Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HowFewRemain

Go To

OR

Added: 584

Removed: 581

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ForWantOfANail: The novel--and [[Literature/Timeline191 the ten-novel series that follows it]]--is all happening because ''one'' tiny detail, the finding of Special Order 191. It's even [[LampshadeHanging lampshaded]] in the prologue, where the messenger who dropped the order is effusively telling the two soldiers who noticed it how grateful he is, and how "this could have cost us the war!"
--> Then, as he rides off, one of them turns to the other and says "[[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments Lost the whole war? He don't think much of himself and the papers he carries, now does he?]]"


Added DiffLines:

* PointOfDivergence: The novel--and [[Literature/Timeline191 the ten-novel series that follows it]]--is all happening because ''one'' tiny detail, the finding of Special Order 191. It's even [[LampshadeHanging lampshaded]] in the prologue, where the messenger who dropped the order is effusively telling the two soldiers who noticed it how grateful he is, and how "this could have cost us the war!"
--> Then, as he rides off, one of them turns to the other and says "[[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments Lost the whole war? He don't think much of himself and the papers he carries, now does he?]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


But in this universe, [[ForWantOfANail the orders were never intercepted]]... Instead, Lee defeated [=McClellan=], marched on into Philadelphia, and Britain and France officially recognized the Confederacy as a nation-state and mediated a peace settlement. As a result, Lincoln is disgraced rather than assassinated, both Stonewall Jackson and Jeb Stuart survive the war, [[Creator/MarkTwain Samuel Clemens]] stays in San Francisco instead of writing fiction, etc. In short, ButterflyOfDoom ensues.

to:

But in this universe, [[ForWantOfANail [[PointOfDivergence the orders were never intercepted]]... Instead, Lee defeated [=McClellan=], marched on into Philadelphia, and Britain and France officially recognized the Confederacy as a nation-state and mediated a peace settlement. As a result, Lincoln is disgraced rather than assassinated, both Stonewall Jackson and Jeb Stuart survive the war, [[Creator/MarkTwain Samuel Clemens]] stays in San Francisco instead of writing fiction, etc. In short, ButterflyOfDoom ensues.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
dewicking disambiguation page


* OddCouple: Lincoln and Douglass. In the middle of a heated argument, Douglass even declares that they're having a "[[JustForPun Lincoln-Douglass]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln%E2%80%93Douglas_debates debate]]"

to:

* OddCouple: Lincoln and Douglass. In the middle of a heated argument, Douglass even declares that they're having a "[[JustForPun "[[{{Pun}} Lincoln-Douglass]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln%E2%80%93Douglas_debates debate]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
We now have a Useful Notes on Frederick Douglass.


* [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Douglass Frederick Douglass]], a former slave and fiery orator, observes the Union forces at war.

to:

* [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Douglass Frederick Douglass]], UsefulNotes/FrederickDouglass, a former slave and fiery orator, observes the Union forces at war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* BadassInCharge: Roosevelt and Custer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Oh yeah.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's actually a central plot point, pointed out in-universe even by the Confederate leadership that they can't possibly defeat the United States in a one-on-one fight, if for no other reason than that they outnumber them (and while the Confederacy has made some industrialization efforts over the intervening decades, the USA will always outpace them). The entire victory of the Confederacy is due to foreign alliances with Britain and France, giving them massive amounts of foreign aid, and forcing them to fight a two-front war with Canada. The US leadership is just too stubborn to get over their fears of foreign alliances, until the humiliation of this war leads to them allying with Germany...

to:

