Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ReinventingTheTelephone

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''(Negi receives cell phone call from Asuna that Konoka has been kidnapped.)''\\

to:

''(Negi receives a cell phone call from Asuna that Konoka has been kidnapped.)''\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Negi:''' I can't hear Asuna-san's voice with [[{{Telepathy}} this]]?
-->'''Chamo:''' Yeah, that's how it is.
-->'''Negi:''' Wouldn't a mobile phone be better then?
-->''*Receives cell phone call from Asuna that Konoka has been kidnapped* ''
-->'''Chamo:''' ''*exasperated* '' What kind of mage uses a cell phone?
-->-- MahouSenseiNegima


to:

-->'''Negi:''' ->'''Negi:''' I can't hear Asuna-san's voice with [[{{Telepathy}} this]]?
-->'''Chamo:'''
this]]?\\
'''Chamo:'''
Yeah, that's how it is.
-->'''Negi:'''
is.\\
'''Negi:'''
Wouldn't a mobile phone be better then?
-->''*Receives
then?\\
''(Negi receives
cell phone call from Asuna that Konoka has been kidnapped* ''
-->'''Chamo:''' ''*exasperated* ''
kidnapped.)''\\
'''Chamo:''' ''(exasperated)''
What kind of mage uses a cell phone?
-->-- MahouSenseiNegima

''MahouSenseiNegima''

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Naruto'' is ostensibly set in a pseudo-present day world, just with ninjas. And magic/jutsu. Really, they just use modern technology whenever it would get in the way for them not to. The five village Kages meet in person even though there is a tendency for Kages to be assassinated. When their Feudal Lords have to ratify the formation of the Shinobi Alliance, however, they have a quick video conference.

to:

* ''Naruto'' ''{{Naruto}}'' is ostensibly set in a pseudo-present day world, just with ninjas. And magic/jutsu. Really, they just use modern technology whenever it would get in the way for them not to. The five village Kages meet in person even though there is a tendency for Kages to be assassinated. When their Feudal Lords have to ratify the formation of the Shinobi Alliance, however, they have a quick video conference.

Added: 182

Changed: 148

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n



[[AC:Anime and Manga]]

to:

[[AC:Anime [[foldercontrol]]

[[folder: Anime
and Manga]]Manga ]]



[[AC:ComicBooks]]

to:

[[AC:ComicBooks]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Comic Books ]]



[[AC:{{Film}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{Film}}]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Film ]]



[[AC:{{Literature}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{Literature}}]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Literature ]]



** Also, the use of said extremely difficult spell is justified because it is the only method that can't be intercepted.

to:

** Also, the use of said extremely difficult spell is justified because it is the only method that can't be intercepted.



[[AC:LiveActionTV]]

to:

[[AC:LiveActionTV]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Live Action TV ]]



[[AC:{{Webcomics}}]]

to:

[[AC:{{Webcomics}}]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Webcomics ]]



[[AC:WesternAnimation]]

to:

[[AC:WesternAnimation]][[/folder]]

[[folder: Western Animation ]]


Added DiffLines:


[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Daffy Duck takes this up while trying to get rich inventing on ''TheLooneyTunesShow'''s "Peel of Fortune." He invents sliced bread, toilet paper, and a suitcase.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] by the backwardness of wizard society, a rather large portion of which doesn't seem ''aware'' of the technological advances the {{Muggles}} have made over the past few centuries. They have adapted some Muggle technology, but only after putting their own twists on it. The general Wizarding population is apparently so unaware of Muggle technology that their premier newspaper, the Daily Prophet, feels obliged to explain to its readers what ''firearms'' are, in the expectation that a significant number of wizards have never even ''heard'' of them!

to:

** [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] by the backwardness of wizard society, a rather large portion of which doesn't seem ''aware'' of the technological advances the {{Muggles}} have made over the past few centuries. They have adapted some Muggle technology, but only after putting their own twists on it. The general Wizarding population is apparently so unaware of Muggle technology that their premier newspaper, the Daily Prophet, feels obliged to explain to its readers what ''firearms'' are, in the expectation that a significant number of wizards have never even ''heard'' of them!them! In general, wizards actually kind of suck at anything that can't be achieved solely by magic, when compared to muggles.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ''Naruto'' is ostensibly set in a pseudo-present day world, just with ninjas. And magic/jutsu. Really, they just use modern technology whenever it would get in the way for them not to. The five village Kages meet in person even though there is a tendency for Kages to be assassinated. When their Feudal Lords have to ratify the formation of the Shinobi Alliance, however, they have a quick video conference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also averted by the WordOfGod that no one else knows how to do Patronus communications- [[http://www.jkrowling.com/textonly/en/faq_view.cfm?id=99 Dumbledore invented the method, and the only people he taught it to is the Order of the Phoenix.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Basically, when somebody in a show (set in the 'present day' or even TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture) uses a [[RuleOfCool pointlessly cool]] method of communication, which is frequently [[CoolButImpractical lot less practical]] than the ordinary, everyday type. Arguably, telepathic communication ''would'' be better, depending on exactly how many [[PstandardPsychicPstance strange hand gestures]] you have to make, and whether it can inflict {{Psychic Nosebleed}}s, but all the others...

