Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / SpinningSilver

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
shifting Adult Fear entries to other tropes

Added DiffLines:

* {{Mundanger}}: The threat of antisemitic violence is always present, sometimes with immediate danger or prejudice, but even when it isn't, Miryem and her family always have the possibility in the back of their minds. When the Staryk King first takes notice of Miryem, her mother is less afraid of the Staryk themselves than their human neighbors finding out that the Staryk are talking to them. She recalls how one Staryk raid years ago happened to skip a village with a high Jewish population, and now there are no more Jews in that village (with the implication being that their neighbors committed a pogrom afterwards). Miryem takes this warning more seriously than the strange and inhuman threat of the Staryk.


Added DiffLines:

* ProtagonistJourneyToVillain: Miryem's mother fears this when Miryem takes up the debt collection. She and her husband worry that they'll watch Miryem become cold and ruthless, but they can't talk her out of it because Miryem's efforts ''work''. Miryem, for her part, feels no moral qualms about collecting from their bigoted neighbors even if it means accepting payment in prized heirlooms, but she always makes sure to deal fairly and never cheats them the way they've cheated the Mandelstams over the years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adult Fear is now a disambig


* AdultFear:
** Miryem's mother fears her daughter becoming cold and ruthless, and her father does too, but they can't talk her out of her debt-collecting - because her father being too softhearted for collecting debt got them almost starving to death and/or dying of cold and Miryem's mother was practically dying of a sickness before Miryem took over collecting. [[spoiler:Then they become afraid for her life as a result of the Staryk king's dealings with her.]]
** The threat of antisemitic violence is always present, sometimes with immediate danger or prejudice, but even when it isn't, Miryem and her family always have the possibility in the back of their minds. Miryem finds it easier to fear that because it's so real and ubiquitous, rather than the inhuman and storied Staryk.
** Early on in her marriage/captivity, Miryem barters her [[UnusualEuphemism marriage rights]] away to the Staryk king in exchange for answers to questions in order to keep him from ''acting'' on those rights (namely consummating their marriage). Later, one he's developed a sense of respect for her cleverness, he thinks her bartering tactic was meant to subtly belittle him, and declares that that night, he [[RapeAsDrama won't be answering any questions for her]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ColorCodedCastes: The Staryk King wears pure white, whereas his subjects wear progressively more and darker shades of grey in decreasing order of rank.

Added: 1158

Changed: 108

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Miryem and her family are Jewish, and the townsfolk's antisemitism goes from fairly passive to outright aggressive once Miryem starts collecting the money they're legally owed. It's implied that her father's passiveness when it comes to moneylending is because he doesn't want the villagers to see him as a GreedyJew... but [[MortonsFork they regard him as such anyway]] even though he's actually generous to a fault. Miryem's mother is also terrified of the Staryk tracks not just because of the Staryk themselves, but because during one raid a few years ago the Staryk happened to ignore a village that had a number of Jewish families living there--and now there are no more Jews in that village.

to:

** Miryem and her family are Jewish, which means the townsfolk shun them, cheat her father, upcharge them in the market, and the townsfolk's try to pass off shoddy goods. Their antisemitism goes from fairly passive to outright aggressive once Miryem starts collecting the money they're legally owed. It's implied that her father's passiveness when it comes to moneylending is because he doesn't want the villagers to see him as a GreedyJew... but [[MortonsFork they regard him as such anyway]] even though he's actually generous to a fault. Miryem's mother is also terrified of the Staryk tracks not just because of the Staryk themselves, but because during one raid a few years ago the Staryk happened to ignore a village that had a number of Jewish families living there--and now there are no more Jews in that village.village.
** Magreta, who is otherwise a sympathetic character, is privately antisemetic thanks to events early in her life. Her father kept borrowing money due to his alcoholism and gambling, which pushed Magreta into service, and a friend of hers had to pawn a beloved heirloom to pay for an abortion; Magreta blames the Jews for conducting these transactions and not her loved ones for making choices that led to financial emergency. (This was a common way for Christian rulers to have a banking system that permitted the charging of interest, which Christians couldn't do, while also having a handy scapegoat around to blame everyone's poverty on when it became convenient.)


Added DiffLines:

* JesusTaboo: The majority religion is never actually named as Christianity, nor the midwinter festival as Christmas, but the fact that it has the same relationship with Judaism that medieval Christianity did and Irina's references to the Holy Mother mean that it isn't anything else.


Added DiffLines:

* StrongFamilyResemblance: Irina notes that all of the men from Mirnatius' father's side look like burly woodsmen stuffed into court finery, further emphasizing that his PrettyBoy appearance is not natural.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Skunk Stripe is no longer a trope. Zero Context Examples and examples that do fit existing tropes will be deleted.


* MysticalWhiteHair: The Staryk have powerful magic, particularly related to winter, and pure white hair. One [[HalfHumanHybrid half-Staryk child]] inherited both the hair and a tiny bit of power, and his child got only a SkunkStripe.

to:

* MysticalWhiteHair: The Staryk have powerful magic, particularly related to winter, and pure white hair. One [[HalfHumanHybrid half-Staryk child]] inherited both the hair and a tiny bit of power, and his child got only a SkunkStripe.skunk streak.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope has been renamed.


