Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Up

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting a misunderstanding

Added DiffLines:

** There was indeed something else to it that you missed. Earlier in the film, Russel tells Carl that if he's ever in danger to use the Wilderness Explorer cry for help, which is "Caw-caw! Rawr!" Although Carl didnt take it seriously at the time, but he knew Russel still would, and that it would be enough to encourage him to climb up the hose.

Added: 494

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The real answer, of course, is that it symbolically cements Carl as Russell's father figure. In-universe, Carl almost certainly got the okay from Russell's mom, who equally was almost certainly happy to have a positive paternal role model enter Russell's life.



** I'm guessing nobody saw him do it, so they didn't have enough evidence to press charges. Prune juice isn't always unique to a specific jug like fingerprints or DNA, and it's entirely possible for a defense attorney to reasonably argue that a troublemaking kid was pulling what he thought was an innocent prank on the construction boss.**

to:

** I'm guessing nobody saw him do it, so they didn't have enough evidence to press charges. Prune juice isn't always unique to a specific jug like fingerprints or DNA, and it's entirely possible for a defense attorney to reasonably argue that a troublemaking kid was pulling what he thought was an innocent prank on the construction boss.**


Added DiffLines:

** Unfortunately, "little kids don't drink prune juice!" isn't legally admissable evidence. While it's ''suggestive'', it's still circumstantial evidence (since it could be plausibly argued that someone was trying to set him up).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This seems like AluminumChristmasTrees. At the time when Carl and Ellie were a young couple, people often did just chuck money they were saving in a cheap glass/ceramic container and then just smash it when they needed to get into it, because they were cheap to replace and there was usually no other way to get the money out once you'd put it in. You wouldn't necessary go out and buy one specially, you'd just repurpose a glass jar you'd gotten some groceries in or something. Private safes would be expensive and reuseable piggy banks and the like didn't really start taking off until consumer rubber and plastics started becoming more widely available, by which point Carl and Ellie were likely just old enough to keep in the habit.

to:

** This seems like AluminumChristmasTrees. At the time when Carl and Ellie were a young couple, people often did just chuck money they were saving in a cheap glass/ceramic glass/ceramic/porcelain/etc. container and then just smash it when they needed to get into it, because they were cheap to replace and there was usually no other way to get the money out once you'd put it in. You wouldn't necessary go out and buy one specially, you'd just repurpose a large glass jar you'd gotten some groceries in or something. Private safes would be expensive and reuseable reusable piggy banks and the like didn't really start taking off until consumer rubber and plastics started becoming more widely available, by which point Carl and Ellie were likely just old enough to keep in the habit.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This seems like AluminumChristmasTrees. At the time when Carl and Ellie were a young couple, people often did just chuck money they were saving in a cheap glass/ceramic container and then just smash it when they needed to get into it, because they were cheap to replace and there was usually no other way to get the money out once you'd put it in. You wouldn't necessary go out and buy one specially, you'd just repurpose a glass jar you'd gotten some groceries in or something. Private safes would be expensive and reuseable piggy banks and the like didn't really start taking off until consumer rubber and plastics started becoming more widely available, by which point Carl and Ellie were likely just old enough to keep in the habit.


Added DiffLines:

** This is, sadly, TruthInTelevision for a lot of unfortunate kids after their parents split up. Presumably Russell's dad simply wasn't interested in being a father to him. Regrettably, it happens more often than you'd like to think.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The House wouldn't have been believed. As for the Spirit of Adventure, given that Muntz was flying it around South America for decades without modern radar picking it up (South America has plenty of regular air traffic after all) it presumably has some kind of stealth system (I mean if Muntz can make talking dog collars.....) And afterwards it's possible Carl got it registered with the FAA as his private aircraft and gets clearance when he goes places with it.


Added DiffLines:

** It's possible Muntz just traveled out to local cities without bringing his blimp to buy supplies. Given that he'd aged and probably wore different clothing it's possible South American residents in outlier towns wouldn't have recognized him as lost US explorer Charles Muntz.


