History FridgeHorror / MylittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic

* During the episode Discord reveals that although he has been immobile for the last 1000 years he was still conscious and able to hear what others were saying around him, it make you wonder what toll it took on his personality.

* During the episode Discord reveals that although he has been immobile for the last 1000 years he was still conscious and able to hear what other people were saying around him, it make you wonder what toll it took on his personality.

* This is actually FridgeHorror about the fandom: I can't help but notice that a lot of the fanon and fanwork that has sprung up around this show assumes the existence of a lot of bullying and other assorted cruelty in Equestria. There are fans that seem to believe that Twilight was bullied as a child, that Derpy was possibly abused and abandoned as a child by one or both parents, or that Derpy was bullied and tormented as a child and as an adult for being different, that Pinkie Pie's differences are the result of past trauma, etc., etc. This is despite the all the overt evidence that Equestria, in Chrysalis' words, is "full of love," that the ponies are, as a rule, kind, generous, and accepting, and that bullying and cruelty are rare exceptions, and not at all the norm. So it seems to me that a lot of fans are projecting their own experiences of life in our world onto Equestria.

*** You sure you wanna put that kind of faith in [[http://www.deviantart.com/download/210445217/trollbox_by_blackfeathr-d3hakkh.png Ponyville's mail service.]]

** Though it is sad, it has the unintended consequence of him not giving into his inherent greed (as seen in the episode) so, so far the on thing that's stopped there being another fully grown dragon was Twilight's social ineptness.

* How much do Elements of Harmony bearers qualifty for their Elements if "New Fluttershy" is technically still the bearer of the Element of Kindness? Is "Old Fluttershy" really that kind or is she actually a BitchInSheepsClothing and the Elements can't distinguish this because they're simply magical inanimate objects?

FridgeHorror for WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic.
----

* The exterior of Rarity's house is supposed to look like a carousel, complete with artificial horses with rods going through where their ribcages would be. In universe, this should be ''NightmareFuel''

* [[TheBigLebowski My Little Lebowski]] becomes NightmareFuel when you realize that the Cutie Mark Crusaders, along with a number of other young'uns, are in the same bowling alley as a stallion who is likely a foal-mounter. As if there weren't enough AdultFear in the episode already.

* On a different tangent. What the hell was that [[AccidentalNightmareFuel horrifying]] [[http://imgur.com/eBd2p balloon Dash]] in the [=CMC=] clubhouse all about?

* [[FridgeLogic Some have noticed]] that if the [=CMCs=] wanted to nullify the effects of the poison, they could've just waited for both Big Mac and Cheerilee to fall asleep. However...[[NightmareFuel what if it prevented them from falling asleep?]] There are nasty health-related implications behind this, much like with the Cutie Pox.

* In 'Putting Your Hoof Down', Fluttershy uses the [[BodyHorror feathers of her wings as if they were fingers to open her saddlebag]]. While this is creepy, FridgeBrilliance steps in with an X-ray from 'Read it and Weep' of Dash's broken wing, which shows that wings have bones where there would normally be just delicate feathers. Knowing that Pegasi have bones in some of their feathers, the FridgeHorror comes when you consider 'Hearts and Hooves Day', where one of Scootaloo's feathers are yanked out without warning to make a potion. [[NightmareFuel What if Sweetie Belle pulled]] [[BodyHorror the wrong feather]]?

** "Alicorn" is not a fandom nod. Not EVERYTHING is a fandom nod. Sheesh. Edited for correctness.
** Sweet Celestia! That's a great fan fic idea!

** Not just any date rape drug, '''''the''' perfect date rape drug''. It's dirt cheap (you can find the ingredients by looking out your window), can be made in your living room in less than a minute, instantly brainwashes the victim into ''absolute mind slavery'', lasts exactly as long as the rapist wants it to, leaves no marks, and the victim doesn't remember a single thing...

[[AC: MMMystery on the Friendship Express]]

** My theory (to make it all less creepy) is this potion doesn't work onesided. So if it was only Cherilee who drank it she wouldn't fall in love with Big Mac. Wich means you can't give someone Love Poison to make them love you unless you drink it yourself and fall for them as well. Also judging by Cherilee's and Big Mac's behaviour the potion is more about platonic love rather than sexual. Those two couldn't stop looking each other in the eyes but they didn't even kiss.

** From this episode on, no matter what happens, for the entire run of the show, there will be a quiet, nagging suspicion in the back of your mind that Pinkie Pie is no longer the real Pinkie Pie.

%% Please don't bother to "explain" or "justify" any moments because they are subjective opinions and can't be justified.

%% Don't use "I", "me" or "this troper" either.

*** Pinkie Pie having Dissociative Identity Disorder might have already happened, depending on if you view her depressed side [[FanNickname "Pinkamena"]] as a seperate personality or not.

** Pinkie Pie's also a bit of a fridge TearJerker: It's likely that she doesn't constantly throw parties just because she likes them. It's because she knows everyone ''else'' likes them, and it's the only way she knows to be sociable on a normal level. The GenkiGirl randomness that she's known for is too much for most folks, who've probably actively avoided her for it in the past. But if she throws a party, suddenly everyone likes her, and she clings to that. So it's parties forever, and nothing else. Because if she stops, she stops being "That eccentric girl who throws awesome parties all the time" and reverts to "That annoying girl who talks too quickly about things that don't make sense." And then she's all alone. Again.
** In the season 2 episode "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E3LessonZero Lesson Zero]]", Twilight's [[SanitySlippage behavior]] in the episode becomes all the more horrifying given the fact that the previous episode had them dealing with Discord. Maybe his MoreThanMindControl of the ponies had some lasting effects...