* AlwaysChaoticEvil: PlayedWith for the Staryk. They've earned themselves the reputation, with all their raids and kidnappings, and [[spoiler:Miryem's family finds it hard to believe any of them are worth saving]]. But [[spoiler:Miryem points out she met at least three good individuals among them, and that ChildrenAreInnocent; even if the unseen masses supported the actions of the knights, it was out of an attempt at self-preservation from [[BiggerBad Chernobog]]. If he was defeated and a proper contract drawn up, she's certain the Staryk would be no more evil than anyone else. And she's right.]]

to:

* AlwaysChaoticEvil: PlayedWith for the Staryk. They've earned themselves the reputation, with all their raids and kidnappings, and [[spoiler:Miryem's family finds it hard to believe any of them are worth saving]]. But [[spoiler:Miryem points out she met at least three good individuals among them, and that ChildrenAreInnocent; even if the unseen masses supported the actions of the knights, it was out of an attempt at self-preservation from [[BiggerBad Chernobog]].Chernobog. If he was defeated and a proper contract drawn up, she's certain the Staryk would be no more evil than anyone else. And she's right.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BlueAndOrangeMorality: Miryem has much difficulty negotiating with the Staryk Lord and getting information out of him because he refuses to treat her like someone born and raised in a society not so radically focused on holding up your end of an agreement and giving people what they're owed. Hence, even though ''neither of them want to go through with it'', [[spoiler: he insists on marrying her when she succeeds at turning his silver into gold.]] This is only further complicated by how people in the Staryk Land don't just give up on things of value even if they don't want them, and will give what is owed/deserved even if the owed party doesn't want the payment. [[spoiler: Such as a wife's right to have sex with her husband. Miryem has to announce that she'll gladly trade info for not having sex to avoid being deflowered by an ice demon.]] The Staryk are also horrified at the ease to which humans address each other by name, not realizing that it doesn't put them in danger of binding.

to:

* BlueAndOrangeMorality: Miryem has much difficulty negotiating with the Staryk Lord and getting information out of him because he refuses to treat her like someone born and raised in a society not so radically focused on holding up your end of an agreement and giving people what they're owed. Hence, even though ''neither of them want to go through with it'', [[spoiler: he [[spoiler:he insists on marrying her when she succeeds at turning his silver into gold.]] This is only further complicated by how people in the Staryk Land don't just give up on things of value even if they don't want them, and will give what is owed/deserved even if the owed party doesn't want the payment. [[spoiler: Such [[spoiler:Such as a wife's right to have sex with her husband. Miryem has to announce that she'll gladly trade info for not having sex to avoid being deflowered by an ice demon.]] The Staryk are also horrified at the ease to which humans address each other by name, not realizing that it doesn't put them in danger of binding.



* CainAndAbel: Many suspect Mirnatius of having murdered his kind-hearted older brother for the throne. [[spoiler: {{Subverted|Trope}} when Mirnatius admits that Chernobog killed him against his wishes and that his brother, despite being the one who taught him CrueltyToAnimals, was the only person he truly loved.]]

to:

* CainAndAbel: Many suspect Mirnatius of having murdered his kind-hearted older brother for the throne. [[spoiler: {{Subverted|Trope}} [[spoiler:{{Subverted|Trope}} when Mirnatius admits that Chernobog killed him against his wishes and that his brother, despite being the one who taught him CrueltyToAnimals, was the only person he truly loved.]]



* DealWithTheDevil: [[spoiler: The Tzar, Mirnatius, is in one of these, although eventually we find out that he was not the one who made the deal: his mother was, selling her unborn child for the demon's power. He is forced to share his body with a fire demon who uses magic to manipulate those around him and who got him the throne by killing his father and beloved half brother.]]

to:

* DealWithTheDevil: [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The Tzar, Mirnatius, is in one of these, although eventually we find out that he was not the one who made the deal: his mother was, selling her unborn child for the demon's power. He is forced to share his body with a fire demon who uses magic to manipulate those around him and who got him the throne by killing his father and beloved half brother.]]



* EndlessWinter: The Staryk's world is like this. [[spoiler: Their King's goal is to do this to the human world as well, as the colder Earth is, the stronger the Staryk King's palace is.]]

to:

* EndlessWinter: The Staryk's world is like this. [[spoiler: Their [[spoiler:Their King's goal is to do this to the human world as well, as the colder Earth is, the stronger the Staryk King's palace is.]]



** At one point, the Staryk challenges Miryem to turn the contents of three of his treasure chambers from silver to gold. [[spoiler: After spending a massive amount of time changing just one, she gets her servants to empty out all the silver from the largest vault while she changes the second. As the Staryk said, she had to change 'everything in the chambers'.]]
** This is how much of the magic in this setting works. For example, it doesn't matter how Miryem comes by it, but she manages to take three large amounts of silver and come back with equal amounts of gold. [[spoiler: This gives her the power to transform silver into gold.]]
** Irina asks nothing from Chernobog, only that he leave "me and mine alone." [[spoiler:Because she is the tsarina, this means that he can't touch ''anyone in the country of Lithvas''. That also includes her husband once he leaves his body, because her rights to him as his wife legally override his mother's contract.]]

to:

** At one point, the Staryk challenges Miryem to turn the contents of three of his treasure chambers from silver to gold. [[spoiler: After [[spoiler:After spending a massive amount of time changing just one, she gets her servants to empty out all the silver from the largest vault while she changes the second. As the Staryk said, she had to change 'everything in the chambers'.]]
** This is how much of the magic in this setting works. For example, it doesn't matter how Miryem comes by it, but she manages to take three large amounts of silver and come back with equal amounts of gold. [[spoiler: This [[spoiler:This gives her the power to transform silver into gold.]]
** Irina asks nothing from Chernobog, only that he leave "me and mine alone." [[spoiler:Because she is the tsarina, this means that he can't touch ''anyone in the country of Lithvas''. That also includes her husband once he leaves his body, because [[PositionOfLiteralPower her rights to him as his wife wife]] legally override his mother's contract.]]