Added DiffLines:

** South America isn't just one big uninhabited jungle except for a crazy old man. He could have taken him to a village and saw to it that he made it to one of the countries with airports and got him a flight back to the US.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is a film that features talking dogs and a man who gets his house to fly by tying a physically-inadequate amount of balloons to it. Why can't people just wrap their heads around a particular elderly character having aged mildly well?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

****If the purpose was financial screening they could just investigate the family’s finances like a mortgage company does. They charge a lot because they are companies and have expenses to cover. People who would prefer to adopt for free or close to it can generally adopt through the state. The movie takes place in an earlier era when some people were fairly uncomfortable with adoption. But really it’s probably just a story device - they didn’t want the couple to have kids, so they didn’t.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No good; the reason Russell wanted the badge was to get the whole collection so he could ''see'' his father at the ceremony. If he saw him every weekend, that wouldn't be much of a motivator.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** [[BadassGrandpa Yeah, he's a regular Yoda]].

to:

** [[BadassGrandpa Yeah, he's a regular Yoda]].Yoda.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
moved from fridge

Added DiffLines:


* How did Russell get onto the porch? We never see him during takeoff, but he says he was underneath. It's established very early on that Russell is anything ''but'' athletic. So how'd he get up there?
** Adreneline rush kicked in. People do crazy stuff when their lives are on the line.
* How did Muntz get his hands on the Wilhelm scream sound clip? Wasn't that thing first used in the '50s?
** RuleOfFunny, or maybe he's got really [=WiFi=] and downloaded it.
* If Ellie actually got to go to paradise falls, [[spoiler:Isn't it likely that Muntz, her childhood hero, would have tried to kill her?]]
** No. Ellie is badass. She would've grown into a NeverMessWithGranny type and kicked his ass.
*** Really? Never are we shown that she's a master at martial arts. Just because she has an adventure-spirit it doesn't mean that she's an ActionGirl.
* Dobermans and Rottweilers make sensible guard dogs, and could probably be used for hunting if you trained them well. But English bulldogs, like the one that went along with Alpha and Beta to hunt down Kevin, are far from athletic enough for such jobs and would probably faint from overexertion if they attempted to perform them. Now, this could be overlooked if he were built more like the original bulldog breed (which was probably still around when Muntz went on his expedition), but he's clearly a modern bulldog. What the crap is he doing going hunting in the South American jungles?!
** Perhaps Gamma is supposed to be a bull ''terrier'': a Staffordshire, an American Staffordshire (Amstaff), or a Pit Bull Terrier. (Clearly not a Bull Terrier.) With the Creative Allowance for Animation, he could easily end up looking more like a bulldog. Of course, he could also be a shout-out to Marc Anthony of Looney Toons fame . . .
* Who was taking pictures of Carl and Ellie's intimate moments (her birthday, feeding pigeons and just laying out together)?
** A friend who passed later on, I guess.
** They used a camera with a time-delay shutter, mounted on a tripod. [[Tropers/{{Kalmbach}} This troper]] used that process to photograph his own wedding.
* Carl is eight years old at the start of the film, whereas Muntz is an established explorer, probably around thirty if not older. They meet again when Carl is 78, ''seven decades later''. Muntz is now either close to or over 100 years old, and has been living without any sort of healthcare or modern medicine for all that time. How is he even able to walk by himself, let alone swing a sword or give chase to a man over twenty years his junior across the top of a flying airship?
** The guy made dog collars that allow the wearers to talk, he probably [[{{Steampunk}} steampunked]] himself up some sort of [[Franchise/{{Batman}} Lazarus pit]], Ra's Al Ghul style.
* At several points during the movie Russell is referred to as a "small mailman". These are dogs born and bred in the wilderness, how would they know what a mailman was having presumably never seen one before?
** It's probably something to do with--SQUIRREL!!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** Also: while it might seem hard to believe a boy who couldn't even climb the garden hose due to being out-of-shape and untrained could have climbed out from under the porch, adrenaline and fear are great motivators. Not to mention he later proves capable of it during his HeroicResolve CrowningMomentOfAwesome.

to:

** Also: while it might seem hard to believe a boy who couldn't even climb the garden hose due to being out-of-shape and untrained could have climbed out from under the porch, adrenaline and fear are great motivators. Not to mention he later proves capable of it during his HeroicResolve CrowningMomentOfAwesome.SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome.


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The villain in the FiveEpisodePilot of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/DuckTales'' lived for 500 years because he was ''that obsessed'' with finding a hidden treasure. Seems to be a Disney trend for evil {{Cool Old Guy}}s.

to:

** The villain in the FiveEpisodePilot of Disney's ''WesternAnimation/DuckTales'' ''WesternAnimation/DuckTales1987'' lived for 500 years because he was ''that obsessed'' with finding a hidden treasure. Seems to be a Disney trend for evil {{Cool Old Guy}}s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** And besides, the only person who we know for sure knows how Muntz died is Carl, and he's not going to tell the story in such a way that it makes him out to be responsible. Russell can vouch for the fact that Muntz was trying to murder them, and the dogs would be able to testify as to all the times they were set loose on others Muntz thought were after his bird. No one has any evidence that would lead to Carl facing legal trouble - he could probably say that he found the Spirit of Adventure abandoned, and everyone would assume Muntz died decades ago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I'm guessing nobody saw him do it, so they didn't have enough evidence to press charges. Prune juice isn't always unique to a specific jug like fingerprints or DNA, and it's entirely possible for a defense attorney to reasonably argue that a troublemaking kid was pulling what he thought was an innocent prank on the construction boss.