** It's actually a central plot point, pointed out in-universe even by It is noted in the Confederate novel that the US both outnumbers the CSA and outstrips them in industrial capacity. Their victory is due to having better military leadership that they can't possibly defeat the United States in a one-on-one fight, if for no other reason than that they outnumber them (and while the Confederacy has made some industrialization efforts over the intervening decades, the USA will always outpace them). The entire victory of the Confederacy is due to foreign and alliances with Britain France and France, giving them massive amounts of foreign aid, and forcing them to fight a two-front war with Canada. England. The US leadership is just too stubborn to get over their fears of foreign alliances, until the humiliation of this the war leads finally prods the US to them allying seek an alliance with Germany...Germany.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** General Willcox's command of the Battle of Louisville fails, primarily because he displays little imagination and does everything too slowly. Schlieffen frequently muses that his strategies might have worked if he'd put them into effect a few days earlier. General Jackson, on the other side, repeatedly notes that Willcox is obligingly doing exactly what they'd expected him to do.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The rather melodramatic RichardNixonTheUsedCarSalesman portrayal of UsefulNotes/UlyssesSGrant as an alcoholic wreck is largely based on DatedHistory founded on hostile rumours with virtually no solid evidence and now considered a myth by most serious historians. At most, Grant may have ''occasionally'' drank too much, which would've been easy for a man who CantHoldHisLiquor in a profession where drinking was common for coping with boredom and stress. This is even more interesting since ''three'' of Turtledove's protagonists--Teddy Roosevelt, Frederick Douglass, and Mark Twain--all idolized Grant in RealLife for his character even more than his generalship.

to:

** The rather melodramatic RichardNixonTheUsedCarSalesman portrayal of UsefulNotes/UlyssesSGrant as an alcoholic wreck a largely forgotten drunk is largely based on DatedHistory founded on hostile rumours with virtually no solid evidence and now considered a myth by most serious historians. At most, Grant may have ''occasionally'' drank too much, which would've been easy for a man who CantHoldHisLiquor in a profession where drinking was common for coping with boredom and stress. This is even more interesting since ''three'' of Turtledove's protagonists--Teddy Roosevelt, Frederick Douglass, and Mark Twain--all idolized Grant in RealLife for his character even more than his generalship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheAlcoholic: Ulysses S. Grant, embittered by the outcome of the war, gets a brief scene as an old, drunken vagabond.

to:

* TheAlcoholic: Downplayed with Ulysses S. Grant, embittered by the outcome of the war, Grant. He gets a brief scene as an old, drunken vagabond.audience member at a Frederic Douglass lecture. Douglass notes that his suit looks the worse for wear and his breath smells of whiskey.

Changed: 197

Removed: 371

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* NotSoDifferent:
** After coming face to face, [[spoiler:both Jackson and Douglass]] are surprised at how human they find each other--things aren't quite as [[IncrediblyLamePun black and white]] as they thought.
** Custer's constant mockery of the Mormons' polygamy looks much more hypocritical when his affair with a local woman is nipped in the bud by the unexpected arrival of his wife.

to:

* NotSoDifferent:
**
NotSoDifferentRemark: After coming face to face, [[spoiler:both Jackson and Douglass]] are surprised at how human they find each other--things aren't quite as [[IncrediblyLamePun black and white]] as they thought.
** Custer's constant mockery of the Mormons' polygamy looks much more hypocritical when his affair with a local woman is nipped in the bud by the unexpected arrival of his wife.
thought.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**It's actually a central plot point, pointed out in-universe even by the Confederate leadership that they can't possibly defeat the United States in a one-on-one fight, if for no other reason than that they outnumber them (and while the Confederacy has made some industrialization efforts over the intervening decades, the USA will always outpace them). The entire victory of the Confederacy is due to foreign alliances with Britain and France, giving them massive amounts of foreign aid, and forcing them to fight a two-front war with Canada. The US leadership is just too stubborn to get over their fears of foreign alliances, until the humiliation of this war leads to them allying with Germany...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SecondAmericanCivilWar: PlayedWith - The book starts with the Confederates ''winning'' the Civil War at Antietam, and fast-forwards twenty years, and the North and South fight a second war over control of the West (and also Northern resentment for losing) in what is for all intents and purposes, a second round of the American Civil War, but by then, it's no longer a ''civil'' war, and instead, a regular war between two independent countries that just so happen to be the United States of America and the Confederate States of America.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added image.


[[quoteright:350:https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/how_few_remain.png]]



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** ... which wasn't a real strategy, just a thought experiment (just look at that Other Wiki article - not a single primary source, albeit on account of the fact that ''none exists''). But the breadth and depth of the stuff Turtledove touches makes it inevitable he'll fall behind the cutting-edge of historical research ''somewhere'', especially as new research surfaces. Though there was that egregious depiction a WWII Chinese peasant as both liking the Chinese Communist Party and believing that it fights Japan (and that the Guomindang doesn't!) that sounds like it was lifted verbatim from a PRC school-textbook.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--> Then, as he rides off, one of them turns to the other and says "[[CrowningMomentOfFunny Lost the whole war? He don't think much of himself and the papers he carries, now does he?]]"

to:

--> Then, as he rides off, one of them turns to the other and says "[[CrowningMomentOfFunny "[[SugarWiki/FunnyMoments Lost the whole war? He don't think much of himself and the papers he carries, now does he?]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CavalryOfficer: Custer, Roosevelt, and Suart all ''love'' being one.

to:

* CavalryOfficer: Custer, Roosevelt, and Suart Stuart all ''love'' being one.

