Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / TheIshmael

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{300}}'' has Herodotus as the narrator, despite the main character being Leonidas.

to:

* ''{{300}}'' ''300'' has Herodotus as the narrator, despite the main character being Leonidas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*''{{300}}'' has Herodotus as the narrator, despite the main character being Leonidas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This is probably what Milanor of ''YggdraUnion'' was intended to be, but because Yggdra winds up being the viewpoint character of most of the game (right down to our getting her internal monologues), he just winds up being a rather useless side character [[TheWesley who gets a disproportionate amount of lines]] for someone who's not all that important.

to:

* This is probably what Milanor of ''YggdraUnion'' was intended to be, but because Yggdra winds up being the viewpoint character of most of the game (right down to our getting her internal monologues), he just winds up being a rather useless side character [[TheWesley [[CreatorsPet who gets a disproportionate amount of lines]] for someone who's not all that important.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* {{Fairy Tail}} is undeniably Lucys story. Lucys story about Natsu and Fairy Tail.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also TheWatson, whose job it is to merely ''set up'' exposition.

to:

See also TheWatson, whose job it is to merely ''set up'' exposition.
exposition, and POVBoyPosterGirl, where the boy often resembles this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Gil Abad in the Spanish novel series ''Marijuli & Gil Abad''. Despite being one of the titular characters, he's a [[TheWatson Watson]] at best.

to:

* Gil Abad in the Spanish novel series ''Marijuli & Gil Abad''. Despite being one of the titular characters, he's a [[TheWatson Watson]] at best.
best. The (few) chapters that aren't written under his point of view are all in a different font, to make this tope even more obvious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Gil Abad in the Spanish novel series ''Marijuli & Gil Abad''. Despite being one of the titular characters, he's a [[TheWatson Watson]] at best.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[YourMileageMayVary Some]] consider this an [[AvertedTrope aversion]] if you take into account DeathOfTheAuthor.

to:

** [[YourMileageMayVary Some]] consider this an [[AvertedTrope aversion]] if you take into account DeathOfTheAuthor. [[hottip:*: Lightning shares the focus between several other characters equally throughout the entire game. Taking that into account, FFXIII features more of an EnsembleCast rather than one main character specifically.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**[[YourMileageMayVary Some]] consider this an [[AvertedTrope aversion]] if you take into account DeathOfTheAuthor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[LegacyCharacter The various]] Links from ''TheLegendOfZelda'' act as this, but especially in ''[[{{ptitle6ibfdbcv}} Majora's Mask]]'', where the {{NPC}}s are given an unusual amount of in depth characterization.

to:

* [[LegacyCharacter The various]] Links from ''TheLegendOfZelda'' act as this, but especially in ''[[{{ptitle6ibfdbcv}} Majora's Mask]]'', ''MajorasMask'', where the {{NPC}}s are given an unusual amount of in depth characterization.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[LampshadeHanging Lampshaded]] in ''FinalFantasyXII'' where Vaan himself admits he's "just along for the ride." (though he is the main character of the story in the SpinOff ''RevenantWings'') and his role is decent untill he joins Ashe.

to:

* [[LampshadeHanging Lampshaded]] in ''FinalFantasyXII'' where Vaan himself admits he's "just along for the ride." (though he is the main character of the story in the SpinOff ''RevenantWings'') and his role is decent untill he joins Ashe.''RevenantWings'').



** In a bit of a twist, when he says the words "This is ''our'' story." is the point in the story where he's managed to wrestle the spotlight back from Yuna.

to:

** In a bit of a twist, when he says the words "This is ''our'' story." story" is the point in the story where he's managed to wrestle the spotlight back from Yuna.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Dilios telling the story of ''ThreeHundred''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
mismatched spoiler tags~


** Subverted in ''The Rolling Bootlegs'': while it appears that Maiza relating the story about his friend and subordinate Firo to a Japanese tourist, [[spoiler:it's actually [[ActuallyIAmHim Firo himself]] telling the tale, and the tourist just assumed otherwise because Firo never properly introduced himself and was wearing glasses like Maiza's.

to:

** Subverted in ''The Rolling Bootlegs'': while it appears that Maiza relating the story about his friend and subordinate Firo to a Japanese tourist, [[spoiler:it's actually [[ActuallyIAmHim Firo himself]] telling the tale, and the tourist just assumed otherwise because Firo never properly introduced himself and was wearing glasses like Maiza's.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"Call me Ishmael."''

to:

->''"Call ->''"[[TropeNamer Call me Ishmael.Ishmael]]."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Arguably the first three ''PiratesOfTheCaribbean'' movies. While Jack Sparrow (and maybe Will Turner) is our hero, the films are actually told from Elizabeth Swann's point of view.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Subverted in ''The Rolling Bootlegs'': while it appears that Maiza relating the story about his friend and subordinate Firo to a Japanese tourist, [[spoiler:it's actually [[ActuallyIAmHim Firo himself]] telling the tale, and the tourist just assumed otherwise because Firo never properly introduced himself and was [[BrainySpecs wearing glasses]] like Maiza's]].

to:

** Subverted in ''The Rolling Bootlegs'': while it appears that Maiza relating the story about his friend and subordinate Firo to a Japanese tourist, [[spoiler:it's actually [[ActuallyIAmHim Firo himself]] telling the tale, and the tourist just assumed otherwise because Firo never properly introduced himself and was [[BrainySpecs wearing glasses]] glasses like Maiza's]].Maiza's.

Changed: 199

Removed: 43

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Narrator (a pudgy snowman) in the famous Rankin/Bass animated adaptation of ''Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer''. Apparently, his only ''raison d'etre'' besides telling the audience the story is to sing and perform on the guitar songs that are only tangentially related to the plot. The story's ''real'' protagonist, of course, is Rudolph - but since we are viewing ''everything'' through the Narrator's perspective, Herbie the Elf and the Misfit Toys also are depicted as well-rounded characters, and arguably alternate protagonists themselves. (Of course, the FridgeLogic - no pun intended - of a snowman still being around many years later to tell the story when there have obviously been many summers as well as winters is never addressed.)
** A snowman...who lives in the North Pole.

to:

* The Narrator (a pudgy snowman) in the famous Rankin/Bass animated adaptation of ''Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer''. Apparently, his only ''raison d'etre'' besides telling the audience the story is to sing and perform on the guitar songs that are only tangentially related to the plot. The story's ''real'' protagonist, of course, is Rudolph - but since we are viewing ''everything'' through the Narrator's perspective, Herbie the Elf and the Misfit Toys also are depicted as well-rounded characters, and arguably alternate protagonists themselves. (Of course, the FridgeLogic - no pun intended - of a snowman still being around many years later to tell the story when there have obviously been many summers as well as winters is never addressed.)\n** A snowman...who lives in the North Pole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Since no one seems to be able to make the Ringworld entry a fitting example, it\'s yanked.


* In LarryNiven's ''The Ringworld Throne'', Louis Wu (the protagonist of all of the other ''{{Ringworld}}'' novels) serves as TheIshmael. The actual protagonist is Tunesmith, the Night People Protector.
** You may be CompletelyMissingThePoint. [[spoiler:Louis Wu chose the king of Ringworld when he said (paraphrased). "You let Fist of God hit Ringworld. I deem you unworthy of the Ringworld Throne!]]
*** Note the TitleDrop.
*** Note that during the post fight reminiscing [[spoiler: Louis Wu commented that the Protector he defeated was fighting purely on instinct. Not thinking about what he was doing. For a Protector this is the equivalent of barely trying. i.e. committing suicide since Wu's judgment mattered that much.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added \"Withnail and I\" example.



to:

* The unnamed narrator in ''WithnailAndI''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Although he's the title character, ''BeauGeste'' is told from the perspective of Michael's younger brother because he's [spoiler:the only of the three brothers to survive the entire story.]]

to:

* Although he's the title character, ''BeauGeste'' is told from the perspective of Michael's younger brother because he's [spoiler:the [[spoiler:the only of the three brothers to survive the entire story.]]