* In "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E10SecretOfMyExcess Secret of my Excess]]", Spike says he's only been given one present each year for his birthday--a gift from Twilight. But in the ''first episode'', he is seen with a present intended for Moon Dancer. So he's been giving all these gifts, but he's never received any for himself. Poor guy.

* With the way Pinkie Pie eats, had she been a real horse, she should have died several times already. Especially after eating the "baked bads".

** The creators had Spike eat gems to get around the "eating ponies" problem. [[DoubleSubversion Instead]], they changed "dragons eating everything not tied down" to "dragons ''[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS2E10SecretOfMyExcess stealing]]'' everything tied not tied down (and even most things that are)".

** "The Cutie Pox" could be counted as 5/6 if you take the whole StoryOfTheBlanks similarities and potential death by exhaustion or dangerous cutie marks into account. But even if you don't count it, you could still say that Season 2 has half as many episodes of Nightmare Fuel so far as Season 1 did, and the Season is only a forth of the way over. As for overthinking everything, we're tropers, it's a natural thing.

** Humans feed their pets things we wouldn't eat ourselves all the time, so why should ponies be different in that respect? Just because [[HerbivoresAreFriendly herbivores are supposed to be "friendly"]]?

* The whole "Spike loves Rarity" subplot is kind of weird, and not just because he's a baby (although seeing how he matures by hoarding, there's probably some funky genetic loophole going on there). There's been griffins on the show, sure, but how exactly would a canon dragon-pony relationship work out? Could they have children? Then it hit me: We've ''seen'' a dragon/equine hybrid already. A dracon-equus: ''Discord''.

*** I think people put too much emphasis on the words "special talent". Characters have capabilities that aren't purely based on their talents. Twilight, despite having the talent "magic" works as a librarian instead of a court mage, and has a lot of skills in organizing others. Just because something is their "talent" doesn't mean they are irrevocably shackled to said talent.

*** Not to mention, she has the support and backing of one of the most influential ponies in Canterlot - Fancy Pants, whom more than likely considers Rarity a good friend. That connection and support alone really boosted her standing in Canterlot society in "Sweet and Elite".

* This is actually FridgeHorror about the fandom: I can't help but notice that a lot of the fanon and fanwork that has sprung up around this show assumes the existence of a lot of bullying and other assorted cruelty in Equestria. There are fans that seem to believe that Twilight was bullied as a child, that Derpy was possibly abused and abandoned as a child by one or both parents, or that Derpy was bullied and tormented as a child and as an adult for being different, that Pinkie Pie's differences are the result of past trauma, etc., etc. This is despite the all the overt evidence that Equestria, in Chrysalis' words, is "full of love," that the ponies are, as a rule, kind, generous, and accepting, and that bullying and cruelty are rare exceptions, and not at all the norm. So it seems to me that a lot of fans are projecting their own experiences of life in our world onto Equestria.

[[AC: Mare in the Moon & The Elements of Harmony]]

* When Twi teleports herself and Spike to the library, Spike comes out singed. This doesn't seem like a big deal, but then he mentions in "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E5GriffonTheBrushOff Griffon the Brush Off]]" that dragons are fireproof. If Twilight's teleport was enough to singe a fireproof dragon, imagine what would have happened if it had been a pony (or any other non-fireproof creature)!

* Throughout the episode, Twilight implores Applejack to accept her friends' help in harvesting the bumper crop that was wearing her out, and when Applejack finally accepts, we see Rainbow and Pinkie working together on one tree, Fluttershy on another, Rarity hauling full bushels, and Twilight...harvesting ''half the orchard by herself in seconds'' with her magic. Clearly, the involvement of the others was just a fig leaf. What Twilight really meant was 'let me use my magical powers to do this for you, effortlessly.' Think about that: what for an earth pony like Applejack is the work of her lifetime is to a powerful unicorn like Twilight nothing more than a minor nuisance. For that matter, is Granny Smith's "saggy old hip" the result of old age alone, or the result of age and a lifetime spent bucking apple trees? Now think about why Applejack was so reluctant to accept Twilight's help, and why Applejack was so upset that Twilight used magic a few months later in "Winter Wrap-Up," or why the earth ponies insist that in an earth-pony town, no magic is to be used to wrap up winter. Now, it has been implied that earth ponies get superior strength and endurance to compensate for not having magic or the ability to fly, but imagine if some people were born with the ability to use magic, some people were born with the ability to fly, but you were born an ordinary human being without any such abilities. Mightn't you have a chip on your shoulder, and always seek to prove that you were just as capable as any other person, even without magic or wings? Don't forget, we're seeing them ''harvesting'' the apples at that point. Who put in the work to ''grow'' them?
** Unicorns and Earth Ponies are a lot more balanced than you might think. In the occurrence it's not ''magic'' itself that is overpowered, it's ''Twilight''. Most unicorns would not have been able to harvest the apples with any less effort than Applejack, but [[StoryBreakerPower Twilight Sparkle is not "most unicorns"]]. There's a reason she's been compared to [[{{Watchmen}} Doctor Manhattan]] at times.

** FridgeLogic: if gryphons hate ponies, why would Gilda's "mate" be Rainbow Dash?

** Maybe, but I interpret it like this: laughing only makes the ''fear'' disappear; what happened within the song aside, the "faces" in the tree remained, scary to all except the one who had a trick for dealing with fear. And once she taught it to the others, they could all see the "faces" for what they were: harmless holes in trees.

