Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TheHumanCentipede

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** No, the director Tom Six was just chilling with his friends and then they started talking about what they would do to whoever raped their daugthers, he said he would do what the film shows, thought it was brilliant idea, and decided to make a film about it.

Changed: 6

Removed: 97

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing entry that's purely complaining.


*** I'm going to agree with that but also the science part. He's whacked but his passion here seems for science. He's no doubt spent years upon years detaching twins, so his next step is to unite people (lol) and make a pet. It's a weird jump for anyone sane, but not exactly that out there if someone was that science brilliant and that obsessed with twins as we are lead to believe from what little characterization we see from him and his home.

to:

*** I'm going to agree with that but also the science part. He's whacked but his passion here seems for science. He's no doubt spent years upon years detaching twins, so his next step is to unite people (lol) and make a pet. It's a weird jump for anyone sane, but not exactly that out there if someone was that science brilliant and that obsessed with twins as we are lead to believe from what little characterization we see from him and his home.



* Why do the other parts get fed by eating feces, rather than connecting the intestines?
* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''HOW THE FUCK WAS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''

to:

* Why do the other parts get fed by eating feces, rather than connecting the intestines?
* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''HOW THE FUCK WAS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''
intestines?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just because something is ILLEGAL, doesn't mean it can't be done. If you really wanted to get hold of a handgun in the UK, you could do so relatively easily. People just generally don't seek them out because A: They have no use or desire for one, and B: The consequences if you are caught attempting to purchase or in possession of one are severe to say the least.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Strictly speaking, not everything in a stool is waste that can't be digested. In the same way that urine contains SOME water, a stool contains SOME digestible matter. If the centipede was two people, person B could survive for a surprising amount of time. Possibly months. In a three person centipede, once the stool has gone through two people, though, person C would be getting nothing of nutritional value and would last maybe a couple of weeks, tops. In both cases, though, the people behind the "head" would be incredibly sickly and malnourished for the period they did survive, likely unable to get to their knees, let alone crawl around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Exactly. She can and will be saved. It's just that the movie ended before that happened because Tom Six is "MISTER EDGY"!

Added: 282

Changed: 17

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film ends at that point for dramatic reasons. [[spoiler:While I doubt she would have survived an attempt to cut herself free, there's very little chance otherwise that the police wouldn't have shown up in time to save her life]]. That isn't nearly as bleak an ending, though.



** Heiter is based off of the real-world Dr. Josef Mengele, along with other Nazi scientists and medical researchers whose "experiments" weren't any better. Without going into too much detail, their "experiments" were often just the result of a double-dose of sadism and curiosity, with the outcome already being both obvious and inevitable. He clearly knows that his Centipede won't survive on its own, which is why he provides an IV drip for nutrition and to prevent dehydration. He's just on a sadistic power trip and wants to see exactly what happens to the three subjects, along with how long he can keep them alive.

to:

** Heiter is based off of the real-world Dr. Josef Mengele, along with other Nazi scientists and medical researchers whose "experiments" weren't any better. Without going into too much detail, their "experiments" they were often just the result of a double-dose of sadism and curiosity, with the outcome already being both obvious and inevitable. He clearly knows that his Centipede won't survive on its own, which is why he provides an IV drip for nutrition and to prevent dehydration. He's just on a sadistic power trip and wants to see exactly what happens to the three subjects, along with how long he can keep them alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Heiter is based off of the real-world Dr. Josef Mengele, along with other Nazi scientists and medical researchers whose "experiments" weren't any better. Without going into too much detail, their "experiments" were often just the result of a double-dose of sadism and curiosity, with the outcome already being both obvious and inevitable. He clearly knows that his Centipede won't survive on its own, which is why he provides an IV drip for nutrition and to prevent dehydration. He's just on a sadistic power trip and wants to see exactly what happens to the three subjects, along with how long he can keep them alive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''WHY THE FUCK WAS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''

to:

* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''WHY '''''HOW THE FUCK WAS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''WHY THE FUCK WSS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''

to:

* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''WHY THE FUCK WSS WAS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why do the other parts get fed by eating feces, rather than connecting the intestines?

to:

* Why do the other parts get fed by eating feces, rather than connecting the intestines?intestines?
* And now for the biggest headscratcher of all: '''''WHY THE FUCK WSS THIS FILM APPROVED?!?!'''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How in the hell did Martin, the VillainProtagonist of the second movie, manage to get a job as a security guard? His psychiatrist outright calls him mentally challenged, he's in terrible shape, clearly has very poor eyesight judging from those thick glasses of his and is incontinent. Also, how in the hell did he get a ''gun in the UK?'' It's possible to legally own some firearms there, but not a handgun.

to:

* How in the hell did Martin, the VillainProtagonist of the second movie, manage to get a job as a security guard? His psychiatrist outright calls him mentally challenged, he's in terrible shape, clearly has very poor eyesight judging from those thick glasses of his and is incontinent. Also, how in the hell did he get a ''gun in the UK?'' It's possible to legally own some firearms there, but not a handgun.handgun.
* Why do the other parts get fed by eating feces, rather than connecting the intestines?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I'm honestly more curious why the first thing Katsuro did when getting the scalpel wasn't handing it down the line so they could cut themselves free from one another. They wouldn't be able to stand due to the knee procedure, but it'd still have been easier for them to get up the stairs.

to:

** I'm honestly more curious why the first thing Katsuro did when getting the scalpel wasn't handing it down the line so they could cut themselves free from one another. They wouldn't be able to stand due to the knee procedure, but it'd still have been easier for them to get up the stairs.stairs.
* How in the hell did Martin, the VillainProtagonist of the second movie, manage to get a job as a security guard? His psychiatrist outright calls him mentally challenged, he's in terrible shape, clearly has very poor eyesight judging from those thick glasses of his and is incontinent. Also, how in the hell did he get a ''gun in the UK?'' It's possible to legally own some firearms there, but not a handgun.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why doesn't the first guy attack the doctor? He seems young and strong, and the doctor is an aging nerd. Even with his anus attached to someone's mouth, he should have been able to grab the doctor, yank his feet out from under him, wrestle him and strangle him. At the very least, he should have tried.

to:

* Why doesn't the first guy attack the doctor? He seems young and strong, and the doctor is an aging nerd. Even with his anus attached to someone's mouth, he should have been able to grab the doctor, yank his feet out from under him, wrestle him and strangle him. At the very least, he should have tried.tried.
** I'm honestly more curious why the first thing Katsuro did when getting the scalpel wasn't handing it down the line so they could cut themselves free from one another. They wouldn't be able to stand due to the knee procedure, but it'd still have been easier for them to get up the stairs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also the way the first film portrays the doctor seems to put emphasis his fascination that turned to sick obsession came from siamese twins. Two beings that have to share some part of the body. In his mad science ravings i guess he chose digestive track so they could have something edible? Even though given that the film does have him use IVs (even if they are that prominently featured) so clearly he did use some thinking about how to make it live longer.

to:

** Also the way the first film portrays the doctor seems to put emphasis his fascination that turned to sick obsession came from siamese twins. Two beings that have to share some part of the body. In his mad science ravings i guess he chose digestive track so they could have something edible? Even though given that the film does have him use IVs (even if they are that prominently featured) so clearly he did use some thinking about how to make it live longer.longer.
* Why doesn't the first guy attack the doctor? He seems young and strong, and the doctor is an aging nerd. Even with his anus attached to someone's mouth, he should have been able to grab the doctor, yank his feet out from under him, wrestle him and strangle him. At the very least, he should have tried.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I get that the big bad is nuts in the head, but really, if his plan is actually instrumentality as opposed to "I need a clever conversation piece and a novelty coffee table just ain't gonna cut it," you'd think Sign No. 1 that turning mankind into an [[IncrediblyLamePun ATM machine]] wasn't gonna pan out was that its biology only worked when supplemented with life-support machines. I know, ExcusePlot and all, but damn, Mad Scientist Guy, you could've done much more awesomely horrible things than slake your desire for corporophagia.

to:

* I get that the big bad is nuts in the head, but really, if his plan is actually instrumentality as opposed to "I need a clever conversation piece and a novelty coffee table just ain't gonna cut it," you'd think Sign No. 1 that turning mankind into an [[IncrediblyLamePun ATM machine]] wasn't gonna pan out was that its biology only worked when supplemented with life-support machines. I know, ExcusePlot and all, but damn, Mad Scientist Guy, you could've done much more awesomely horrible things than slake your desire for corporophagia.coprophagiaphilia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I get that the big bad is nuts in the head, but really, if his plan is actually instrumentality as opposed to "I need a clever conversation piece and a novelty coffee table just ain't gonna cut it," you'd think Sign No. 1 that turning mankind into an [[IncrediblyLamePun ATM machine]] wasn't gonna pan out was that its biology only worked when supplemented with life-support machines. I know, ExcusePlot and all, but damn, Mad Scientist Guy, you could've done much more awesomely horrible things than slake your desire for corporophagiaphilia.

to:

* I get that the big bad is nuts in the head, but really, if his plan is actually instrumentality as opposed to "I need a clever conversation piece and a novelty coffee table just ain't gonna cut it," you'd think Sign No. 1 that turning mankind into an [[IncrediblyLamePun ATM machine]] wasn't gonna pan out was that its biology only worked when supplemented with life-support machines. I know, ExcusePlot and all, but damn, Mad Scientist Guy, you could've done much more awesomely horrible things than slake your desire for corporophagiaphilia.corporophagia.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** From a more non-conformist critique if all they had was suspicions both probably should have left for the warrant. Heiter's action with the needle though really should have been a red flag enough to risk having one officer stay there. As far as back up, they mostly just believed him to be a solo actor kidnapping several people, two cops in theory should be enough to take down one solo actor and call ambulances if they find kidnapping victims. They had no idea at the time of course his victims were surgically sewn together, they probably just thought they were tied up in the basement or something.
** Although one last point to stress here: While the above is probably the best rational explanation on what cops should have done here, that is not to say that every cop fictional or real is actually component at their job any more than everyone else is. It sucks for the centipede victims that they didn't get grade a supercops. But again how many real life people actually do get them when they are in trouble?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Accordint to TheOtherWiki they were wearing an especial underwear with a prostetic that allow the actor to bite some sort of rubber object giving the impression that they were joint anus-to-mouth, but not really near the anus.

to:

** Accordint to TheOtherWiki Wiki/TheOtherWiki they were wearing an especial underwear with a prostetic that allow the actor to bite some sort of rubber object giving the impression that they were joint anus-to-mouth, but not really near the anus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Accordint to TheOtherWiki they were wearing an especial underwear with a prostetic that allow the actor to bite some sort of rubber object giving the impression that they were joint anus-to-mouth, but not really near the anus.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Only one of them, Kranz, found the Centipede. Then he heard the gunshot and went to find Voller. By that time, Voller was dead, and Kranz himself was quickly dispatched by Heiter. There was no time to call for backup.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** I think this might be classified as the other end of the screwed up spectrum. The idea of the whole series existence is as you say from the director's own mind. But in the film you are commenting on, the doctor does hook them up to IVs each night. So by that he seems to at least know that he can't expect them to live on it alone.

to:

** I think this might be classified as the other end of the screwed up spectrum. The idea of the whole series existence is as you say from the director's own mind. But in the film you are commenting on, the doctor does hook them up to IVs each night. So by that he seems to at least know that he can't expect them to live on it alone.alone.
** Also the way the first film portrays the doctor seems to put emphasis his fascination that turned to sick obsession came from siamese twins. Two beings that have to share some part of the body. In his mad science ravings i guess he chose digestive track so they could have something edible? Even though given that the film does have him use IVs (even if they are that prominently featured) so clearly he did use some thinking about how to make it live longer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** I'm going to agree with that but also the science part. He's whacked but his passion here seems for science. He's no doubt spent years upon years detaching twins, so his next step is to unite people (lol) and make a pet. It's a weird jump for anyone sane, but not exactly that out there if someone was that science brilliant and that obsessed with twins as we are lead to believe from what little characterization we see from him and his home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The second film wound up being about a LoonyFan of the first film who got off to the idea of a human centipede and wanted to create one himself. The third, meanwhile, was about a human centipede being used as punishment by a sadistic prison warden.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**The excuse for having a human centipede in any of these movies will pretty much always just be "Man has mental illness, and wants to sew people ass to mouth."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the first movie they were hooked up to an IV for part of it... The second movie they more than likely did die of dehydration.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** I'm guessing he's based off of the real life Doctor Mengele who also studied twins, and was known for doing experiments like sewing two people together and other experiments that were more or less done so that he could "See what happens"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why would ''anyone'' with ''any'' sort of degree in science/biology think that a human would be able to survive eating another human's waste products? You know, the stuff they ''can't digest properly''? Just be honest and say that you're doing it because you have screwed-up fetishes, don't try to come up with stupid scientific explanations to "justify" your screwed-upness.

