Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Headscratchers / MassEffect3

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No longer a trope.


** Same reason anyone one cheats on their girlfriend, really. Seriously, the [[YourCheatingHeart list is staggering]]. it seems to be Bioware's fault that every relationship so far has been permanent (unless if you cheat on your [=ME=]1 love interest), and Jacob gets the flak because he's the only one who does and because he happens to be black. Why aren't you complaining if your black Shepard cheats on Ashley, Miranda, or Jack?

to:

** Same reason anyone one cheats on their girlfriend, really. Seriously, the [[YourCheatingHeart list is staggering]].staggering. it seems to be Bioware's fault that every relationship so far has been permanent (unless if you cheat on your [=ME=]1 love interest), and Jacob gets the flak because he's the only one who does and because he happens to be black. Why aren't you complaining if your black Shepard cheats on Ashley, Miranda, or Jack?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility is that some pf those units represent the units that don't have to be deployed to that area thanks to Shep. So,for example, scanning a planet means that the Turian ship that would have been sent out to scout the area can instead be reassigned to the Alliance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Another possibility is that Cerberus was already building up forces, but had been running in stealth mode prior to ME3. They just deployed their forces after things hit the fan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** This is more TruthInTelevision than you'd think. A lot of soldiers - especially experienced ones - go around with non-standard weapons, or weapons that they've purchased and customized for themselves. This is very common with sidearms in particular, but even primary weapons can be swapped out for custom or personalized firearms at the discretion of the individual or commanding officer. One of the main reasons why standard-issue weapons is a major thing - ease of logistics - is far less significant in Mass Effect due to omnigel making it much easier to maintain equipment, along with the lack of necessity for standardized ammunition. As long as it gets the job done, soldiers carry whatever gear they want.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Alliance Military Issued Weaponry]]
* The M-3 Predator's description states that it's not used by Alliance Military personnel, yet Anderson carries one and gives one to you at the beginning, and Alliance troops are seen using it frequently. Furthermore, the M-92 Mantis is stated to be used only by planetary militia groups, yet the first time you find one is by a dead Alliance Marine. Does BioWare not pay attention to detail?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Cerberus used to be divided into independent cells before it reorganised as a huge paramilitary group between the second and third games. Miranda probably didn't have any access to information that wasn't relevant to her own cell's work, anything she could possibly know about them would be informal at most.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Staff officers are rear-echelon office workers, analysts, and technicians. They're not front-line fighters. A staff officer would not necessarily be familiar with front-line military hardware, any more than an infantryman would be familiar with complex radio or fighter craft.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[Folder: Staff Analyst Brooks ignorance of basic Alliance Technology.]]

to:

[[Folder: [[folder: Staff Analyst Brooks ignorance of basic Alliance Technology.]]the Mako]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[Folder: Staff Analyst Brooks ignorance of basic Alliance Technology.]]
*I don't know enough about what all Staff Analysts do or have knowledge of in the Alliance let alone Real Life Militaries. During the early part of Shepard's infiltration of the Citadel Archives. At one point Brooks asks what is a Mako, Shouldn't a Staff Officer know what a Mako is?
** And considering how many members of Shepard's team are part of the military wouldn't they pick up on that discrepancy that Staff Analyst Brooks isn't who she claims she is?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They could have evolved on a world similar to that of the krogan. The krogan are predatory but their eyes developed on the sides of their heads to give them a better field of view. Also remember that evolution does not develop in a 100% optimal manner, but rather in a manner that is good enough to guarantee the passing of genes. If they're predators whose eyes are good enough to let them catch prey, then that will be how they develop - especially if they develop intelligence to offset physical disadvantages, like humans did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[/folder]]

[[folder: Javik's eyes]]
* Javik claims that the Protheans evolved from predators/hunters, which is why their sensory abilities were so necessary. So how do we explain the eyes? They're extremely wide set with elongated pupils like a goat's; those features are usually associated with prey animals, who need a wider range of vision to check their surroundings. Predator eyes are usually set on the front of the head to focus on a target.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* The codex has established that just one projectile from a dreadnought-scale mass accelerator hits like a nuclear weapon. In fact the Drill Sergeant in ME2 specified that the impact of a 2kg slug from an Everest-class dreadnought releases a third of the energy of the Hiroshima bomb. Orbital bombardment obliterates whole cities; in fact exploration reveals dead worlds which have been subjected to precisely this form of genocide. The Reapers do it to planets they can't be bothered to harvest. BUT here we have Shepard, standing not 50 yards from the Reaper he's targeting for ''the entire Quarian fleet'' -- the impact of whose barrage would have ''vaporized'' Shepard, Tali, the other squadmate, Legion, and everybody and everything else within five miles of Ground Zero. SlapOnTheWristNuke indeed!

to:

* The codex has established that just one projectile from a dreadnought-scale mass accelerator hits like a nuclear weapon. In fact the Drill Sergeant in ME2 ''VideoGame/MassEffect2'' specified that the impact of a 2kg slug from an Everest-class dreadnought releases a third of the energy of the Hiroshima bomb. Orbital bombardment obliterates whole cities; in fact exploration reveals dead worlds which have been subjected to precisely this form of genocide. The Reapers do it to planets they can't be bothered to harvest. BUT here we have Shepard, standing not 50 yards from the Reaper he's targeting for ''the entire Quarian fleet'' -- the impact of whose barrage would have ''vaporized'' Shepard, Tali, the other squadmate, Legion, and everybody and everything else within five miles of Ground Zero. SlapOnTheWristNuke indeed!



* Real answer: rushed development. ME3 was done in a tearing hurry to meet EA's release deadline, and corners had to be cut. Each additional dialogue option starts an exponential chain of responses, each of which then has to be voice-acted and possibly mo-capped or hand-animated (although you may notice that ME3 doesn't bother animating a lot of conversations). In fact, even the apparent binary dialogue choice is often an illusion- the response is the same either way, and in some cases even what Shepard says is the same!

to:

* Real answer: rushed development. ME3 The game was done in a tearing hurry to meet EA's release deadline, and corners had to be cut. Each additional dialogue option starts an exponential chain of responses, each of which then has to be voice-acted and possibly mo-capped or hand-animated (although you may notice that ME3 the game doesn't bother animating a lot of conversations). In fact, even the apparent binary dialogue choice is often an illusion- the response is the same either way, and in some cases even what Shepard says is the same!



** Revisit the Temple with Javik in your party. The asari probably got the idea for male divinities from the protheans. As for why that didn't turn any heads, this information was probably kept hidden by the asari government, same as with the Beacon/Prothean VI hidden in the Athame statue itself.

to:

** Revisit the Temple with Javik in your party. The asari probably got the idea for male divinities from the protheans.Protheans. As for why that didn't turn any heads, this information was probably kept hidden by the asari government, same as with the Beacon/Prothean VI hidden in the Athame statue itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's possible that they were using point-defense and low-powered weaponry instead of their main guns. We know that ME ships do have these weapons for precision targeted bombardment around friendly positions. That would also explain why the Reaper was able to take multiple direct hits from the ship guns while it was in-atmosphere.

to:

*** It's possible that they were using point-defense and low-powered weaponry instead of their main guns. We know that ME ships do have these weapons for precision targeted bombardment around friendly positions. That would also explain why the Reaper was able to take multiple direct hits from the ship guns while it was in-atmosphere. In the cutscene, we specifically only see turret-mounted weapons shooting at the Reaper, which indicates lower-powered broadsidess and not the massive spinal nuclear-grade weapons.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** It's possible that they were using point-defense and low-powered weaponry instead of their main guns. We know that ME ships do have these weapons for precision targeted bombardment around friendly positions. That would also explain why the Reaper was able to take multiple direct hits from the ship guns while it was in-atmosphere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

***The problem with that is that the Quarian fleet is clearly stated to be in orbit above Rannoch, not in the atmosphere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Any ship that enters an atmosphere must devote the majority of its power to atmospheric operations, to the point where they can be seriously damaged by light vehicle portable weaponry. This was established back in ''Revelation'' before the very first game came out. There's a reason why Joker avoids going into areas with anti-air weaponry, and weapons are similarly underpowered due to having to devote so much energy to atmospheric operations. If that Reaper was in orbit, things would be very different.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The codex has established that just one projectile from a dreadnought-scale mass accelerator hits like a nuclear weapon. In fact the Drill Sergeant in ME2 specified that the impact of a 2kg slug from an Everest-class dreadnought releases a third of the energy of the Hiroshima bomb. Orbital bombardment obliterates whole cities; in fact exploration reveals dead worlds which have been subjected to precisely this form of genocide. The Reapers do it to planets they can't be bothered to harvest. BUT here we have Shepard, standing not 50 yards from the Reaper he's targeting for ''the entire Quarian fleet'' -- the impact of whose barrage would have ''vaporized'' Shepard, Tali, the other squadmate, Legion, and everybody and everything else within five miles of Ground Zero. PlotArmor indeed!

to:

* The codex has established that just one projectile from a dreadnought-scale mass accelerator hits like a nuclear weapon. In fact the Drill Sergeant in ME2 specified that the impact of a 2kg slug from an Everest-class dreadnought releases a third of the energy of the Hiroshima bomb. Orbital bombardment obliterates whole cities; in fact exploration reveals dead worlds which have been subjected to precisely this form of genocide. The Reapers do it to planets they can't be bothered to harvest. BUT here we have Shepard, standing not 50 yards from the Reaper he's targeting for ''the entire Quarian fleet'' -- the impact of whose barrage would have ''vaporized'' Shepard, Tali, the other squadmate, Legion, and everybody and everything else within five miles of Ground Zero. PlotArmor SlapOnTheWristNuke indeed!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[folder: Rannoch: Why isn't Shepard dead?]]
*The codex has established that just one projectile from a dreadnought-scale mass accelerator hits like a nuclear weapon. In fact the Drill Sergeant in ME2 specified that the impact of a 2kg slug from an Everest-class dreadnought releases a third of the energy of the Hiroshima bomb. Orbital bombardment obliterates whole cities; in fact exploration reveals dead worlds which have been subjected to precisely this form of genocide. The Reapers do it to planets they can't be bothered to harvest. BUT here we have Shepard, standing not 50 yards from the Reaper he's targeting for ''the entire Quarian fleet'' -- the impact of whose barrage would have ''vaporized'' Shepard, Tali, the other squadmate, Legion, and everybody and everything else within five miles of Ground Zero. PlotArmor indeed!
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*Real answer: rushed development. ME3 was done in a tearing hurry to meet EA's release deadline, and corners had to be cut. Each additional dialogue option starts an exponential chain of responses, each of which then has to be voice-acted and possibly mo-capped or hand-animated (although you may notice that ME3 doesn't bother animating a lot of conversations). In fact, even the apparent binary dialogue choice is often an illusion- the response is the same either way, and in some cases even what Shepard says is the same!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** EDI mentions in a banter with Adams that she was making some experiments with the Reaper IFF trying to disguise herself as a Reaper. In fact, given that she mentions that "Humans are dust in the estelar winds" are no longer enough, means that she already fool a Reaper.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The fact that it's "Artistic licence meant meant to help the player understand what is going on" is further demonstrated by the fact that these videos [[AliensSpeakingEnglish have Javik speaking in [the language your copy of the game is translated into]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Even ''more'' factors: 1)For obvious reasons, evolution is slower in organisms that breed slower, and larger species generally breed slower than smaller ones. The Leviathans are freaking huge. 2)The rate of evolution is also affected by the intensity of environmental pressures. Significantly reduced environmental pressures result in laughably unsurvivable organisms like the dodo. Half the plot of ''Flm/Idiocracy'' is the fact that sapient civilization removes nearly all factors that might thin the herd, so the only traits that get selected for are ones that result in more offspring.

to:

** Even ''more'' factors: 1)For obvious reasons, evolution is slower in organisms that breed slower, and larger species generally breed slower than smaller ones. The Leviathans are freaking huge. 2)The rate of evolution is also affected by the intensity of environmental pressures. Significantly reduced environmental pressures result in laughably unsurvivable organisms like the dodo. Half the plot of ''Flm/Idiocracy'' ''Film/Idiocracy'' is the fact that sapient civilization removes nearly all factors that might thin the herd, so the only traits that get selected for are ones that result in more offspring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Even ''more'' factors: 1)For obvious reasons, evolution is slower in organisms that breed slower, and larger species generally breed slower than smaller ones. The Leviathans are freaking huge. 2)The rate of evolution is also affected by the intensity of environmental pressures. Significantly reduced environmental pressures result in laughably unsurvivable organisms like the dodo. Half the plot of ''Flm/Idiocracy'' is the fact that sapient civilization removes nearly all factors that might thin the herd, so the only traits that get selected for are ones that result in more offspring.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Personally, I put the main story of the DLC as following the retaking of Rannoch and prior to the fall of Thessia - Shepard's crew has been fully assembled by this point, so far, all the major Normandy missions have been victories, everyone's feeling relatively on top of things, plus the Normandy has been in combat, Traynor says some shots from the Reaper on Rannoch put them through their paces... In the whole of the game, this feels like the most appropriate time for the more screwball comedy aspect of the DLC, with all the various meet-ups taking place in between then and the endgame. The party itself, then, becomes something done on the eve of the launch against Chronos Station (or, if you prefer, a celebration of victory done after the endgame).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Guys, the codex entry for banshees says they're made "from asari ''with active or latent predispositions to becoming'' Ardat-Yakshi." Meaning oyu don't have to actually ''be'' an ardat-yakshi to qualify for reaperization, you just have to be a carrier for the pertinent allele. So even if the Codex ''didn't'' say that 1% of Asari are ardat yakshi, that's still a lot more potential future-banshees than just those Asari actually going around literally fucking people to death.

to:

** Guys, the codex entry for banshees says they're made "from asari ''with active or latent predispositions to becoming'' Ardat-Yakshi." Meaning oyu you don't have to actually ''be'' an ardat-yakshi to qualify for reaperization, you just have to be a carrier for the pertinent allele. So even if the Codex ''didn't'' say that 1% of Asari are ardat yakshi, that's still a lot more potential future-banshees than just those Asari actually going around literally fucking people to death.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Guys, the codex entry for banshees says they're made "from asari ''with active or latent predispositions to becoming'' Ardat-Yakshi." Meaning oyu don't have to actually ''be'' an ardat-yakshi to qualify for reaperization, you just have to be a carrier for the pertinent allele. So even if the Codex ''didn't'' say that 1% of Asari are ardat yakshi, that's still a lot more potential future-banshees than just those Asari actually going around literally fucking people to death.