Changed: 551

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Keiichi in ''HigurashiNoNakuKoroNi'' is actually only the second most important character. He's certainly TheHero, but the story isn't about TheHero. [[spoiler:The story is actually about the often overshadowed Furude Rika, which is kept a secret until the end because the only thing she doesn't know about the plot is the reason it's even necessary.]] This makes for an interesting case where Keiichi is not actually a ''full'' example of the trope because the actual protagonist is incredibly passive while undeniably being the focus of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing some grocer\'s apostrophes (or is that grocers\' apostrophes?).


** Originally Carrot was going to be the viewpoint character, but then Pratchett decided it would be more interesting to leave his thoughts out of the narrative, and shifted the viewpoint to Vimes. This ended up having [[EnsembleDarkhorse very interesting results]]. In fact, in the entire series, there is exactly one page written from Carrot's point of view, even if the story is revolving around him. Sometimes the book spends some time on other character's thoughts on what Carrot is thinking, because he's like a well: both extremely simple, and extremely deep.

to:

** Originally Carrot was going to be the viewpoint character, but then Pratchett decided it would be more interesting to leave his thoughts out of the narrative, and shifted the viewpoint to Vimes. This ended up having [[EnsembleDarkhorse very interesting results]]. In fact, in the entire series, there is exactly one page written from Carrot's point of view, even if the story is revolving around him. Sometimes the book spends some time on other character's characters' thoughts on what Carrot is thinking, because he's like a well: both extremely simple, and extremely deep.



* Robert Graves's historical novel, ''Count Belisarius'' is narrated by a servant of Belisarius's wife.

to:

* Robert Graves's Graves' historical novel, ''Count Belisarius'' is narrated by a servant of Belisarius's Belisarius' wife.



* Just about all of H.G. Wells's books, including the above-mentioned ''Island of Dr. Moreau'' and ''The Time Machine,'' fall prey to this. Perhaps the only novel to avert this is ''TheWarOfTheWorlds,'' where the unnamed narrator is the protagonist by default because no other major characters last for more than a handful of chapters or have any real motives or character development.

to:

* Just about all of H.G. Wells's Wells' books, including the above-mentioned ''Island of Dr. Moreau'' and ''The Time Machine,'' fall prey to this. Perhaps the only novel to avert this is ''TheWarOfTheWorlds,'' where the unnamed narrator is the protagonist by default because no other major characters last for more than a handful of chapters or have any real motives or character development.



* Used often in the ''DragonQuest'' series, especially in ''DragonQuestVIII'' [[spoiler: where King Trode and Princess Medea are the main characters and the The Hero barely get's any development until the post-game]] and DragonQuestV [[spoiler: where arguably your mother or your children are the main characters]].

to:

* Used often in the ''DragonQuest'' series, especially in ''DragonQuestVIII'' [[spoiler: where King Trode and Princess Medea are the main characters and the The Hero barely get's gets any development until the post-game]] and DragonQuestV [[spoiler: where arguably your mother or your children are the main characters]].



** Then Yggdra gets kidnapped. [[AscendedExtra Who will be the one]] [[KnightinShiningArmor that lead the team to rescue her?]] That's probably the only time the player's playing Milanor's as a full time hero.

to:

** Then Yggdra gets kidnapped. [[AscendedExtra Who will be the one]] [[KnightinShiningArmor that lead the team to rescue her?]] That's probably the only time the player's playing Milanor's Milanor as a full time hero.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {...} from Hanna is Not a Boy's Name, natch, especially considering Hanna's Dark and Troubling past, and Terrible Secret.

to:

* [[NoNameGiven {...}]] from ''HannaIsNotABoysName,'' natch. [[ThePollyanna Hanna]] himself is AmbiguouslyHuman and is implied to have a DarkAndTroubledPast, which remains mysterious as {...} from Hanna is Not a Boy's Name, natch, especially considering Hanna's Dark and Troubling past, and Terrible Secret.
himself doesn't know anything about it. (Heck, [[GhostAmnesia he doesn't even know his own past]], for that matter.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The protagonist of ''TheLordOfTheRings'' is ostensibly [[TheEveryman Frodo Baggins]], although in fact most of the action is carried forward by other characters. [[spoiler: He's not even the one to destroy the Ring in the end.]]

to:

* The protagonist of ''TheLordOfTheRings'' is ostensibly [[TheEveryman Frodo Baggins]], although in fact most of the action is carried forward by other characters. [[spoiler: He's [[spoiler:He's not even the one to destroy the Ring in the end.]]
end]].
* Barbara Robinson's three ''[[strike:Worst]] Best'' novels (most famously ''The Best Christmas Pageant Ever'') are all about the Herdmans, a group of misbehaved siblings with a difficult home life, as they interact with their town's other children. The books are narrated by a girl in their class, however, who relates information about the family and the children's various antics as the plot of each book unfolds.