* In "Boast Busters", the Ursa Minor destroys Trixie's stagecoach. This is made even worse by the fact that Trixie is a travelling performer, so that coach was also her home. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Great job, Snips and Snails, you just made your former idol into a beggar.]]

* In "Bridle Gossip", due to Rainbow Dash's flower-induced inability to fly straight, Spike calls her "Rainbow Crash". Later in the series, we learn that this was the cruel nickname she was saddled with by a group of pegasus bullies when she dropped out of flight school. Nice going, [[JerkAss Spike]].

* The ending of "Winter Wrap-Up" has Spike left asleep on a chunk of ice floating on the water. The other ponies, instead of HELPING him, just joke about how Spike is "in for a big surprise as soon as that there ice melts" and then ''laugh''. Sure, Spike gets better, but he was ''wearing a towel and shivering'', implying that the ponies let him fall in, continued to laugh as he was (presumably) thrashing around screaming for help, and then said, "Ok, we can help him now." Would if Spike drowned or died of hypothermia?! Would it be so funny then, [[{{Jerkass}} ponies]]?

* Applejack's outfit includes what seems to be a pair of ''leather'' cowboy boots. But in "[[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E4ApplebuckSeason Applebuck Season]]", we see that cows in Equestria are also sentient, talking beings. Wonder how ''that'' conversation went over?
---> '''Rarity:''' Excuse me, sir! Might you be Moorice?\\

'''Rarity:''' Could you do me a teensy tiny, itty bitty favor aaaand..." *STAB*

* From the Aesop of "Suited for Success": "In other words, you shouldn't look a gift horse in the mouth." So slavery is legal in Equestria?

* Rainbow and Rarity have to perform at the same time. Normally you'd think "how do they not have time for everyone in their own competition?" but what would have happened if they had gone at different times? Rarity would have plummeted while Dash was cowering in the lobby, would have knocked out the Wonderbolts and they all would have fallen to their death while [[ApatheticCitizens everyone else would have sat back and watched them die.]]

* In "Stare Master", when Fluttershy is chasing the girls chasing her escaped chicken through the Everfree Forest (which most of the ponies generally avoid if they can help it) they run across Twilight Sparkle [[TakenForGranite after her encounter with a cockatrice]]. The FridgeHorror kicks in when you realize that Twilight may have been there a very, very long time if Fluttershy's chicken hadn't escaped.

* FridgeHorror in "The Show Stoppers" episode (and possibly others): The ponies are raising pigs. Why, so that they can eat them? What would a pony want with a pig if not to eat its flesh as humans do.

* When Sweetie Belle says "Break a leg" to the other ponies, Apple Bloom responds with "Sweetie Belle! What a thing to say!" Sweetie Belle knows the phrase means "good luck" and so do we the viewers, but since horses with broken legs are often put down because of how hard it is to rehabilitate and the likelihood of breaking again, Apple Bloom probably thought she was telling the other performers to '''go ahead and die'''.
** In "Read it and Weep", the hospital has facilities for broken limbs. While broken legs might be more serious in Equestria, it's not an automatic cause for euthanasia.

* "Over a Barrel" establishes that pies can be used as weapons are are thrown during combat. In the next episode, "A Bird in the Hoof", Pinkie throws a pie at her own head. Did... did Pinkie just shoot herself in the face? [[CrazyAwesome Yes.]]

* Fluttershy mentions that she was at flight camp with Dash in her flashback, despite looking older then the other ponies there, so presumably her parents sent her there as a drastic measure to improve her flying capacity...and instead, Fluttershy plummeted to the earth and discovered her talent for communicating with animals. If she hadn't have fallen to the ground, would she have ''never'' found her cutie-mark, or would she have actually become a good flier? In "Hurricane Fluttershy", she does improve with a little training, but it's still pretty weak compared to the other Pegasi. This has a little FridgeHorror for Scootaloo- Is this going to be Scootaloo's fate as well, bearing in mind that other fillies her age have been shown flying (specifically Thunder Lane's little brother in "Hurricane Fluttershy") Fluttershy almost ''is'' an Earth pony anyway, not being a good flier and having a talent that is very unusual for a pegasus, so it probably doesn't concern her, but Scootaloo is a much more active, energetic character who idolises Rainbow Dash, the fastest pony around. Is Scootaloo doomed to an earthbound existence, and if so, will she never get a cutiemark or be forced to developing a pedestrian skill to make a living in Ponyville?

* As Spike is going around town to find a quill for Twilight, he goes over to Pinkie Pie, who among the list of items that begin with a "Q", tosses him a quince. A quince is a fruit that is poisonous to equines (aka PONIES).

** If you look at the attitudes some of the other Mane Five have towards Pinkie, it can leave you with doubts. Twilight in particular is often very condescending to Pinkie Pie and in "Feeling Pinkie Keen" she sounded almost like she was ''relishing'' the idea of Pinkie being humiliated. Applejack frequently brushes her off, and in "Swarm of the Century" dismisses her as being "A few apples short of a bushel." Fluttershy would later tear her to shreds (along with Rarity) in "Putting Your Hoof Down", and it's not unfeasible to think Rarity might be annoyed with how many horrible things seem to happen to her when Pinkie's around ("Return of Harmony Part 2", "The Last Roundup".) Dash is the only one who seems to genuinely bond with Pinkie over being a fellow prankster, and even she is pretty rude towards her on occasion (but then, at least you can't argue that Pinkie is the only one of Dash's friends to get this treatment). If you think as well that Twilight is the "Hero", Applejack is her "second-in-command", Rainbow Dash is TheLancer, Rarity is TheChick, Fluttershy is TheHeart, and Spike is the TagalongKid, where does that leave poor Pinkie Pie? Is she the ''de facto'' Omega of the group who only manages it because of her positive outlook and SarcasmBlind nature? And, as this episode suggests, is she aware of this or is she one hell of a StepfordSmiler?