Changed: 62

Removed: 81

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheCavalry:
** Custer ''loves'' being the Cavalry.
** The Unauthorized Regiment does this too.

to:

* TheCavalry:
** Custer ''loves''
CavalryOfficer: Custer, Roosevelt, and Suart all ''love'' being the Cavalry.
** The Unauthorized Regiment does this too.
one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Abe Lincoln basically walks around doing this all the time. Oh, and being a ChummyCommunist.

to:

** Abe Lincoln basically walks around doing this all the time. Oh, and being a ChummyCommunist.[[ChummyCommies Chummy Commie]].

Added: 3702

Changed: 2573

Removed: 200

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnyoneCanDie: As the end draws near, [[spoiler:Jeb Stuart and Tom Custer]] both die. [[spoiler:Tom]]'s at least is in battle, so it's sad but not surprising, but killing off one of the main characters, out of ''nowhere,'' is a real shock.

to:

* AnyoneCanDie: As the end draws near, [[spoiler:Jeb Stuart and Tom Custer]] both die. [[spoiler:Tom]]'s at least is in battle, so it's sad but not surprising, but killing off one of the main characters, out of ''nowhere,'' is a real shock.



* AlternateHistory

to:

* AlternateHistoryAlternateHistory: And not a very pleasant one either since the on-going rivalry between the two countries just results in being more militaristic, jingoistic, and less self-sufficient.
* AlternateUniverseReedRichardsIsAwesome: Played with by George Custer who rather than being massacred at Little Bighorn rises to prominence by providing the USA with its only conclusive victory of the Second Mexican War ''despite'' having the same GloryHound and LeeroyJenkins tendencies as RealLife.
* AnalogyBackfire: Schlieffen quotes the Latin phrase "Vae Victus" (meaning "Woe to the Conquered", first attributed to Brennus the Gaul after defeating the Romans in battle) when telling President Blaine that he has no choice but to accept defeat. Blaine quickly retorts that it was the ''Romans'', not the Gauls, who ultimately won that conflict.
* AnyoneCanDie: As the end draws near, [[spoiler:Jeb Stuart and Tom Custer]] both die. [[spoiler:Tom]]'s at least is in battle, so it's sad but not surprising, but killing off one of the main characters, out of ''nowhere,'' is a real shock.



* UsefulNotes/AntebellumAmerica: Unlike [[Film/CSATheConfederateStatesOfAmerica some attempts]] to show what the world would be like if the Confederates won, ''How Few Remain'' actually explores socio-economic and cultural issues that ''don't'' have to do with slavery.

to:

* UsefulNotes/AntebellumAmerica: Unlike [[Film/CSATheConfederateStatesOfAmerica some attempts]] to show what the world would be like if the Confederates won, ''How Few Remain'' actually explores socio-economic and cultural issues that ''don't'' have ''beyond'' those to do with slavery.



** The rather melodramatic RichardNixonTheUsedCarSalesman portrayal of UsefulNotes/UlyssesSGrant as an alcoholic wreck is largely based on DatedHistory founded on hostile rumours with virtually no solid evidence and now considered a myth by most serious historians. At most, Grant may have ''occasionally'' drank too much, which would've been easy for a man who CantHoldHisLiquor in a profession where drinking was common for coping with boredom and stress.
** By the time of the novel, William S. Rosecrans has risen to General-in-Chief of U.S. forces basically because he [[DamnedByFaintPraise didn't get a chance to fail]] in the last war, yet Ulysses S. Grant's ''victories'' at Fort Donelson, Shiloh, Iuka, and Corinth, which had already made him a national hero for capturing an entire Confederate army and forcing them out of southern Kentucky and western Tennessee including Nashville, all receive next-to-no mention as far as 'Remembrance' ideology is concerned even though Rosecrans was merely Grant's ''subordinate'' and remained so until more than a month after the series' divergence point. This is even more interesting since ''three'' of Turtledove's protagonists--Teddy Roosevelt, Frederick Douglass, and Mark Twain--all idolized Grant in RealLife for his character even more than his generalship.

