History Headscratchers / ClassicDisneyShorts

23rd Apr '17 5:36:41 AM HarpieSiren
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** To come back to the "why", out-of-universe it's because Donald's quacking voice was literally part of his personality, a source of gag, while making all the later characters quack to (then using the same gag) would have seemed redundant. Also, remember that it's because they had a good duck-imitator that they could make Donald quack properly. They most certainly couldn't find enough good quacking actors for all the Duck characters, and it wouldn't have been funny if all of them were dubbed by the same guy. In-universe, maybe it's a genetic matter (perhaps the gene that make ducks quack is recessive; then it was enough than ONE duck in history had a mutation that gave him a normal voice, and then all his children had too). Alternatively, Donald's quacking is just a pronunciation flaw; he COULD speak normally but nobody dared to tell him "you should do something about your voice" because of his well-known temper. Evidence of that: in the short "Donald's dilemma", Donald is psychologically shocked and that makes him speak normally.

to:

** To come back to the "why", out-of-universe it's because Donald's quacking voice was literally part of his personality, a source of gag, while making all the later characters quack to (then using the same gag) would have seemed redundant. Also, remember that it's because they had a good duck-imitator that they could make Donald quack properly. They most certainly couldn't find enough good quacking actors for all the Duck characters, and it wouldn't have been funny if all of them were dubbed by the same guy. In-universe, maybe it's a genetic matter (perhaps the gene that make ducks quack is recessive; then it was enough than ONE duck in history had a mutation that gave him a normal voice, and then all his children had too). Alternatively, Donald's quacking is just a pronunciation flaw; he COULD speak normally but nobody dared to tell him "you should do something about your voice" because of his well-known temper. Evidence of that: in the short "Donald's dilemma", Donald is psychologically shocked and that makes him speak normally.normally.
** It's a speech impediment, simple as that.
17th Nov '16 12:09:26 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I know the Pete Jr. (or PJ) from ''WesternAnimation/{{Goof Troop}}'' originated from the "Bellboy Donald" (1942), Junior just like Max from ''WesternAnimation/{{Goof Troop}}'' originated from the red-headed, "Fathers are People" (1951) Goofy Jr., but the WesternAnimation/{{Goof Troop}}/{{A Goofy Movie}} versions of the two characters don't look much like the original versions. In fact, they look so different from each other that I think the original and modern day versions of both of the characters as separate entities. Even though the original and modern day versions of Mickey, Minnie, Clarabelle, Horace, Donald, and Goofy look pretty different from each other, I still see both versions of those six characters as one entity.

to:

* I know the Pete Jr. (or PJ) from ''WesternAnimation/{{Goof Troop}}'' ''WesternAnimation/GoofTroop'' originated from the "Bellboy Donald" (1942), Junior just like Max from ''WesternAnimation/{{Goof Troop}}'' ''WesternAnimation/GoofTroop'' originated from the red-headed, "Fathers are People" (1951) Goofy Jr., but the WesternAnimation/{{Goof Troop}}/{{A Goofy Movie}} WesternAnimation/GoofTroop[=/=]WesternAnimation/AGoofyMovie versions of the two characters don't look much like the original versions. In fact, they look so different from each other that I think the original and modern day versions of both of the characters as separate entities. Even though the original and modern day versions of Mickey, Minnie, Clarabelle, Horace, Donald, and Goofy look pretty different from each other, I still see both versions of those six characters as one entity.
17th Nov '16 12:06:24 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** The modern day (WesternAnimation/GoofTroop, AGoofyMovie, ''An Extremely Goofy Movie'', and WesternAnimation/HouseOfMouse) Max has black hair, a black nose, looks more like his dad, Goofy, has longer ears than the original version, and is less earnest and humble but more "normal" than his dad.

to:

*** The modern day (WesternAnimation/GoofTroop, AGoofyMovie, WesternAnimation/AGoofyMovie, ''An Extremely Goofy Movie'', and WesternAnimation/HouseOfMouse) Max has black hair, a black nose, looks more like his dad, Goofy, has longer ears than the original version, and is less earnest and humble but more "normal" than his dad.
17th Nov '16 12:03:15 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** The modern day (WesternAnimation/GoofTroop, AGoofyMovie, and ''An Extremely Goofy Movie'') Pete jr., better known as PJ, is overweight like his dad, has a double chin, has small ears like his dad, is shy, and is a loyal friend to Max.

