[LudicrousPrecision 97.835 megatons]].

to:

* FeedItABomb: And 97 [[LudicrousPrecision 97.835 megatons]] megatons of fusion energy make for one hell of a bomb.
** [[LudicrousPrecision 97.835 megatons]].
bomb.



** As an old friend, Kirk calls Decker "Matt" when the damage control party first finds him. After he realizes the risk Decker is causing to the Enterprise, he switches to "Commodore" when telling him to give command back to Spock. Later, starting with "Matt, you'll be killed," he goes back to his friend's first name, begging him not to kamikaze the planet killer.
** Decker also does this. When he's first found, he calls Kirk "Jim." Later, though, after taking command of the Enterprise, he calls him "Kirk" or "Captain."

to:

** As an old friend, Kirk calls Decker "Matt" when the damage control party first finds him. After he realizes the risk Decker is causing to the Enterprise, ''Enterprise'', he switches to "Commodore" when telling him to give command back to Spock. Later, starting with "Matt, you'll be killed," he goes back to his friend's first name, begging him not to kamikaze the planet killer.
** Decker also does this. When he's first found, he calls Kirk "Jim." Later, though, after taking command of the Enterprise, ''Enterprise'', he calls him "Kirk" or "Captain."



* GenericDoomsdayVillain: A giant cone mindlessly bent on planetary destruction spinning around in space like a forgotten land mine.



* GoingDownWithTheShip: Decker intended to do this. Ironically, however, the planet he sent his crew to for their safety was destroyed, leaving him alive. Decker had to settle for going down with a shuttlecraft.

to:

* GoingDownWithTheShip: Decker intended to do this. Ironically, Tragically, however, the planet he sent killer wasn't interested in his ship, so his entire crew to for their safety was destroyed, leaving him alive. killed while he lived. Decker had to settle for ends up going down with a shuttlecraft.shuttlecraft later on.



** Another example: The planet killer, well, [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin destroys planets]]. Decker sees it cutting up a planet when the ''Constellation'' finds it. It's pretty much the machine's only function. Yet, when he gives the order to abandon ship (even though life support is still working), he beams the crew of the ''Constellation'' down TO A PLANET.

to:

** Another example: The planet killer, well, [[ExactlyWhatItSaysOnTheTin destroys planets]]. Decker sees it One that happens offscreen is Decker's initial decision to have the crew evacuate to a planet. It was cutting up a planet when the ''Constellation'' finds it. It's pretty much the machine's only function. Yet, when found it, so they should have considered it would continue doing so. Instead, he gives the order fails to abandon ship (even though life support is still working), he beams the consider it would go right back to what it was doing before it engaged his ship, and his entire crew of the ''Constellation'' down TO A PLANET.is killed as a result.



* MadeOfIron: The planet killer's hull is composed of neutronium, which is the super-compressed material that makes up white dwarf stars (to give an idea of how dense it is, a matchbox-sized amount of neutronium weighs ''six million tons''). This allows it to easily shrug off everything both the ''Constellation'' and the ''Enterprise'' throw at it from the outside. On the other side the ''Constellation'' is able to move, maneuver, and attack after some TLC from Scotty, even with one nacelle blown in half and holes all over its structure.

to:

* MadeOfIron: MadeOfIndestructium: The planet killer's hull is composed of neutronium, which is the super-compressed material that makes up white dwarf stars (to give an idea of how dense it is, a matchbox-sized amount of neutronium weighs ''six million tons''). This allows it to easily shrug off everything both the ''Constellation'' and the ''Enterprise'' throw at it from the outside. On the other side the outside.
* MadeOfIron: The
''Constellation'' is able to move, maneuver, and attack after some TLC from Scotty, even with one nacelle blown in half and holes all over its structure.



* NegativeSpaceWedgie: Giant cone of planetary destruction spinning around in space like a forgotten land mine.



