Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / LossofIdentity

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The upcoming ''TabletopGame/DeviantTheRenegades'' doesn't make it part of the KarmaMeter... because it's a default for the characters. Deviants have been so broken by being [[PlayingWithSyringes remade]] that they can only really define themselves by external principles or relationships; the "they" has been carved out.

to:

** The upcoming ''TabletopGame/DeviantTheRenegades'' doesn't make it part of the KarmaMeter... because it's a default for the characters. Deviants have been so broken by being [[PlayingWithSyringes remade]] that they can only really define themselves by external principles or relationships; the "they" has been carved out.

Added: 462

Changed: 785

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This was a major plot revelation in ''Videogame/FinalFantasyVII'' when we discover that [[spoiler:Cloud Strife, due to psychological trauma and denial, had altered his own memories and adopted the persona of his dead friend Zack Fair, losing his own identity in the process.]]
* ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyXIII'': Explicitly the fate that awaits any l'Cie who fails to complete the Focus given to them by the Fal'Cie. They slowly degenerate into mindless Cie'th, monstrous and aggressive creatures with tainted crystals jutting out of their bodies. Given the Fal'Cie tend to give VERY vague instructions when it comes to what they want done, this fate is far more common than success (and even what you get if you succeed is not that great).

to:

* ''Franchise/FinalFantasy'':
**
This was a major plot revelation in ''Videogame/FinalFantasyVII'' when we discover that [[spoiler:Cloud Strife, due to psychological trauma and denial, had altered his own memories and adopted the persona of his dead friend Zack Fair, losing his own identity in the process.]]
* ** ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyXIII'': Explicitly the fate that awaits any l'Cie who fails to complete the Focus given to them by the Fal'Cie. They slowly degenerate into mindless Cie'th, monstrous and aggressive creatures with tainted crystals jutting out of their bodies. Given the Fal'Cie tend to give VERY vague instructions when it comes to what they want done, this fate is far more common than success (and even what you get if you succeed is not that great).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' animated series, Fixit tries to "repair" Cyborg by taking away all that made him human and replacing it with fully mechanical parts and a mechanical brain. Cyborg is justifiably freaked out, because, without his humanity, he'd be just an emotionless machine with his memories. Eventually, it is Cyborg's humanity that causes Fixit to remember [[WasOnceAMan what ''he'' lost]].

to:

* In the ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' animated series, ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans2003'', Fixit tries to "repair" Cyborg by taking away all that made him human and replacing it with fully mechanical parts and a mechanical brain. Cyborg is justifiably freaked out, because, without his humanity, he'd be just an emotionless machine with his memories. Eventually, it is Cyborg's humanity that causes Fixit to remember [[WasOnceAMan what ''he'' lost]].''[[WasOnceAMan he]]'' lost.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also QuestForIdentity where an identity loss is the starting premise of the story. Can lead to or be part of an IdentityBreakdown. GrandTheftMe can happen if said identity was stolen. Living in a society where you can't have a real identity is IndividualityIsIllegal. See also . If this is a character's backstory, it might be a PreInsanityReveal.

to:

See also QuestForIdentity where an identity loss is the starting premise of the story. Can lead to or be part of an IdentityBreakdown. GrandTheftMe can happen if said identity was stolen. Living in a society where you can't have a real identity is IndividualityIsIllegal. See also . If this is a character's backstory, it might be a PreInsanityReveal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/AbsentedAgeSquarebound'': Without her Heart Fragments, Karen is in danger of losing her identity. [[spoiler:What this means is that if the Gangers take her Heart Fragments, they can become "Karen" while the real one is doomed to wander the Driftworlds as a ghost. When a Ganger steals her first and most important fragment, it's considered closer to being Karen than Karen herself, making it so that the rest of the Heart Fragments gravitate towards the Ganger while rejecting the ghost Karen.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlayedForLaughs in ''Manga/AyakashiTriangle'': Matsuri at one point square his GenderBenderAngst by say he is "not really [himself]" so long as his body remains female. However, he ''only'' expresses this concern to say dating Suzu as a girl would be [[AccidentalAdultery cheating on his "real" male self]]--which is treated not as a worrying sign of dissociation, but a ridiculous excuse to [[spoiler:avoid hooking up with Suzu once they know they love each other]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* The point of most {{Assimilation Plot}}s - as seen on ''Anime/NeonGenesisEvangelion'' and ''Anime/YuGiOhGX'' among others - is to relieve humanity of the burden of isolation that comes with individual identities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Fanon example not canon.