* GoodIsNotNice: A mild variant with Miryem. She isn't a loan shark, only charging a fair amount of interest and giving people fair prices for whatever they offer to her as payment, but it's known that her grandfather is wealthy and powerful, and she has the ledgers to prove what she is owed. She's not above threatening to get the law involved if it means getting what she is owed, and has Gorek's daughter, Wanda, pay off his debts by working for her, first as a maid and then also as a debt collector. [[spoiler: This turns out to be a blessing for Wanda.]]

to:

* GoodIsNotNice: A mild variant with Miryem. She isn't a loan shark, only charging a fair amount of interest and giving people fair prices for whatever they offer to her as payment, but it's known that her grandfather is wealthy and powerful, and she has the ledgers to prove what she is owed. She's not above threatening to get the law involved if it means getting what she is owed, and has Gorek's daughter, Wanda, pay off his debts by working for her, first as a maid and then also as a debt collector. [[spoiler: This [[spoiler:This turns out to be a blessing for Wanda.]]



** Irina takes no joy in the fact that [[spoiler: her plan for saving the kingdom from an eternal winter means that all Staryk, including innocent children, will be devoured by Chernobog. Knowing that Mirnatius had no say in being bound to it, she is also not joyful at all when planning to out him as a witch and burning him at the stake.]]

to:

** Irina takes no joy in the fact that [[spoiler: her [[spoiler:her plan for saving the kingdom from an eternal winter means that all Staryk, including innocent children, will be devoured by Chernobog. Knowing that Mirnatius had no say in being bound to it, she is also not joyful at all when planning to out him as a witch and burning him at the stake.]]



* IJustWantToBeNormal: [[spoiler: Mirnatius never wanted the throne and loved his brother]]; he would have been happy living a life devoid of politics in which he could be an artist. [[spoiler: Chernobog had other plans.]]

to:

* IJustWantToBeNormal: [[spoiler: Mirnatius [[spoiler:Mirnatius never wanted the throne and loved his brother]]; he would have been happy living a life devoid of politics in which he could be an artist. [[spoiler: Chernobog [[spoiler:Chernobog had other plans.]]



** This is the cornerstone of binding magic. Staryk only give their names to those they trust the most. [[spoiler: The book ends with Miryem learning of the Staryk Lord's name when he signs a wedding contract with her.]]

to:

** This is the cornerstone of binding magic. Staryk only give their names to those they trust the most. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The book ends with Miryem learning of the Staryk Lord's name when he signs a wedding contract with her.]]



* IncestantAdmirer: Ilias to Mirnatius, much to the latter's annoyance. Mirnatius doesn't seem particularly bothered by the fact that Ilias is his male cousin, so much that [[spoiler: if Ilias ever did manage to sneak into his bedroom, Chernobog would kill him, and covering up the death of a royal cousin would be harder to cover up than any of the commoners Chernobog usually kills]].

to:

* IncestantAdmirer: Ilias to Mirnatius, much to the latter's annoyance. Mirnatius doesn't seem particularly bothered by the fact that Ilias is his male cousin, so much that [[spoiler: if [[spoiler:if Ilias ever did manage to sneak into his bedroom, Chernobog would kill him, and covering up the death of a royal cousin would be harder to cover up than any of the commoners Chernobog usually kills]].



** Gorek, Wanda's father, can in many ways be described as the polar opposite of Miryem's father. Miryem's father would go hungry so his wife and daughter could eat and was happy to help his wife with women's work to make things easier for her; his only fault was that he was too kind to collect on the debts people owed him unless they desperately needed the money. Gorek is a domestic abuser who gambles away money he could use to feed his starving family, and [[spoiler: would have pimped his daughter out to the village men had Miryem not unknowingly saved her by arranging for Wanda to work as a housemaid for her family to pay off his debts.]]

to:

** Gorek, Wanda's father, can in many ways be described as the polar opposite of Miryem's father. Miryem's father would go hungry so his wife and daughter could eat and was happy to help his wife with women's work to make things easier for her; his only fault was that he was too kind to collect on the debts people owed him unless they desperately needed the money. Gorek is a domestic abuser who gambles away money he could use to feed his starving family, and [[spoiler: would [[spoiler:would have pimped his daughter out to the village men had Miryem not unknowingly saved her by arranging for Wanda to work as a housemaid for her family to pay off his debts.]]



* TheManBehindTheMan: Irina as tsarina. When she learns that magic exists [[spoiler: and that her husband gets away with whatever he wants with the help of a demon]], she reminds him that unless he can snap his fingers and make money and goods this will do him little if there's a famine or he runs out of money. She also suggests that if his powers have a limited range he'll be just as vulnerable as anyone else to stray arrows on the battlefield. Once she's ensured her immediate safety, she sets about cleaning up the political mess caused by Mirnatius' neglectful rule, which has left the nobility a scant few inches away from revolt. Although he's as acerbic about it as he is about everything, Mirnatius doesn't interfere with any of the decisions she makes.

to:

* TheManBehindTheMan: Irina as tsarina. When she learns that magic exists [[spoiler: and [[spoiler:and that her husband gets away with whatever he wants with the help of a demon]], she reminds him that unless he can snap his fingers and make money and goods this will do him little if there's a famine or he runs out of money. She also suggests that if his powers have a limited range he'll be just as vulnerable as anyone else to stray arrows on the battlefield. Once she's ensured her immediate safety, she sets about cleaning up the political mess caused by Mirnatius' neglectful rule, which has left the nobility a scant few inches away from revolt. Although he's as acerbic about it as he is about everything, Mirnatius doesn't interfere with any of the decisions she makes.



* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: Miryem briefly has this reaction when [[spoiler: she finds out that the gold is the key to stealing the spring from the world and that her transmutations have been extending the winter.]] She again has this reaction when she realizes [[spoiler: that defeating the Staryk King could also mean that the innocent Staryk commoners could also become food for Chernobog. She has no guilt about the King or the other nobles who have been killing and raiding for gold, but she can't stand the idea of the children being punished.]]

to:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: Miryem briefly has this reaction when [[spoiler: she [[spoiler:she finds out that the gold is the key to stealing the spring from the world and that her transmutations have been extending the winter.]] She again has this reaction when she realizes [[spoiler: that [[spoiler:that defeating the Staryk King could also mean that the innocent Staryk commoners could also become food for Chernobog. She has no guilt about the King or the other nobles who have been killing and raiding for gold, but she can't stand the idea of the children being punished.]]