Added: 230

Changed: 200

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In GeneWolfe's Book Of The Long sun, Silk is the protagonist but two of his pupils, Horn and Nettle, turn out to be the narrators.

to:

* In GeneWolfe's Book Of The ''Book of the Long sun, Sun, Silk is the protagonist but two of his pupils, Horn and Nettle, turn out to be the narrators.
* Although he's the title character, ''BeauGeste'' is told from the perspective of Michael's younger brother because he's [spoiler:the only of the three brothers to survive the entire story.]]
* The protagonist of ''TheLordOfTheRings'' is ostensibly [[TheEveryman Frodo Baggins]], although in fact most of the action is carried forward by other characters. [[spoiler: He's not even the one to destroy the Ring in the end.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The new series of ''{{Doctor Who}}'' starts with the episode "Rose", which has the title character as {{The Watson}} and {{The Ishmael}} to ease the audience into the series.

to:

* The new series of ''{{Doctor ''Series/{{Doctor Who}}'' starts with the episode "Rose", which has the title character as {{The Watson}} and {{The Ishmael}} to ease the audience into the series.

Added: 43

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Narrator (a pudgy snowman) in the famous Rankin/Bass animated adaptation of ''Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer''. Apparently, his only ''raison d'etre'' besides telling the audience the story is to sing and perform on the guitar songs that are only tangentially related to the plot. The story's ''real'' protagonist, of course, is Rudolph - but since we are viewing ''everything'' through the Narrator's perspective, Herbie the Elf and the Misfit Toys also are depicted as well-rounded characters, and arguably alternate protagonists themselves. (Of course, the FridgeLogic - no pun intended - of a snowman still being around many years later to tell the story when there have obviously been many summers as well as winters is never addressed.)

to:

* The Narrator (a pudgy snowman) in the famous Rankin/Bass animated adaptation of ''Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer''. Apparently, his only ''raison d'etre'' besides telling the audience the story is to sing and perform on the guitar songs that are only tangentially related to the plot. The story's ''real'' protagonist, of course, is Rudolph - but since we are viewing ''everything'' through the Narrator's perspective, Herbie the Elf and the Misfit Toys also are depicted as well-rounded characters, and arguably alternate protagonists themselves. (Of course, the FridgeLogic - no pun intended - of a snowman still being around many years later to tell the story when there have obviously been many summers as well as winters is never addressed.) )
** A snowman...who lives in the North Pole.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** You may be CompletelyMissingThePoint. [[spoiler:Louis Wu chose the king of Ringworld when he said (paraphrased). "You let Fist of God hit Ringworld. I deem you unworthy of the RingworldThrone!]]

to:

** You may be CompletelyMissingThePoint. [[spoiler:Louis Wu chose the king of Ringworld when he said (paraphrased). "You let Fist of God hit Ringworld. I deem you unworthy of the RingworldThrone!]] Ringworld Throne!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Enter The Ishmael, a character not that compelling in and of himself, but who is chosen as the {{narrator}} and protagonist because he has an excellent view of the action surrounding the real focal character.

to:

Enter The Ishmael, a character not that compelling in and of himself, but who is chosen as the {{narrator}} and protagonist because he has an excellent view of the action surrounding the real focal character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rule of fun. :)


** Well, minus ...[[spoiler:Vainly attempting to stop Lavos from killing all his friends and Magus and dying in a HeroicSacrifice]]. That scene alone basically gives him some kind of characterization even if he's Silent, not unlike the Persona MCs.

to:

** Well, minus ...[[spoiler:Vainly attempting to stop Lavos from killing all his friends [[AndZoidberg and Magus Magus]] and dying in a HeroicSacrifice]]. That scene alone basically gives him some kind of characterization even if he's Silent, not unlike the Persona MCs.

Top