Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / OrphanedEtymology

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''A Feast for Crows'' the phrase "that way lay madness" is used (in Jon Snow's interior monologue during [[spoiler:the wildling attack on Castle Black]]. Of course, this is just a string of perfectly innocuous words, but put into that phrase they stick out because it's a common RealLife phrase that originates in paraphrasing from ''Theatre/{{Hamlet}}'', a work that does not exist in this universe.
** There are also some American phrases (such as "laying down" on a bed) that can seem out-of-place in the MedievalEuropeanFantasy setting.

Added: 102

Changed: 387

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Natter


* The 1980 ''Film/FlashGordon'' movie has the War Rocket Ajax as part of Ming's fleet. Ajax, of course, was a famous Greek hero, and Ming has never heard of Earth before the start of the movie.
** Well, if one wants to go that route, then Ming himself is an alien emperor sharing his name with a famous ''Chinese'' imperial dynasty...

to:

* The 1980 ''Film/FlashGordon'' ''Film/FlashGordon'':
** The
movie has the War Rocket Ajax as part of Ming's fleet. Ajax, of course, was a famous Greek hero, and Ming has never heard of Earth before the start of the movie.
** Well, if one wants to go that route, then And Ming himself is an alien emperor sharing his name with a famous ''Chinese'' imperial dynasty...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, if one wants to go that route, then Ming himself is an alien emperor sharing his name with a famous ''Chinese'' imperial dynasty...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Andrzej Sapkowski, best known for creating TheWitcher short stories and novels, eventually answered occasional criticisms of the Witcher world being "anachronistic" (such as the mention of a woman's panties) by pointing out the ubiquity of this trope. By that logic, he noted, no fantasy novel published in Polish should ever include a king, as the word for "king" (in the Polish language) is derived from Charlemagne's name. A wholly imaginary world, he notes, has just as much reason to include modern women's underwear as it has to use modern words or ones that reference the real world. In another novel of his, with fantasy elements but set in medieval Europe, a character uses the word "cholera", a common and rather modern-sounding curse word in Polish. A footnote notes that the name of the sickness dates back to antiquity and the well-educated character who uses it would know the word and, furthermore, cursing by invoking the names of illnesses and maladies has a very long history. The footnote ends with "while there is no evidence that this particular word was used for cursing in medieval times, there is also no evidence that it wasn't", in what is possibly a TakeThat against such criticism.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Thanks to ThrowItIn, ''BattlestarGalactica's'' Colonel Tigh exclaims "Jesus!" in a polytheistic society that's never heard of [[spoiler:and predates]] Abrahamic religions.

to:

* Thanks to ThrowItIn, ''BattlestarGalactica's'' ''Series/{{Battlestar Galactica|Reimagined}}'' Colonel Tigh exclaims "Jesus!" in a polytheistic society that's never heard of [[spoiler:and predates]] Abrahamic religions.

Added: 1755

Changed: 1798

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': As far as it's shown, there's nothing like a benevolent monotheist deity — there's the jerkass god, Truth, and there's Father, who's kind of like {{Satan}}. However, Greed does a SeeYouInHell to his family and Buccaneer references FluffyCloudHeaven. Then again, people are shown to ''believe'' in a variety of religions.

to:

* ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'':
**
As far as it's shown, there's nothing like a benevolent monotheist deity — there's the jerkass god, Truth, and there's Father, who's kind of like {{Satan}}. However, Greed does a SeeYouInHell to his family and Buccaneer references FluffyCloudHeaven. Then again, people are shown to ''believe'' in a variety of religions.



* One of the earlier ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'' books references gypsies, which is kind of a problem, since there's no Egypt in the universe to derive that name— the equivalent is called Djelibeybi. So, if there are Roma on the Disc, they should probably be nicknamed Jelibeybs or something like that.

to:

* ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'':
**
One of the earlier ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'' books references gypsies, which is kind of a problem, since there's no Egypt in the universe to derive that name— the equivalent is called Djelibeybi. So, if there are Roma on the Disc, they should probably be nicknamed Jelibeybs or something like that.