to:

** I'm guessing nobody saw him do it, so they didn't have enough evidence to press charges. Prune juice isn't always unique to a specific jug like fingerprints or DNA, and it's entirely possible for a defense attorney to reasonably argue that a troublemaking kid was pulling what he thought was an innocent prank on the construction boss.**
** Prune juice, though? Little kids don't drink prune juice, unless they're extraordinarily ill.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I thought she was his older sister, but I could be wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[foldercontrol]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The audio description track on the DVD describes Ellie as being distraught specifically over her inability to have children, for what it's worth. It never says anything about her suffering a miscarriage.

Added: 687

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Where Did They Get the Helmets?]]

to:

[[Where [[folder: Where Did They Get the Helmets?]]


Added DiffLines:

*** In-universe, a glass jar like that also serves a decorative purpose, meaning it can be left in a high-traffic part of the house for them to deposit some loose change as they happen to pass by it, without seeming out of place. This troper's family has kept a near-identical jar in their sitting room for the same purpose. Not only would a tin can or a piggy bank not nearly be large enough to contain the funds they need for the trip, but neither one is something that they could leave lying around somewhere. The ''real'' question is why they smashed the jar open with a hammer each time they needed the money for something, instead of just tipping it over and pouring the money out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Not a JustBugsMe, but a mere continuity error -- Russell calls Carl "Mr. Fredricksen", even though Carl never told him what his name was.

to:

* Not a JustBugsMe, but a A mere continuity error -- Russell calls Carl "Mr. Fredricksen", even though Carl never told him what his name was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why did Russell need so many more badges than all the other kids to graduate to Senior Wilderness Explorer? At the beginning he shows Carl all his badges and tells him he needs one more in order to graduate, and he has a ridiculously large amount of badges. At the end of the movie, all the other kids graduating have, like, five or ten badges. Why show favoritism to everybody but Russell, Scout Master? Oh, let's pick on the fat kid. To hell with you! Russell's awesome. All those other kids can bite me! ... ItJustBugsMe.

to:

* Why did Russell need so many more badges than all the other kids to graduate to Senior Wilderness Explorer? At the beginning he shows Carl all his badges and tells him he needs one more in order to graduate, and he has a ridiculously large amount of badges. At the end of the movie, all the other kids graduating have, like, five or ten badges. Why show favoritism to everybody but Russell, Scout Master? Oh, let's pick on the fat kid. To hell with you! Russell's awesome. All those other kids can bite me! ... ItJustBugsMe.me!



* Why doesn't Russell get the Scout Badge of Honor/Heroism? I know it's the RuleOfFunny but it JustBugsMe still.

to:

* Why doesn't Russell get the Scout Badge of Honor/Heroism? I know it's the RuleOfFunny but it JustBugsMe a Headscratcher still.

Added: 3138

Changed: 1252

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I just like naming the Headscratchers, :P


[[folder: It's Not Called "Up and Down"!]]



[[/folder]]
[[folder: Breaking the Jar]]



[[/folder]]
[[folder: Divorced Equals Disappeared?]]



[[/folder]]
[[folder: Fetching the Voices]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Where are All the Lady Dogs?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Muntz the Spry, Evil Old Man--How?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: I Made It--But How Do I Get Back?]]




to:

*** Even if he didn't want to die, he might've wanted to set up camp there.
[[/folder]]
[[folder: A Waste of a Honeymoon?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Squirrels in South America?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Miscarriage vs Infertility]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Where are Russell's Parents?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: His Back Seems Fine to Me]]




to:

** Maybe he doesn't have a bad back, maybe he has a bad ''leg'', hence the walking stick, but he'd still be spry for someone with a bad leg.
[[/folder]]
[[folder: How Did Russell Get There?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: What Were the Dogs' Destinies?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Where Does Carl Live Now?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Didn't He Fly Into Legal Trouble?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: There's Something Different About Russell]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Didn't He Hand Over Kevin?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Does Russell Need More Badges?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Is That Not Honorable or Heroic Enough for You?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Who's the Other Master?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: There are No Hot Dog Stands in the Jungle]]




* My suspension of disbelief is pretty schizo- I can dismiss the flying houses and talking dogs and all of that stuff, but there's just one tiny thing that bothered me: when Carl was looking through the "Stuff I Want To Do" in Ellie's adventure book and seeing all the pictures from his life with Ellie... who took all those photos.

to:

\n[[/folder]]
[[folder: Who Took the Pictures?]]
* My suspension of disbelief is pretty schizo- I can dismiss the flying houses and talking dogs and all of that stuff, but there's just one tiny thing that bothered me: when Carl was looking through the "Stuff I Want To Do" in Ellie's adventure book and seeing all the pictures from his life with Ellie... who took all those photos.photos?




