Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / TengenToppaGurrenLagann

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Rossiu isn't thinking straight now. He's firmly gripped by fear and is likely projecting a good deal of his frustration and anxiety onto Simon because he can't really control him. That and he wants to keep up the perception that Simon is a dangerous renegade so his plan to use him as the scapegoat for the Anti-Spiral attacks. Simon being seen keeping up his usual heroics without any form of coercion would only weaken Rossiu's already-flimsy case to the public.

to:

** Simon was the one to suggest putting bombs in the mech. Rossiu knows that this means that Simon isn't concerned enough about his own life for just some bombs to to be an adequate threat. So he has Kinon, someone Simon knows and considers an innocent, ride along as extra insurance. Rossiu is getting paranoid, but he still knows Simon well enough to be sure that he'd never risk Kinon dying with him. Since her life would be in danger until they returned and she voluntarily leaves, Simon would have no choice but to follow through the mission and allow himself to be brought back into custody. It's cold blooded and probably unnecessary since Simon had been nothing but cooperative despite the fake charges and [[KangarooCourt sham "trial"]], but Rossiu isn't thinking straight now. He's firmly gripped by fear and is likely projecting a good deal of his frustration and anxiety onto Simon because he can't really control him. That and he wants willing to keep up the perception take any chances that Simon is a dangerous renegade so his would pull something crazy if he thought it would save the day. If anything, it was probably Kinon herself that came up with the plan and volunteered to use him as be the scapegoat ride-along hostage/potential executioner. She had the detonator for the Anti-Spiral attacks. Simon being seen keeping up his usual heroics without any form of coercion would only weaken Rossiu's already-flimsy case to bombs herself and was so fanatically in love with Rosssiu that she'd have seriously pulled the public. trigger if things came down to it.

Added: 679

Changed: 2680

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Because he didn't know that. However, if he just didn't bother, they'd have no way to find the Anti-Spirals at all and almost certainly be wiped out when they inevitably came to Earth for a large scale attack. Even if he did know she would fade out with them, do you seriously think he would care? The woman he loved was suffering as a pawn for a malicious group of aliens. Why would he let her suffer a second longer if he had any power to put a stop to it? Yeah, he didn't get to fully ride off into the sunset with her, but that doesn't mean what he and she did share wasn't meaningful.
** Besides that, why do people think it would be a simple thing to transform Nia? She is inherently tied to the Anti-Spirals. Her whole existence depended on them. It took a massive amount of willpower for her to keep existing for a week after they were destroyed. Spiral Energy is a lot of things, but it isn't magic. You can't just undo everything bad by focusing on it hard enough. Yeah, it was a gut punch for Nia to die herself, but it happened and she chose to spend her remaining time with the man she loved rather than look for some desperate solution that probably doesn't exist. Worse, if she was kept alive, it could risk reviving the Anti-Spirals as well. Either way,



** It's not about hating Rossiu. I have real respect for him as the [[OnlySaneMan Only Sane Man.]] I just can't get why he wouldn't have a contingency for that, when it was indeed a possibility that Simon would do so. Rossiu just doesn't strike me as the type who would rely on others' motives and emotions. He'd have a plan for every single possibility.

to:

** It's not about hating Rossiu. I have real respect for him as the [[OnlySaneMan Only Sane Man.]] OnlySaneMan. I just can't get why he wouldn't have a contingency for that, when it was indeed a possibility that Simon would do so. Rossiu just doesn't strike me as the type who would rely on others' motives and emotions. He'd have a plan for every single possibility.




to:

** Simon showed that he cared so little about risking his own life that he would happily accept having his mech loaded with bombs. Meaning that the bombs aren't effective as a threat because Simon is comfortable with the risk. So Rossiu put Kinon as his co-pilot to add an additional layer of insurance that he knows Simon wouldn't be comfortable with. Now he can be absolutely sure that Simon wouldn't dare risk her life by doing anything except completeing the mission and returning to base. He should know Simon well enough to realize none of this was necessary, but he's gotten so paranoid that he's not going to take any chances.



** That's the whole point. they realized the destructive power of spiral energy so they limited their use of it. the abuse eariler was nessecary. but, now that the threat is gone, they can limit the use of spiral energy to prevent the destruction of any dimensions

to:

** That's the whole point. they realized the destructive power of spiral energy so they limited their use of it. the abuse eariler earlier was nessecary.necessary. but, now that the threat is gone, they can limit the use of spiral energy to prevent the destruction of any dimensions




to:

** Spiral Energy isn't magic. It's incredible, but it has limits. You can't simply undo everything bad because you want to. The final battle took place in a realm with a ludicrous amount of the stuff and they still didn't just wish all their old friends who died moments before back to life. [[AllDeathsFinal Dead is dead in this world.]] Spiral Energy just can't fix it. At least no nearly as easily as some people seem to think it can. Simon accepting Nia's death is no different than him accepting the others. It's showing that he realizes he isn't a god and that he can't let tragedy stop him from living. Even if he tried to remake her, it would almost certainly be just a sort of clone that isn't really her. Effectively a doll that only exists for his own self-indulgence, rather than the one he loved and an insult to her memory. Simon accepting her death is both a sign of maturity and a direct refutation of the Anti-Spiral's rant that he and others would let the power of the Spiral delude them into thinking they were gods.




to:

** He saw Enkidu had a second head, Lagann is proportionate size of a head for Gurren and can sprout a giant drill where a neck should be, and he was all about working with Simon. So, being the [[IdiotHero impulsive nut]] he is, he stabbed Lagann on top of Gurren and called it a combination. It was pure dumb luck that Lagann was designed with the power to make his stupid plan actually work.