to:

Basically, when somebody in a show (set in the 'present day' or even TwentyMinutesIntoTheFuture) uses a [[RuleOfCool pointlessly cool]] method of communication, which is frequently [[CoolButImpractical lot less practical]] than the ordinary, everyday type. Arguably, telepathic communication ''would'' be better, depending on exactly how many [[PstandardPsychicPstance strange hand gestures]] you have to make, whether it allows for [[PokeInTheThirdEye protection from "brain tapping"]], and whether it can inflict {{Psychic Nosebleed}}s, but all the others...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The canon explanation for this need is the galaxy-spaning [[TheInternet Holonet]] had been shattered at this point by the Sith, and Star Wars ships have always travelled at around the same speed as transmitted messages, anyway.

Added: 121

Changed: 216

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In the first episode of ''Series/{{Sherlock}}'', [[spoiler:Mycroft Holmes]] contacts Watson by watching him on London's ubiquitous [=CCTVs=] and calling every public phone he walks by until he picks one of them up.
-->'''Watson''': You know, I've got a phone. Very clever, and all that, but, uh, you could just... phone me. On my phone.

Changed: 123

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Related to WeHaveTheKeys. If you're looking for something a little more convenient, try CommLinks.

to:

Related to WeHaveTheKeys. If you're looking for something a little more convenient, try CommLinks. Works written about the future before the widespread use of cell phones may get a pass but might qualify for {{Zeerust}}.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Additional Batman example

Added DiffLines:

** Invoked in a specific Batman story arc as well. Azrael discovered the cure to the deadly plague known as the Clench, and hurriedly returned to Gotham to deliver the information. A comrade of his who was present when the cure was found simply sent the formula to Gotham via a fax machine.

Changed: 253

Removed: 227

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This was [[http://www.mangafox.com/manga/mahou_sensei_negima/v04/c031/8.html said]] of the Pactio cards in ''MahouSenseiNegima''. Their main problem is that the card can only send, and you have to hold it to your forehead. Not to mention that a single pactio card can contact only that partner and nobody else, and the telepathy is easily blocked anyway.
** Actually that's false. The card can be used to communicate telepathichally not only to just the Magister, but also with any other person who also has a Pactio with the same Magister. Not to mention all their other abilities.

to:

* This was [[http://www.mangafox.com/manga/mahou_sensei_negima/v04/c031/8.html said]] of the Pactio cards in ''MahouSenseiNegima''. Their main problem is that the The card can only send, and only to specific people (the Magister who made the Pactio, or anyone else who has a Pactio with the same Magister). In addition, you have to hold it to your forehead. Not to mention that a single pactio card can contact only that partner and nobody else, forehead, and the telepathy is easily blocked anyway.
** Actually that's false. The card can be used to communicate telepathichally not only to just the Magister, but also with any other person who also has a Pactio with the same Magister. Not to mention all their other abilities.
blocked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Power Rangers can be made more concise


* ''PowerRangers'' surprisingly justifies the fact that morphers have communication equipment as often as it plays the trope straight. The early seasons were in the 90's, when not everybody had cell phones yet. And in the later seasons, the morphers often ''are'' cell phones (or at least can be used as such).

to:

* ''PowerRangers'' surprisingly justifies the fact that morphers have communication equipment as often as it plays the trope straight. The early seasons were in the 90's, when not everybody had cell phones yet. And in the later seasons, the Later seasons often have morphers often ''are'' with built-in cell phones (or at least can be used as such).phones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In several incarnations of Batman (most famously in the Adam West TV series) Commissioner Gordon has a red phone with a direct line to Batman as well as a Bat-Signal.

to:

*** In several incarnations of Batman (most famously in the Adam West TV series) Commissioner Gordon has a red phone with a direct line to Batman as well as a Bat-Signal.
Bat-Signal.
* In the ''StarWars'' [[StarWarsExpandedUniverse comic]] ''Jedi vs. Sith'', they use ''messengers''. In ''Star Wars''. Granted, this takes place 1,000 years before the films, and there's already a good deal of SchizoTech in place like wooden spacecraft and bows-and-arrows being used alongside lightsabers, but comlinks were definitely invented by then.

Changed: 107

Removed: 352

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
One Piece does not fit this trope since it does not have modern communication for the Den Den Mushi to be inferior to.