* As someone said on ponibooru, ''Party Of One'' suggests Pinkie's codependent with her friends and needs their love and attention... to the point that her parties are almost like attempts at validation. "People love me! Because they come to my parties! PLEASE, PLEASE come to my parties!"

** "All you have to do is take a cup of flour, add it to the mix..."
*** She was insane by that point. She uses flour to entertain the babies in "Baby Cakes," though. [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fSIzmYm-28w And]], [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CgF0x-g_xAk&t=0m24s well]]...

** The groundskeeper looked more like a donkey or mule than a pony, similar to Cranky Doodle Donkey and Matilda from "A Friend in Deed", neither of whom have cutie marks either.

*** The point of mentioning the worshiping aspect is to emphasize that she is the ultimate [[ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem secular authority]], [[ScrewTheRulesIHaveSupernaturalPowers the ultimate religious authority]], and [[HundredPercentAdorationRating people just plain like her]]. She does not "have to" attend. She could probably have the bloody thing cancelled, or remove herself from any obligation to attend (or at least, having to greet everyone) and ponies would be tripping over themselves to accommodate her. Instead, she lets her friends ruin things for hundreds of ponies who don't know she has a problem because she doesn't mention a damn thing to anyone except her friends. Basically imagine if you found out the ruler of the land, whom you love, respect, and depend upon holds you in complete contempt, will let her friends run roughshod over you, and wouldn't even tell you she had a problem.

[[AC: The Return of Harmony, Parts 1 & 2]]
* The season 2 opener gives a little piece in the form of one of Discord's lines directed at Princess Celestia: "It's quite lonely being encased in stone, but you wouldn't know that ''because I don't turn ponies into stone!''"

** Phoenixes have a species name, and we in RealLife (at least where English is spoken) say "phoenixes" these days at least as often as we say "the phoenix", if not far more. Alternately, all that might mean is that Discord is to Draconequii what Hitler was to emo art students who flunked their entrance exam- Much more powerful, and certainly not lumped in with the others, but still technically part of that class.
* Discord created a "game" for the Mane Six to locate the Elements of Harmony, and Twilight Sparkle took it to mean in the Canterlot Hedge maze, which Discord took advantage of to corrupt them. In reality, the Elements were safely at Twilight's home in Ponyville... but suppose she ''had'' figured out the correct answer... how do we know Discord wouldn't have corrupted them there anyway?!

** Everyone gives certain "tells" when they're lying from facial expressions to tone of voice. Applejack is just a really bad liar.

* Another example of a Fridge TearJerker: The scene where Twilight is trying to find the book about the Elements of Harmony, but her friends keep interfering her due to their corruption. It is, in a way, a rather accurate portrayal of bullying: what bully victim ''wouldn't'' relate to Twilight, whose own friends are bothering her for absolutely no reason? Who wouldn't be in a completely irritated mood, and on the verge of giving up? And think from the other ponies' perspective, the ''bullies''' perspective. One day, you might be friends, possibly best friends with someone, but out of some internal and/or external force (think peer pressure and insecurity instead of MindRape), you find yourself to be the very person you hated. Then you start bullying your former friends; and it doesn't help that bully victims are often socially awkward "nerds" like Twilight. Fluttershy's reaction after being restored pretty much confirms this.

* While a lot of people consider Discord to be "evil" due to his MindRape and BreakTheCutie tendencies, when you think about it, being the "Spirit Of Chaos", he most likely has [[BlueAndOrangeMorality no sense of "good" and "evil" (or at least not one that's the same as ours or the ponies')]]. This actually makes him ''more'' terrifying than if he were straight-up evil. Think about it. To him, causing all this mayhem, destruction, and insanity is a ''good'' thing to him. Rather than being outright malevolent, he's playful (well, as playful as a psychotic reality-warping god can get) towards the ponies much like a prankster child is to the people he tricks. He thinks ''everything'' is a game (hence why he gloats when he thinks he's won) without realizing/caring that he's hurting others. Imagine being an "ant" being at the mercy of a bored child and you'll get why Discord is more terrifying being "chaos" rather than just being "evil".

* Twilight Sparkle's SanitySlippage fits in context of the episode of "Lesson Zero". [[http://knowyourmeme.com/photos/186252 Out of context]], however....
* "Want-It Need-It spell, works every time".

* At the end of "Lesson Zero" Princess Celestia declares that the Mane Six must start sending in friendship reports whenever they discover them so that Twilight isn't punished, essentially placing them in an open-ended contract with no specificities, agreements between parties, or terms over what qualifies as a friendship report leaving plenty of room for Celestia to change it as she chooses, such as establishing a report quota, a required length, declaring what the punishment for not sending in friendship reports would be, or just all out declaring the invalidity of lessons learned in friendship reports. And we don't even know what Twilight's punishment was going to be, the Mane Six could have just entered a [[IncrediblyLamePun Faustian]] bargain to prevent a punishment to Twilight that could have been disproportionately better than them spending the rest of their lives filling friendship reports for Celestia.