Added: 302

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Just corssed my mind, and maybe I'm overthinking, but think about it for a minute: The clone was simply that - a clone of the original Shepard. He did not undergo extensive surgery and cybernetic augmentation that turned the original Shepard into the SuperSoldier he is since [=ME2=], he would only have Shepard's original body and abilities. Which are formidable, sure, but not on par with the enhanced version.

to:

* Just corssed crossed my mind, and maybe I'm overthinking, but think about it for a minute: The clone was simply that - a clone of the original Shepard. He did not undergo extensive surgery and cybernetic augmentation that turned the original Shepard into the SuperSoldier he is since [=ME2=], he would only have Shepard's original body and abilities. Which are formidable, sure, but not on par with the enhanced version.version.
** The clone wasn't a match for real Shepard, at no point were they ever even implied to be winning and Shepard treats the whole situation as more annoying than anything else. The only reason the fight lasts more than a minute is because Brooks and the merchs keep you from just focussing on the clone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* I can understand that the Citadel DLC is a lighthearted comedy episode that serves as a hillarious and heartwarming farewell to the Normandy crew you come to know and love so the Reaper War going on in-universe isn't the main focus, but in order to get the most out of it (aka all your crew are at the party), you'll have to hold it off until you finished Priority: Horizon, after Miranda saves her sister and deals with her father. After that event, though, Miranda says that she puts a tracker on Kai Leng and tells Shepard to act fast to track him back to the Illusive Man before the trail goes cold. If that's the case, how did Shepard and his crew have the time for all the events in Citadel DLC before going back to their mission? The event of the Citadel DLC took place about two days at the very least (one day dealing with the Shepard Clone, and another day spending time with your crew at the party).It was obvious that the party isn't held on the same day as the clone incident, because Wrex said he had to go back to Tuchanka first and told him to call him again should they decide to hold a party, and your ME2 crew are obviously going to take some time to travel to the Citadel as well. In all that time, Cerberus apparently never found out about the tracer Miranda put on Kai Leng and removes it?

to:

* I can understand that the Citadel DLC is a lighthearted comedy episode that serves as a hillarious and heartwarming farewell to the Normandy crew you come to know and love so the Reaper War going on in-universe isn't the main focus, but in order to get the most out of it (aka all your crew are at the party), you'll have to hold it off until you finished Priority: Horizon, after Miranda saves her sister and deals with her father. After that event, though, Miranda says that she puts a tracker on Kai Leng and tells Shepard to act fast to track him back to the Illusive Man before the trail goes cold. If that's the case, how did Shepard and his crew have the time for all the events in Citadel DLC before going back to their mission? The event of the Citadel DLC took place about two days at the very least (one day dealing with the Shepard Clone, and another day spending time with your crew at the party).It was obvious that the party isn't held on the same day as the clone incident, because Wrex said he had to go back to Tuchanka first and told him to call him again should they decide to hold a party, and your ME2 [=ME2=] crew are obviously going to take some time to travel to the Citadel as well. In all that time, Cerberus apparently never found out about the tracer Miranda put on Kai Leng and removes it?



* Just corssed my mind, and maybe I'm overthinking, but think about it for a minute: The clone was simply that - a clone of the original Shepard. He did not undergo extensive surgery and cybernetic augmentation that turned the original Shepard into the SuperSoldier he is since ME2, he would only have Shepard's original body and abilities. Which are formidable, sure, but not on par with the enhanced version.

to:

* Just corssed my mind, and maybe I'm overthinking, but think about it for a minute: The clone was simply that - a clone of the original Shepard. He did not undergo extensive surgery and cybernetic augmentation that turned the original Shepard into the SuperSoldier he is since ME2, [=ME2=], he would only have Shepard's original body and abilities. Which are formidable, sure, but not on par with the enhanced version.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Their ships are {{Palette Swap}}s of normal human ships of their classes, and Cerberus has Cord-Hislop Aerospace as a front. I speculate they built or acquired normal ships through fronts then upgraded them with Reaper tech when they were ready to come out of hiding.

to:

** Their ships are {{Palette Swap}}s of normal human ships of their classes, and Cerberus has Cord-Hislop Aerospace as a front. I speculate they They could have built or acquired normal ships through fronts then upgraded them with Reaper tech when they were ready to come out of hiding.

Top