[[OnePiece http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/dendenmushi.jpg]]
[[caption-width:374:No snails were harmed in the making of this product]]



* The Den Den Mushi (pictured above) from ''OnePiece'', are telesnails. Yeah, thats right. Tele''snails''.
** That also serve as fax machines. Baby ones act as a sort of cell phone that is limited to the island they are on at the time.
** Later in the series there are also versions that function as video-cameras.

to:

* The Den Den Mushi (pictured above) from ''OnePiece'', are telesnails. Yeah, thats right. Tele''snails''.
** That also serve as fax machines. Baby ones act as a sort of cell phone that is limited to the island they are on at the time.
** Later in the series there are also versions that function as video-cameras.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, the use of said extremely difficult spell is justified because it is the only method that can't be intercepted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Actually that's false. The card can be used to communicate telepathichally not only to just the Magister, but also with any other person who also has a Pactio with the same Magister. Not to mention all their other abilities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* [[http://www.agirlandherfed.com/comic/?602 Preparing for battle]] in ''AGirlAndHerFed'' -- with [[LampshadeHanging lampshade]] and [[JustifiedTrope justification]].

Changed: 421

Removed: 312

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Warehouse 13'' is made of this trope, but more specifically does this with some steampunk-ish video phones. But there's only two of them, and they are huge. Yet they persist in using them, despite the fact that they have no real advantages over, say, the smart phones they are running around with. (It is possible that they are more secure that regular phones. Since no one else has them, it's an example of security through obscurity.)
** It is later confirmed that they are unhackable, can only lose signal due to massive electrical interference, and there's at least 4 of them (Artie's, Pete/Myka's, Claudia's, Mrs. Fredrick's). They also have blueprints for them, and can presumably make more.

to:

* ''Warehouse 13'' ''{{Warehouse 13}}'' is made of this trope, but more specifically does this with some steampunk-ish video phones. But there's only two phones, invented by Philo Farnsworth. There's a limited number of them, but they're unhackable and they are huge. Yet they persist in using them, despite the fact that they have no real advantages over, say, the smart phones they are running around with. (It is possible that they are more secure that regular phones. Since no one else has them, it's an example of security through obscurity.)
** It is later confirmed that they are unhackable,
can only lose signal due to massive electrical interference, and there's at least 4 of them (Artie's, Pete/Myka's, Claudia's, Mrs. Fredrick's). They interference. It's also shown that Pete and Myka have blueprints regular cell phones for them, and can presumably make more. communicating with each-other in the field.




----
<<|AppliedPhlebotinum|>>
<<|TruthInTelevision|>>
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In TheFoundation, the second foundation communicate telepathically. It can't be detected, let alone intercepted, but it's also likely to result in miscommunication. The Foundation itself, however, seem to communicate primarily by ''telegrams'', which are distributed by ''pneumatic tube''.

to:

* In TheFoundation, ''{{Foundation}}'', the second foundation communicate telepathically. It can't be detected, let alone intercepted, but it's also likely to result in miscommunication. The Foundation itself, however, seem to communicate primarily by ''telegrams'', which are distributed by ''pneumatic tube''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Negi:''' Can't I hear Asuna-san's voice with this?

to:

-->'''Negi:''' Can't I can't hear Asuna-san's voice with this?[[{{Telepathy}} this]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It is later confirmed that they are unhackable, can only lose signal due to massive electrical interference, and there's at least 4 of them (Artie's, Pete/Myka's, Claudia's, Mrs. Fredrick's). They also have blueprints for them, and can presumably make more.

to:

* ** It is later confirmed that they are unhackable, can only lose signal due to massive electrical interference, and there's at least 4 of them (Artie's, Pete/Myka's, Claudia's, Mrs. Fredrick's). They also have blueprints for them, and can presumably make more.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* It is later confirmed that they are unhackable, can only lose signal due to massive electrical interference, and there's at least 4 of them (Artie's, Pete/Myka's, Claudia's, Mrs. Fredrick's). They also have blueprints for them, and can presumably make more.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** In several incarnations of Batman (most famously in the Adam West TV series) Commissioner Gordon has a red phone with a direct line to Batman as well as a Bat-Signal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->''* Receives cell phone call from Asuna that Konoka has been kidnapped* ''
-->'''Chamo:''' ''* exasperated* '' What kind of mage uses a cell phone?

to:

-->''* Receives -->''*Receives cell phone call from Asuna that Konoka has been kidnapped* ''
-->'''Chamo:''' ''* exasperated* ''*exasperated* '' What kind of mage uses a cell phone?