** Firstly, the Staryk King [[spoiler: tasking Miryem with turning his silver into gold results in her having it turned into jewelry and sold.]] This jewelry winds up in the hands of Irina, and [[spoiler: its magic allows her to use mirrors as portals to the Staryk's world. She's able to hide there from a demon her husband harbors which intends on devouring her life force.]]
** Then, Gorek's drunken rage [[spoiler: at Wanda's refusal to accept the marriage he arranged for her provokes her brother into action to save her. Gorek dies in the struggle. The two of them escape to the woods and hide in a cabin that turns out to be connected to the Staryk's realm as well, and some of the things they make and food they cook wind up in the other world's reflection of the cabin. This winds up saving Irina and her nanny when they're close to dying in the cold. They also are in the perfect place to find their younger brother and Miryem's parents when they're stranded in the woods.]]
** And on top of all of this [[spoiler: Irina winds up returning the favor to Miryem, as they meet up in the Staryk's realm and hatch a plan to save the world and get the demon to leave Irina alone by feeding it the Staryk Lord. Things don't work out as planned, but ultimately Chernobog is defeated and the Staryk Lord stops his raids on the human world.]]

to:

** Firstly, the Staryk King [[spoiler: tasking [[spoiler:tasking Miryem with turning his silver into gold results in her having it turned into jewelry and sold.]] This jewelry winds up in the hands of Irina, and [[spoiler: its [[spoiler:its magic allows her to use mirrors as portals to the Staryk's world. She's able to hide there from a demon her husband harbors which intends on devouring her life force.]]
** Then, Gorek's drunken rage [[spoiler: at [[spoiler:at Wanda's refusal to accept the marriage he arranged for her provokes her brother into action to save her. Gorek dies in the struggle. The two of them escape to the woods and hide in a cabin that turns out to be connected to the Staryk's realm as well, and some of the things they make and food they cook wind up in the other world's reflection of the cabin. This winds up saving Irina and her nanny when they're close to dying in the cold. They also are in the perfect place to find their younger brother and Miryem's parents when they're stranded in the woods.]]
** And on top of all of this [[spoiler: Irina [[spoiler:Irina winds up returning the favor to Miryem, as they meet up in the Staryk's realm and hatch a plan to save the world and get the demon to leave Irina alone by feeding it the Staryk Lord. Things don't work out as planned, but ultimately Chernobog is defeated and the Staryk Lord stops his raids on the human world.]]



* ObstructiveCodeOfConduct: Part of the Staryks' general BlueAndOrangeMorality. For example, they cannot give or receive gifts, seeing them as devastating insults or signs of weakness (even the concept of "thanks" is disdainful to them), which means that when a Staryk is mortally wounded, they cannot accept the unbidden help of those around them without bartering first, choosing instead of kill their would-be helper and die in the process themselves, something we hear both from Miryem's recollection of a family who attempted to help a Staryk knight (only two children were left alive, and that was because they were hiding), as well as what happens when [[spoiler: Sergey attempts to aid the Staryk King, who almost kills him until Miryem convinces the two to deal first]].
* OhCrap: [[spoiler: Oleg's]] reaction to realizing the gold he was about to steal was earmarked for the Staryk is not exactly a stoic one. This is fully justified, as their magic takes his life shortly afterwards.

to:

* ObstructiveCodeOfConduct: Part of the Staryks' general BlueAndOrangeMorality. For example, they cannot give or receive gifts, seeing them as devastating insults or signs of weakness (even the concept of "thanks" is disdainful to them), which means that when a Staryk is mortally wounded, they cannot accept the unbidden help of those around them without bartering first, choosing instead of kill their would-be helper and die in the process themselves, something we hear both from Miryem's recollection of a family who attempted to help a Staryk knight (only two children were left alive, and that was because they were hiding), as well as what happens when [[spoiler: Sergey [[spoiler:Sergey attempts to aid the Staryk King, who almost kills him until Miryem convinces the two to deal first]].
* OhCrap: [[spoiler: Oleg's]] [[spoiler:Oleg's]] reaction to realizing the gold he was about to steal was earmarked for the Staryk is not exactly a stoic one. This is fully justified, as their magic takes his life shortly afterwards.



* ReluctantRuler: It becomes clear over the course of the book that Mirnatius is far more interested in beauty than anything resembling statecraft. [[spoiler: He did not want the job, nor did he want his half-brother to die, but Chernobog had different ideas.]]
* RescueRomance: It's implied that [[spoiler: Mirnatius falls in love with Irina after she tricks Chernobog into leaving him.]]

to:

* ReluctantRuler: It becomes clear over the course of the book that Mirnatius is far more interested in beauty than anything resembling statecraft. [[spoiler: He [[spoiler:He did not want the job, nor did he want his half-brother to die, but Chernobog had different ideas.]]
* RescueRomance: It's implied that [[spoiler: Mirnatius [[spoiler:Mirnatius falls in love with Irina after she tricks Chernobog into leaving him.]]



** Then Miryem [[spoiler: completes the Staryk Lord's tasks and goes from wealthy commoner to queen. The book ends this way as she's fallen in love with him for real.]]

to:

** Then Miryem [[spoiler: completes [[spoiler:completes the Staryk Lord's tasks and goes from wealthy commoner to queen. The book ends this way as she's fallen in love with him for real.]]



