Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / Neongenesisevangelion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Episode 13, Rei, Asuke and Shinji need to shower 17 times in a row in order to enter a "super clean" room for special Eva tests. When they exit the shower stalls, Asuka complains that they're walking in front of a surveillance camera naked, but she is assured that the visual is turned off and it's just a voice they're hearing. Right before the scene changes, they begin to walk out, and the red light flashes on the camera as a closeup shot. Does this mean they were being lied to and have no such privacy? Or was the camera on UNTIL this red light flashed? A red light flashing on, to me, means ON, as in RECORDING.

to:

* In Episode 13, Rei, Asuke and Shinji need to shower 17 times in a row in order to enter a "super clean" room for special Eva tests. When they exit the shower stalls, Asuka complains that they're walking in front of a surveillance camera naked, but she is assured that the visual is turned off and it's just a voice they're hearing. Right before the scene changes, they begin to walk out, and the red light flashes on the camera as a closeup shot. Does this mean they were being lied to and have no such privacy? Or was the camera on UNTIL this red light flashed? A red light flashing on, to me, means ON, as in RECORDING.RECORDING.
** Considering the number and magnitude of vital secrets being kept in this show, its the lies about camera use that surprise you?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).

to:

** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).side-effects).
*In Episode 13, Rei, Asuke and Shinji need to shower 17 times in a row in order to enter a "super clean" room for special Eva tests. When they exit the shower stalls, Asuka complains that they're walking in front of a surveillance camera naked, but she is assured that the visual is turned off and it's just a voice they're hearing. Right before the scene changes, they begin to walk out, and the red light flashes on the camera as a closeup shot. Does this mean they were being lied to and have no such privacy? Or was the camera on UNTIL this red light flashed? A red light flashing on, to me, means ON, as in RECORDING.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not the purpose of this page.


** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).

* Good grief, this page is huge!!!

to:

** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).

* Good grief, this page is huge!!!
side-effects).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
coolness


** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).

to:

** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).side-effects).

* Good grief, this page is huge!!!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***constant pressure. A nuke is like getting hit with a hammer, while a volcano is like getting hit with a small hammer, every second for however long your in the volcano. A Eva just jumping in for a dip, no problem but for extended operations at extreme depth, ya i can see why it would be needed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Forget that. There's a couple of officially made ''strip'' mahjong games featuring Rei and Asuka in various states of undress and uncensored sexy poses.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** They probably wanted to make sure Bardiel was completely dead, considering the implication that Bardiel IS the EVA, or something close to that. SuperRobotWars has it where Bardiel is the SOUL of the unit itself, and you can recruit Touji in it by basically [[DefeatMeansFriendship Friendship Through Superior Firepower]]. And SRW tends to use a lot of AllThereInTheManual.

to:

*** They probably wanted to make sure Bardiel was completely dead, considering the implication that Bardiel IS the EVA, or something close to that. SuperRobotWars ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWars'' has it where Bardiel is the SOUL of the unit itself, and you can recruit Touji in it by basically [[DefeatMeansFriendship Friendship Through Superior Firepower]]. And SRW tends to use a lot of AllThereInTheManual.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* At the end of the EoE, when everyone comes back, how exactly are they supposed to survive? No access to food - all organic life was absorbed back into tang together with all humans, after all. Even safe drinking water is probably not available any more. Everything is destroyed - there is little shelter from the elements in the broken structures. And I am not even going to mention anything beyond the most basic needs, such as culture and technology, in case they somehow manage not to starve without succumbing to cannibalism. So it seems to be a very pitiful and cruel existence - to go from being part of one single eternal consciousness back to mortality, only to die for real this time within maximum of a week. (And, really, that's how I see TV ED and EoE tie together - how Shinji rejects instrumentality with hope for future, realizes how well and truly everything humanity is screwed, completely snaps and tries to kill Asuka)

to:

* At the end of the EoE, when everyone comes back, how exactly are they supposed to survive? No access to food - all organic life was absorbed back into tang together with all humans, after all. Even safe drinking water is probably not available any more. Everything is destroyed - there is little shelter from the elements in the broken structures. And I am not even going to mention anything beyond the most basic needs, such as culture and technology, in case they somehow manage not to starve without succumbing to cannibalism. So it seems to be a very pitiful and cruel existence - to go from being part of one single eternal consciousness back to mortality, only to die for real this time within maximum of a week. (And, really, that's how I see TV ED and EoE tie together - how Shinji rejects instrumentality with hope for future, realizes how well and truly everything humanity is screwed, completely snaps and tries to kill Asuka)Asuka)
** The animals and trees come back too if they chose to, so food is covered. Not everything is destroyed; Tokoyo-3 is not the entire world, just because it got turned into a warzone in EoE doesn't mean that all of Japan is a wasteland. Where they end EoE is where Shinji is standing at the start of episode 24 in the series which had been decimated by all the previous angel fights, the rest of the world should be more or less the same as it was before. The ocean was already contaminated so GNR's corpse resting in it wouldn't make much of a difference, whilst inland water sources wouldn't have been touched (and even if they were, Lilth's blood is just LCL, which the pilots spend the entire series getting submerged in on a daily basis with no side-effects).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's not really rational. However I suppose you could look at it as Shinji being insensitive towards (read: not having any clue about) Asuka's issues regarding sucess and proving herself, so him syncing up to Rei with no difficulty showed he could do it and the fault lay with Asuka, which is proven to be the quickest way to hit her where it hurts. It's completely unintentional and you'd have to stretch it to lay the blame on him, but that's the teenage logic behind it.

to:

** It's not really rational. However I suppose you could look at it as Shinji being insensitive towards (read: not having any clue about) Asuka's issues regarding sucess and proving herself, so him syncing up to Rei with no difficulty showed he could do it and the fault lay with Asuka, which is proven to be the quickest way to hit her where it hurts. It's completely unintentional and you'd have to stretch it to lay the blame on him, but that's the teenage logic behind it.it.
* At the end of the EoE, when everyone comes back, how exactly are they supposed to survive? No access to food - all organic life was absorbed back into tang together with all humans, after all. Even safe drinking water is probably not available any more. Everything is destroyed - there is little shelter from the elements in the broken structures. And I am not even going to mention anything beyond the most basic needs, such as culture and technology, in case they somehow manage not to starve without succumbing to cannibalism. So it seems to be a very pitiful and cruel existence - to go from being part of one single eternal consciousness back to mortality, only to die for real this time within maximum of a week. (And, really, that's how I see TV ED and EoE tie together - how Shinji rejects instrumentality with hope for future, realizes how well and truly everything humanity is screwed, completely snaps and tries to kill Asuka)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It's not really rational. However I suppose you could look at it as Shinji being insensitive towards (read: not having any clue about) Asuka's issues regarding sucess and proving herself, so him syncing up to Rei with no difficulty showed he could do it and the fault lay with Asuka, which is proven to be the quickest way to hit her where it hurts. It's completely unintentional and you'd have to stretch it to lay the blame on him, but that's the teenage logic behind it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Other than that being the worst episode... honestly, they probably just overestimated the volcano. An Eva unit can take a nuke to the face ''unshielded''. Off the top of my head, I doubt a volcano's going to be able to match the overpressure wave from a nuke.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


* In Episode 10, Magma Diver, Asuka has to wear a special plug suit and Unit 02 has to be outfitted with special armor to survive the incredible heat and pressure inside the volcano. Misato orders her to sink past the point where it would be safe even with the armor. How do Shinji and Unit 01 sink all the way to Asuka's level and survive without any special equipment whatsoever?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


**** The Angel himself was stupid too. He had to rely completely on intercepting Unit-03's transport. And if he misses it?[[hottip:* :Humorously lampshaded in a fanfic where he became a "very sad cloud" due to Unit-03 being ferried via ship. It also effectively defeated him since he couldn't do shit without a host.]]

to:

**** The Angel himself was stupid too. He had to rely completely on intercepting Unit-03's transport. And if he misses it?[[hottip:* :Humorously it?[[note]]Humorously lampshaded in a fanfic where he became a "very sad cloud" due to Unit-03 being ferried via ship. It also effectively defeated him since he couldn't do shit without a host.]][[/note]]



** ...What is it supposed to mean?! Seriously, is it a lampshade on the Freudian imagery in the series?[[hottip:*:Yes]] Or was something lost in translation?

to:

** ...What is it supposed to mean?! Seriously, is it a lampshade on the Freudian imagery in the series?[[hottip:*:Yes]] series?[[note]]Yes[[/note]] Or was something lost in translation?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Just because there aren't enough alternate theories, aside from the obvious issue that Shinji was the only person capable of killing Kaworu at the time (except maybe Rei III, but no guarantees on that front) and Kaworu explicitly states that only one life form can survive, and he want its to be humans, maybe Kaworu wanted to die by Shinji's hand. It's actually surprisingly common, both in fiction and real life, that people want to be killed by the people they love most if they go wrong. And Kaworu kinda was born wrong (not his fault), so he just wanted to die by Shinji's hand. Similarly, maybe he thought that asking Shinji to kill him was the best thing for him. We never see Kaworu grow up, remember, except in the manga where he lives for something like nine days. He might just have a alternate viewpoint on how all this stuff works.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also worth noting, Dr Akagi Senior [[spoiler: starts seeing images of Yui when Rei I calles her obasan/hag.]] She noticed. Maybe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also worth noting here, that particular pattern of wings was used for the one of seven great Archangels in Medieval and later artworks. I'm not sure which one, sorry. But I'm pretty sure it was one of the more important ones. Just another layer of the whole religious image thing, in a way.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The short version is that the Positron Sniper Rifle is AwesomeButImpractical. The long version is that Episode 6/Evangelion1.0 showed there was a lot of setup involved. They had to pick the best spot, they had to lay down miles of cables, they had to do all sorts of preparations, all of which took hours before Operation Yashima even began. Even if you only count the setup involved after the operation began, that's still approximately 3-6 minutes of setup. And keep in mind, the 5th Angel wasn't moving at all during this. It is infinitely harder to hit a moving target, like most of the other Angels are.

to:

** The short version is that the Positron Sniper Rifle is AwesomeButImpractical. The long version is that Episode 6/Evangelion1.0 6 showed there was a lot of setup involved. They had to pick the best spot, they had to lay down miles of cables, they had to do all sorts of preparations, all of which took hours before Operation Yashima even began. Even if you only count the setup involved after the operation began, that's still approximately 3-6 minutes of setup. And keep in mind, the 5th Angel wasn't moving at all during this. It is infinitely harder to hit a moving target, like most of the other Angels are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The short version is that the Positron Sniper Rifle is AwesomeButImpractical. The long version is that Episode 6/Evangelion1.0 showed there was a lot of setup involved. They had to pick the best spot, they had to lay down miles of cables, they had to do all sorts of preparations, all of which took hours before Operation Yashima even began. Even if you only count the setup involved after the operation began, that's still approximately 3-6 minutes of setup. And keep in mind, the 5th Angel wasn't moving at all during this. It is infinitely harder to hit a moving target, like most of the other Angels are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Okay, so compared to many of the other questions about the series, this is fairly minor, but in Episode 9, "Both of You, Dance Like You Want to Win!", after Shinji and Rei do the synchronization exercise, Asuka storms out, crying. Hikari then gets angry at Shinji, demanding that he apologize to her, saying he made her cry. Except he didn't. At all. If anyone is to blame, it's Misato. She's the one who ordered Rei and Shinji to do the exercise together, to prove to Asuka that synchronizing with him was possible, and she's the one who threatened/suggested taking Asuka out of the operation and replacing her with Rei. Why, exactly, is Shinji the one being forced to apologize, aside from him being the show's scapegoat/punching bag?

Added: 337

Changed: 458

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Why isn't the Positron Sniper Rifle ever used again? They later show a lower power version of the weapon, but it lacked the tremendous punch of the original. It can't be just because the power requirements, as defending the world from extinction would justify blacking out Japan for some minutes.

to:

*** Does the LCL have DNA? It makes everything in-universe, and not everything has the same DNA. But if they just gathered LCL and put a soul in it to give it shape and told everyone it is a robot it can work. The AT thing i can't understand. If Lilith has no AT at the moment it wold just be goo.
* Why isn't the Positron Sniper Rifle ever used again? They later show a lower power version of the weapon, but it lacked the tremendous punch of the original. It can't be just because the power requirements, as defending the world from extinction would justify blacking out Japan for some minutes.minutes.
** It wold end the series for starters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Well Lilith is bleeding a sea of LCL, plenty of DNA to scoope up. But Angels aren't immune to normal weapons, they just can't be put down for good by them. Most of the time N2 mines are deployed the Angel is visibly damaged, and in theory if there is no AT protecting their cores conventional weaponry could kill one. Since Lilith is inactive and not pumping out an AT field there's nothing stoping them from using the tools they had to deal with her (although considering there's a shot showing that the missing half of Lilith is actually Unit 01 there's the question of just how they managed to seperate the two of them).

to:

** Well Lilith is bleeding a sea of LCL, plenty of DNA to scoope up. But Angels aren't immune to normal weapons, they just can't be put down for good by them. Most of the time N2 mines are deployed the Angel is visibly damaged, and in theory if there is no AT protecting their cores conventional weaponry could kill one. Since Lilith is inactive and not pumping out an AT field there's nothing stoping them from using the tools they had to deal with her (although considering there's a shot showing that the missing half of Lilith is actually Unit 01 there's the question of just how they managed to seperate the two of them).them).
* Why isn't the Positron Sniper Rifle ever used again? They later show a lower power version of the weapon, but it lacked the tremendous punch of the original. It can't be just because the power requirements, as defending the world from extinction would justify blacking out Japan for some minutes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's a fairly good theory on EvaGeeks that says his words were "I needed you."

to:

** There's a fairly good theory on EvaGeeks [=EvaGeeks=] that says his words were "I needed you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** There's a fairly good theory on EvaGeeks that says his words were "I needed you."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Minor nitpick; Doctor Akai jumped to her death since the chalk outline is on the floor below where she strangled Rei I to death, with the blood splatter giving a good indication she hit her head on one of the Magi cases first (which would also render her brain unsuitable for use), but as it's pointed out the MAGI system was completed and operational before her suicide, so the Brains are artifical ones and thus her death has no impact on their use.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If the angels are immune to normal weapons how did they get the DNA from Lilith?

to:

* If the angels are immune to normal weapons how did they get the DNA from Lilith?Lilith?
** Well Lilith is bleeding a sea of LCL, plenty of DNA to scoope up. But Angels aren't immune to normal weapons, they just can't be put down for good by them. Most of the time N2 mines are deployed the Angel is visibly damaged, and in theory if there is no AT protecting their cores conventional weaponry could kill one. Since Lilith is inactive and not pumping out an AT field there's nothing stoping them from using the tools they had to deal with her (although considering there's a shot showing that the missing half of Lilith is actually Unit 01 there's the question of just how they managed to seperate the two of them).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To show that she didn't think it was gross. She just said that 'cause she was embarrassed about the idea of liking him.

to:

** To show that she didn't think it was gross. She just said that 'cause she was embarrassed about the idea of liking him.him.
* If the angels are immune to normal weapons how did they get the DNA from Lilith?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

** I think I get it. SEELE causes Instrumentality and Rei reverses it. If so she ''needs'' an image link on BigDamnHeroes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In episode 22 during Asuka's MindRape sequence what's that scary sound after Asuka spots Shinji behind Kaji and says "Why are you there damn you?!/What are you doing there?!" Just wanted to know so I could put it under the NeonGenesisEvangelion entry on the HellIsThatNoise page.

to:

* In episode 22 during Asuka's MindRape sequence what's that scary sound after Asuka spots Shinji behind Kaji and says "Why are you there damn you?!/What are you doing there?!" Just wanted to know so I could put it under the NeonGenesisEvangelion Anime/NeonGenesisEvangelion entry on the HellIsThatNoise page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Asuka was so grossed out by kissing Shinji that once it ended she ran to the bathroom to wash out her mouth, then why did she keep the kiss going for so long?

to:

* If Asuka was so grossed out by kissing Shinji that once it ended she ran to the bathroom to wash out her mouth, then why did she keep the kiss going for so long?long?
** To show that she didn't think it was gross. She just said that 'cause she was embarrassed about the idea of liking him.

Added: 163

Changed: -8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If Anno really didn’t want people to fetishize Rei and Asuka why did he sexualize them in the first place? I know blah blah FanDisservice blah blah FreudianExcuse but when you have a shot of Rei with nothing but a towel covering her breasts or a shot down Asuka’s shirt you have to admit you might have given people a reason to see them as a sex symbol. Did the plug-suits ''really'' need to be that tight? Or emphasize their breasts? Did that have some deep psychological meaning too?

to:

* If Anno really didn’t want people to fetishize Rei and Asuka why did he sexualize them in the first place? I know blah blah FanDisservice blah blah FreudianExcuse but when you have a shot of Rei with nothing but a towel covering her breasts or a shot down Asuka’s shirt you have to admit you might have given people a reason to see them as a sex symbol. Did the plug-suits ''really'' need to be that tight? Or emphasize their breasts? Did that have some deep psychological meaning too?too?
* If Asuka was so grossed out by kissing Shinji that once it ended she ran to the bathroom to wash out her mouth, then why did she keep the kiss going for so long?

Top