* OffTheShelfFX: The show's budget wouldn't stretch to building a model of the ''Constellation'' at the same level of detail as the ''Enterprise'' (since, unlike the ''Enterprise'', they couldn't spread the cost out by reusing it in other episodes), so the damaged ''Constellation'' was represented by a shop-bought Enterprise model with the serial number stickers applied in a different order.
** [[AvertedTrope Averted]] in the remastered version, wherein the CGI of the ''Constellation'' has quite detailed battle damage.

to:

* OffTheShelfFX: The show's budget wouldn't stretch to building a model of the ''Constellation'' at the same level of detail as the ''Enterprise'' (since, unlike the ''Enterprise'', they couldn't spread the cost out by reusing it in other episodes), so the damaged ''Constellation'' was represented by a shop-bought Enterprise model with the serial number stickers applied in a different order.
**
order. [[AvertedTrope Averted]] in the remastered version, wherein the CGI of the ''Constellation'' has quite detailed battle damage.



* SacrificialPlanet: The titular weapon has already annihilated a solar system and all but two planets of another by the time the Enterprise gets on the scene. It's set on a course through the most densely populated section of the galaxy to sustain itself.

to:

* SacrificialPlanet: The titular weapon has already annihilated a solar system and all but two planets of another by the time the Enterprise ''Enterprise'' gets on the scene. It's set on a course through the most densely populated section of the galaxy to sustain itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WaveMotionGun: The planet killer's antiproton particle beam used to slice up planets for consumption and attack the starships.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Actually, I'm pretty sure Spock NEVER addressed Kirk as just "Kirk".


* YouCalledMeXItMustBeSerious: Spock calls Kirk, not "Captain" or "Kirk", but "Jim" when he protests his plan to destroy the machine.

to:

* YouCalledMeXItMustBeSerious: Spock calls Kirk, not "Captain" or "Kirk", but "Jim" when he protests his plan to destroy the machine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
That is not Just Eat Gilligan


* JustEatGilligan: Photon torpedoes have yields comparable to that of the overloaded impulse drive of the ''Constellation'', but they don't even try firing one down the machine's gullet. They didn't even {{Lampshade}} it by mentioning that the launcher was damaged in the attack, or that the subspace field put out by the machine made them unusable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Took a closer look, courtesy of Memory Alpha. The bridge clearly took a damaging hit.


** Bizarrely, except for the bridge. It is stated in dialouge the bridge has gone, but in the new remastered version, it is quite clearly intact!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ReversePolarity: What finally gets the transporter to work properly after malfunctioning for the whole episode is when Spock tells Scotty to try something called "inverse phasing". This is reversing the polarity with help from a thesaurus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JustEatGilligan: Photon torpedoes have yields comparable to that of the overloaded impulse drive of the ''Constellation'', but they don't even try firing one down the machine's gullet. They didn't even {{Lampshade}} it by mentioning that the launcher was damaged in the attack, or that the subspace field put out by the machine made them unusable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AsteroidThicket: A more {{justified}} example than most, as it's the remains of a planet that was recently [[EarthShatteringKaboom blasted to pieces]]. There hasn't been enough time for it to either dissipate or coalesce into a new planetoid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: The episode ends with Spock and Kirk wondering if there are any more planet-killers out there. A sequel to this episode has never been made.

to:

* SequelHook: The episode ends with Spock and Kirk wondering if there are any more planet-killers out there. A sequel to this episode has never been made.produced; Harve Bennett passed it over when looking for potential follow-up stories for [[Film/StarTrekIITheWrathofKhan the second Star Trek film]] in favor of "Space Seed". The popular FanFilm series ''WebVideo/StarTrekNewVoyages'' did a sequel of sorts to this episode (and "The City on the Edge of Forever", and "The Menagerie", among others) in their first proper episode, "In Harm's Way".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Decker:''' '''''[[WhamLineDon't you think I know that?!?]]''''' There was! [[EarthShatteringKaboom But not anymore!]] They called me, they ''begged'' me for help! ''Four hundred'' of them! [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone I couldn't!!]] [[MyGreatestFailure I... I couldn't...]] ''[[[DespairEventHorizon breaks into sobs]]]''

to:

'''Decker:''' '''''[[WhamLineDon't '''''[[WhamLine Don't you think I know that?!?]]''''' There was! [[EarthShatteringKaboom But not anymore!]] They called me, they ''begged'' me for help! ''Four hundred'' of them! [[MyGodWhatHaveIDone I couldn't!!]] [[MyGreatestFailure I... I couldn't...]] ''[[[DespairEventHorizon breaks into sobs]]]''

Top