** Irina, once she becomes tsarina, sets to work immediately both on the demon problem and the political problems of Lithvas, knowing that the country is a few bad decisions away from civil war. She notes that technically her job just to produce a tsarevitch, but very few tsarinas actually confine themselves just to that.

to:

** Irina, once she becomes tsarina, sets to work immediately both on the demon problem and the political problems of Lithvas, knowing that the country is a few bad decisions away from civil war. She notes that technically her job is just to produce a tsarevitch, but very few tsarinas actually confine themselves just to that.



* SoProudOfYou: Irina's father has ignored her for most of her life. [[spoiler: He finally tells her that he is proud of her when she shows she can play the game as well as he can.]]

to:

* SoProudOfYou: Irina's father has ignored her for most of her life. [[spoiler: He [[spoiler:He finally tells her that he is proud of her when she shows she can play the game as well as he can.]]



* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: Miryem is an inversion of this for Wanda, as her demand that Wanda work off her father's debt [[spoiler: prevents him from marrying her off for a dowry, and they provide her with dinner free of charge, unaware that she usually goes hungry at home. However, when Miryem finds out that Wanda's father was beating her and that Wanda had hidden her raise from him in order to try and save up enough to escape, Miryem is aghast at how easily it all could have fallen apart if Gorek had complained to her and Miryem had fired back.]]

to:

* UnwittingInstigatorOfDoom: Miryem is an inversion of this for Wanda, as her demand that Wanda work off her father's debt [[spoiler: prevents [[spoiler:prevents him from marrying her off for a dowry, and they provide her with dinner free of charge, unaware that she usually goes hungry at home. However, when Miryem finds out that Wanda's father was beating her and that Wanda had hidden her raise from him in order to try and save up enough to escape, Miryem is aghast at how easily it all could have fallen apart if Gorek had complained to her and Miryem had fired back.]]



* WhamEpisode: Chapter 10. [[spoiler: The marriage chapter in which Miryem is taken to the Staryk lands, Wanda's father dies, and we learn that the tsar is harboring a demon that wants to devour Irina.]]

to:

* WhamEpisode: Chapter 10. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The marriage chapter in which Miryem is taken to the Staryk lands, Wanda's father dies, and we learn that the tsar is harboring a demon that wants to devour Irina.]]



* WhatTheHellHero: Played with. [[spoiler: The Staryk King is more of an AntiVillain, sacrificing humanity to save his people from Chernobog,]] but Miryem calls him out on how even that justification is flimsy at best as [[spoiler: nobody knew that Mirnatius was harboring a demon when they crowned him king, and would have burnt him at the stake if they'd known. Unbeknownst to either of them, Mirnatius has no say in harboring a demon or becoming king, but Chernobog went ahead and killed his family against his wishes. She also reminds him how the Staryk were pillaging human villages well before Chernobog came to power. He ultimately ''admits'' she was right and enters a contract to stop their pillaging if Chernobog is defeated.]]

to:

* WhatTheHellHero: Played with. [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The Staryk King is more of an AntiVillain, sacrificing humanity to save his people from Chernobog,]] but Miryem calls him out on how even that justification is flimsy at best as [[spoiler: nobody [[spoiler:nobody knew that Mirnatius was harboring a demon when they crowned him king, and would have burnt him at the stake if they'd known. Unbeknownst to either of them, Mirnatius has no say in harboring a demon or becoming king, but Chernobog went ahead and killed his family against his wishes. She also reminds him how the Staryk were pillaging human villages well before Chernobog came to power. He ultimately ''admits'' she was right and enters a contract to stop their pillaging if Chernobog is defeated.]]



* WouldNotHurtAChild: [[spoiler: The knowledge that there are Staryk children]] is what drives Miryem to defeat Chernobog.

to:

* WouldNotHurtAChild: [[spoiler: The [[spoiler:The knowledge that there are Staryk children]] is what drives Miryem to defeat Chernobog.

Added: 1083

Changed: 275

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllFirstPersonNarratorsWriteLikeNovelists: Averted. Miryem, Irina, Magreta, and Mirnatius are all educated and use varying levels of polish in their internal monologues, distiguished by their individual personalities (Mirnatius, for example, is witheringly sarcastic in almost every line). Wanda and Stepon, who are illiterate when the story begins, use simpler vocabulary and a much more basic way of describing the events around them.



* EveryoneHasStandards: After learning that [[spoiler:Mirnatius was given to Chernobog as a "promissory note" while his mother was pregnant]], Irina finds a strange comfort in knowing that for all the Duke's faults as a father, she can be sure that he would never have sold her to a demon for his own gain.



* LoveRevelationEpiphany: Magreta loves Irina like the child she never had but had never been sure it was returned because of Irina's quiet, almost stoic personality. It's not until Magreta is taken to the tsar's household as a hostage that she sees how frightened Irina is over Magreta's safety.
--> "Oh, it was a strange way to be happy."



* MaritalRapeLicense: The concept of a married couple being entitled to the other's body is in force both in the human and the Staryk world. The Staryk king obviously does not want to do this and immediately takes her deal for questions in exchange for her rights, but he doesn't mention ''his'' until [[spoiler:she succeeds in her task--ironically, his newfound respect for her means she's less safe. She makes sure to specify that "no taking unwilling women" includes herself when she makes her second pact with him later on]].

to:

* MaritalRapeLicense: The concept of a married couple spouse being entitled to the other's body is in force both in the human and the Staryk world. The Staryk king obviously does not want to do this and immediately takes her Miryem's deal for questions in exchange for lieu of her rights, "marital rights", but he doesn't mention ''his'' until [[spoiler:she succeeds in her task--ironically, his newfound respect for her means she's less safe. She makes sure to specify that "no taking unwilling women" includes herself when she makes her second pact with him later on]].