Added: 670

Changed: 8863

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None







to:

** People get really hung up on the "do the impossible" thing and forget that the characters aren't omnipotent gods. They miss the whole point that the Spiral King had that people assuming that Spiral Energy is some magical solution to any desire will only lead to destruction.




to:

** Team Dai-Gurren, less than fifty people, were collectively able to make a mech the size of galaxies. It's implied that the effects of Spiral Energy become exponentially more powerful as the number of people increase. The things that could happen if all of humanity, let alone the unknown numbers of other sentient species, were to abuse it would lead to destruction on the level of galactic groups, even if the universe itself survives.




to:

** Rossiu was giving in to complete despair at the scale of the problem. In his mind, any fighting was pointless. Worse, it could invite the Anti-Spirals to attack in full. He thought that the only way to survive was to basically surrender and retreat to some far off corner of space to live in a way that suppressed Spiral Energy, i.e. hope. Since that would effectively be returning to the same sort of suppressed life as they had underground, he knew that the others, especially Simon, would never accept that. So he decided to turn Simon into a scapegoat so the public would be more likely to reject resistance to the Anti-Spirals and would more readily accept his plan to simply escape. It's not a rational plan, but Rossiu was letting his fears rule him and regressed back to the mindset he grew up in.




to:

** I think people severely misinterpret the message of the series. It isn't "you can do anything, so never accept any outcome you dislike" it's "you can do what seems impossible, but don't assume that gives you the right to do everything you want". Saving Nia was, in part, what let them find and destroy the Anti-Spirals. They pulled some absurd things to do it, but it came with a high cost. Nia, unfortunately, was one of those costs. She held on for a time, but she did all she could do and faded with no regrets. If Nia could simply become permanently human, she'd probably have done it. Unfortunely, changes like that don't seem to be possible to make permanent. She'd rather spend what time she had as happily as possible rather than try to force someone to keep her on Spiral life-support forever. It sucked, but it did happen. He'd rather try to move on in life than assume that he could undo every tragedy by raging at it hard enough. At no point was it ever shown that Spiral Energy could fully undo death. Stall it, sure, but never fully undo it. Death is still death. Simon understood that and wasn't about to dishonor her memory by giving in to grief and risk causing disaster by abusing his power and assuming he was all-powerful.




to:

** Simone was miserable as a politician. He just isn't the type for a desk job. The battle is over and all he does by being there is keep the public from moving on into their new future. He outright said that Nia was the only thing keeping him in the city. After she died, he decided to move on himself and leave leading the new era to those like Rossiu who are more suited for it than him.




to:

** Simon has always been humble himself. He doesn't try to use Spiral Energy unless it is needed because he never really saw himself as anything special. Even at his peak, he was just doing what he felt needed to be done. Now that there isn't anything holding humanity back, he decided to remove himself from the picture so that he doesn't become that obstacle himself. He trusts that the others and humanity (and beastmen) can fend for themselves without the need of someone like him. The future they're building towards has [[NoPlaceForMeThere no place for him]] and he's fine with that.




to:

** Remember the absurd power being tossed around in the final battle? Things like moon-sized drills, firing at all points in space, throwing galaxies like frisbees? Now imagine insanity a fraction of this scale becomes standard military procedure. That kind of thing and more would happen if militaries of Spiral races fought on a large scale. The universe as whole may or may not be at stake, but it would be more than enough to render it void of life before it got to that point.




to:

** He was a short, scrawny, shy kid who was always nervous and had little to no social skills. Not to mention he had to be constantly dirty, likely smelled, and hung out with a troublemaker like Kamina. Why would the girls bother with him before the story started?




to:

** It really doesn't matter what was in the book. Even if it was an actual religious text, it almost certainly didn't say any of what the elders claimed it did because none of them could ever even read it. It was just a tool to prop up the authority of the elders and keep the villagers from rejecting their edicts on population control. It could have been a phone book or something for all they knew. Rossiu and the elder were having a sort of resigned/relieved laugh that the contents of the book being effectively meaningless was the final nail in the coffin for any chance to validate their religion. Now they could finally move on from it without any lingering doubts to hold them back.




to:

** Beyond a repeat of the Anti-Spirals' dream manipulations? None that we know of. Simon isn't so desperate as to waste his life searching for a chance to make contact with the dead. More to the point, it would go against his and their entire ethos of moving forward in life instead of dwelling on the past. Hell, if he did, Kamina's ghost would punch him in the mouth for even thinking about such a thing. He'd rather accept the grief and maturely move forward, seeing the world and future that he worked so hard to secure than to let his losses define him.




to:

** They weren't his daughters. They were his concubines. His mech "ate" them so he could use them as, effectively, Spiral Energy batteries.




to:

** Rossiu isn't thinking straight now. He's firmly gripped by fear and is likely projecting a good deal of his frustration and anxiety onto Simon because he can't really control him. That and he wants to keep up the perception that Simon is a dangerous renegade so his plan to use him as the scapegoat for the Anti-Spiral attacks. Simon being seen keeping up his usual heroics without any form of coercion would only weaken Rossiu's already-flimsy case to the public.




to:

** All they know that that Simon's fiancée was taking responsibility for an attack that did significant damage to the city and killed an unknown number of people. Simon's first attempt to fight them only lead to more destruction. The public is terrified that the new life they have is at risk and, as far as they know, their leader and hero was closely associated with the one face they have to put to their aggressors. It's irrational fear but it is understandable. Rossiu and Co. could have helped calm it, but he fell to panic himself and decided to exacerbate the public's fury so he could gain support for his plans to escape instead.