to:

* Why would ''anyone'' with ''any'' sort of degree in science/biology think that a human would be able to survive eating another human's waste products? You know, the stuff they ''can't digest properly''? Just be honest and say that you're doing it because you have screwed-up fetishes, don't try to come up with stupid scientific explanations to "justify" your screwed-upness.screwed-upness.
** I think this might be classified as the other end of the screwed up spectrum. The idea of the whole series existence is as you say from the director's own mind. But in the film you are commenting on, the doctor does hook them up to IVs each night. So by that he seems to at least know that he can't expect them to live on it alone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* How was the girl that ended up in the middle not able to carry her friend in the attempted escape? The friend weighed atmost 140 pounds. She should have been able to carry her friend, not have to struggle just to barely be able to drag her. THe effort put into the dragging also brings up another thing. How were her feet not cut when she was walking on the glass, or her freinds legs not cut when being drug through the glass?

to:

* How was the girl that ended up in the middle not able to carry her friend in the attempted escape? The friend weighed atmost 140 pounds. She should have been able to carry her friend, not have to struggle just to barely be able to drag her. THe The effort put into the dragging also brings up another thing. How were her feet not cut when she was walking on the glass, or her freinds legs not cut when being drug through the glass?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Page appeared to be indented wrongly (with many questions as sub-indents of a previous question). I think I fixed it, but one or two of the questions might have been intnentionally indented.

























** The middle and back actors really had to play large parts of the film with their mouth at someone else's butt, right?
*** Oh, I'm sure they were wearing underpants and some padding over their asses. Altough shooting in a hot studio with your nose right in someone's sweating butt can't have been fun...
** Why did the police not call for backup immediately, especially after [[spoiler:Seeing the Human Centipede in Heiter's Bedroom?]]
** Why was the truck driver the only person Heiter gagged? With all the shouting Lindsay, Jenny and Katsuro do during his lecture you'd think he'd wanna keep ''them'' quiet, too.

to:

** * The middle and back actors really had to play large parts of the film with their mouth at someone else's butt, right?
*** ** Oh, I'm sure they were wearing underpants and some padding over their asses. Altough shooting in a hot studio with your nose right in someone's sweating butt can't have been fun...
** * Why did the police not call for backup immediately, especially after [[spoiler:Seeing the Human Centipede in Heiter's Bedroom?]]
** * Why was the truck driver the only person Heiter gagged? With all the shouting Lindsay, Jenny and Katsuro do during his lecture you'd think he'd wanna keep ''them'' quiet, too.



*** It's not going to be easy, just coordinating everyone when they can't communicate and are all stuck together like this.
*** He has a secret elevator with a key so only he can use it?
** Why is Lindsay treated like a corpse in waiting? She's not in a good spot, true, but the police arrived in a vehicle that's going to be noticed missing in hours, tops, and that's before considering how she may be able to cut her way free.

to:

*** ** It's not going to be easy, just coordinating everyone when they can't communicate and are all stuck together like this.
*** ** He has a secret elevator with a key so only he can use it?
** * Why is Lindsay treated like a corpse in waiting? She's not in a good spot, true, but the police arrived in a vehicle that's going to be noticed missing in hours, tops, and that's before considering how she may be able to cut her way free.

Added: 618

Changed: 269

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Why is Lindsay treated like a corpse in waiting? She's not in a good spot, true, but the police arrived in a vehicle that's going to be noticed missing in hours, tops, and that's before considering how she may be able to cut her way free.

to:

*** He has a secret elevator with a key so only he can use it?
** Why is Lindsay treated like a corpse in waiting? She's not in a good spot, true, but the police arrived in a vehicle that's going to be noticed missing in hours, tops, and that's before considering how she may be able to cut her way free.free.
* Why would ''anyone'' with ''any'' sort of degree in science/biology think that a human would be able to survive eating another human's waste products? You know, the stuff they ''can't digest properly''? Just be honest and say that you're doing it because you have screwed-up fetishes, don't try to come up with stupid scientific explanations to "justify" your screwed-upness.

Top