* NobilityMarriesMoney: The Duke of Vysnia's second marriage.

to:

* NobilityMarriesMoney: The Duke of Vysnia's second marriage.marriage was to a rich widow who, likewise, bargained the total independence she could have had to raise her place in society. Their marriage appears to be an amiable and pragmatic one, with both being well-satisfied with the arrangement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreSavvy: Irina recognizes the similarity of being married to the tsar to Scheherazade's own marriage to a monstrous husband, but she doesn't want to beg nightly for her life over ''quite'' so long a period of time. (She also doesn't ''have'' the time, given Lithvas' desperate situation.)

to:

* GenreSavvy: Irina recognizes the similarity of being married to the tsar to Scheherazade's own marriage to a monstrous husband, but she doesn't want to beg nightly for her life over ''quite'' so long a period of time. (She also doesn't ''have'' (However, she does seem to forget that Scheherazade got herself married to the time, given Lithvas' desperate situation.sultan as part of a deliberate plan.)

Added: 1331

Changed: 36

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreSavvy: Irina recognizes the similarity of being married to the tsar to Scheherazade's own marriage to a monstrous husband, but she doesn't want to beg nightly for her life over ''quite'' so long a period of time. (She also doesn't ''have'' the time, given Lithvas' desperate situation.)



* MaritalRapeLicense: The concept of a married couple being entitled to the other's body is in force both in the human and the Staryk world. The Staryk king obviously does not want to do this and immediately takes her deal for questions in exchange for her rights, but he doesn't mention ''his'' until [[spoiler:she succeeds in her task--ironically, his newfound respect for her means she's less safe. She makes sure to specify that "no taking unwilling women" includes herself when she makes her second pact with him later on]].



* ParentalAbuse: Gorek hits his children whether they please him or displease him, when they speak up, and when they don't. The way the Mandelstams treat Miryem ''confuses'' Wanda and Stepon at first because it's utterly foreign to their experience of a parent.
* ParentalNeglect: The Duke has Irina occupy the highest, most remote rooms of his house after his second marriage produces two boys. With her looks unlikely to attract a useful husband, he treats her like a useless item that he's put in the attic.



** Irina's father, the Duke, is a fair ruler who focuses on the big picture and refuses to be courted into rebellion, but he views his daughter largely as a waste of resources because he can't give her a dowry and she's not beautiful enough to tempt any high-ranking lords into marrying without one. She muses that he can give his daughter to an unpleasant and troublesome marriage because he put himself through unpleasant and troublesome battles to attain his own position. [[spoiler:When she demonstrates that she can play the game as well as he can, he expresses his approval of her, and she realizes that this affects her more than she expected.]]

to:

** Irina's father, the Duke, is a fair ruler who focuses on the big picture and refuses to be courted into rebellion, but he views his daughter largely as a waste of resources because he can't give her a dowry and she's not beautiful enough to tempt any high-ranking lords into marrying without one. She muses that he can give his daughter to an unpleasant and troublesome difficult marriage because he put himself through unpleasant and troublesome difficult battles to attain his own position. [[spoiler:When she demonstrates that she can play the game as well as he can, he expresses his approval of her, and she realizes that this affects her more than she expected.]]

Added: 1583

Changed: 718

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: Miryem briefly has this reaction when [[spoiler: she finds out that the gold is the key to stealing the spring from the world.]] She again has this reaction when she realizes [[spoiler: that defeating the Staryk King could also mean that the innocent Staryk commoners could also become food for Chernobog. She has no guilt about the King or the other nobles who have been killing and raiding for gold, but she can't stand the idea of the children being punished.]]

to:

* MyGodWhatHaveIDone: Miryem briefly has this reaction when [[spoiler: she finds out that the gold is the key to stealing the spring from the world.world and that her transmutations have been extending the winter.]] She again has this reaction when she realizes [[spoiler: that defeating the Staryk King could also mean that the innocent Staryk commoners could also become food for Chernobog. She has no guilt about the King or the other nobles who have been killing and raiding for gold, but she can't stand the idea of the children being punished.]]



* RapePillageAndBurn: Magreta, Irina's nurse, narrowly avoided this as a younger woman when the present duke seized his seat--the former duchess locked the women of her household in a basement chamber for their protection. By the time they were found, the soldiers were too tired from battle to do anything but bring them to the duke. He instructed that they be let alone, because "we don't always need to be brutal."

to:

* RapePillageAndBurn: RapePillageAndBurn:
**
Magreta, Irina's nurse, narrowly avoided this as a younger woman when the present duke seized his seat--the former duchess locked the women of her household in a basement chamber for their protection. By the time they were found, the soldiers were too tired from battle to do anything but bring them to the duke. He instructed that they be let alone, because "we don't always need to be brutal.""
** Staryk knights have always done this minus the "burn" part; Irina has Staryk blood because her grandmother was raped by a raiding Staryk knight. [[spoiler:Miryem puts a stop to this by making a new pact with the Staryk king that they will ''only'' kill in defense of their own lands, not raid for gold, and only take willing women.]]



* SoBeautifulItsACurse: Wanda becomes uncomfortably aware of her physical attributes the first time her father rejects an offer for her hand and does what she can to make herself appear more plain, but she can't stop her figure from filling out or her hair from being thick and yellow. It's pure luck that leads her to get a job in Miryem's house before he starts pimping her out in the market.



* ThirdPartyDealBreaker: The climax has a heroic version when Irina breaks the [[DemonicPossession demonic pact]] that keeps her husband TrappedInVillainy. His mother sold him into the pact, but Irina argues that a wife's claim to her husband supersedes a mother's claim to her son.

to:

* ThirdPartyDealBreaker: The climax has a heroic version when Irina [[spoiler:Irina breaks the [[DemonicPossession demonic pact]] that keeps her husband TrappedInVillainy. His mother sold him into the pact, but Irina argues that a wife's claim to her husband supersedes a mother's claim to her son.]]