* Twilight's SanitySlippage in "Lesson Zero" ''really'' starts after her friends make light of her problem and even laugh at it a bit. Now remember what their "Discorded" selves did to her in "Return Of Harmony, Part 2" and [[BreakTheCutie what that]] [[DespairEventHorizon did to]] [[HeroicBSOD poor Twilight]]. Imagine how it felt to an already ''very'' frustraited Twilight to have her friends laughing to her again after that and their innocent joking seems a ''lot'' less innocent.

*** In her "BBBFF" song, though, she says outright that she thought friendship was "silly", so maybe she just wasn't even all that interested in friendship? It would explain her line in the pilot, when she says saving Equestria does not revolve around her making friends.

* "Sisterhooves Social", when Apple Bloom covers Applejack in smashed up grapes, Sweetie Belle's reaction is to panic and beg Applejack not to punish her. That almost comes off looking like the reaction of a child in an abusive home.

* When Twilight looks up the cure, she says that the disease disappears as mysteriously as it arrived. The Cutie Pox creates a random cutie mark and the infected is forced to perform the talent related to it and as Apple Bloom shows us, it can be anything to be able to perform tricks with a "Loopty Hoop" to speaking French to being a proficient fencer and no one is able to stop her. That is already frightening enough that Apple Bloom can't stop, but what happens if a more deadly Cutie Mark shows up? One that involves hurting possibly even killing the ponies around her? ''She'd be forced to perform '''THAT''' talent against her will!'' To add to that, why does the disease disappear as mysteriously as it arrived? If the above FridgeHorror is true, then no pony would be left to tell the tale if it does get that deadly. That or the ponies would be forced to kill the infected before it gets to that point.

** The Cutie Pox is very similar to a disease called "The Dancing Fever". If you think humans can't get infected by a disease that eventually kills you from exhaustion, think again. More information about it can be found on TheOtherWiki [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dancing_Plague_of_1518 here]].

* Rainbow Dash names her new pet tortoise Tank, because he's "built like a tank." You know, not the container for fluids, the armored vehicle. Although this is a good name, it implies the existence of mechanized warfare in Equestria.

** Her personality isn't based just around being a great flyer, it's about just being generally great. She's highly competitive when it comes to pretty much everything, even board games. As such, she'd probably take quite well to being a CoolOldLady who is looked up to by younger ponies. No doubt she'd have lots of cool stories to tell. Think Granny Smith's presentation in the school, but even more awesome (and with a few embellishments; this ''is'' RD we're talking about). "...and I saved the world from eternal night, and I kicked a dragon in the face, and I saved the Wonderbolts, and I defeated the spirit of chaos, and I fought off an army of changelings..."

* Where the ''[[NoOSHACompliance HELL]]'' was the Pony equivalent of OSHA? Seriously, so many disasters, so many crumbling/damaged structures, why has the town not been condemned yet? Couple this with the obviously crumbling city hall in "The Last Roundup," and Ponyville really starts to look ramshackle and unsafe. How many ponies have been hurt or killed due to structural damage?

** Coupling these troubled signs with how Sweetie Belle reacts to Applejack and Apple Bloom about to fight and the whole "it doesn't have to be physical to be abuse" mantra...One has to wonder if they're parents are really as nice as they seem. There could be a very good reason why Sweetie is living with her big sister instead of their parents.

** Spike has shown to have different "adult" forms though, one being [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E23TheCutieMarkChronicles magically induced]] and the other part of an [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E19ADogAndPonyShow imagine spot]]. There's no guarantee his natural adult self will be the same as this greedy version. As long as they help quell his hoarding tendencies, one would expect his growth to be more manageable.

** Ponyville generally falls somewhere between CrazyPrepared and ProperlyParanoid in terms of handling emergencies. But maybe it was installed during the fifties, it would explain the cute lil' hazmat suits from "The Cutie Pox".

** That water tower thing has a hole in the "funnel". When Twilight used it to hold milk to feed to the Ursa Minor, it had no problem sucking out of it like a baby bottle. Presumably, she didn't have to uncap it for this.

** Although that seems highly unlikely coming from this kind of series, it does bring up some unsettling AdultFear: Since Pumpkin can walk through the basket using her magic, what's going to stop her from getting into something ''dangerous''? Like the Drain-O in the sink cabinet, the deadly sharp silverware in the kitchen drawer, [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking or the stash of "Equestria After Dark" magazines Mr. Cake hides in his closet?]]

** Another thing is that Pound Cake is ''one month old'' and he can already fly to the point that he can speed around a house while carrying a pony several times his size and weight. If this is just a fraction of what he'll be able to do, he might be outdoing Rainbow Dash when he's older. If Baby Dashie had to have her wings tied, ask yourself: What's faster than a sonic rainboom? Now apply that to Pound Cake. Now factor in Pound Cake's name. He already likes to "pound" things. Sooner or later, he's going to figure out that faster speeds equal harder pounding on things. Here's to hoping he never thinks to try '''pounding the ground at supersonic speed.'''
* At the end of "Baby Cakes", neither twin has a diaper on before the go to sleep. It's more than likely they'll "make lemonade" [[WesternAnimation/AdventureTime or "boom-boom"]] not too long after.
* When Pinkie is looking for Pound Cake about halfway through the episode, the house is dark and the only sound other than Pinkie is Pumpkin Cake with the rubber chicken. The window is also open. Suddenly Pinkie hears a whispered "Pinkie..." followed by laughter. It's frightening because she can't see that Pound Cake is flying above her, and up until that moment neither of the twins had ever spoken before. So to her there's an [[TheCallsAreComingFromInsideTheHouse unknown disembodied voice]] of an intruder in a dark house whispering her name and laughing while she frantically searches for a missing child.