to:

** The number was less important than just ensuring that Lordgenome was keeping his end of the bargain. As long as the humans were suppressed to below that point, the Anti-Spirals know that Lordgenome was following through. If it ever rose above that number, that means that Lordgenome was either breaking his word and potentially turning on them, was losing his control over the humans, or was removed from power entirely by someone powerful enough to oppose him. In any of those cases, the Anti-Spirals know that their puppet king on Earth isn't doing his job anymore and they're ready to nip this potential problem in the bud before things get out of their control. Since Lordgenome's promise to enforce his control was the only reason that they hadn't destroyed Earth already, they have no reason to ever rescind their kill order when the limit was reached.
** Another thing to note is that the limit was for people on the surface. Lordgenome was meant to keep humans underground as much as possible. If a significant number like that was above ground, that means that means that they're either opposing him successfully or he is helping them. We saw that the humans can almost instinctively figure out and replicate Spiral technology in a very short time, which means that they would likely have had more than long enough to build up a force that could grow into a threat. All the more reason to squash them with overwhelming force before they have enough time to develop into something that could stand up to the Anti-Spirals.




to:

** Not every major city has that large a population. The city we saw was relatively small as it's still in a wasteland. We can assume it has hundreds of thousands within it, but not at the one million mark.




to:

** The Anti-Spirals aren't worried about conventional armies. They are powerful enough that normal weaponry is practically useless against them. What they're worried about is Spiral Energy use. That could be a threat not just to them, but the universe itself. Lordgenome made the Beastmen as sort of a compromise. Beastmen can't reproduce on their own and aren't supposed to be able to use Spiral Energy at all. If they did, he kill any who did show signs of Spiral Energy and edit the gene of a new batch to avoid that outcome. Viral somehow breaking the rules and producing Spiral Energy of his own in the last battles was something that shouldn't have been possible. If the Anti-Spirals won, they'd destroy probably destroy all life on Earth since they now know that Beastmen are also a potential threat.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Did he see them that way? They were nakama, for sure, but he was really only able to fully relate to Nia and Kamina. After the way Team Dai-Gurren treated him post-Kamina's death (especially Yoko. Jesus. She of anyone should have been able to empathize with his pain and yet she discouraged others from offering Simon emotional support), Rossiu (the other person who came closest to friendship with him) basically sacrificing him to appease the public after the TimeSkip, and Nia's death? What on earth did he have left to keep him there?

to:

** Did he see them that way? They were nakama, ''nakama'', for sure, but he not ''tomodachi''. He was really only able to fully relate to Nia and Kamina. After the way Team Dai-Gurren treated him post-Kamina's death (especially Yoko. Jesus. She of anyone should have been able to empathize with his pain and yet she discouraged others from offering Simon emotional support), Rossiu (the other person who came closest to friendship with him) basically sacrificing him to appease the public after the TimeSkip, and Nia's death? What on earth did he have left to keep him there?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Saving the woman he loved from being used as a tool and savoring whatever time he had with her is more than enough. He accepted her death after that, but that doesn’t mean he wasted his time. The final message of the series was that there must be a balance between reaching for more achievements and accepting responsibility with your power. Nia dying is no less unfair than the death of any other member of Team Dai-Gurren during the battle, but I don’t see people complaining that he didn’t resurrect everyone because “do the impossible”.

to:

** Saving the woman he loved from being used as a tool and savoring whatever time he had with her is more than enough. He accepted her death after that, but that doesn’t mean he wasted his time. The final message of the series was that there must be a balance between reaching for more achievements and accepting responsibility with your power. Nia dying is no less unfair than the death of any other member of Team Dai-Gurren during the battle, but I don’t see people complaining that he didn’t resurrect everyone because “do the impossible”.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** [[CompletelyMissingThePoint Actually]], Simon finding Nia wasn't as bad as you think. If he never found Nia, they would've never gone to the Anti-Spiral universe to get her back, and wouldn't even been able to get there even if they want to. The only reason they could even get there in the fist place was because of the engagement ring, and that was only there because Nia still loved Simon even while being controlled. Sure, she may have been an ApocalypseMaiden, but if anyone else had been the Anti-Spiral messenger, humanity would've either been locked in an eternal battle with no possibility to win, or just plain dead.

to:

** [[CompletelyMissingThePoint Actually]], Simon finding Nia wasn't as bad as you think. If he never found Nia, they would've never gone to the Anti-Spiral universe to get her back, and wouldn't even been able to get there even if they want to. The only reason they could even get there in the fist place was because of the engagement ring, and that was only there because Nia still loved Simon even while being controlled. Sure, she may have been an ApocalypseMaiden, but if anyone else had been the Anti-Spiral messenger, humanity would've either been locked in an eternal battle with no possibility to win, or just plain dead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Did he see them that way? They were nakama, for sure, but he was really only able to fully relate to Nia and Kamina. After the way Team Dai-Gurren treated him post-Kamina's death (especially Yoko. Jesus. She of anyone should have been able to empathize with his pain and yet she discouraged others from offering Simon emotional support), Rossiu (the other person who came closest to friendship with him) basically sacrificing him to appease the public after the TimeSkip, and Nia's death? What on earth did he have left to keep him there?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well duh. [[TerryPrachet If there was a button labeled "do not press or world will end", the paint wouldn't have time to dry]]. As a species, we tend to learn what works and what doesn't by trial and error, which is fine when the trial is over fire makes a good loincloth adornment, but doesn't when it comes to altering fundamental constants of the universe or working out significant moral dilemmas.

to:

** Well duh. [[TerryPrachet [[Creator/TerryPratchett If there was a button labeled "do not press or world will end", the paint wouldn't have time to dry]]. As a species, we tend to learn what works and what doesn't by trial and error, which is fine when the trial is over fire makes a good loincloth adornment, but doesn't when it comes to altering fundamental constants of the universe or working out significant moral dilemmas.