* Deliberately averted in ''TheLordOfTheRings''. Tolkien, as a linguist, did his best to remove and replace modern English words that derived from languages other than English. For example, "pipe weed" is clearly tobacco, but isn't called such because the word "tobacco" comes from a language native to the Caribbean.

to:

* ''TheLordOfTheRings'':
**
Deliberately averted in ''TheLordOfTheRings''.most of the time. Tolkien, as a linguist, did his best to remove and replace modern English words that derived from languages other than English. For example, "pipe weed" is clearly tobacco, but isn't called such because the word "tobacco" comes from a language native to the Caribbean.



* In ''The Ringworld Throne'', a native of {{Ringworld}} refers to how the irritable chieftain of the Grass Giants might "go off like a volcano" if he finds out about something, which is puzzling because Ringworld has no volcanic activity.

to:

* In ''The Ringworld Throne'', a Throne'':
** A
native of {{Ringworld}} refers to how the irritable chieftain of the Grass Giants might "go off like a volcano" if he finds out about something, which is puzzling because Ringworld has no volcanic activity.



* In ''StarFox64'', Falco, rather [[MemeticMutation infamously]], sarcastically calls Fox [=McCloud=] "Einstein" if you shoot him. When a reader of ''NintendoPower'' magazine sent in a letter questioning how could a being from another galaxy know about AlbertEinstein, the editors' response was, "Because [[{{Doylist}} the game's creators are from this galaxy]], Einstein."

to:

* In ''StarFox64'', ''StarFox64'':
**
Falco, rather [[MemeticMutation infamously]], sarcastically calls Fox [=McCloud=] "Einstein" if you shoot him. When a reader of ''NintendoPower'' magazine sent in a letter questioning how could a being from another galaxy know about AlbertEinstein, the editors' response was, "Because [[{{Doylist}} the game's creators are from this galaxy]], Einstein."



* ''{{Exiern}}'', a HighFantasy world with no relation to Earth, much less Japan, apparently has [[http://www.exiern.com/?p=1033 Yaoi Porn]], mentioned by name.

to:

* ''{{Exiern}}'', a ''{{Exiern}}'':
**
HighFantasy world with no relation to Earth, much less Japan, apparently has [[http://www.exiern.com/?p=1033 Yaoi Porn]], mentioned by name.



* Ponies in WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic say "Oh my gosh", without an "Oh my god".
*** In the same sense, Rainbow Dash likes to exclaim "For Pete's sake!" once in a while, even though St. Peter is also a Christian figure.

to:

* WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic:
**
Ponies in WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic say "Oh my gosh", without an "Oh my god".
*** ** In the same sense, Rainbow Dash likes to exclaim "For Pete's sake!" once in a while, even though St. Peter is also a Christian figure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** In the same sense, Rainbow Dash likes to exclaim "For Pete's sake!" once in a while, even though St. Peter is also a Christian figure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''Boast Busters'', Spike mentions a Fu Manchu moustache. How exactly does a world of magical talking ponies know about a human-created YellowPeril villain?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* According to ''DinosaurComics''' [[http://www.qwantz.com/index.php?comic=2090 summary of the play]], {{Hamlet}} said, "Record scratch! Say WHAAAAAT?" when he found out how his father died.

to:

* According to ''DinosaurComics''' [[http://www.qwantz.com/index.php?comic=2090 summary of the play]], {{Hamlet}} said, "Record scratch! "[[RecordNeedleScratch Record scratch!]] Say WHAAAAAT?" when he found out how his father died.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''TheFiveStarStories'' has numerous things and people named after Earth stuff despite either taking place ALongTimeAgoInAGalaxyFarAway or a future so distant that nobody knows much about life before space colonization. Lampshaded at one point where Ladios Sopp indulges in a bit of LeaningOnTheFourthWall and jokingly asks Chrome Ballanche, a MadScientist who has created several ArtificialHuman "Fatimas" with names based on Greek and other mythologies just where he comes up with these names.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace thing Changed, yeah