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: He Didn't Read the Book All That Time?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Nobody Gets the References?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Who's Phyllis?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Carl Gets the Blame-Why?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Ignoring the Option of Adoption?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Kevin's Not a Killer]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: How Does He Know His Name?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: He Knows a Lot But Still Believes in Snipes?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: How Could a Cane Make That Much Pain?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Distracted Dogs]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Russell Has Many Skills But Building Tents is Not One of Them]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: How Did He Obtain and Fill Up So Many Balloons in One Night?]]




to:

** And who says he has serious back problems?
[[/folder]]
[[folder: Who's the Real Master?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Cropping Alpha's Ears]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: How Did He Get His Cane Back?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: He Can Hold a House, But Not a GPS]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Did Russell Think Kevin Was a Snipe?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Did Carl Find the House?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Not Send an Army and Sell the Collars?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Killing Kevin?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Where's the Jungle?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: From Where Did They Retrieve the Retriever?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[Where Did They Get the Helmets?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: They Think He's Always Wrong Now?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Missing the "Point"]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: How Did Scientists Suspect the Skeleton was a Scam?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Replacing the Receptacle?]]




to:

*** But InUniverse?
[[/folder]]
[[folder: It's My Spirit of Adventure Now]]



[[/folder]]
[[folder: A Bleeding Inconsistency]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Just Building Around Someone's House?]]





to:

\n[[/folder]]
[[folder: No Hitting or No House]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: What Would've Happened to Russell?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Was Russel Mad at Carl?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Taking Down the House from Below?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Where Did He Get the Leaf Blower?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Russell's Back-How?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Why Didn't Russell's Mom Pin on His Badge?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Is it More than Just a Bunch of Animal Noises?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: If Muntz is Crazy, Why Did He Spare Them?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Being the Perpetrator of a Prune Juice Prank Doesn't Cause Problems with the Police?]]




to:

[[/folder]]
[[folder: Never Catching the Bird?]]


Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** There's also the fact that Russel is a kid and as a result, he wouldn't be able to think about the situation like that. As far as he can probably understand, Carl made a promise to protect Kevin but Kevin got caught.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Hell, Betty White is 96 and she still seems fairly vibrant, and looks fantastic. Is it REALLY such a stretch that Muntz, in his late 80s/early 90s, would still be pretty spry himself? (And let's not forget, we ARE talking about a movie where a freaking ''house'' can fly by attaching a fuckton of balloons to it, and be easily steered.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** No, he didn't get pulled out. Kevin barged past him and broke through the front window to get to the chocolate Carl was holding, knocking the gun out of Muntz's hands, and he proceeded to jump out of the window after her without realizing that he wouldn't make it back onto the airship.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[SweeneyTodd Mrs. Lovette would like to trade some recipes.]]

to:

*** [[SweeneyTodd [[Theatre/SweeneyTodd Mrs. Lovette would like to trade some recipes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***It's pretty difficult to take the money out of those jars, especially if you need a lot of it. Maybe they thought it was easier to just smash it and then replace it, it wouldn't cost more than a broken leg or a destroyed roof.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Clearly, he must've tried. It just didn't work, obviously. As stated, trying to capture the bird alive and uninjured is probably much more difficult than just killing it, since it's too fast to capture easily ''without'' injuring it in some capacity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** InUniverse, though?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** And he had absolutely no chance to refine his techniques in all that time?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** From what we see in the film, he seemed to leave his dogs to do most of the work, and while they're certainly possess more dexterity than the average dog, they're still not the sharpest knives in the drawer. Couple this with how fast Kevin is, how strong her legs probably are, how her species might be endangered, and the fact that she lives in a deadly labyrinth that's impossible to navigate...and with Muntz seemingly going a little too far of the deep end over the years, and it's plausible that he never had the chance to catch her. (Especially since his claim to the world was that he would bring the bird back ''alive'', which limits severely the means his dogs can use to catch her very easily.)

Top