** Also, [[{{thatother1dude}} the same guy (me)]] wrote most (all?) of them and I think I just miscounted (as it says the explosion was [[EditedForSyndication cut for time on the Sci Fi Channel broadcast]], so I haven't seen it since I watched a FanSub like a year ago).

to:

** Also, [[{{thatother1dude}} [[Tropers/{{thatother1dude}} the same guy (me)]] wrote most (all?) of them and I think I just miscounted (as it says the explosion was [[EditedForSyndication cut for time on the Sci Fi Channel broadcast]], so I haven't seen it since I watched a FanSub like a year ago).



** Can't remember precisely, but seeing how his Gunmen is a massive walking battleship with more dakka than you can possibly imagine, perhaps he was just being full of himself. Or seeing how the full output of DaiGurren could create a metaphorical 'wall of fire', he could've been referring to that.

to:

** Can't remember precisely, but seeing how his Gunmen is a massive walking battleship with more dakka than you can possibly imagine, perhaps he was just being full of himself. Or seeing how the full output of DaiGurren Dai-Gurren could create a metaphorical 'wall of fire', he could've been referring to that.



** Maybe it's a cultural thing? Maybe it's more culturally accepted in the world of TTGL to show skin, but female nipples are taboo, and Yoko just never really thought about the FridgeLogic inherit in that particular rule. Also, in the fourth Parallel Works, she runs around in the Lagann topless, more peeved at Gimmy for [[spoiler:stealing her Bikini top]] than for having seen her nipples. Also, perhaps she enjoys ThesisTitillationTheory and believes that if anyone sees her nipples, her sex appeal will drop?

to:

** Maybe it's a cultural thing? Maybe it's more culturally accepted in the world of TTGL to show skin, but female nipples are taboo, and Yoko just never really thought about the FridgeLogic inherit in that particular rule. Also, in the fourth Parallel Works, she runs around in the Lagann topless, more peeved at Gimmy for [[spoiler:stealing her Bikini top]] than for having seen her nipples. Also, perhaps she enjoys ThesisTitillationTheory TheissTitillationTheory and believes that if anyone sees her nipples, her sex appeal will drop?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Discussion
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Discussion



to:

** Personal theory (WMG, probably) is that they were Lazengann’s actual batteries, transformed into women so Lordgenome could have some company. The guy seemed perfectly capable of running Lazengann by himself in the finale, and the ‘girls’ seemed...a bit off. They didn’t seem to have normal human skin tone (though that may be due to color filters), and giggled when they swallowed by the drills. Not to mention, Spiral Energy is highest amongst those with hot-blooded passion; a handful of mentally broken consorts don’t seem like they’d generate much, especially since Lordgenome could have used Guame as a partner like in the past. If they are Nia’s ‘aunts?’ and one of them was, presumably, her mother, this does imply Lordgenome knocked up his own mecha...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reverting Bowdlerization


** Because it would probably require mechs the size of ''the moon'' to fully capture such manly awesomeness for the finale.

to:

** Because it would probably require mechs the size of ''the goddamn moon'' to fully capture such manly awesomeness for the finale.



** You can't expect someone like Kittan to change no matter how much time passes. He himself basically admits he's ill-suited for the job they gave him. There are basically two camps among the Gurren-dan post time skip: People like Rossiu, Yoko, and Dayakka who changed in some way in the seven years, and people like Kittan, Simon, Nia, and Viral who really didn't change all that much. In fact, although it's not really easy to see between the mind blowing battles, there is the overarching theme of "growing up" present in the post-time skip world. The problem is it's a lot more subtle (and in Simon's case with refusing to even try to bring back Nia at the end, mindblowingly misguided...personally if I heard someone say to let the girl who went poof stay poofed because it was time to move on and leave it to the next generation, I'd sock him in the face and ask "What about YOUR next generation? You just saved the universe, be a little selfish just this once!") in that it addresses a problem with 20-somethings moving forward in life. Most of the protagonists have this stagnation in their lives as a character flaw. This growth, however, is incredibly hard to portray in any form of media, since almost everyone is still going through it in their own lives. It's like a 10 year old writing about puberty.

to:

** You can't expect someone like Kittan to change no matter how much time passes. He himself basically admits he's ill-suited for the job they gave him. There are basically two camps among the Gurren-dan post time skip: People like Rossiu, Yoko, and Dayakka who changed in some way in the seven years, and people like Kittan, Simon, Nia, and Viral who really didn't change all that much. In fact, although it's not really easy to see between the mind blowing battles, there is the overarching theme of "growing up" present in the post-time skip world. The problem is it's a lot more subtle (and in Simon's case with refusing to even try to bring back Nia at the end, mindblowingly misguided...personally if I heard someone say to let the girl who went poof stay poofed because it was time to move on and leave it to the next generation, I'd sock him in the face and ask "What about YOUR next generation? You just saved the Goddamn universe, be a little selfish just this once!") in that it addresses a problem with 20-somethings moving forward in life. Most of the protagonists have this stagnation in their lives as a character flaw. This growth, however, is incredibly hard to portray in any form of media, since almost everyone is still going through it in their own lives. It's like a 10 year old writing about puberty.