* This was [[http://www.onemanga.com/Mahou_Sensei_Negima!/31/09/ said]] of the Pactio cards in ''MahouSenseiNegima''. Their main problem is that the card can only send, and you have to hold it to your forehead. Not to mention that a single pactio card can contact only that partner and nobody else, and the telepathy is easily blocked anyway.

to:

* This was [[http://www.onemanga.com/Mahou_Sensei_Negima!/31/09/ mangafox.com/manga/mahou_sensei_negima/v04/c031/8.html said]] of the Pactio cards in ''MahouSenseiNegima''. Their main problem is that the card can only send, and you have to hold it to your forehead. Not to mention that a single pactio card can contact only that partner and nobody else, and the telepathy is easily blocked anyway.



** Later in the series there are also versions that function as video-cameras

to:

** Later in the series there are also versions that function as video-cameras
video-cameras.



** [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] by the backwardsness of wizard society, a rather large portion of which doesn't seem ''aware'' of the technological advances the {{Muggles}} have made over the past few centuries. They have adapted some Muggle technology, but only after putting their own twists on it. The general Wizarding population is apparently so unaware of Muggle technology that their premiere newspaper, the Daily Prophet, feels obliged to explain to its readers what ''firearms'' are, in the expectation that a significant number of wizards have never even ''heard'' of them!

to:

** [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] by the backwardsness backwardness of wizard society, a rather large portion of which doesn't seem ''aware'' of the technological advances the {{Muggles}} have made over the past few centuries. They have adapted some Muggle technology, but only after putting their own twists on it. The general Wizarding population is apparently so unaware of Muggle technology that their premiere premier newspaper, the Daily Prophet, feels obliged to explain to its readers what ''firearms'' are, in the expectation that a significant number of wizards have never even ''heard'' of them!



** Of course, the Tick parodied Comicbook/{{Batman}}'s BatSignal, which is one of the earlier versions of the trope. At least back then there weren't any cell phones, but regular phones --as well as the ''Bat-Phone'' -- did exist.

to:

** Of course, the Tick parodied Comicbook/{{Batman}}'s BatSignal, which is one of the earlier versions of the trope. At least back then there weren't any cell phones, but regular phones --as -- as well as the ''Bat-Phone'' -- did exist.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The [[{{Bamtan}} Bat-Signal]]. Of course, Gordon has easier ways of getting in touch with Batman too.

to:

* The [[{{Bamtan}} [[{{Batman}} Bat-Signal]]. Of course, Gordon has easier ways of getting in touch with Batman too.



* The wizards of ''{{Harry Potter}}'' when they really need to contact each other, take an extremely difficult spell most wizards can't cast, and then complicate it by making it talk. Also mail taken by owl, which as such moves at a bird's flying speed. Oh, and their "stick your head in the fireplace and hope someone is within earshot" method. Yes, they claim that magic interferes with electronics, but these are still terrible methods for people who can do things by magic.

to:

* The wizards of ''{{Harry Potter}}'' ''HarryPotter'' when they really need to contact each other, take an extremely difficult spell most wizards can't cast, and then complicate it by making it talk. Also mail taken by owl, which as such moves at a bird's flying speed. Oh, and their "stick your head in the fireplace and hope someone is within earshot" method. Yes, they claim that magic interferes with electronics, but these are still terrible methods for people who can do things by magic.



* Of course, the Tick parodied Comicbook/{{Batman}}'s BatSignal, which is one of the earlier versions of the trope. At least back then there weren't any cell phones, but regular phones --as well as the ''Bat-Phone'' -- did exist.
** The Bat-Phone only existed in the 60s TV series; in less ludicrous versions, the idea of a dedicated phone line between the police station and Batman's ''secret headquarters'' was seen as a bad idea. The Batphone made its first comics appearance in 2003, as an encrypted cellphone.

to:

* ** Of course, the Tick parodied Comicbook/{{Batman}}'s BatSignal, which is one of the earlier versions of the trope. At least back then there weren't any cell phones, but regular phones --as well as the ''Bat-Phone'' -- did exist.
** The Bat-Phone only existed in [[Series/{{Batman}} the 60s TV series; series]]; in less ludicrous versions, the idea of a dedicated phone line between the police station and Batman's ''secret headquarters'' was seen as a bad idea. The Batphone made its first comics appearance in 2003, as an encrypted cellphone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* All this time and nobody's mentioned the Bat-Signal yet? Of course, Gordon has easier ways of getting in touch with Batman too.

to:

* All this time and nobody's mentioned the Bat-Signal yet? The [[{{Bamtan}} Bat-Signal]]. Of course, Gordon has easier ways of getting in touch with Batman too.



* Averted in TheMovie of ''Film/IronMan'', where Stark has apparently programmed his armor to act as a cell phone.

to:

* Averted in TheMovie of ''Film/IronMan'', where Stark has apparently programmed his armor to act as a cell phone.

Top