* One of the earlier ''{{Discworld}}'' books references gypsies, which is kind of a problem, since there's no Egypt in the universe to derive that name— the equivalent is called Djelibeybi. So, if there are Roma on the Disc, they should probably be nicknamed Jelibeybs or something like that.

to:

* One of the earlier ''{{Discworld}}'' ''Literature/{{Discworld}}'' books references gypsies, which is kind of a problem, since there's no Egypt in the universe to derive that name— the equivalent is called Djelibeybi. So, if there are Roma on the Disc, they should probably be nicknamed Jelibeybs or something like that.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Surprisingly, there are actual pre-Christian Roman coins marked with years "BC." Current speculation is that were issued to commemorate a particular battle (in Latin, bellus) against a person or at a place whose name began with "C." The actual pre-Christian Latin dating system was "Ab Urbe Condita" (AUC.), which means "since the founding of the city" (of Rome), though recent history (pre-Empire, at least) was generally rendered as "the year in which [insert name here] and [insert name here] were consuls". For reference, as of June 2012, the current Roman date is 2765 AUC or "the year of the consulship of Obama and Biden" (if you are American - substitute the two highest ranked officials of other countries to taste).

to:

* Surprisingly, there are actual pre-Christian Roman coins marked with years "BC." Current speculation is that were issued to commemorate a particular battle (in Latin, bellus) against a person or at a place whose name began with "C." The actual pre-Christian Latin dating system was "Ab Urbe Condita" "AbUrbeCondita" (AUC.), which means "since the founding of the city" (of Rome), though recent history (pre-Empire, at least) was generally rendered as "the year in which [insert name here] and [insert name here] were consuls". For reference, as of June 2012, the current Roman date is 2765 AUC or "the year of the consulship of Obama and Biden" (if you are American - substitute the two highest ranked officials of other countries to taste).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Or the Roman god Vulcan, for that matter
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
da Namespace Change.


* In MelBrooks' ''HistoryOfTheWorldPartOne'', Comicus says "Jesus" in exasperation during The Last Supper, causing Jesus to answer, "Yes?" assuming that Comicus was addressing him.

to:

* In MelBrooks' Creator/MelBrooks' ''HistoryOfTheWorldPartOne'', Comicus says "Jesus" in exasperation during The Last Supper, causing Jesus to answer, "Yes?" assuming that Comicus was addressing him.



* In ''{{StarFox 64}}'', Falco, rather [[MemeticMutation infamously]], sarcastically calls Fox [=McCloud=] "Einstein" if you shoot him. When a reader of ''NintendoPower'' magazine sent in a letter questioning how could a being from another galaxy know about AlbertEinstein, the editors' response was, "Because [[{{Doylist}} the game's creators are from this galaxy]], Einstein."

to:

* In ''{{StarFox 64}}'', ''StarFox64'', Falco, rather [[MemeticMutation infamously]], sarcastically calls Fox [=McCloud=] "Einstein" if you shoot him. When a reader of ''NintendoPower'' magazine sent in a letter questioning how could a being from another galaxy know about AlbertEinstein, the editors' response was, "Because [[{{Doylist}} the game's creators are from this galaxy]], Einstein."



* Surprisingly, there are actual pre-Christian Roman coins marked with years "BC." Current speculation is that were issued to commemorate a particular battle (in Latin, bellus) against a person or at a place whose name began with "C." The actual pre-Christian Latin dating system was "Ab Urbe Condita" (AUC.), which means "since the founding of the city" (of Rome), though recent history (pre-Empire, at least) was generally rendered as "the year in which [insert name here] and [insert name here] were consuls". For reference, as of June 2012, the current Roman date is 2765 AUC or "the year of the consulship of Obama and Biden" (if you are American - substitute the two highest ranked officials of other countries to taste).

to:

* Surprisingly, there are actual pre-Christian Roman coins marked with years "BC." Current speculation is that were issued to commemorate a particular battle (in Latin, bellus) against a person or at a place whose name began with "C." The actual pre-Christian Latin dating system was "Ab Urbe Condita" (AUC.), which means "since the founding of the city" (of Rome), though recent history (pre-Empire, at least) was generally rendered as "the year in which [insert name here] and [insert name here] were consuls". For reference, as of June 2012, the current Roman date is 2765 AUC or "the year of the consulship of Obama and Biden" (if you are American - substitute the two highest ranked officials of other countries to taste).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Surprisingly, there are actual pre-Christian Roman coins marked with years "BC." Current speculation is that were issued to commemorate a particular battle (in Latin, bellus) against a person or at a place whose name began with "C."

to:

* Surprisingly, there are actual pre-Christian Roman coins marked with years "BC." Current speculation is that were issued to commemorate a particular battle (in Latin, bellus) against a person or at a place whose name began with "C."" The actual pre-Christian Latin dating system was "Ab Urbe Condita" (AUC.), which means "since the founding of the city" (of Rome), though recent history (pre-Empire, at least) was generally rendered as "the year in which [insert name here] and [insert name here] were consuls". For reference, as of June 2012, the current Roman date is 2765 AUC or "the year of the consulship of Obama and Biden" (if you are American - substitute the two highest ranked officials of other countries to taste).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ponies in MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic say "Oh my gosh", without an "Oh my god".

to:

* Ponies in MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic say "Oh my gosh", without an "Oh my god".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
YMMV sinkhole


* ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': As far as it's shown, there's nothing like a benevolent monotheist deity — there's the jerkass god, Truth, and there's Father, who's kind of like {{Satan}}. However, Greed does a SeeYouInHell to his family and Buccaneer references FluffyCloudHeaven. Then again, people are shown to ''believe'' in a variety of religions, so YourMileageMayVary.

to:

* ''Manga/FullmetalAlchemist'': As far as it's shown, there's nothing like a benevolent monotheist deity — there's the jerkass god, Truth, and there's Father, who's kind of like {{Satan}}. However, Greed does a SeeYouInHell to his family and Buccaneer references FluffyCloudHeaven. Then again, people are shown to ''believe'' in a variety of religions, so YourMileageMayVary.religions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ponies in MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic say "Oh my gosh", without an "Oh my god".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
the Namespace stuff.


* In ''SonicX'', there is a character called 'Black Narcissus' despite his race never having visited Earth and in fact existing in a whole other universe! (also, ''Sonic X''[='s=] earth doesn't appear to have the same countries anyway...)

to:

* In ''SonicX'', there is a character called 'Black Narcissus' despite his race never having visited Earth and in fact existing in a whole other universe! (also, ''Sonic X''[='s=] earth doesn't appear to have the same countries anyway...) )



* ''TheKingkillerChronicle'' plays with this in some weird ways. There are several fictional dead and in-use languages in its world, so a TranslationConvention is assumed. Then you get things like the word 'vintage'. In our world, it comes from Latin by way of French, referring to wine (vin, vino, vinum, etc...), but it's not any more out of place than any other English word in fantasy. However, in the Four Corners there is no OrphanedEtymology, because the word ''vintage'' is derived from the country of ''Vintas'', which happens to produce fine wine.

to:

* ''TheKingkillerChronicle'' plays with this in some weird ways. There are several fictional dead and in-use languages in its world, so a TranslationConvention is assumed. Then you get things like the word 'vintage'. In our world, it comes from Latin by way of French, referring to wine (vin, vino, vinum, etc...), but it's not any more out of place than any other English word in fantasy. However, in the Four Corners there is no OrphanedEtymology, because the word ''vintage'' is derived from the country of ''Vintas'', which happens to produce fine wine.



* In ''DragonQuest'', this is used a lot. It is even {{Lampshaded}} in ''DragonQuestV'', where the phrase "proud as [[PunchAndJudy Punch]]" is used and the Hero's daughter wonders what Punch was proud about.

to:

* In ''DragonQuest'', this is used a lot. It is even {{Lampshaded}} in ''DragonQuestV'', ''VideoGame/DragonQuestV'', where the phrase "proud as [[PunchAndJudy Punch]]" is used and the Hero's daughter wonders what Punch was proud about.