* A [[AlternateCharacterInterpretation darker take]] of [[Manga/RanmaOneHalf Ranma's]] situation could lead to this. Additionally, in an anime-exclusive episode, Ranma banged his head hard after being swatted into the Koi Pond and was taken over by an [[IdentityAmnesia alternate personality]] that thought it truly was a girl, with almost insultingly stereotypical attitudes and tastes, in a situation that was one part this to one part LaserGuidedAmnesia. FridgeLogic on [[AndIMustScream what might be going on with Ranma's real personality]] while the "girly Ranma" is in control can be terrifying if you're a fan of Ranma...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example

Added DiffLines:

* In ''LightNovel/TheExecutionerAndHerWayOfLife'', some people have Pure Concepts attached to their souls. A Pure Conce[t grants incredible power, but erodes the memories and personality of the wielder each time its used. Eventually, a user loses their entire personal identity and acts as nothing more than an avatar of the Pure Concept they wield.

Added: 351

Changed: 330

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
re tooled the description a bit to make it flow more, added identity breakdown, removed the link to amnesiac lover as losing one's identity doesn't necessarily mean losing one's memories


Not to be confused with an AssimilationPlot, in which one's identity is subsumed into a HiveMind. Neither is it the same as EmptyShell, in which any ability to function as an individual is lacking. Compare SplitPersonalityMerge, where two personalities become one, and MentalFusion, where separate minds briefly become one. See also AmnesiacLover, who doesn't know how to love back after becoming an amnesiac. GrandTheftMe can happen if said identity was stolen. Living in a society where you can't have a real identity is IndividualityIsIllegal. See also QuestForIdentity. Compare LostInCharacter, where an actor becomes lost in a role, and SecretIdentityIdentity in which it's possible for a character to completely lose their base identity in favor of their outward persona. If this is a character's backstory, it might be a PreInsanityReveal.

to:

Not to be confused with an AssimilationPlot, in which one's identity is subsumed into a HiveMind. Neither is it the same as EmptyShell, in which any ability to function as an individual is lacking. Compare SplitPersonalityMerge, where two personalities become one, and MentalFusion, where separate minds briefly become one. one, LostInCharacter, where an actor becomes lost in a role, and SecretIdentityIdentity in which it's possible for a character to completely lose their base identity in favor of their outward persona.

See also AmnesiacLover, who doesn't know how QuestForIdentity where an identity loss is the starting premise of the story. Can lead to love back after becoming or be part of an amnesiac.IdentityBreakdown. GrandTheftMe can happen if said identity was stolen. Living in a society where you can't have a real identity is IndividualityIsIllegal. See also QuestForIdentity. Compare LostInCharacter, where an actor becomes lost in a role, and SecretIdentityIdentity in which it's possible for a character to completely lose their base identity in favor of their outward persona.also . If this is a character's backstory, it might be a PreInsanityReveal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
added a line in the description to connect this to secretidentityidentity


Not to be confused with an AssimilationPlot, in which one's identity is subsumed into a HiveMind. Neither is it the same as EmptyShell, in which any ability to function as an individual is lacking. Compare SplitPersonalityMerge, where two personalities become one, and MentalFusion, where separate minds briefly become one. See also AmnesiacLover, who doesn't know how to love back after becoming an amnesiac. GrandTheftMe can happen if said identity was stolen. Living in a society where you can't have a real identity is IndividualityIsIllegal. See also QuestForIdentity. Compare LostInCharacter, where an actor becomes lost in a role. If this is a character's backstory, it might be a PreInsanityReveal.

to:

Not to be confused with an AssimilationPlot, in which one's identity is subsumed into a HiveMind. Neither is it the same as EmptyShell, in which any ability to function as an individual is lacking. Compare SplitPersonalityMerge, where two personalities become one, and MentalFusion, where separate minds briefly become one. See also AmnesiacLover, who doesn't know how to love back after becoming an amnesiac. GrandTheftMe can happen if said identity was stolen. Living in a society where you can't have a real identity is IndividualityIsIllegal. See also QuestForIdentity. Compare LostInCharacter, where an actor becomes lost in a role.role, and SecretIdentityIdentity in which it's possible for a character to completely lose their base identity in favor of their outward persona. If this is a character's backstory, it might be a PreInsanityReveal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the sci-fi film ''Eleven'', by Makodap, the main character Pete Baxter attempts to leave a future hotel without paying his bill. Before he can leave, a woman called Miss Stevens gives him a gift of scotch, upon drinking it and phoning for a call girl, Pete is [[PainfulTransformation transformed]] into the woman he ordered, and slowly starts to lose his mind, becoming her mentally.

to:

* In the sci-fi film ''Eleven'', ''Film/{{Eleven}}'', by Makodap, the main character Pete Baxter attempts to leave a future hotel without paying his bill. Before he can leave, a woman called Miss Stevens gives him a gift of scotch, upon drinking it and phoning for a call girl, Pete is [[PainfulTransformation transformed]] into the woman he ordered, and slowly starts to lose his mind, becoming her mentally.



