Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / UnseenAcademicals

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Even Nutt's "little brother" probably can't revive him if he's riddled with crossbow bolts unless somebody ''pulls them out'' first.

Changed: 507

Removed: 281

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



nobody is forced to be present for ''every'' meal - look at wizards like Ponder, who manage to stay normally slim - but the dining times are there and on offer.
***** (Hi there, dude. It's me, the (more) crazy one) That might be one answer, but it still baffles me what actual reason there is to have 9 meals instead of, well, stretching the availability time of 4 or 5. At my brother's university you can get breakfast from 6 am to 11:30 pm.

to:

\nnobody ** Nobody is forced to be present for ''every'' meal - look at wizards like Ponder, who manage to stay normally slim - but the dining times are there and on offer.
***** (Hi there, dude. It's me, the (more) crazy one) one.) That might be one answer, but it still baffles me what actual reason there is to have 9 meals instead of, well, stretching the availability time of 4 or 5. At my brother's university you can get breakfast from 6 am to 11:30 pm.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In ''Discworld/TheScienceOfDiscworld 3'', several of these meals are named: Dinner, Second Dinner, Midnight Snack, Somnambulistic Nibbles, Early Breakfast and Second Breakfast. Presumably there's a couple of Lunches and a Tea (or vice versa) to round off the rest of the day. Not every wizard necessarily ''has'' to attend them all; it's implied that everyone but Ridcully and the Librarian sleeps through Early Breakfast, for example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's actually mentioned in ''Lords and Ladies'' that when Ridcully had his own unique hat (i.e. the one with a liquor bottle and a fold-out tent in it) made, it "put a stop" to the problem of the hereditary Archchancellor's Hat getting ideas of its own. As Ridcully wasn't at UU during ''Sorcery'', when the Hat first revealed it could talk, and the only wizards who aren't ashamed to discuss those events are the Librarian (who spent that novel hiding out with his books and unaware what was going on) and Rincewind (whom Ridcully hadn't met as of ''L&L''), it's unlikely that he would have known it '''was''' a potential problem unless the Hat, itself, told him.

to:

*** It's actually mentioned in ''Lords and Ladies'' that when Ridcully had his own unique hat (i.e. the one with a liquor bottle and a fold-out tent in it) made, it "put a stop" to the problem of the hereditary Archchancellor's Hat getting ideas of its own. As Ridcully wasn't at UU during ''Sorcery'', ''Sourcery'', when the Hat first revealed it could talk, and the only wizards who aren't ashamed to discuss those events are the Librarian (who spent that novel hiding out with his books and unaware what was going on) and Rincewind (whom Ridcully hadn't met as of ''L&L''), it's unlikely that he would have known it '''was''' a potential problem unless the Hat, itself, told him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** It's actually mentioned in ''Lords and Ladies'' that when Ridcully had his own unique hat (i.e. the one with a liquor bottle and a fold-out tent in it) made, it "put a stop" to the problem of the hereditary Archchancellor's Hat getting ideas of its own. As Ridcully wasn't at UU during ''Sorcery'', when the Hat first revealed it could talk, and the only wizards who aren't ashamed to discuss those events are the Librarian (who spent that novel hiding out with his books and unaware what was going on) and Rincewind (whom Ridcully hadn't met as of ''L&L''), it's unlikely that he would have known it '''was''' a potential problem unless the Hat, itself, told him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** As Margolotta would have known about the Little Brother, there's no saying that 'killing' Nutt wouldn't be part of a hugely elaborate BatmanGambit she never gets to put into action. It could even be a publicity stunt for something-or-other. She's that sort of character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Point taken, though one then could still argue that Vetinari lost his reputation when he initially forbid foot-the-ball for being ''too brutal'' but left the fans unristricted. Even with the new rules, they will remain as brutal as before, jumping each others throats for the colours they wear, etc. Not to mention the former Dean as referee and then NOT have him try to undermine the UU and Vetinari and thereby Ankh-Morpork as total? But that's another question...

to:

*** Point taken, though one then could still argue that Vetinari lost his reputation when he initially forbid foot-the-ball for being ''too brutal'' but left the fans unristricted. Even with the new rules, they will remain as brutal as before, jumping each others throats for the colours they wear, etc. Not to mention the former Dean as referee and then NOT have him try to undermine the UU and Vetinari and thereby Ankh-Morpork as total? But that's another question...question...
*** They explained why the ex-Dean would be an impartial judge: his personal desire to see UU lose was balanced by his professional distaste for seeing wizards beaten by non-wizards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** True, you need to have two eyes to have 'eyes'. You don't necessarily need to have two ''working'' eyes, however: a sliced cornea is entirely possible, and would better convince Andy to stay away because he can't afford to lose the other one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** That would explain why they almost totally ignored most of them when writing the new rules.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The Emperor supposedly ruled for centuries, so maybe he was a vampire who also knew wizard magic?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It doesn't help that goblins themselves are considered vermin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Rename