** It's possible the races never, or rarely mixed before then, as they loathed each other. Since Mr. Cake explained that there were unicorns and pegasi in his family tree (or both his and Mrs. Cake's?), thus providing the possibility that the genes needed to be present to allow for it to even happen. Not to mention, any pony not fitting the society may have just been cast out to live in the "proper" society.

** Very doubtful. Perhaps back in the old days before Equestria was founded this could be a problem but in the SugarBowl that is modern Equestria this kind of pony "racism" would be absurd. An earth pony would be able to live among unicorns without any problem (remember that Canterlot - the most high class city shown - has plenty of earth ponies in high positions). For an non-pegasus born in Cloudsdale, there may be creative solutions we haven't seen. Or maybe in such an instance the parents would simply move to a different town - a normal sacrifice loving parents are expected to make in such a situation. [[ThreeHundred That or they just simply chuck the babies down to the earth below]].

** Since Sweetie Belle can't use magic while Pumpkin Cake clearly can, it's implied Pound Cake is having a "pegasus magic" spurt, and will lose his flight after about a year and then regain it during, say, tail end of puberty. After all, Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash were admitted to Flight Camp at an age where Fluttershy is clearly having a growth spurt.

* Also in "Hearth's Warming Eve", the main antagonists are Windigos. Traditionally, Windigos are the spirit of Cannibalism from the Native American Algonquian people. It was said that people caught in a blizzard would be possessed by the Windigo, and eat their companions, which would make them into a Windigo themselves. Meaning if the ponies hadn't made peace, they would have ate each other.
* The Hearth's Warming Eve pageant has a happy ending, with the three tribes coming together in harmony. However, at the beginning, it's noted that this took place long before the rule of Celestia and Luna. In "Return of Harmony", Celestia notes that she and Luna began their reign after they deposed Discord. The play may have a happy ending, but they eventually are taken over by Discord after founding their new land. And not all that much later, considering that Luna remembers Star Swirl The Bearded, who was mentioned in the pageant.

** The disappearance of background ponies coincides with the introduction of Private Pansy, Clover the Clever and Smart Cookie...right before the journey to Equestria. Notice how Spike keeps talking about "the tribes" in his narration. Whoever directed the play probably decided that three anonymous masses in movement could as well be represented by three actors.

** She knew him well enough to know that Twilight had "even gotten the bells right". Of course Luna herself might only have seen pictures of him with his bells but I prefer to think that she met him herself.

*** Like I said, "not necessarily". But the claim is not absolute proof either way

* We now have a new one. Princess Platinum is described as the "daughter of the Unicorn King." Who's the only unicorn king we know of as of Series 3? '''[[EvilOverlord Sombra.]]''' (Yes, the events depicted in the play take place before Celestia and Luna were in power, but if you take the theory that Discord's rule happened soon after into account...)

** Keep all that in mind while watching "Green Isn't Your Color" and note how Pinkie shows up whenever it seems Twilight's gonna break her Pinkie Promise. If she feels inclined to, she can ''follow you anywhere'' to make sure you don't break one, like she did with Twilight. Now think about The Last Roundup, and [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NgVPun6TuQQ let the title of this vid sink in]]...

* "Onto the next town", the Flim Flam brothers say. One: they've presumably done this before. Have they succeeded in driving other Apple families out of business? Two: they're doing it again. Will the next town's citizens be so lucky as Applejack's?

*** That's assuming the other Apple's aren't as prideful as Apple Jack was in Applebucking. "I wasn't the best." seems to be a running theme for AJ and may very well be in the family.

** There probably are some sort of regular "sky ferries", or magical teleporters, or something like that, which would allow earthbound ponies access Cloudsdale whenever they need to.

** It also mentions "something about a dragon". Discord's species is ''Dracon''equus, dragon horse.

** My thoughts upon reading this: "That's stupid. If clouds and rainbows accidentally get mixed, they're still not going to be accidentally stirred with a pegasus feather, fast, not slow. For that matter, 'give it to two ponies who are not in the know' implies that it only works if given to two ponies, whereas an accident might well only administer it to one, not to mention that it may imply that it only works if administered as a deliberate deception . . . wait, that's worse."

* Mrs. Cake has a throw-away line about the fact that she "could use the catering business" from the wedding. Perhaps the fact that Sugarcube Corner has taken considerable damage in Season 2, and even in this episode, has left them teetering on the brink of financial ruin from the continuous repairs.

* New Fluttershy has no qualms about resorting to violence for minor slights. "Old Fluttershy" kicked a bear's ass and almost snapped his neck. And until [[spoiler: she had her MyGodWhatHaveIDone moment]], she seemed to be steadily getting worse. What if she had not HAD that moment?

* It might seem like a lot of the ponies in "Putting Your Hoof Down" have taken [[TookALevelInJerkass levels in jerkass]], but how many times have we really seen Fluttershy in Ponyville by herself? It's almost always with her friends, or at least while guiding some animals around town. They might act civil because her friends will stand up for her, or because a pack of wild animals is [[Recap/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagicS1E4ApplebuckSeason more trouble than it's worth,]] but what if that's how they act when she's alone all the time because they know Fluttershy won't do anything about it?

* How much do Elements of Harmony bearers qualifty for their Elements if "New Fluttershy" is technically still the bearer of the Element of Kindness? Is "Old Fluttershy" really that kind or is she actually a BitchInSheepsClothing and the Elements can't distinguish this because they're simply magical inanimate objects?

** "...but that still could be enough to change the course of time radically." Thankfully no. The spell is clearly shown to operate on YouAlreadyChangedThePast principles.