to:

*** The modern day (WesternAnimation/GoofTroop, AGoofyMovie, WesternAnimation/AGoofyMovie, and ''An Extremely Goofy Movie'') Pete jr., better known as PJ, is overweight like his dad, has a double chin, has small ears like his dad, is shy, and is a loyal friend to Max.
5th Nov '16 9:38:36 AM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** And according to ''HouseofMouse'', [[Disney/TheAristocats Abagail and Amelia Gabble]] (both geese) are also Donald's cousins.
* Not exactly orginal, but how come Goofy's a dog (supposedly) and gets to live in a house, have a job, talk, etc. while Pluto is a pet that lives like and acts like...well a pet dog; he doesn't talk, have a job, or have any human-like freedoms.

to:

** And according to ''HouseofMouse'', ''WesternAnimation/HouseofMouse'', [[Disney/TheAristocats Abagail and Amelia Gabble]] (both geese) are also Donald's cousins.
* Not exactly orginal, original, but how come Goofy's a dog (supposedly) and gets to live in a house, have a job, talk, etc. while Pluto is a pet that lives like and acts like...well a pet dog; he doesn't talk, have a job, or have any human-like freedoms.



*** The modern day (WesternAnimation/GoofTroop, AGoofyMovie, ''An Extremely Goofy Movie'', and HouseOfMouse) Max has black hair, a black nose, looks more like his dad, Goofy, has longer ears than the original version, and is less earnest and humble but more "normal" than his dad.

to:

*** The modern day (WesternAnimation/GoofTroop, AGoofyMovie, ''An Extremely Goofy Movie'', and HouseOfMouse) WesternAnimation/HouseOfMouse) Max has black hair, a black nose, looks more like his dad, Goofy, has longer ears than the original version, and is less earnest and humble but more "normal" than his dad.



** To come back to the "why", out-of-universe it's because Donald's quacking voice was literally part of his personality, a source of gag, while making all the later characters quack to (then using the same gag) would have seemed redundant. Also, remember that it's because they had a good duck-imitator that they could make Donald quack properly. They most certainly couldn't find enough good quacking actors for all the Duck characters, and it wouldn't have been funny if all of them were dubbed by the same guy. In-universe, maybe it's a genetic matter (perhaps the gene that make ducks quack is recessive; then it was enough than ONE duck in history had a mutation that gave him a normal voice, and then all his children had too). Alternatively, Donald's quacking is just a pronunciation flaw; he COULD speak normally but nobody dared to tell him "you should do something about your voice" because of his well-known temper. Evidence of that: in the short "Donald's dilemma", Donald is psychologically shocked and that makes him speak normally.

to:

** To come back to the "why", out-of-universe it's because Donald's quacking voice was literally part of his personality, a source of gag, while making all the later characters quack to (then using the same gag) would have seemed redundant. Also, remember that it's because they had a good duck-imitator that they could make Donald quack properly. They most certainly couldn't find enough good quacking actors for all the Duck characters, and it wouldn't have been funny if all of them were dubbed by the same guy. In-universe, maybe it's a genetic matter (perhaps the gene that make ducks quack is recessive; then it was enough than ONE duck in history had a mutation that gave him a normal voice, and then all his children had too). Alternatively, Donald's quacking is just a pronunciation flaw; he COULD speak normally but nobody dared to tell him "you should do something about your voice" because of his well-known temper. Evidence of that: in the short "Donald's dilemma", Donald is psychologically shocked and that makes him speak normally.
6th Jun '15 1:57:35 PM ScroogeMacDuck
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I can't believe no one has ever asked this: OK, in the Disney universe there are lots of ducks, most of them from Donald's family tree: There's Daisy, there's Huey, Dewey and Louie, there's Scrooge, there's also Joe McQuack, Darkwing Duck, Gozalin... Then why in the World is Donald the only duck in Disney universe that quacks?

to:


* I can't believe no one has ever asked this: OK, in the Disney universe there are lots of ducks, most of them from Donald's family tree: There's Daisy, there's Huey, Dewey and Louie, there's Scrooge, there's also Joe McQuack, Darkwing Duck, Gozalin... Then why in the World is Donald the only duck in Disney universe that quacks?quacks?
**That's indeed weird that most of the ducks don't quack in that universe. However, you can't say NO other one.
***First, there are the characters who actually quacked at some point, despite it was changed in their later appearances on TV: Huey, Dewey and Louie quacked in their first cartoons, that was just changed in Ducktales for some odd reason. Same for Daisy Duck, if you look at her first cartoon "Mr Duck steps out" she talks in quacking-voice. We have also Gus Goose, who… Well I can't say he quacks per say, but as a goose he honks, which is the same basic idea (doing his specie's normal sound).
***Then, there's a BUNCH of comic-only characters whose voice remains unknown. We may very well assume that Mrs Quackfaster or Fethry Duck quack, after all.
**To come back to the "why", out-of-universe it's because Donald's quacking voice was literally part of his personality, a source of gag, while making all the later characters quack to (then using the same gag) would have seemed redundant. Also, remember that it's because they had a good duck-imitator that they could make Donald quack properly. They most certainly couldn't find enough good quacking actors for all the Duck characters, and it wouldn't have been funny if all of them were dubbed by the same guy. In-universe, maybe it's a genetic matter (perhaps the gene that make ducks quack is recessive; then it was enough than ONE duck in history had a mutation that gave him a normal voice, and then all his children had too). Alternatively, Donald's quacking is just a pronunciation flaw; he COULD speak normally but nobody dared to tell him "you should do something about your voice" because of his well-known temper. Evidence of that: in the short "Donald's dilemma", Donald is psychologically shocked and that makes him speak normally.
16th Jul '14 6:51:43 PM JamesSwann
Is there an issue? Send a Message




to:

\n*** Or, perhaps, as Mickey's dog, Pluto has taken it upon himself to protect Mickey. By sleeping outside, he can see everything and thus protect Mickey better.

11th May '14 12:27:33 PM LongLiveHumour
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** How about the fact during WorldWarII, the studio had a cartoon series where Donald joins the Army as a trooper. Wouldn't having him in the US Navy or at least as a Marine have been more logical for a duck?

to:

** How about the fact during WorldWarII, UsefulNotes/WorldWarII, the studio had a cartoon series where Donald joins the Army as a trooper. Wouldn't having him in the US Navy or at least as a Marine have been more logical for a duck?
12th Apr '14 10:37:15 PM PPPSSC
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* I can't believe no one has ever asked this: OK, in the Disney universe there are lots of ducks, most of them from Donald's family tree: There's Daisy, there's Huey, Dewey and Louie, there's Scrooge, there's also Joe McQuack, Darkwing Duck, Gozalin... Then why in the World is Donald the only duck in Disney universe that quacks?
* OK, here's the mother of all Disney's headscratchers: If Goofy and Pluto are both dogs, they why does Goofy talk, walk over two legs, wear clothes and lives in a house while Pluto barks, walks over four legs, doesn't wear clothes and lives in a doghouse?

to:

* I can't believe no one has ever asked this: OK, in the Disney universe there are lots of ducks, most of them from Donald's family tree: There's Daisy, there's Huey, Dewey and Louie, there's Scrooge, there's also Joe McQuack, Darkwing Duck, Gozalin... Then why in the World is Donald the only duck in Disney universe that quacks?
* OK, here's the mother of all Disney's headscratchers: If Goofy and Pluto are both dogs, they why does Goofy talk, walk over two legs, wear clothes and lives in a house while Pluto barks, walks over four legs, doesn't wear clothes and lives in a doghouse?
quacks?
25th Jan '14 9:40:00 PM nombretomado
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* How can Donald ''Duck'' have Gus ''Goose'' as a cousin? And the extended DonRosa [=McDuck=] family tree also includes coots, which aren't even in the Anseriformes (duck/goose) family.

to:

* How can Donald ''Duck'' have Gus ''Goose'' as a cousin? And the extended DonRosa Creator/DonRosa [=McDuck=] family tree also includes coots, which aren't even in the Anseriformes (duck/goose) family.
This list shows the last 10 events of 44. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=Headscratchers.ClassicDisneyShorts