* This is the crux for much of the drama in ''Regarding Henry'', starring Creator/HarrisonFord. In it, the title character [[TisOnlyABulletInTheBrain survives a gunshot wound to the head]], only for the resulting pinched artery to affect his memory. Cue the rest of the movie depicting him [[QuestForIdentity coming to terms]] with [[LossOfIdentity not remembering anything]] about [[MissingTime his life before]] the [[TraumaInducedAmnesia shot]].

to:

* This is the crux for much of the drama in ''Regarding Henry'', ''Film/RegardingHenry'', starring Creator/HarrisonFord. In it, the title character [[TisOnlyABulletInTheBrain survives a gunshot wound to the head]], only for the resulting pinched artery to affect his memory. Cue the rest of the movie depicting him [[QuestForIdentity coming to terms]] with [[LossOfIdentity not remembering anything]] about [[MissingTime his life before]] the [[TraumaInducedAmnesia shot]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/FateStrangeFake'', Soldier 1 was raised from infancy as a soldier, and was never treated like a child, but a weapon. By the time the story starts, he's an EmptyShell fully devoted to his mission, whatever it is. He really doesn't have a concept of empathy or any idea of how to interact with others outside of combat. His Servant Watcher intends to break him out of this mindset; their first conversation has the boy renounce the title his superiors gave him and name himself Sigma.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[FanFic/TheRivalPrefectsTrilogy The New Prefect]]'', [[spoiler:Thomas has spent the past century as a statue and has difficulty remembering his life as a human]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** GenkiGirl Nora suffers from this during volume 8, after several arguments with her best friend/love interest Ren leave her realizing that, ever since the pair had met, it'd always been "Ren and Nora" and never "just Nora". She claims during this period that she only knows how to "be strong and hit stuff, and when [[spoiler:her overcharging herself to take down a forcefield leaves her horribly injured and unable to do even that, she's left wondering what's left that she's even good for anymore.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as [[PsychoForHire ruthless mercenaries]], as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia. Although they all retain certain personality traits. For example, Two is the ''de facto'' captain of the ship, and was captain as Portia Lin before she lost her memories as well. The one who has changed the least, as Four notes in Season Three [[spoiler:when he recovers his original memories as Ryo Ishida]], is Five (an innocent-seeming TeenGenius girl whose presence amongst these hardened criminals starts out as [[MysteriousWaif a mystery]]), the only one whose birth name is initially unknown anyway as she has no rapsheet in the files.

to:

* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as [[PsychoForHire ruthless mercenaries]], as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia. Although they all retain certain personality traits. For example, Two is the ''de facto'' captain of the ship, and was captain as Portia Lin before she lost her memories as well. The one who has changed the least, as Four notes in Season Three [[spoiler:when he recovers his original memories as Ryo Ishida]], is Five (an innocent-seeming TeenGenius girl whose presence amongst these hardened criminals starts out as [[MysteriousWaif a mystery]]), the only one whose birth name is initially unknown anyway as she has no rapsheet in the files.computer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as [[PsychoForHire ruthless mercenaries]], as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia. Although they all retain certain personality traits. For example, Two is the ''de facto'' captain of the ship, and was captain as Portia Lin before she lost her memories as well. The one who has changed the least, as Four notes in Season Three [[spoiler:when he recovers his original memories as Ryo Ishida]], is Five (an innocent-seeming TeenGenius girl whose presence amongst these hardened criminals starts out as [[MysteriousWaif a mystery]]), the only one whose birth name is initially unknown anyway.

to:

* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as [[PsychoForHire ruthless mercenaries]], as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia. Although they all retain certain personality traits. For example, Two is the ''de facto'' captain of the ship, and was captain as Portia Lin before she lost her memories as well. The one who has changed the least, as Four notes in Season Three [[spoiler:when he recovers his original memories as Ryo Ishida]], is Five (an innocent-seeming TeenGenius girl whose presence amongst these hardened criminals starts out as [[MysteriousWaif a mystery]]), the only one whose birth name is initially unknown anyway.anyway as she has no rapsheet in the files.