** In the episode Twilight tells Pinkie Pie and Spike, "Time spells are kept in the Star Swirl the Bearded wing, the most secure section of the archives. That's why we're sneaking around!"

** And even if all four of them were no match for those dragons, I think a certain [[http://niban-destikim.deviantart.com/art/The-Namby-Pamby-princess-291325254 "namby pamby princess pony"]] would not take kindly to a group of riff-raff harming her closest student and her companions.

** It might just be currently settled Equestria, given that Everfree is so "spooky" because it works on its own like a forest here on Earth, and that we know that Celestia and Luna had at one time called it their home. It's quite likely that the clouds that need managing (for example, the ones RD takes care of in ten second flat in the first episode) come from Everfree and other, similarly wild areas.

[[AC: A Canterlot Wedding, Parts 1 & 2]]

* Pay close attention to how Celestia delievers the line "You have a ''lot'' to think about." It is not unlike the way she delievered the line "You won't get away with this, Discord!" back in the first part of The Return of Harmony. Now, before she delievered that line, it was already preestablished that she felt nothing but pure hatred for Discord. I'll let that sink in for a minute.

** It gets worse: did anypony else notice that Celestia, after being proven conclusively wrong and almost dooming all of Equestria because she didn't listen to Twilight, ''[[MoralDissonance never apologized]]''? She gave Twilight some vaguely approving line about learning to "trust her instincts", but to quote Applejack, Twilight didn't learn anything! She ''knew'' to trust her instincts; it was Celestia who, despite the fact that Twilight has been right each and every time she's predicted some supernatural disaster, didn't give her desperate warning a second thought, and in fact dismissed her as coldly as she once did ''Discord''.
*** That's softened somewhat when you remember that Twilight ''has'' been slightly "possessive" of her brother all along, and also when you remember that Cadence can hardly help but earn people's love; Twilight was, from Celestia's perspective, attacking a pony who's probably her niece with no evidence and no provocation. Her disappointment probably stemmed mainly from the fact that not only did it seem like Twilight was being childish and freaking out over nothing--like in Lesson Zero--but as an Element Bearer, she should ''know better''.
*** That ''was'' Celestia apologizing to Twilight. She's immortal. [[WhoWantsToLiveForever The longer she lives, the harder it becomes to move past the mistakes she's made.]] Apologizing for them only keeps them fresh on her mind and slows the healing process. Here, we see her using a technique for getting around that problem; Celestia "apologizes" by showering Twilight with praise for going right where Celestia went wrong.

*** The others hardly had time to grovel to Twilight- there were more pressing matters to be dealing with at the time. Also, the attitudes of Shining Armour, Celestia and the Mane Five may have seemed harsh to some, but again, Twilight bursts in with no evidence, accuses "Cadance" of being evil and then is swiftly proved totally wrong. Honestly, they had every right to be annoyed with Twilight, she'd already been shown to be incredibly possessive of Shining Armour. Not to mention, Twilight almost got Ponyville torn apart because of her "Want It, Need It" spell that didn't need casting in the first place and in "It's About Time", she went back in time for a pretty flimsy reason. Are they supposed to believe her every time she's suspicious about something? Sure, she turned out to be right, but she went about proving it really badly.

**** Even then, a simply "Sorry" won't suffice.

** Specifically (different troper here), it's entirely possible that the original spell already started to fail around the time of Nightmare Moon's banishment -- and that it then ''still'' took the thousand-odd years since then for it to weaken enough that Discord could finally break free. (Yes, this is straying into {{WMG}} territory a bit, but let's give the Elements of Harmony their due: in the right hooves at the right time, they ''should'' be able to do better than just "turn this villain into stone until the next time somepony has an argument nearby". If ''that'' was the case, Discord would likely have been free again already circa mid-season...)

** ''[[Series/DoctorWho "Humans need water, they can still drown in it!"]]''

* [[spoiler: In all likelihood, Chrysalis intended Twilight to ''kill'' the real Princess Cadence. I mean, she goaded her into blowing up the very wall Cadence was trapped behind. Sure, she ''said'' Twilight would only have to "[[NeverSayDie catch]]" her, but given how rage-filled Twilight was at that point...]]

* The moral from A Canterlot Wedding is pretty lousy. "Trust your instincts". That's fine, since it turned out that Twilight was right and it wasn't the real Cadence, but what if it was just pre-royal wedding nerves? Twilight would have been alienated Princess Celestia and her friends.

* Chrysalis admires how Equestria has more love than she's ever encounterd. Just how many countries/worlds has she already..."encountered" and what became of them?
* Imagine the sort of tyrant Cadence could be if she used her powers for evil. She has the power to make every pony in Equestria completely devoted to her. [[hottip:*:''More like she has the power to bolster the love one already feels toward another."]]

** This creates even more implications if the audience has prior knowledge of [[SwordOfTruthThe Sword Of Truth]] series of books, which have the Confessor. A being who's ability is to suppress a person's ability to feel anything but love for the Confessor and magnifies it tenfold. If a confessor asks a person she has "touched" to die, they are so devoted their heart simply stops. If Cadence became a Tyrant, and Love is implied to be stronger than Celestia (Chrysalis beats Celestia --> Chrysalis is beaten by Love) she could either enslave or kill both Princesses on a whim.
** There is a way that Cadance basically could use her powers for evil, even if her main power is to strengthen love already there - remember the "Want It Need It spell"? It's likely that Twilight learned that from Cadance, and it forced everypony to fall in love with her Smarty Pants doll. A "Want It Need It" spell there, a bit of her love-strengthening magic there, and Cadance could have every stallion in Equestria under her control to be a slave to her love if she really wanted.