* Does anyone have any idea what was with that thing through the end of the book'? Spoilering in case it's spoilery, I don't think it is but since I don't think I get it, better safe than sorry: [[spoiler: Where it has the blank pages with "'''You think this is over?'''" in the middle, several times, and then the last page is something along the lines of "Okay, ''now'' it's over." I assumed it was something like the Summoning Dark in ''Discworld/TheFifthElephant'', PaintingTheFourthWall and all, and it was The Shove, or whatever the tin can was (the spirit of football?) talking, but... it's left totally unexplained, almost like a weak joke that decided to go into BreakingTheFourthWall just for the heck of it. Maybe it was supposed to be a note to readers that this is the last "real" Discworld book (The Tiffany Aching books either not counting, or the plans for ''I Shall Wear Midnight'' being foregone), but that... doesn't sound right. Was it some theme I completely missed, like an expansion on Glenda's repeated mention of fairy tales, that went Meta?]] Did ''anyone'' get that?

to:

* Does anyone have any idea what was with that thing through the end of the book'? Spoilering in case it's spoilery, I don't think it is but since I don't think I get it, better safe than sorry: [[spoiler: Where it has the blank pages with "'''You think this is over?'''" in the middle, several times, and then the last page is something along the lines of "Okay, ''now'' it's over." I assumed it was something like the Summoning Dark in ''Discworld/TheFifthElephant'', PaintingTheFourthWall PaintingTheMedium and all, and it was The Shove, or whatever the tin can was (the spirit of football?) talking, but... it's left totally unexplained, almost like a weak joke that decided to go into BreakingTheFourthWall just for the heck of it. Maybe it was supposed to be a note to readers that this is the last "real" Discworld book (The Tiffany Aching books either not counting, or the plans for ''I Shall Wear Midnight'' being foregone), but that... doesn't sound right. Was it some theme I completely missed, like an expansion on Glenda's repeated mention of fairy tales, that went Meta?]] Did ''anyone'' get that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Did Not Do The Research has been perma-redlinked.


**** I'm not sure who Malich is but it isn't uncommon for exploding stuff to later reappear. Cue 'Bloody Stupid Johnson' stories.
***** Remove the last letter from Alberto's name and think of Death.
****** Terry Pratchett is widely read and aware of Roundworld tropes he can work into Discworld as references and sly allusions - he'd be aware, for instance, that the University of Rejkjavik in Iceland was legendarily founded by an actual wizard, whose statue proudly stands at the main gates. With an example like that to refer to, do you think he'd refrain from incorporating it into the Discworld?

to:

**** *** I'm not sure who Malich is but it isn't uncommon for exploding stuff to later reappear. Cue 'Bloody Stupid Johnson' stories.
***** *** Remove the last letter from Alberto's name and think of Death.
****** *** Terry Pratchett is widely read and aware of Roundworld tropes he can work into Discworld as references and sly allusions - he'd be aware, for instance, that the University of Rejkjavik in Iceland was legendarily founded by an actual wizard, whose statue proudly stands at the main gates. With an example like that to refer to, do you think he'd refrain from incorporating it into the Discworld?



*** That would be Josh Kirby, not Paul Kidby, who drew the cover of The Color of Magic (and all Discworld books up to Thief of Time). Kidby is more faithful to the books, so in this case, it's probably a case of DidNotDoTheResearch.

to:

*** That would be Josh Kirby, not Paul Kidby, who drew the cover of The Color of Magic (and all Discworld books up to Thief of Time). Kidby is more faithful to the books, so in this case, it's probably a case of DidNotDoTheResearch.
books.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** That would be Josh Kirby, not Paul Kidby, who drew the cover of The Color of Magic (and all Discworld books up to Thief of Time). Kidby is more faithful to the books, so in this case, it's probably a case of DidNotDoTheResearch.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** One of the cover artists, I ''believe'' Paul Kidby, is known for putting unique interpretations in his cover art. For example, on the cover of The Color of Magic, Twoflower literally has four eyes, instead of glasses. So it probably has little to do with the actual book...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Actually, it says that he "regards the decimal point as a nuisance." This may mean that, like Detritus in the Pork Futures Warehouse, he has gained the ability to do math so advanced that it renders him completely useless for mere arithmetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Nonsense word fix.