Changed: 525

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as ruthless mercenaries, as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia.

to:

* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as [[PsychoForHire ruthless mercenaries, mercenaries]], as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia. Although they all retain certain personality traits. For example, Two is the ''de facto'' captain of the ship, and was captain as Portia Lin before she lost her memories as well. The one who has changed the least, as Four notes in Season Three [[spoiler:when he recovers his original memories as Ryo Ishida]], is Five (an innocent-seeming TeenGenius girl whose presence amongst these hardened criminals starts out as [[MysteriousWaif a mystery]]), the only one whose birth name is initially unknown anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Doctor's ability to [[TheNthDoctor regenerate]] is an interesting twist on this: the many incarnations of the Doctor have entirely different looks and some personality traits that are unique to each, yet they somehow remain fundamentally the same character.

to:

** The Doctor's Doctor and other Time Lords' ability to [[TheNthDoctor regenerate]] is an interesting twist on this: the many incarnations of the Doctor have entirely different looks and some personality traits that are unique to each, yet they somehow remain fundamentally the same character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Doctor's ability to [[TheNthDoctor regenerate]] is an interesting twist on this: the many incarnations of the Doctor have entirely different looks and personalities, yet they somehow remain fundamentally the same character.

to:

** The Doctor's ability to [[TheNthDoctor regenerate]] is an interesting twist on this: the many incarnations of the Doctor have entirely different looks and personalities, some personality traits that are unique to each, yet they somehow remain fundamentally the same character.

Added: 491

Removed: 491

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as ruthless mercenaries, as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia.



* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as ruthless mercenaries, as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia.

Added: 491

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Death of personality has replaced capital punishment. A machine [[LaserGuidedAmnesia wipes the personality and memory]] of a murderer and [[FakeMemories replaces them with a new set]], letting them live out a life of willing hard community service with an assumed identity without them ever being the wiser. A telepath is present to perform scans before and after, so as to ascertain that the process has worked, but does not carry it out themself.

to:

** Death of personality has replaced capital punishment.punishment for crimes like murder (though not treason, still). A machine [[LaserGuidedAmnesia wipes the personality and memory]] of a murderer and [[FakeMemories replaces them with a new set]], letting them live out a life of willing hard community service with an assumed identity without them ever being the wiser. A telepath is present to perform scans before and after, so as to ascertain that the process has worked, but does not carry it out themself.



* In ''Series/BattlestarGalactica2003'' a number of characters suffer identity crises of various types. The Eights get the worst of this: Boomer [[spoiler: almost shoots herself]] because she 'doesn't know who she is anymore'. She [[spoiler: and other 'sleeper' cylons]] have serious identity crises when they [[spoiler: discover that they've been cylons the entire time]] and that [[spoiler: all their memories are falsehoods implanted by Cavil or other cylons.]]

to:

* In ''Series/BattlestarGalactica2003'' a number of characters suffer identity crises of various types. The Eights get the worst of this: Boomer [[spoiler: almost shoots herself]] because she 'doesn't know who she is anymore'. She [[spoiler: and other 'sleeper' cylons]] Cylons]] have serious identity crises when they [[spoiler: discover that they've been cylons Cylons the entire time]] and that [[spoiler: all their memories from before their placement are falsehoods implanted by Cavil or other cylons.Cylons.]]


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/DarkMatter'': At the beginning of the show, the crew agree that they are not defined by their past actions as ruthless mercenaries, as they don't remember any of them. They decide to instead use their skills and equipment for what feels right to them as they are now without those memories, [[ThatManIsDead declining to even use their original names]] except when necessary, instead [[YouAreNumberSix going by One through Six]] in the order they awakened from stasis with amnesia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/InCryptid'', one variety of [[OurMermaidsAreDifferent merfolk]] is born looking and behaving human. But shortly after puberty, any exposure to water will bring forth their oceangoing nature. Saltwater makes it happen faster; and the land memory erodes as fast as the sea traits return, eventually leaving a typical merperson out of myth who may only barely remember anything about those they knew and loved on dry land.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Fanfic/EncryptWithinTheDarkToSaveTheClockworkOfAHeart'': What essentially happens with Ai during the start of the story. He knows from his few fragmented memories that he had a close connection to Yusaku before and still acts like his goofy self, but feels he isn't complete and unsure why he would partner up with someone like [[JerkWithAHeartOfGold Yusaku]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/AllMySinsRemembered'': This is the problem facing Otto McGavin, and indeed all Prime Operators employed by the Confederacion, by the end of the book. A long career of having his real identity subsumed by false or stolen personalities has caused him to suffer a crisis of identity as his mind tried to reconcile his true memories with the various implanted ones used to shield him from detection on missions. He's ultimately left howling in madness as his handlers lament his fate due to him being one of their best agents, ultimately retiring him by permanently locking him in suspended animation.


Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/FinalFantasyXIII'': Explicitly the fate that awaits any l'Cie who fails to complete the Focus given to them by the Fal'Cie. They slowly degenerate into mindless Cie'th, monstrous and aggressive creatures with tainted crystals jutting out of their bodies. Given the Fal'Cie tend to give VERY vague instructions when it comes to what they want done, this fate is far more common than success (and even what you get if you succeed is not that great).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*It has been implied by WordOfGod that this is what happens to those who become Warmongers, of original ''Fanfic/FreedomDiesWithMe'' and ''Splatoon: Crimson Gaze'' fame. The condition is treated as an extreme Fugue state; the old personality "dies" and what replaces it is a violent and embittered parody of who they were. This reaches its logical endpoint with "Ferals", where even that facade is dropped and the victim reverts to primal instincts, and the mysterious "[[EmptyShell Blanks]]".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The [[Music/{{Vocaloid}} Gumi]] song "Copycat" about a girl who erases her personality and remakes it in the image of whatever the people around her are like in order to please them, until she eventually starts to forget who she was in the first place.
-->I've become what you like
-->I am what you wanted, ''right?!''
-->Sacrified all I've known
-->I have taught myself to let go

Added: 389

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/BigSky'': [[spoiler:Legarski]] forgets the last three years as a result of brain damage, and this includes his criminal history apparently. When he wakes up to find himself accused of murder and sex trafficking, he's incredulous, repeating "I'm a Montana state trooper" then horrified when he realizes this must be true. The decent guy he used to be is all that's left it seems.



* A related philosophical question is called "The Ship of Theseus": if each plank in the ship is replaced when it starts to rot, and over time one-by-one every single plank is replaced, at what point (if ever) does it stop being the same ship? [[note]] This is also known as George Washington's axe (my grandpa replaced the handle, and my father replaced the head). Furthermore, there's Kerryman joke to that effect: a Kerryman boasts that he's had the same axe for the past fifty years - with the handle and head replaced, respectively, five and eight times. [[/note]] Specifically, this trope is about the [[ContemplateOurNavels philosophical problem]] of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_identity_%28philosophy%29 personal identity]]. The general notion is that people stay more or less the same throughout their lives, ''despite'' changes to their bodies (if these changes do not drastically change the way the body functions). Just ''what'' makes several iterations the same person, is central to the debate. The debate itself is notorious for the heavy use of [[AppliedPhlebotinum science-fiction]] examples, such as:

to:

* A related philosophical question is called "The Ship of Theseus": if each plank in the ship is replaced when it starts to rot, and over time one-by-one every single plank is replaced, at what point (if ever) does it stop being the same ship? [[note]] This is also known as George Washington's axe (my grandpa replaced the handle, and my father replaced the head). Furthermore, there's a Kerryman joke to that effect: a Kerryman boasts that he's had the same axe for the past fifty years - with the handle and head replaced, respectively, five and eight times. [[/note]] Specifically, this trope is about the [[ContemplateOurNavels philosophical problem]] of [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_identity_%28philosophy%29 personal identity]]. The general notion is that people stay more or less the same throughout their lives, ''despite'' changes to their bodies (if these changes do not drastically change the way the body functions). Just ''what'' makes several iterations the same person, person is central to the debate. The debate itself is notorious for the heavy use of [[AppliedPhlebotinum science-fiction]] examples, such as:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicBook/WonderWoman'' [[ComicBook/WonderWoman1942 Vol 1]]: When ComicBook/SteveTrevor learns he's the transplanted Steve from another dimension whose memories were all crafted by the Amazons (without his or Diana's knowlege) to replace the presumed dead Earth-One Steve he's quite unsettled. He ends up merging with what is left of the Earth-One Steve and feels like a more complete person for it, being quite glad to have [[GhostMemory real memories]] now.

Top