Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekPicardS3E04NoWinScenario

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SaveTheVillain: Averted after the ''Shrike'' is crippled by Riker. After everything Vadic put them through over the last three episodes, nobody aboard ''Titan'' feels particularly inclined to offer to render assistance to their adversary (plus leaving Vadic and company behind gives them a head start to make it back to the safety of Federation space).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ContinuitySnarl: The Changeling shouldn't need a salad bowl to regenerate for 8 hours in resigoo state. Back on DS9, Odo did... but this was eventually revealed to not be a trait of the species as a whole, as was formerly thought, but a side effect of Odo being a HeartwarmingOrphan who had to ''teach himself'' how to use his powers, and didn't fully master them. Since it moves the plot along, this particular bit of continuity is ignored.

to:

* ContinuitySnarl: The Changeling shouldn't need a salad bowl to regenerate for 8 hours in resigoo state. Back on DS9, [=DS9=], Odo did... but this was eventually revealed to not be a trait of the species as a whole, as was formerly thought, but a side effect of Odo being a HeartwarmingOrphan who had to ''teach himself'' how to use his powers, and didn't fully master them. Since it moves the plot along, this particular bit of continuity is ignored.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Misblamed}}: Like Sisko before him, Shaw hates Picard for his role as Locutus and the Wolf 359 Massacre -- never mind that Picard was just as much a victim as the other Starfleet casualties, that he was forced into the Collective against his will, and there was literally nothing he could've done to stop them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Again, no matter how advanced the ''Shrike'''s armaments and shielding are, it still has to obey the laws of physics. So, if it gets struck by something with enough mass and kinetic energy as the asteroid Riker throws at them, it ''will'' do damage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WhamLine: Shaw joins the conversation while Picard is sharing stories about adventures he had with Jack Crusher's [[DeadGuyJunior namesake.]]
-->'''Shaw''': But, uh, speaking of harrowing stories... Did your old man ever tell you about the time that he and I first met?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ContinuitySnarl: The Changeling shouldn't need a salad bowl to regenerate for 8 hours in resigoo state. Back on DS9, Odo did... but this was eventually revealed to not be a trait of the species as a whole, as was formerly thought, but a side effect of Odo being a HeartwarmingOrphan who had to ''teach himself'' how to use his powers, and didn't fully master them. Since it moves the plot along, this particular bit of continuity is ignored.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also justified because the Titan was racing as fast as it could to keep up with the wave and heading right at the Shrike at high speed. Riker snagged an asteroid in passing and then let it go at the right moment, transferring all of that momentum into the asteroid, which then smashed into the Shrike at that same very high speed.

to:

** Also justified because the Titan ''Titan'' was racing as fast as it could to keep up with the wave and heading right at the Shrike ''Shrike'' at high speed. Riker snagged an asteroid in passing and then let it go at the right moment, transferring all of that momentum into the asteroid, which then smashed into the Shrike ''Shrike'' at that same very high speed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BrickJoke: One that took 34 years to pay off. In "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS2E11Contagion Contagion]]," faced with a situation in which he had no weapons, Riker asked if tactical could arrange for him to throw some rocks at the Romulans. Here, he uses the tractor beam to throw an asteroid at the ''Shrike''.

to:

* BrickJoke: One that took 34 years to pay off. In "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS2E11Contagion Contagion]]," Contagion]]", faced with a situation in which he had no weapons, Riker asked if tactical could arrange for him to throw some rocks at the Romulans. Here, he uses the tractor beam to throw an asteroid at the ''Shrike''.



** Shaw wonders aloud why a changeling would infiltrate the transporter room and replace its duty officer. [[spoiler:Oh, there's a reason...]]
** Though Shaw is aware of what Picard accomplished in the previous season in creating a kinder, gentler Borg, [[spoiler:he disregards it: "The ''real'' Borg are still out there." JerkassHasAPoint.]]
** Jack's hallucination while washing his face is nearly identical to [[spoiler:the nightmare his father experienced back in ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact'']].

to:

** Shaw wonders aloud why a changeling would infiltrate replace the transporter room and replace its duty officer. [[spoiler:Oh, there's a reason...]]
officer, when there are far more important positions it could have targeted.
** Though Shaw is aware of what Picard accomplished in the previous season in creating a kinder, gentler Borg, [[spoiler:he he disregards it: "The ''real'' Borg are still out there." JerkassHasAPoint.]]
"
** Jack's hallucination while washing his face is nearly identical to [[spoiler:the the nightmare his father experienced back in ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact'']].''Film/StarTrekFirstContact''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InnocentlyInsensitive: A flashback shows that Jack did indeed visit Picard at Ten Forward, but just asked if Picard ever had a real family without introducing himself. Surrounded by a bunch of cadets and that being an understandably sore subject, Picard simply says that Starfleet is the only family he's ever needed, not exactly the thing Jack came to hear.

to:

* InnocentlyInsensitive: A two-way version. A flashback shows that Jack did indeed visit Picard at Ten Forward, but just asked if Picard ever had a real family without introducing himself. Surrounded by a bunch of cadets and that being an understandably sore subject, subject given the death of his brother Robert and nephew Renée, Picard simply says that Starfleet is the only family he's ever needed, not exactly the thing Jack came to hear.hear.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Picard's "Starfleet is the only family I have ''ever'' needed" rings hollow when you recall that this conversation took place in 2396, when ''he had already resigned from it'' in the wake of the Romulan Supernova and the destruction of Mars (''PIC'': "[[Recap/StarTrekPicardS1E01Remembrance Remembrance]]"). The cadets are apparently starry-eyed enough to ignore the FridgeLogic of his statement.

to:

** Picard's "Starfleet is the only family I have ''ever'' needed" rings hollow when you recall that this conversation took place in 2396, when ''he had already resigned from it'' in the wake of the Romulan Supernova and the destruction of Mars (''PIC'': "[[Recap/StarTrekPicardS1E01Remembrance Remembrance]]"). The cadets are apparently starry-eyed enough to ignore the FridgeLogic of his statement.inconsistency, and Picard has numerous reasons to be more charitable towards Starfleet in this moment than he would in a more honest setting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PsychologicalProjection: Shaw's furious words to Picard on the Holodeck show that like Sisko 30 years earlier during "Emissary", he likwise blames Picard for Wolf 359 and losing everything. ''Unlike'' Sisko, however, Shaw's words reveal much of his anger at Picard is really towards ''himself'' and his self-loathing and hatred from his SurvivorsGuilt.

to:

* PsychologicalProjection: Shaw's furious words to Picard on the Holodeck show that like Sisko 30 years earlier during "Emissary", he likwise likewise blames Picard for Wolf 359 and losing everything. ''Unlike'' Sisko, however, Shaw's words reveal much of his anger at Picard is really towards ''himself'' and his self-loathing and hatred from his SurvivorsGuilt.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Shaw wonders aloud why a changeling would infiltrate the transporter room and replace its duty officer. [[spoiler:Oh, there's a reason...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* InVinoVeritas: Just before Shaw begins laying on his story about Wolf 359, he says he is "out of sorts" with Doctor Crusher having prescribed him a generous dose of painkillers.

Added: 354

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RiddleForTheAges: No really, how ''did'' the Hirogen wind up in the Alpha Quadrant?



* RousseauWasRight: From Shaw's tale of Wolf 359, those who gathered at the last remaining escape pod didn't fight over the limited seats, but instead waited for orders. The one who chose the survivors didn't include herself either, but instead willingly chose to die.



* ThisIsGonnaSuck: When Shaw tells Picard that they first met on Stardate 44002.3, Picard quietly realizes that he's about to get an earful from a Wolf 359 survivor.

to:

* ThisIsGonnaSuck: When Shaw tells Picard that they first met on Stardate 44002.3, Picard quietly realizes that he's about to get an earful from a Wolf 359 survivor. Again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThisIsGonnaSuck: When Shaw tells Picard that they first met on Stardate 44002.3, Picard quietly realizes that he's about to get an earful from a Wolf 359 survivor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Shaw:''' ''(to Jack)'' You know where your old man was on that day? He was on that Borg cube, setting the world on fire! ''(to Picard)'' Forget about all that weird shit on the ''Stargazer''. The real Borg are still out there, and they have a name for you: Locutus of Borg. The only Borg so deadly they gave him a goddamn name!

to:

-->'''Shaw:''' ''(to Jack)'' You know where your old man was on that day? He was on that Borg cube, setting the world on fire! ''on fire''! ''(to Picard)'' Forget about all that weird shit on the ''Stargazer''. The real Borg are still out there, and they have a name for you: Locutus of Borg. The only Borg so deadly they gave him a goddamn name!



* FlashbackEcho: Shaw has a monologue describing the evacuation of the USS Constance after Wolf 359. Faint sound effects can be heard of weapons fire, alarms and a murmuring crowd as he describes what happened, none of it diegetic but [[ShellShockedVeteran underlining that he is reliving those events]].

to:

* FlashbackEcho: Shaw has a monologue describing the evacuation of the USS Constance ''Constance'' after Wolf 359. Faint sound effects can be heard of weapons fire, alarms and a murmuring crowd as he describes what happened, none of it diegetic but [[ShellShockedVeteran underlining that he is reliving those events]].



* SurvivorsGuilt: Shaw was an engineer during Wolf 359, and was one of ten officers out of fifty who was selected to evacuate in the remaining escape pod. He doesn't get why he, "a dipshit from Chicago," deserved to live more than those other forty souls.

to:

* SurvivorsGuilt: Shaw was an engineer during Wolf 359, and was one of ten officers out of fifty who was selected ordered to evacuate in the remaining escape pod. He doesn't get why he, "a "some dipshit from Chicago," deserved to live more than those other forty souls.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChekhovsGun: The ''Titan'' spends much of the episode getting hit by regular bursts of energy from deep inside the nebula. Those bursts turn out to be the equivalent of labor contractions, leading to the birth of space-dwelling jellyfish.