* WinterRoyalLady: Irina becomes this thanks to the jewelry made of Staryk silver. Others looking at her describe her pieces as having "winter around her throat" or on her brow, and her own clothing (unless Mirnatius fancies it up) is usually in shades of grey or blue.

to:

* WinterRoyalLady: WinterRoyalLady:
**
Irina becomes this thanks to the jewelry made of Staryk silver. Others looking at her describe her pieces as having "winter around her throat" or on her brow, and her own clothing (unless Mirnatius fancies it up) is usually in shades of grey or blue.blue.
** Miryem is mistaken for one when she turns up at Basia's wedding in the full regalia of a Staryk queen. She feels absurd and uncomfortable in garb that was designed for someone who is made out of ice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Genre Savvy is specifically about characters referring to fictional conventions in-universe, not being savvy about the world they live in.


* GenreSavvy: Irina is an extremely savvy leader, quickly figuring out how to escape from the demon her husband harbors, including limitations that he hadn't considered, and [[spoiler: deftly takes over leading the kingdom after they capture the Staryk King.]] During the book's finale, she wisely [[spoiler: refuses to strike a deal with Chernobog and forces him to leave her kingdom forever, using ExactWords to force him to free her husband in the process.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ThirdPartyDealBreaker: The climax has a heroic version when Irina breaks the [[DemonicPossession demonic pact]] that keeps her husband TrappedInVillainy. His mother sold him into the pact, but Irina argues that a wife's claim to her husband supersedes a mother's claim to her son.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A SpiritualSuccessor to the author's previous novel, ''Literature/{{Uprooted}}''. While the two books don't share a setting, their tones and themes overlap significantly, with this book being ''very'' loosely based on the stories of Literature/{{Rumpelstiltskin}}, Literature/{{Bluebeard}}, and Literature/HanselAndGretel.

to:

A SpiritualSuccessor to the author's author Creator/NaomiNovik's previous novel, ''Literature/{{Uprooted}}''. While the two books don't share a setting, their tones and themes overlap significantly, with this book being ''very'' loosely based on the stories of Literature/{{Rumpelstiltskin}}, Literature/{{Bluebeard}}, and Literature/HanselAndGretel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Transmutation}}: Miryem completes the Staryk King's challenge to "turn silver into gold" by trading the silver up to an equal quantity of gold. This gives her the power to literally transmute silver into gold while she's in the [[LandOfFaerie Staryk realm]], even though she's an otherwise non-magical human.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Irina's father, the Duke, is a fair ruler who focuses on the big picture and refuses to be courted into rebellion, but he views his daughter largely as a waste of resources because he can't give her a dowry and she's not beautiful enough to tempt any high-ranking lords into marrying without one. She muses that he can give his daughter to an unpleasant and troublesome marriage because he put himself through unpleasant and troublesome battles to attain his own position.

to:

** Irina's father, the Duke, is a fair ruler who focuses on the big picture and refuses to be courted into rebellion, but he views his daughter largely as a waste of resources because he can't give her a dowry and she's not beautiful enough to tempt any high-ranking lords into marrying without one. She muses that he can give his daughter to an unpleasant and troublesome marriage because he put himself through unpleasant and troublesome battles to attain his own position. [[spoiler:When she demonstrates that she can play the game as well as he can, he expresses his approval of her, and she realizes that this affects her more than she expected.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreSavvy: Irina is an extremely savvy leader, quickly figuring out how to escape from the demon her husband harbors, including limitations that he hadn't considered, and [[spoiler: deftly takes over leading the kingdom after they capture the Staryk King.]] During the book's finale, she wisely [[spoiler: refuses to strike a deal with Chernobog and forces him to leave her kingdom forever.]]

to:

* GenreSavvy: Irina is an extremely savvy leader, quickly figuring out how to escape from the demon her husband harbors, including limitations that he hadn't considered, and [[spoiler: deftly takes over leading the kingdom after they capture the Staryk King.]] During the book's finale, she wisely [[spoiler: refuses to strike a deal with Chernobog and forces him to leave her kingdom forever.forever, using ExactWords to force him to free her husband in the process.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForcedIntoEvil: Mirnatius was [[spoiler:forced into villainy by a DealWithTheDevil his mother made before he was even born, binding a demon into him that he has no way to keep from feeding as long as he lives.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fixed spoiler tag


* IncestantAdmirer: Ilias to Mirnatius, much to the latter's annoyance. Mirnatius doesn't seem particularly bothered by the fact that Ilias is his male cousin, so much that [[spoiler: if Ilias ever did manage to sneak into his bedroom, Chernobog would kill him, and covering up the death of a royal cousin would be harder to cover up than any of the commoners Chernobog usually kills].

to:

* IncestantAdmirer: Ilias to Mirnatius, much to the latter's annoyance. Mirnatius doesn't seem particularly bothered by the fact that Ilias is his male cousin, so much that [[spoiler: if Ilias ever did manage to sneak into his bedroom, Chernobog would kill him, and covering up the death of a royal cousin would be harder to cover up than any of the commoners Chernobog usually kills].kills]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenreSavvy: Irina is an extremely savvy leader, quickly figuring out how to escape from the demon her husband harbors, including limitations that he hadn't considered, and [[spoiler: deftly takes over leading the kingdom after they capture the Staryk King.]] During the book's finale, she wisely [[spoiler: refuses to strike a deal with Chernobog and forces him to leave her kingdom forever.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BitchInSheepsClothing: The townsfolk in general, but [[spoiler:Oleg in particular for trying to ''murder'' Miryem out of greed and and antisemitism. It's hinted that although he enjoyed an excellent reputation among his neighbors, he was abusing his wife behind closed doors]].

to:

* BitchInSheepsClothing: The townsfolk in general, but [[spoiler:Oleg in particular for trying to ''murder'' Miryem out of greed and greed and antisemitism. It's hinted that although he enjoyed an excellent reputation among his neighbors, he was abusing his wife behind closed doors]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The entry doesn't refer to a specific trope being deconstructed, so I think this is more appropriate.