** There is something wrong with you. No one here is denying ''him'' anything. He made the decision himself, (if the possibility is even ''there'' "potential of evolution" does not equate to "screw causality" any more than [[HumanPopsicle cryogenics]] equate to [[SetRightWhatOnceWasWrong time travel]]) and he would not be never has been that presumptuous. There is a ''very big difference'' between [[BadassBoast "Who the hell do you think I am?"]] and [[AGodAmI "I will become the god of the new world."]] That you think for some reason that that level of idiocy is acceptable proves nothing about the characters. All it shows is that you weren't paying attention.

to:

** There is something wrong with you. No one here is denying ''him'' anything. He made the decision himself, (if the possibility is even ''there'' "potential of evolution" does not equate to "screw causality" any more than [[HumanPopsicle cryogenics]] equate to [[SetRightWhatOnceWasWrong time travel]]) and he would not be never has been that presumptuous. There is a ''very big difference'' between [[BadassBoast "Who the hell do you think I am?"]] and [[AGodAmI "I will become the god of the new world."]] That you think for some reason that that level of idiocy ''assholery'' is acceptable proves nothing about the characters. All it shows is that you weren't paying attention.



* Why do people say Kittan is like Kamina? Kittan is a violent jerk, and Kamina is an inspiring and fairly kind man who inspires the insecure. They do have physical similarities and do similar stuff but that's it.
** Kamina can be a jerk too, but both are aggressive thrill-seekers, mainly. The main difference is that Kamina is good with words, and Kittan isn't (which is somewhat lampshaded later on).
** The ressemblance between Kittan and Kamina is alluded in the movies where it is said that, while Kamina was in the front leading everyone, Kittan was in the rear pushing them forward. Also, after [[spoiler:the death of Kamina]], Kittan is chosen as a leader because, well, because he is one like Kamina. As for Kittan being a jerk, after watching the series a couple of time, I think that Kittan deserves more credit than he gets. While he acts all tough with guys, that facade melts with girls, like when he intterrogate Nia or when he is with his sister after the timeskip. And he is truly shocked by Lordgenome rejecting Nia, saying : "What kind of man would do such a thing?"
** Also, he may not actually be as jerkish as you make him out to be. While Kamina's good with words and knows what to say to someone, Kittan doesn't have a gift with words and usually tries to hide his emotions and put up a barrier. It seems more like Kittan just acts abrasive and mean, but inside he's soft and mushy. Kamina doesn't seem to hide anything.

to:

* Why do people say Kittan is like Kamina? Kittan is a violent jerk, dick, and Kamina is an inspiring and fairly kind man who inspires the insecure. They do have physical similarities and do similar stuff but that's it.
** Kamina can be a jerk dick too, but both are aggressive thrill-seekers, mainly. The main difference is that Kamina is good with words, and Kittan isn't (which is somewhat lampshaded later on).
** The ressemblance between Kittan and Kamina is alluded in the movies where it is said that, while Kamina was in the front leading everyone, Kittan was in the rear pushing them forward. Also, after [[spoiler:the death of Kamina]], Kittan is chosen as a leader because, well, because he is one like Kamina. As for Kittan being a jerk, dick, after watching the series a couple of time, I think that Kittan deserves more credit than he gets. While he acts all tough with guys, that facade melts with girls, like when he intterrogate Nia or when he is with his sister after the timeskip. And he is truly shocked by Lordgenome rejecting Nia, saying : "What kind of man would do such a thing?"
** Also, he may not actually be as jerkish dickish as you make him out to be. While Kamina's good with words and knows what to say to someone, Kittan doesn't have a gift with words and usually tries to hide his emotions and put up a barrier. It seems more like Kittan just acts abrasive and mean, but inside he's soft and mushy. Kamina doesn't seem to hide anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because it would probably require mechs the size of ''the goddamn moon'' to fully capture such manly awesomeness for the finale.

to:

** Because it would probably require mechs the size of ''the goddamn moon'' to fully capture such manly awesomeness for the finale.



** You can't expect someone like Kittan to change no matter how much time passes. He himself basically admits he's ill-suited for the job they gave him. There are basically two camps among the Gurren-dan post time skip: People like Rossiu, Yoko, and Dayakka who changed in some way in the seven years, and people like Kittan, Simon, Nia, and Viral who really didn't change all that much. In fact, although it's not really easy to see between the mind blowing battles, there is the overarching theme of "growing up" present in the post-time skip world. The problem is it's a lot more subtle (and in Simon's case with refusing to even try to bring back Nia at the end, mindblowingly misguided...personally if I heard someone say to let the girl who went poof stay poofed because it was time to move on and leave it to the next generation, I'd sock him in the face and ask "What about YOUR next generation? You just saved the Goddamn universe, be a little selfish just this once!") in that it addresses a problem with 20-somethings moving forward in life. Most of the protagonists have this stagnation in their lives as a character flaw. This growth, however, is incredibly hard to portray in any form of media, since almost everyone is still going through it in their own lives. It's like a 10 year old writing about puberty.

to:

** You can't expect someone like Kittan to change no matter how much time passes. He himself basically admits he's ill-suited for the job they gave him. There are basically two camps among the Gurren-dan post time skip: People like Rossiu, Yoko, and Dayakka who changed in some way in the seven years, and people like Kittan, Simon, Nia, and Viral who really didn't change all that much. In fact, although it's not really easy to see between the mind blowing battles, there is the overarching theme of "growing up" present in the post-time skip world. The problem is it's a lot more subtle (and in Simon's case with refusing to even try to bring back Nia at the end, mindblowingly misguided...personally if I heard someone say to let the girl who went poof stay poofed because it was time to move on and leave it to the next generation, I'd sock him in the face and ask "What about YOUR next generation? You just saved the Goddamn universe, be a little selfish just this once!") in that it addresses a problem with 20-somethings moving forward in life. Most of the protagonists have this stagnation in their lives as a character flaw. This growth, however, is incredibly hard to portray in any form of media, since almost everyone is still going through it in their own lives. It's like a 10 year old writing about puberty.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There is something wrong with you. No one here is denying ''him'' anything. He made the decision himself, (if the possibility is even ''there'' "potential of evolution" does not equate to "screw causality" any more than [[HumanPopsicle cryogenics]] equate to [[SetRightWhatOnceWasWrong time travel]]) and he would not be never has been that presumptuous. There is a ''very big difference'' between [[BadassBoast "Who the hell do you think I am?"]] and [[AGodAmI "I will become the god of the new world."]] That you think for some reason that that level of ''assholery'' is acceptable proves nothing about the characters. All it shows is that you weren't paying attention.

to:

** There is something wrong with you. No one here is denying ''him'' anything. He made the decision himself, (if the possibility is even ''there'' "potential of evolution" does not equate to "screw causality" any more than [[HumanPopsicle cryogenics]] equate to [[SetRightWhatOnceWasWrong time travel]]) and he would not be never has been that presumptuous. There is a ''very big difference'' between [[BadassBoast "Who the hell do you think I am?"]] and [[AGodAmI "I will become the god of the new world."]] That you think for some reason that that level of ''assholery'' idiocy is acceptable proves nothing about the characters. All it shows is that you weren't paying attention.



* Why do people say Kittan is like Kamina? Kittan is a violent dick, and Kamina is an inspiring and fairly kind man who inspires the insecure. They do have physical similarities and do similar stuff but that's it.
** Kamina can be a dick too, but both are aggressive thrill-seekers, mainly. The main difference is that Kamina is good with words, and Kittan isn't (which is somewhat lampshaded later on).
** The ressemblance between Kittan and Kamina is alluded in the movies where it is said that, while Kamina was in the front leading everyone, Kittan was in the rear pushing them forward. Also, after [[spoiler:the death of Kamina]], Kittan is chosen as a leader because, well, because he is one like Kamina. As for Kittan being a dick, after watching the series a couple of time, I think that Kittan deserves more credit than he gets. While he acts all tough with guys, that facade melts with girls, like when he intterrogate Nia or when he is with his sister after the timeskip. And he is truly shocked by Lordgenome rejecting Nia, saying : "What kind of man would do such a thing?"
** Also, he may not actually be as dickish as you make him out to be. While Kamina's good with words and knows what to say to someone, Kittan doesn't have a gift with words and usually tries to hide his emotions and put up a barrier. It seems more like Kittan just acts abrasive and mean, but inside he's soft and mushy. Kamina doesn't seem to hide anything.

to:

* Why do people say Kittan is like Kamina? Kittan is a violent dick, jerk, and Kamina is an inspiring and fairly kind man who inspires the insecure. They do have physical similarities and do similar stuff but that's it.
** Kamina can be a dick jerk too, but both are aggressive thrill-seekers, mainly. The main difference is that Kamina is good with words, and Kittan isn't (which is somewhat lampshaded later on).
** The ressemblance between Kittan and Kamina is alluded in the movies where it is said that, while Kamina was in the front leading everyone, Kittan was in the rear pushing them forward. Also, after [[spoiler:the death of Kamina]], Kittan is chosen as a leader because, well, because he is one like Kamina. As for Kittan being a dick, jerk, after watching the series a couple of time, I think that Kittan deserves more credit than he gets. While he acts all tough with guys, that facade melts with girls, like when he intterrogate Nia or when he is with his sister after the timeskip. And he is truly shocked by Lordgenome rejecting Nia, saying : "What kind of man would do such a thing?"
** Also, he may not actually be as dickish jerkish as you make him out to be. While Kamina's good with words and knows what to say to someone, Kittan doesn't have a gift with words and usually tries to hide his emotions and put up a barrier. It seems more like Kittan just acts abrasive and mean, but inside he's soft and mushy. Kamina doesn't seem to hide anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Saving the woman he loved from being used as a tool and savoring whatever time he had with her is more than enough. He accepted her death after that, but that doesn’t mean he wasted his time. The final message of the series was that there must be a balance between reaching for more achievements and accepting responsibility with your power. Nia dying is no less unfair than the death of any other member of Team Dai-Gurren during the battle, but I don’t see people complaining that he didn’t resurrect everyone because “do the impossible”.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

Added: 375

Changed: 264

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Why did Simon even bother?]]

* If he knew that Nia would be erased after the death of the Anti-Spiral and never intended to use Spiral Power to either turn her into a full human or some other method to prevent her death, then why did he rush off to save her the first chance he got? Think about it. It wouldn't have made any difference if he had rescued her or not.




to:

** You make a valid point and it's why I hate Simon's character. If he wasn't going to go all the way to save her, then why did he race off the first chance he got to rescue her. It wouldn't have made any difference if he had allowed the Anti-spiral to kill her.