* In the end of Unseen Academicals when Glenda and [[spoiler: the orc]] go to the palace, Lady Margolotta apparently adviced Drumknott to station guards with crossbows in the hall to shoot the two. And she seems rather offended when Vetinari tells his secretary to 'stand them (the guards) down'. Now, we learned that [[spoiler: the orc]] is pretty much nigh-immortal and that the bolts therefore would only harm/kill Glenda, very likely sending him in a near impossible to stop bersekerrage and rampage. Margolotta's ought to be fully aware of that. What the hell was that woman thinking/planning?

to:

* In the end of Unseen Academicals when Glenda and [[spoiler: the orc]] go to the palace, Lady Margolotta apparently adviced advised Drumknott to station guards with crossbows in the hall to shoot the two. And she seems rather offended when Vetinari tells his secretary to 'stand them (the guards) down'. Now, we learned that [[spoiler: the orc]] is pretty much nigh-immortal and that the bolts therefore would only harm/kill Glenda, very likely sending him in a near impossible to stop bersekerrage and rampage. Margolotta's ought to be fully aware of that. What the hell was that woman thinking/planning?



*** But we never learn what it took to take them down completely. And, as said, it might be viewed as a bit weird that Margolotta adviced Drumknott to prepare a way of dealing with the two she should have known could easily have ...very negative consequences.

to:

*** But we never learn what it took to take them down completely. And, as said, it might be viewed as a bit weird that Margolotta adviced advised Drumknott to prepare a way of dealing with the two she should have known could easily have ...very negative consequences.



*** ''I'' am fully aware of that. But as said, the text suggests ''she'' adviced to arm the guards with crossbows and ''she'' seemed offended when Vetinari ordered to stand them down. I am not saying that it DOES mean anything, just that it COULD.

to:

*** ''I'' am fully aware of that. But as said, the text suggests ''she'' adviced advised to arm the guards with crossbows and ''she'' seemed offended when Vetinari ordered to stand them down. I am not saying that it DOES mean anything, just that it COULD.

Changed: 149

Removed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** Over on the L-Space Wiki (to which I contribute and edit) the speculation is (backed by observational evidence) that wizards are offered a meal ina set pattern corresponding to either monastic prayer times, or the sounding of Bells aboard a ship.

http://wiki.lspace.org/wiki/Unseen_University_Mealtimes

to:

**** Over on the L-Space Wiki (to which I contribute and edit) the speculation is (backed by observational evidence) that wizards are offered a meal ina set pattern corresponding to either monastic prayer times, or the sounding of Bells aboard a ship. \n\n http://wiki.lspace.org/wiki/Unseen_University_Mealtimes




to:

*** "[[Literature/TheHitchhikersGuideToTheGalaxy Time is an illusion. Lunchtime doubly so.]]"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No, but you do need two or more to have 'eyes' rather than 'eye'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I\'m in ur post, closin ur boldz and fixin ur links.


* Does anyone have any idea what was with that thing through the end of the book'? Spoilering in case it's spoilery, I don't think it is but since I don't think I get it, better safe than sorry: [[spoiler: Where it has the blank pages with "'''You think this is over?" in the middle, several times, and then the last page is something along the lines of "Okay, ''now'' it's over." I assumed it was something like the Summoning Dark in ''[[Discworld/TheFifthElephant]]'', PaintingTheFourthWall and all, and it was The Shove, or whatever the tin can was (the spirit of football?) talking, but... it's left totally unexplained, almost like a weak joke that decided to go into BreakingTheFourthWall just for the heck of it. Maybe it was supposed to be a note to readers that this is the last "real" Discworld book (The Tiffany Aching books either not counting, or the plans for ''I Shall Wear Midnight'' being foregone), but that... doesn't sound right. Was it some theme I completely missed, like an expansion on Glenda's repeated mention of fairy tales, that went Meta?]] Did ''anyone'' get that?

to:

* Does anyone have any idea what was with that thing through the end of the book'? Spoilering in case it's spoilery, I don't think it is but since I don't think I get it, better safe than sorry: [[spoiler: Where it has the blank pages with "'''You think this is over?" over?'''" in the middle, several times, and then the last page is something along the lines of "Okay, ''now'' it's over." I assumed it was something like the Summoning Dark in ''[[Discworld/TheFifthElephant]]'', ''Discworld/TheFifthElephant'', PaintingTheFourthWall and all, and it was The Shove, or whatever the tin can was (the spirit of football?) talking, but... it's left totally unexplained, almost like a weak joke that decided to go into BreakingTheFourthWall just for the heck of it. Maybe it was supposed to be a note to readers that this is the last "real" Discworld book (The Tiffany Aching books either not counting, or the plans for ''I Shall Wear Midnight'' being foregone), but that... doesn't sound right. Was it some theme I completely missed, like an expansion on Glenda's repeated mention of fairy tales, that went Meta?]] Did ''anyone'' get that?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***** A lot of reclusive wizards who hadn't seen the light of day for years got drafted into the Roundworld-saving mission in ''The Science of Discworld III''. It's possible that, now that they've been reminded what sort of banquets they've been missing out on, more of them are coming to the Great Hall for mealtimes and it's necessary to re-stock the dining tables nine times a day just to keep up with demand.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered their first proper (non-practice) game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'' one, Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the [=UAs=] stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.

to:

** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered their first proper (non-practice) game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'' one, Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the [=UAs=] stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.non-wizards.
*** Point taken, though one then could still argue that Vetinari lost his reputation when he initially forbid foot-the-ball for being ''too brutal'' but left the fans unristricted. Even with the new rules, they will remain as brutal as before, jumping each others throats for the colours they wear, etc. Not to mention the former Dean as referee and then NOT have him try to undermine the UU and Vetinari and thereby Ankh-Morpork as total? But that's another question...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered their first proper (non-practice) game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'' one, Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the UAs stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.

to:

** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered their first proper (non-practice) game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'' one, Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the UAs [=UAs=] stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered the game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'', Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the UAs stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.

to:

** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered the their first proper (non-practice) game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'', ''win'' one, Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the UAs stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Some might hate me for this, but there's a sentence about half-way through the book that states -[...]UU's first football match in decades began-. This brings up the following question: Didn't they fulfil the bequest's conditions right there? We never get an information about the bequest's conditions state they have to play a full match (if that were the case they would not fulfil it anyway in the end). Only that they need to ''enter a team in the game of foot-the-ball'' . Didn't they actualy just do that right there?

to:

* Some might hate me for this, but there's a sentence about half-way through the book that states -[...]UU's first football match in decades began-. This brings up the following question: Didn't they fulfil the bequest's conditions right there? We never get an information about the bequest's conditions state they have to play a full match (if that were the case they would not fulfil it anyway in the end). Only that they need to ''enter a team in the game of foot-the-ball'' . Didn't they actualy just do that right there?there?
** Technically, yes, they'd saved the meals budget when they entered the game. But by the time they actually had to ''win'', Ridcully's pride was at stake because of all the dissing by ex-Dean Henry, as was Vetinari's reputation for infallibility. Nor could the UAs stomach the thought of wizards being publicly trounced by non-wizards.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

***** Adrian probably couldn't risk talking to Ponder because of the harsh feelings between their respective bosses. If ex-Dean Henry caught him chatting with one of Ridcully's loyal followers -- and one who'd flatly turned down a job offer from Brazeneck, yet -- then he'd probably have gotten in trouble for "fraternizing with the enemy".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** She probably never intended for them to shoot Nutt himself, but rather, to threaten Glenda if Nutt became a threat. Margolotta knows Nutt and his social insecurities well enough to deduce that any young woman willingly seen in his company is bound to be his LoveInterest, for whose sake he'd back off.

to:

*** She probably never intended for them to shoot Nutt himself, but rather, to threaten Glenda if Nutt became a threat.aggressive. Margolotta knows Nutt and his social insecurities well enough to deduce that any young woman willingly seen in his company is bound to be his LoveInterest, for whose sake he'd back off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** She probably never intended for them to shoot Nutt himself, but rather, to threaten Glenda if Nutt became a threat. Margolotta knows Nutt and his social insecurities well enough to deduce that any young woman willingly seen in his company is bound to be his LoveInterest, for whose sake he'd back off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Those are the rules for football ''as it was previously played at UU''. As in, the place where the porters go through obnoxious rituals about lost keys every morning just because it's always been done. Most of those excess "rules" are probably there to ensure that the ref bows twice towards the Tower of Art before wiping the ball clean, in remembrance of Archchancellar Whatchamacallit, or whatever.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Coin probably put the Hat back in its hatbox and intact when he undid much of the damage caused by his brief reign at UU.

Top