Added DiffLines:

* TheMetricSystemIsHereToStay: A rare inversion when Riker tells Picard that Thad's grave was six feet deep instead of, say, something close to two meters. Then again, it may just be for the longstanding tradition about how deep graves are.


Added DiffLines:

* TheNothingAfterDeath: Riker tells Picard that after Thad died, he lost any faith that there was anything beyond the mortal world.
-->'''Riker:''' When we buried our son... I watched the coffin being lowered into the ground. It was only six feet, but it was so dark. It was like infinite emptiness. And you and I have traveled to the far reaches of space, and yet there's nothing, nothing that proved to me that there is anything... after. And I've tried to shake that. ''(sighs)'' Deanna, as you know, feels everything. But she couldn't live with me feeling nothing. And neither could I, which is why I left and I came here. I was running from this. Only to find it again. Well... This is the end, my friend.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheHunterBecomesTheHunted: Picard tells the Starfleet cadets of how he and Worf turned the tables on a Hirogen who hunted him, making him the prey instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spoilers for future episodes


** Though Shaw is aware of what Picard accomplished in the previous season in creating a kinder, gentler Borg, he disregards it: "The ''real'' Borg are still out there." JerkassHasAPoint.
** Jack's hallucination while washing his face is nearly identical to the nightmare his father experienced back in ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact''.

to:

** Though Shaw is aware of what Picard accomplished in the previous season in creating a kinder, gentler Borg, he [[spoiler:he disregards it: "The ''real'' Borg are still out there." JerkassHasAPoint.
JerkassHasAPoint.]]
** Jack's hallucination while washing his face is nearly identical to the [[spoiler:the nightmare his father experienced back in ''Film/StarTrekFirstContact''.''Film/StarTrekFirstContact'']].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RousingSpeech: Riker addresses the crew of the ''Titan'' before executing the plan.
-->'''Riker:''' Crew of the USS ''Titan''. This is Acting Captain William Riker. We have a plan to escape, but to do so, we'll need to draw every ounce of power that we have left on this ship. We're gonna use these energy waves to jump-start us. I'm not gonna lie. It's a hell of a risk. Anything goes wrong, well... anything goes wrong, we'll all know pretty quick. I know many of you don't know me. But like any captain, I know something about you. I'm only as effective as you are. And I also know from experience that if we all hang tight and work together... we're gonna get through this.

Added: 433

Changed: 301

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NoodleIncident: The Starfleet cadets ask Admiral Picard about an encounter with the Hirogen some time after ''Voyager'''s return (since one cadet asks whether Picard had any help from Admiral Janeway). In the same breath, they ask how a Hirogen ended up clear across the galaxy from the Delta Quadrant to begin with.

to:

* NoodleIncident: NoodleIncident:
**
The Starfleet cadets ask Admiral Picard about an encounter with the Hirogen some time after ''Voyager'''s return (since one cadet asks whether Picard had any help from Admiral Janeway). In the same breath, they ask how a Hirogen ended up clear across the galaxy from the Delta Quadrant to begin with.with.
** Jack tells his father a story about resetting an Andorian's broken antenna, but the scene transitions midway to Shaw and Seven.

Added: 973

Changed: 381

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForgottenFirstMeeting: Shaw reveals that he met Picard once before, something Picard is visibly surprised by. Then Shaw reveals it was at Wolf 359...



* TroubledSympatheticBigot: Shaw is an established asshole, with a strong hatred of any ex-Borg. The revelation that he's a traumatized survivor of Wolf 359 puts all that in a much more sympathetic light.



* UnspokenPlanGuarantee: As Shaw and Seven work to open the nacelle housings, Shaw notes that if the Changeling is going to sabotage something, it'll be what they're doing right now. To that end, Seven contacts Riker, and the viewer only hears Riker ending the conversation. When Ensign La Forge shows up to help, Seven reveals that she ordered Riker to not send anyone under any circumstances.

to:

* UnspokenPlanGuarantee: As Both versions are shown with Shaw and Seven:
** Shaw recommends that Seven find the Changeling's pot, find any "resigoo" in it, and then have the ship's internal sensors scan for that same goo. She finds the pot, but the Changeling attacks her and vaporizes it before she can do any scanning.
**As
Shaw and Seven work to open the nacelle housings, Shaw notes that if the Changeling is going to sabotage something, it'll be what they're doing right now. To that end, Seven contacts Riker, and the viewer only hears Riker ending the conversation. When Ensign La Forge shows up to help, Seven reveals that she ordered Riker to not send anyone under any circumstances.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DigitalDeaging: The flashbacks have Creator/PatrickStewart and Creator/JonathanFrakes digitally deaged to look the way they looked shortly after ''Film/StarTrekNemesis'' was released.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DigitalDeaging: The flashbacks have Creator/PatrickStewart and Creator/JonathanFrakes digitally deaged to look the way they looked shortly after ''Film/StarTrekNemesis'' was released.

Top