* DeconstructedTrope: At the end of the book, [[spoiler:Chernobog is defeated and both Lithvas and the Staryk are safe. But although Miryem's neighbors make friendly noises as a result of her father forgiving their debts, no one thinks they've magically lost their prejudice, and the ones who have been particularly hostile remain so. Rather than return their old house, the Mandelstams join Wanda and her brothers in making the witch's hut a large family home.]]

to:

* DeconstructedTrope: {{Deconstruction}}: At the end of the book, [[spoiler:Chernobog is defeated and both Lithvas and the Staryk are safe. But although Miryem's neighbors make friendly noises as a result of her father forgiving their debts, no one thinks they've magically lost their prejudice, and the ones who have been particularly hostile remain so. Rather than return to their old house, the Mandelstams join Wanda and her brothers in making the witch's hut a large family home.]]

Added: 463

Removed: 458

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeconstructedTrope: At the end of the book, [[spoiler:Chernobog is defeated and both Lithvas and the Staryk are safe. But although Miryem's neighbors make friendly noises as a result of her father forgiving their debts, no one thinks they've magically lost their prejudice, and the ones who have been particularly hostile remain so. Rather than return their old house, the Mandelstams join Wanda and her brothers in making the witch's hut a large family home.]]



* RealityEnsues: At the end of the book, [[spoiler:Chernobog is defeated and both Lithvas and the Staryk are safe. But although Miryem's neighbors make friendly noises as a result of her father forgiving their debts, no one thinks they've magically lost their prejudice, and the ones who have been particularly hostile remain so. Rather than return their old house, the Mandelstams join Wanda and her brothers in making the witch's hut a large family home.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HandshakeRefusal: Miryem doesn't try shaking hands with Wanda the first time they make an agreement because she assumes Wanda will either refuse or not mean it because Miryem is Jewish and Wanda is Christian. Wanda, for her part, doesn't expect it because she's so poor and lowly compared to Miryem. Later, Miryem does impulsively stick her hand out when striking the deal that will let Wanda keep working for the Mandelstams until she's earned enough to leave Gorek, and Wanda, though shocked, returns the gesture sincerely.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: Chernobog grows bewildered and frustrated with Irina in front of her enduring refusal to enter into a contract with him, only asking for the demon to "leave me and mine alone".


Added DiffLines:

* LaserGuidedAmnesia: Everything related to the Staryks tend to fade from people's memory when the Staryks are not right there. [[spoiler:After the King takes Miryem away to be his bride, Stepon outright forgets the Mandelstams have a daughter, in spite of her employing her siblings.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SavedToEnslave: Since the Staryk are compelled to repay all debts, to save one's life without first setting a price is to claim them as an eternal slave... not that most humans know this. This causes some confusion when humans try to rescue wounded Staryk, who would rather {{def|iedTrope}}y the trope [[IDieFree at the cost of their own lives]].

Added: 117

Changed: 28

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ParentalSubstitute: Magreta gives Irina all the affection of a mother. Initially she started caring for Irina after her mother's death so she would stay useful enough to be employed, but she quickly came to love Irina as though she was her own daughter.

to:

* ParentalSubstitute: Magreta gives Irina all the affection of a mother. Initially she started caring for Irina after her mother's death so she the duke would stay see her as still useful enough to be employed, employ, but she quickly came to love Irina as though she was her own daughter.


Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOut: Irina reads a book from her father's study [[Literature/ArabianNights about a sultan and a storyteller]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FantasyCounterpartCulture: As in ''Uprooted'', the nations involved are drawn from medieval Eastern European counterparts. Lithvas is Lithuania, mentions of the Khan in the east indicate that there's a counterpart to the Mongols, Mirnatius and one of the guards are descendents of the Tatars, and Miryem's community are Ashkenazi Jews.

Added: 391

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Zigzagged with the village children, several of whom bully Stepon, and seem just as anti-semitic as their parents.

to:

** Zigzagged with the village children, several of whom bully Stepon, and seem just as anti-semitic antisemitic as their parents.


Added DiffLines:

* LoopholeAbuse: Miryem buys herself some time to think by telling the Staryk King that she must observe Shabbos, and if he wants her to do what he demands then he'll extend her deadline by that much. Miryem notes that you're not only allowed but ''required'' to break Shabbos to save a life, including your own, but since the Staryk king doesn't know that then she'll gain the time she can.

Added: 765

Removed: 594

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenreSavvy: When Irina learns that magic exists [[spoiler: and that her husband gets away with whatever he wants with the help of a demon]], she reminds him that unless he can snap his fingers and make money and goods this will do him little if there's a famine or he runs out of money. She also suggests that if his powers have a limited range he'll be just as vulnerable as anyone else to stray arrows on the battlefield. [[spoiler: Her refusal to take anything from Chernobog save for his word that he wouldn't harm her or anyone she cared for results in his banishment from her kingdom.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TheManBehindTheMan: Irina as tsarina. When she learns that magic exists [[spoiler: and that her husband gets away with whatever he wants with the help of a demon]], she reminds him that unless he can snap his fingers and make money and goods this will do him little if there's a famine or he runs out of money. She also suggests that if his powers have a limited range he'll be just as vulnerable as anyone else to stray arrows on the battlefield. Once she's ensured her immediate safety, she sets about cleaning up the political mess caused by Mirnatius' neglectful rule, which has left the nobility a scant few inches away from revolt. Although he's as acerbic about it as he is about everything, Mirnatius doesn't interfere with any of the decisions she makes.

Top