to:

** The rather melodramatic RichardNixonTheUsedCarSalesman portrayal of UsefulNotes/UlyssesSGrant as an alcoholic wreck is largely based on DatedHistory founded on hostile rumours with virtually no solid evidence and now considered a myth by most serious historians. At most, Grant may have ''occasionally'' drank too much, which would've been easy for a man who CantHoldHisLiquor in a profession where drinking was common for coping with boredom and stress.
stress. This is even more interesting since ''three'' of Turtledove's protagonists--Teddy Roosevelt, Frederick Douglass, and Mark Twain--all idolized Grant in RealLife for his character even more than his generalship.
** By the time of the novel, William S. Rosecrans has risen to General-in-Chief of U.S. forces basically because he [[DamnedByFaintPraise didn't get a chance to fail]] in the last war, yet Ulysses S. Grant's ''victories'' at Fort Donelson, Shiloh, Iuka, and Corinth, which Corinth (which had already made him a national hero for capturing an entire Confederate army and forcing them out of southern Kentucky and western Tennessee including Nashville, Nashville) all receive next-to-no mention as far as 'Remembrance' ideology is concerned even though Rosecrans was merely Grant's ''subordinate'' and remained so until more than a month after the series' divergence point. This is gets even more interesting since ''three'' of Turtledove's protagonists--Teddy Roosevelt, Frederick Douglass, weirder given how Custer and Mark Twain--all idolized Grant in RealLife Roosevelt are lauded in-universe for his character even more than his generalship.''their'' singular success in an otherwise embarrassing war.



** Abe Lincoln basically walks around doing this all the time. Oh, and being a DirtyCommunist.

to:

** Abe Lincoln basically walks around doing this all the time. Oh, and being a DirtyCommunist.ChummyCommunist.



* EarlyInstallmentWeirdness: ''How Few Remain'' is the only standalone novel in the entire series, the only one told entirely through the viewpoint of {{Historical Domain Character}}s, and is separated from the rest of the series by a 33-year TimeSkip.



* GatlingGood: Custer dislikes Gatling guns, but gets assigned a whole bunch of them anyway and they play a vital role in gaining him the only US victory of the war.
* GeneralFailure:
** General-in-Chief Rosecrans admits to Schlieffen that he has no coherent plan to defeat the Confederates.
** Custer and Roosevelt triumph in the end not so much through their own genius as because their opponent attempted to used mounted lancers against their Gatling gun emplacement.



* HistoricalBadassUpgrade: Turtledove is rather generous to Stonewall Jackson. He was certainly an excellent semi-independent corps commander but also overbearing, uncommunicative, and argumentative with his own subordinates and the kind of guy who wanted to court-marshal Richard B. Garnett for retreating without permission even though Garnett had already attacked bravely and was low on ammo and surrounded on three sides, leading many historians to consider any theoretical promotion for Jackson a prime recipe for ThePeterPrinciple.



* InThePastEveryoneWillBeFamous: Given, we're following eight historical figures to begin with, but they do seem to bump into an inordinate number of familiar faces (see HistoricalDomainCharacter, above).
** Not as much so in the rest of the Literature/Timeline191 series, where the famous people rub elbows with an extensive cast of Turtledove originals.
* InvadedStatesOfAmerica: San Francisco is shelled and raided by the British. A British invasion of Montana is defeated in what turns out to be the highlight of the war for the USA. Northern Maine is ceded to Canada as part of the peace settlement.
* LargeHam: TruthInTelevision, for Custer and Roosevelt.

to:

* InThePastEveryoneWillBeFamous: Given, we're following eight historical figures to begin with, but they do seem to bump into an inordinate number of familiar faces (see HistoricalDomainCharacter, above).
** Not as much
above) even more so than in the rest of the Literature/Timeline191 series, where the famous people rub elbows with an extensive cast of Turtledove originals.
* InvadedStatesOfAmerica: San Francisco is shelled and raided by the British. A British, a British invasion of Montana is defeated in what turns out to be the highlight of the war for the USA. USA, and Northern Maine is ceded to Canada as part of the peace settlement.
* LaResistance: The Mormons in Utah.
*
LargeHam: TruthInTelevision, TruthInTelevision for Custer and Roosevelt.Roosevelt.
* LoadsAndLoadsOfCharacters: Oh yeah.