Added: 1675

Changed: 172

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Not sure if people are still debating this but I felt I should offer my reasons. Like a lot of viewers, I HATED TTGL's ending. For both personal and impersonal reasons:
** Personal Reasons
*** Simon's reaction to her death. He may have known it was coming, but you do not go through all of that and not even shed a single tear. No. Human emotion does not work that way. If the person I loved was kidnapped, brainwashed, tortured to the brink of death, and then after risking life and limb to save her and losing more than a few comrades I found out she was going to die in a week; I would either spend the rest of my life drinking myself into a stupor or snap and go Joker on the world.
** Impersonal Reasons
*** I don't mind bittersweet or even tragic endings. In fact, a lot of my favorite anime titles ended on a note like that (Fatal Fury:The Motion Picture, Ninja Scroll, Basilisk). The difference between them and Gurren Lagann is that their bittersweet ending served a purpose. It either motivated the characters or it brought closure to certain plot elements. Nia's death did not serve a purpose and was done just for the sake of cheap drama. If it was written as a heroic sacrifice where her death allowed Simon to defeat the Anti-Spiral, then I would be more forgiving and I might even like it.
*** It was completely unnecessary. Granted, I agree with the point that bringing back the dead is in the long term not a good idea. But there is a big difference between playing god and treating a medical condition. And even if using Spiral Energy to keep Nia from fading away does for some reason offset the balance of the universe, people seem to forget that Nia was technically half human/half anti-spiral. So even if her anti-spiral half faded away due to lack of Ontological Inertia, her human half should still have remained.

Added: 2866

Changed: 185

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Maybe they're not related by blood? Not unlike how Simon and Kamina aren't actually related, but they treat each other like relatives anyway; who's to say Beastmen can't do the same?


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Rigging Gurren Lagann with Explosives]]

* If the plan was to create an instant kill scenario for Simon if he did anything Rossiu didn't approve of, why are all of the explosives only in the cockpit of ''Gurren'', and not anywhere else or even apparently in Lagann at all? All Simon would need to do is detach Lagann and leave, and there'd be nothing they could do to him. Sure, Kinon would still be in harms way and Simon would probably never abandon her to die but, would Rossiu really bet on Simon's good will to keep him from running away? He wants ''Simon'' Dead, not not Kinon - why endanger her rather than him?

[[/folder]]

[[folder:The Public Blaming Simon for Everything]]

* Everyone should know exactly why the moon is going to fall on the earth - it was told directly to them during Nia's broadcast and everyone believes it without question. The human population increase has absolutely nothing to do with Simon, so why does everyone thing it's his fault when it reaches the cutoff and the moon goes haywire? If anything it's all of ''their'' faults for reproducing too much.

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Is the "Million Humans" Limit Irreversible?]]

* If, say, the public were to engage in a violent campaign of self-population control, would that prevent the Anti-Spirals from wiping them out? Or heck, even if not that, the Mugan almost certainly kill plenty of people in their attacks - why not just control the population that way?

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Only One Million?]]

* If we're talking about the scope of entire cities and civilizations, isn't a million people pretty dang small? Especially looking at Kamina City - it's a huge metropolitan area with big skyscrapers and everything. Assuming it's comparable in size to a real metropolis, a million people wouldn't even ''begin'' to fill that much space, and that's not even considering that not even all of the people on earth live there.

[[/folder]]

[[folder:Not Considering the Beastmen a Threat]]

* Given that the population count only counts humans, and Lordgenome saw fit to create countless Beastmen to serve him on the surface with little concern, presumably the Anti-Spirals didn't view non-Spiral lifeforms as any potential threat to their plan. But... why? Sure, they can't use Spiral Energy ([[spoiler:unless you count Viral doing it in the movie]]), but who's to say they couldn't just devise ways to combat the Anti-Spirals by other means - they can still ''make'' stuff, can't they? And for that matter, Lordgenome can make them immortal; they'd be ''better'' soldiers than humans at least as far as resilience goes. Just have one single Spiral Energy user like Lordgenome (or even a small team of them) amass a massive army of undetectable, unkillable Beastmen and weapons, and fight the Anti-Spirals without even having to worry about triggering the Spiral Nemesis nearly as much.

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** For what it's worth, Father Magin and Epilogue Rossiu have the same voice actors in both the Japanese and English versions. If it were just one or the other, I'd chalk it up to simple coincidence, but combined with the facial similarity, it definitely appears to imply a deeper connection between the two.

Added: 269

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As I believe was mentioned elsewhere on this page: ''precedent.'' If Simon's allowed to do it, who's to say any of Team Dai-Gurren isn't allowed to do it? You think the Black Sisters would mind having their brother back? You think Kamina would've minded having his dad back if he were in any position to bring him back? Hell, you think any of the Team would mind bringing Kamina back? But that's not what Spiral Power is for. '''''We keep on moving forward.''''' There are people waiting behind you and if you just stand there in the middle of the road like some kinda moron you ruin things for everyone who follows and you spit on everything those who came before you have worked for. '''Just who in the hell do you think you are?'''

to:

** *** As I believe was mentioned elsewhere on this page: ''precedent.'' If Simon's allowed to do it, who's to say any of Team Dai-Gurren isn't allowed to do it? You think the Black Sisters would mind having their brother back? You think Kamina would've minded having his dad back if he were in any position to bring him back? Hell, you think any of the Team would mind bringing Kamina back? But that's not what Spiral Power is for. '''''We keep on moving forward.''''' There are people waiting behind you and if you just stand there in the middle of the road like some kinda moron you ruin things for everyone who follows and you spit on everything those who came before you have worked for. '''Just who in the hell do you think you are?'''are?'''
**** By refusing to do it, he made the very important statement that it was not okay for anyone else to do it. If it was okay for him, someone would have inevitably considered it okay to repeat. And gain enough Spiral Power to do it. Not exactly safe for the universe.