* Cadence's powers. Even if they "strengthen what's already there", that's not exactly much better. For instance, it is never really made clear just what qualifies as "love" for her powers? It's almost guaranteed that you feel more "love" towards any random passerby - even one who you absolutely hate - than you do towards that ant that is crawling along your wall. Can she use that? If so, then even if her powers don't "create" love, then the effects would be effectively indistinguishable.
** Depends a lot on one's personal stance on "love" in general. Is love a good thing? Then Cadence's powers are pretty unquestionably positive. Is it an already-questionable breakdown of rationality (or worse) in its own right? ''Then'' they suddenly look a lot more ominous. (Of course, the real reason her powers are going to be limited is somewhat more meta: most of the show is ''driven'' by interpersonal conflict of some kind or other, and if a Princess DeusExMachina could just pop in and resolve everything with a few strategically-placed pink hearts anytime she liked, that would be kind of anticlimactic. So she probably can't actually do that. Watch out if she ever picks up a SuperpoweredEvilSide, though...)
*** Not to mention the UnfortunateImplications of the "Want It, Need It" spell... take that in account with Cadance's power to amplify love, add a SuperpoweredEvilSide into the mix, and, well, you could have the potential for a [[WorldsMostBeautifulWoman very]] [[TheVamp sinister]] [[IHaveYouNowMyPretty alicorn]].
** Not quite too worrisome, but if her Love magic does not distinguish between TheFourLoves, and she misjudges a "couple" that needs the help of her magic, that might result in some [[BrotherSisterIncest unfortunate]] [[KissingCousins accidents]], as FanArt was [[http://fav.me/d4xc25y quick to elaborate upon]].

* [[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D8hZnE3RJLM&list=PLDEF92F38FC613C55&index=150&feature=plpp_video In this sneak preview]], [[spoiler: the Crystal Pony Twi talks to is clearly having her memories or mind tampered with by the villain in a manner quite like [[VideoGame/MetalGearSolid4 the SOPS]]. All the other Crystal Ponies exhibit similar symptoms and lack of emotion. whoever the villain is, they are clearly using a SOPS-style system to [[MindControl enslave and control the entire population]]! And you thought having absolute control over soldiers was bad enough.]]

* Why are there no children in the Crystal Empire, though some are clearly shown in Celestia's "hologram"?

* Sombra was imprisoned a thousand years ago. Luna became Nightmare Moon and was sealed away in the moon a thousand years ago. WordOfGod says Luna was corrupted by dark magic when she became Nightmare Moon. ''How do we know Sombra didn't infect her with some of his power as a final "screw you" before he was sealed away''? Considering we don't know exactly ''when'' Luna became Nightmare Moon, it could've been some time after Sombra was defeated, and the "infection" had time to grow and consume her!

** "More twisted and depraved"? Not necessarily. Perhaps the pond doesn't create a clone with exaggerated qualities, but rather ones with the same essential nature as the original. The difference is that the clones have none of the original's experience. Pinkie Pie, for all her zaniness, still had to develop the skills and self-control necessary to live in polite pony society. This is why she doesn't go around doing anything but benign if she can help it. The clones emerged fully formed from the pond, complete with all of the original's randomness, but without her learned heed for others that checks Pinkie Pie's behavior (for what it's worth). They didn't know what they were doing. [[spoiler: This of course magnifies the Fridge Horror in that Twilight enacted a holocaust against not just sentient beings, but sentient NEWBORNS.]] As for Discord, whether or not his clones would be more vile would hinge on whether his evil is inherent as a chaos being, or was acquired at some point in his past. If the former, they most certainly be more evil because they'd lack even the barest of Discord's self control, whatever that may be. If the latter, the clones might be random but benign, and lay the groundwork for a "good" Discord.

* Consider what Pinkie Pie had to go through. When all the Pinkies are rounded up to take the test, Twilight simply states that the one who passes "gets to stay" (alive). The real Pinkie has to sit perfectly still and remain quiet while Twilight slaughters the unattentive duplicates, sometimes just for looking at another duplicate. Now, if Pinkie would look away for just a moment (because a duplicate bumps into her by accident, maybe?), she would be disintegrated by Twilight, die and never see her friends again. Basically, she has to suppress her entire personality if she wants to stay alive; even if she manages to do that, she might still die because some random duplicate next to her decides to make a face "crazier than THIS!". Not even Celestia's Royal guards have this much self control. Pinkie has to rely on the small amount of self restraint she has to remain alive during a few hours of crazy duplicates being killed off by an awfully cheery Twilight. How is this not severe psychological torture? Oh, and cue Spike enjoying all this with his trademark bag o' popcorn.

** All foals are supposed to have short tails. Google "foals" and look in the images to see examples.

** "Alicorn" is not a fandom nod. Not EVERYTHING is a fandom nod. Sheesh. Edited for correctness.

* Trixie's spell on Rainbow Dash that was "Supposed to make you writhe in agony". In other words, there are ''[[AgonyBeam spells for torture]]'' in the world of ponies. Talk about a CrapsaccharineWorld.

** Thankfully, the assorted monsters of the Everfree Forest seem content to stay there unless provoked first; monster attacks seem rare enough that something like an Ursa Minor ambling into Ponyville is genuine cause for panic rather than a case of "ho hum, third critter this month...". If the timber wolves ever change their minds about that and their regeneration ability turns out ''not'' to be tied to the forest itself after all on top of that, now...