* NonindicativeName: The Second Mexican War doesn't actually involve Mexico at all.
* NotSoDifferent: After coming face to face, [[spoiler:both Jackson and Douglass are surprised at how human they find each other--things aren't quite as [[IncrediblyLamePun black and white]] as they thought.]]

to:

* NonindicativeName: The Second Mexican War doesn't actually involve Mexico at all.
all; the name refers to the fact that the war was sparked by the Confederates acquiring Mexican territory, which the US attempted to stop to prevent them from forming a transcontinental empire.
* NotSoDifferent: NotSoDifferent:
**
After coming face to face, [[spoiler:both Jackson and Douglass Douglass]] are surprised at how human they find each other--things aren't quite as [[IncrediblyLamePun black and white]] as they thought.]]thought.
** Custer's constant mockery of the Mormons' polygamy looks much more hypocritical when his affair with a local woman is nipped in the bud by the unexpected arrival of his wife.



* OddCouple: Lincoln and Douglass.
** Douglass gets a bonus for, in the middle of a heated argument, saying that they're having a "[[JustForPun Lincoln-Douglass]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln%E2%80%93Douglas_debates debate]]"

to:

* OddCouple: Lincoln and Douglass.
** Douglass gets a bonus for, in
Douglass. In the middle of a heated argument, saying Douglass even declares that they're having a "[[JustForPun Lincoln-Douglass]] [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lincoln%E2%80%93Douglas_debates debate]]"



* OnlyKnownByTheirNickname: Turtledove plays with this in the first section following "Thomas Jackson", knowing that most of the readers won't catch on until someone says "Hey, Stonewall!"

to:

* OnlyKnownByTheirNickname: Turtledove plays with this in the first section following "Thomas Jackson", knowing that most of the readers won't catch on until someone says says, "Hey, Stonewall!"



** Mark Twain's newspaper editorials, providing running commentary on the events leading up to the war, fill the role nicely.

to:

** Mark Twain's newspaper editorials, editorials providing running commentary on the events leading up to the war, war fill the role nicely.



* RubberBandHistory

to:

* RubberBandHistoryRichardNixonTheUsedCarSalesman:
** Sam Clemens the San Francisco new editor.
** Stonewall Jackson and William Rosecrans, the USA and CSA Generals-in-Chief, respectively.
** James G. Blaine and James Longstreet, the USA and CSA Presidents, respectively.
** Abraham Lincoln the disgraced ex-president and prominent socialist.
** Ulysses S. Grant the poor alcoholic.
* RubberBandHistory:



* ShownTheirWork: Turtledove ''does''. All the time. So much so that it's easy to forget you're reading a work of fiction.

to:

** Custer making a LastStand on the Great Plains...
** [[spoiler: Jeb Stuart]] being mortally wounded...
* RuleOfCool: It debatable, but the CSA's success should be taken with a grain of salt considering it's a deeply nepotistic and socially and ethnically divided country still tied to a localized rural economy while the rest of the world is embracing nationalism and the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Industrial_Revolution Second Industrial Revolution]], but hey, Turtledove wanted an American version of the UsefulNotes/FrancoPrussianWar and wrote a pretty damned good one.
* ShownTheirWork: Turtledove ''does''. All ''does'' all the time. So time, so much so that it's easy to forget you're reading a work of fiction.



* StartMyOwn: When his local recruiting-station won't take volunteers, Roosevelt takes it on himself to pull together his own Unauthorized Regiment.

to:

* SpiritualSuccessor: To Turtledove's own [[AlienSpaceBats more outlandish]] ''Literature/TheGunsOfTheSouth''.
* StartMyOwn: When his local recruiting-station recruiting station won't take volunteers, Roosevelt takes it on himself to pull together his own Unauthorized Regiment.



* WhatMightHaveBeen

to:

* WhatMightHaveBeenWhatIf: What if the Confederacy won the Civil War?

Top