** The whole basis of the "bring Nia back" argument seems to be based solely on "Simon saved the universe, he is god and he deserves one selfish wish". Simon made it clear that he never saw himself as anything more than a "driller", which was also the basis of his entire hotblooded, emo-exorcising speech to Guame. He's content with being just who he is, and taking what fate has handed to him. Saying that he should do otherwise means going out of character for him, which is the same as saying that the ending does not suit the series (it's "out of character"). Nia dying also wasn't some way for the writers to screw the characters over, it was (as many people have ALREADY pointed out here) a way to reinforce the AESOP and the ending, since this way we know Simon will not be tempted to abuse Spiral Power until accidentally causing Spiral Nemesis. This is also reinforced during the time where the entire Dai-Gurren team was in the dream world, where they saw their "ideal" life and realised how wrong it was. Simon and Yoko's were the best examples, Simon knew that the Kamina bowing before the cops wasn't really the type of person he wanted to be, while Yoko saw the idealized version of herself, and realised it wasn't her at all.

to:

** The whole basis of the "bring Nia back" argument seems to be based solely on "Simon saved the universe, he is god and he deserves one selfish wish". Simon made it clear that he never saw himself as anything more than a "driller", which was also the basis of his entire hotblooded, emo-exorcising speech to Guame. He's content with being just who he is, and taking what fate has handed to him. Saying that he should do otherwise means going out of character for him, which is the same as saying that the ending does not suit the series (it's "out of character"). Nia dying also wasn't some way for the writers to screw the characters over, it was (as many people have ALREADY pointed out here) a way to reinforce the AESOP and the ending, since this way we know Simon will not be tempted to abuse Spiral Power until accidentally causing Spiral Nemesis. This is also reinforced during the time where the entire Dai-Gurren team was in the dream world, where they saw their "ideal" life and realised realized how wrong it was. Simon and Yoko's were the best examples, Simon knew that the Kamina bowing before the cops wasn't really the type of person he wanted to be, while Yoko saw the idealized version of herself, and realised realized it wasn't her at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** The whole thing still bugs me regardless. It just feels unrealistic, and no do not try to retort that realism doesn't matter because Gurren Lagann doesn't care about the laws of physics. Subverting the laws of physics for the sake of a CrowningMomentofAwesome is irrelevant with regards character interaction and world building.

to:

** The whole thing still bugs me regardless. It just feels unrealistic, and no do not try to retort that realism doesn't matter because Gurren Lagann doesn't care about the laws of physics. Subverting the laws of physics for the sake of a CrowningMomentofAwesome SugarWiki/MomentOfAwesome is irrelevant with regards character interaction and world building.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** She also doesn't really accomplish anything once she's helped guide the group towards a new goal and helped Simon out of his funk. Her role in the first half of the story is to act as a catalyst for character development of the other characters and not much else; a Mary Sue usually tends to completely derail the story and have it revolve around her. That doesn't happen to Nia until post time-skip, and at that point she's a well enough established character that her relationship with Simon being the core of the second half of the story doesn't raise a ton of narrative red flags.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
headscratcher



to:

**The Anti-Spiral's suppressed multiple races across the galaxy, and apparently Lordgenome was renowned all across the galaxy too. Remember, aliens exist in this world. Whoever said that book was written in a human language? And since the sign on the cover matches the one gunman they had, odds are it was the maintenance manual.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Lolicon and shotacon have been disambiguated. Links with too little context are being removed - "paedo" is not always a trope, examples where the tropeworthiness is unclear are being removed. Also, please do not use "loli" as a synonym for little girl; see Lolicon And Shotacon as to why not


** Lolicons.

to:

** Lolicons.{{Lolicon|AndShotacon}}s.



** Nope. Not at all. Maybe Lordgenome was into {{lolicon}} but isn't gay so no {{shotacon}}?

to:

** Nope. Not at all. Maybe Lordgenome was into {{lolicon}} but isn't gay so no {{shotacon}}?paedophilia?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Digging doesn't work that way. Remember ''{{Holes}}''? Subsurface soil is pretty tightly packed, and removing it usually makes it take up much more space. (Some of the non-simplified shots of digging, like when Simon digs out Lagann, show the dirt flying around too.) And this isn't taking account where the air to fill the space comes from.

to:

** Digging doesn't work that way. Remember ''{{Holes}}''? ''Literature/{{Holes}}''? Subsurface soil is pretty tightly packed, and removing it usually makes it take up much more space. (Some of the non-simplified shots of digging, like when Simon digs out Lagann, show the dirt flying around too.) And this isn't taking account where the air to fill the space comes from.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Has nothing to do with familiarity with in-universe fiction.


** Clearly, Reite was GenreSavvy enough to know that painting Dai-Gurren red would make it run three times faster, and therefore made doing so top priority. As for the time, Kinon actually mentioned that it's been a week since they hijacked the thing in episode 9, so that would give them some opportunity to paint it.

to:

** Clearly, Reite was GenreSavvy enough to know knew that painting Dai-Gurren red would make it run three times faster, and therefore made doing so top priority. As for the time, Kinon actually mentioned that it's been a week since they hijacked the thing in episode 9, so that would give them some opportunity to paint it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:If Beast Men can't reproduce, how can Chitori have a father?]]

* Picking PlotHole nits in ''Gurren Lagann'' might be like shooting fish in a barrel, but nonetheless, Episode 5.5, "My Gurren is Sparkling!" introduces a fairly egregious one: if Beast Men can't reproduce, how can Chitori have a father, Jigitalis? (And does this rate mention as a plot hole in the main page? :) )

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:What exactly happened to Lordgenome's children in the Teppelin throne room?]]

to:

[[folder:What exactly happened to Lordgenome's children daughters in the Teppelin throne room?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:What exactly happened to Lordgenome's children in the Teppelin throne room?]]

* Any theories about that? It looked like his mecha just...''ate'' them.

Top