* According to ''DinosaurComics''' [[http://www.qwantz.com/index.php?comic=2090 summary of the play]], {{Hamlet}} said, "Record scratch! Say WHAAAAAT?" when he found out how his father died.

to:

* According to ''DinosaurComics''' [[http://www.qwantz.com/index.php?comic=2090 summary of the play]], {{Hamlet}} said, "Record scratch! Say WHAAAAAT?" when he found out how his father died.

Changed: 4

Removed: 194

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Seems like a Square Peg Round Trope example.


* In ''The Ringworld Throne'', a native of Ringworld refers to how the irritable chieftain of the Grass Giants might "go off like a volcano" if he finds out about something, which is puzzling because Ringworld has no volcanic activity.

to:

* In ''The Ringworld Throne'', a native of Ringworld {{Ringworld}} refers to how the irritable chieftain of the Grass Giants might "go off like a volcano" if he finds out about something, which is puzzling because Ringworld has no volcanic activity.



* Ponies in ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' say "oh my gosh", despite seemingly having no concept of a god, the position already filled by their [[GodEmperor God Enperesses]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the animated ''Animated/TheReturnOfTheKing'', Samwise's response to Gollum's final attack is a very animated '''"Gooood''' help us!"

to:

* In the animated ''Animated/TheReturnOfTheKing'', ''WesternAnimation/TheReturnOfTheKing'', Samwise's response to Gollum's final attack is a very animated '''"Gooood''' help us!"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And yet, we have the interesting fact that in chapter 1, a dragon is compared not only to a [[InexplicableCulturalTies''train'', but an ''express train'']]:

to:

** And yet, we have the interesting fact that in chapter 1, a dragon is compared not only to a [[InexplicableCulturalTies''train'', [[InexplicableCulturalTies ''train'', but an ''express train'']]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** And yet, we have the interesting fact that in chapter 1, a dragon is compared not only to a ''train'', but an ''express train'':

to:

** And yet, we have the interesting fact that in chapter 1, a dragon is compared not only to a ''train'', [[InexplicableCulturalTies''train'', but an ''express train'':train'']]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And yet, we have the interesting fact that in chapter 1, a dragon is compared not only to a ''train'', but an ''express train'':
-->''The dragon passed like an express train, turned a somersault, and burst over Bywater with a defeaning explosion. ''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ponies in ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' say "oh my gosh", despite seemingly having no concept of a god, the position already filled by their GodEmperesses.

to:

* Ponies in ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' say "oh my gosh", despite seemingly having no concept of a god, the position already filled by their GodEmperesses.[[GodEmperor God Enperesses]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the introduction to ''The Discworld Companion'', Pratchett says that a fantasy author may start out trying to avoid references to things like "Toledo steel", but sooner or later will just look up from their keyboard, mutter "what the hell" and give up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[quoteright:200:[[{{xkcd}} http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/falcon_9566.PNG]]]]

to:

[[quoteright:200:[[{{xkcd}} [[quoteright:200:[[Webcomic/{{xkcd}} http://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/falcon_9566.PNG]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ponies in ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' say "oh my gosh", despite seemingly having no concept of a god, the position already filled by their GodEmperesses.

to:

* Ponies in ''MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' ''WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic'' say "oh my gosh", despite seemingly having no concept of a god, the position already filled by their GodEmperesses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is a bit of an aversion, since several of the ''StarWars'' tie-ins around the time it came out seemed to be written under the assumption that earth creatures did in fact exist in the galaxy far far away. [[FridgeLogic The reason Luke doesn't know what a duck is because he lives on a desert world.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Namespace


* Dates in ''ChronoTrigger'' use [=BC=] and [=AD=], even though Jesus Christ does not appear to exist in the game's universe.

to:

* Dates in ''ChronoTrigger'' ''VideoGame/ChronoTrigger'' use [=BC=] and [=AD=], even though Jesus Christ does not appear to exist in the game's universe.

Top