Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fridge / MASH

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** The episode (as do many others others) illustrates that anything of value could be put on the trading block between units. It's entirely plausible that the Canadian unit had taken in the curare in a previous trade, knowing it had high value to a medical unit.


* Whenever Hawkeye replaces Frank's gun with a toy or a gun shaped lighter, he immediately pulls the trigger when unholstering it, thinking it is a real gun. We all know Frank [[YouFailGunSafetyForever failed gun safety]] and RuleOfFunny notwithstanding, he's pointing it at someone '''every''' time. In ''Five O'Clock Charlie'', when he 'arrests' Henry and Pierce for sabotaging his [=AA=] gun, he points the toy popgun at Pierce and pulls the trigger, [[RuleOfFunny if only done for the 'bang' flag to pop out]]. When he builds a small sandbag bunker in the Swamp and is woken up in the middle of the night, he points the lighter in Hawkeye and [=BJ=]'s direction. Again, this was done so the lighter would light, but still. In either time, had he had a real gun and done that, he would have [[IJustShotMarvinInTheFace shot Pierce in the face]]

to:

* Whenever Hawkeye replaces Frank's gun with a toy or a gun shaped lighter, he immediately pulls the trigger when unholstering it, thinking it is a real gun. We all know Frank [[YouFailGunSafetyForever [[ArtisticLicenseGunSafety failed gun safety]] and RuleOfFunny notwithstanding, he's pointing it at someone '''every''' time. In ''Five O'Clock Charlie'', when he 'arrests' Henry and Pierce for sabotaging his [=AA=] gun, he points the toy popgun at Pierce and pulls the trigger, [[RuleOfFunny if only done for the 'bang' flag to pop out]]. When he builds a small sandbag bunker in the Swamp and is woken up in the middle of the night, he points the lighter in Hawkeye and [=BJ=]'s direction. Again, this was done so the lighter would light, but still. In either time, had he had a real gun and done that, he would have [[IJustShotMarvinInTheFace shot Pierce in the face]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** In reality, it was a double-dose of DidNotDoTheResearch. They cast the role of Spearchucker based on the character from the movie, then were informed that there were no black surgeons in Korea. After cutting the role from the series, they were informed that there actually ''were'' a few black surgeons in Korea.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** It was BJ and Hawkeye that were making the rape joke.




to:

** In fairness, a real loaded pistol is heavier than a lighter/toy gun. It's possible that Burns pulled the trigger after realizing he'd been pranked. Then again, this is [[TheNeidermeyer Frank]] we're talking about....





to:

\n*** Henry, in an early episode, tells Frank that Pierce is a better surgeon "when the heat is on." Most likely, Frank is a qualified surgeon in his own right (before he got {{Flanderized}}, at least) but he can't keep his cool when he has to hurry, like when they are overwhelmed with patients. As long as he can take his time and go by the book, Frank will have a successful operation, but drops the ball when having to do 'meatball surgery'.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The irony being that Charles almost kills a patient with curare early on, but is the first to tout its effectiveness in trained hands like theirs.

to:

*** The irony being that Charles almost kills a patient with curare early on, but is the first to tout its effectiveness in trained hands like theirs.theirs.
*** Which brings on even more FrigeLogic, since Charles would have likely studied everything he could about curare so he could avoid that mistake again in the future, meaning he'd be likely to know more about it than the others.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** And this dynamic is inverted, naturally, with Frank Burns. Hawkeye ''et al.'' clearly didn't routinely address him by his first name from a sense of chummy cameraderie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Edward Winter, known for portraying Colonel Samuel Flagg, first appeared as a Captain Halloran, an officer with the CID in the episode ''Deal Me Out'', where he played poker with Sidney Freedman. When Colonel Flagg later met Sidney Freedman in the episode "Quo Vadis, Captain Chandler" he remarked that they once played poker together. Some fans apply FridgeBrilliance to claim Halloran as one of Flagg's alternate identities.

to:

* Edward Winter, known for portraying Colonel Samuel Flagg, first appeared as a Captain Halloran, an officer with the CID in the episode ''Deal Me Out'', where he played poker with Sidney Freedman. When Colonel Flagg later met Sidney Freedman in the episode "Quo Vadis, Captain Chandler" he remarked that they once played poker together. Some fans apply FridgeBrilliance to claim Halloran as one of Flagg's alternate identities.
together.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A rather sad one, but all the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her, and Henry dying was so much of a shock that they couldn't help but think of it.

to:

* A rather sad one, but all All the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her, and Henry dying was so much of a shock that they couldn't help but think of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{MASH}}'', Hawkeye always referred to Colonel Potter by his rank or name ("Colonel, I need some help here"), while he tended to call Lt. Col. Henry Blake by his given name. At first, I thought it was primarily because Hawkeye and Blake were more friends than officers. Then it hit - Hawkeye also had far more respect for Potter than he had for Blake (probably because Potter didn't put up with much from Hawkeye). The only time Hawkeye called Potter by his given name was when he was going to ask Potter to stay in Korea... and it came out like he was asking a loved one not to leave. I have no doubt that Hawkeye loved Henry Blake, but he ''respected'' Potter - and using Potter's rank was his way of showing it. - Tropers/CaliforniaDave

to:

* In ''{{MASH}}'', Hawkeye always referred to Colonel Potter by his rank or name ("Colonel, I need some help here"), while he tended to call Lt. Col. Henry Blake by his given name. At first, I thought it was primarily because Hawkeye and Blake were more friends than officers. Then it hit - Hawkeye also had far more respect for Potter than he had for Blake (probably because Potter didn't put up with much from Hawkeye). The only time Hawkeye called Potter by his given name was when he was going to ask Potter to stay in Korea... and it came out like he was asking a loved one not to leave. I have no doubt that Hawkeye loved Henry Blake, but he ''respected'' Potter - and using Potter's rank was his way of showing it. - Tropers/CaliforniaDave
it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Whenever Hawkeye replaces Frank's gun with a toy or a gun shaped lighter, he immediately pulls the trigger when unholstering it, thinking it is a real gun. We all know Frank [[YouFailGunSafetyForever failed gun safety]] and RuleOfFunny notwithstanding, he's pointing it at someone '''every''' time. In ''Five O'Clock Charlie'', when he 'arrests' Henry and Pierce for sabotaging his [=AA=] gun, he points the toy popgun at Pierce and pulls the trigger, [[RuleOfFunny if only done for the 'bang' flag to pop out]]. When he builds a small sandbag bunker in the Swamp and is woken up in the middle of the night, he points the lighter in Hawkeye and [=BJ=]'s direction. Again, this was done so the lighter would light, but still. In either time, had he had a real gun and done that, he would have killed Pierce.

to:

* Whenever Hawkeye replaces Frank's gun with a toy or a gun shaped lighter, he immediately pulls the trigger when unholstering it, thinking it is a real gun. We all know Frank [[YouFailGunSafetyForever failed gun safety]] and RuleOfFunny notwithstanding, he's pointing it at someone '''every''' time. In ''Five O'Clock Charlie'', when he 'arrests' Henry and Pierce for sabotaging his [=AA=] gun, he points the toy popgun at Pierce and pulls the trigger, [[RuleOfFunny if only done for the 'bang' flag to pop out]]. When he builds a small sandbag bunker in the Swamp and is woken up in the middle of the night, he points the lighter in Hawkeye and [=BJ=]'s direction. Again, this was done so the lighter would light, but still. In either time, had he had a real gun and done that, he would have killed Pierce.
[[IJustShotMarvinInTheFace shot Pierce in the face]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Edward Winter, known for portraying Colonel Samuel Flagg, first appeared as a Captain Halloran, an officer with the CID in the episode ''Deal Me Out'', where he played poker with Sidney Freedman. When Colonel Flagg later met Sidney Freedman in the episode "Quo Vadis, Captain Chandler" he remarked that they once played poker together. Some fans apply FridgeBrilliance to claim Halloran as one of Flagg's alternate identities.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A rather sad one, but all the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her, and Hanry dying was so much of a shock that they couldn't help but think of it.

to:

* A rather sad one, but all the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her, and Hanry Henry dying was so much of a shock that they couldn't help but think of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePools the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].

to:

* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. anesthetic? There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePools the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They probably just wanted to use a unit name that Americans might recognize, but it also suggests a possible bit of fridge horror: since in the real world, curare was a weapon long before it was a medicine, and an infantry regiment would have no ''medical'' reason to keep a supply of a powerful paralytic, were the Canadian Forces involved in secret chemical warfare?

to:

** They probably just wanted to use a unit name that Americans might recognize, but it also suggests a possible bit of fridge horror: since in the real world, curare was a weapon long before it was a medicine, and an infantry regiment would have no ''medical'' reason to keep a supply of a powerful paralytic, were the Canadian Forces involved in secret chemical warfare?warfare?
*** The irony being that Charles almost kills a patient with curare early on, but is the first to tout its effectiveness in trained hands like theirs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePools the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].

to:


* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePools the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].regiment]].
**They probably just wanted to use a unit name that Americans might recognize, but it also suggests a possible bit of fridge horror: since in the real world, curare was a weapon long before it was a medicine, and an infantry regiment would have no ''medical'' reason to keep a supply of a powerful paralytic, were the Canadian Forces involved in secret chemical warfare?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePool the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].

to:

* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePool [[SmallReferencePools the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic.

to:

* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic. There were two Canadian medical units in Korea at the time, the No. 25 Canadian Field Ambulance and No. 37 Field Ambulance, yet the [[DidNotDoTheResearch writers chose]] [[SmallReferencePool the most prolific Canadian infantry regiment]].

Added: 270

Changed: 86

Removed: 67

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Another reason: Harry and Henry are ''the same name''. Keep in mind Henry ''died''.
** Except for the fact that Col. Potter's name is ''Sherman...'' :P

to:

** Another reason: Harry and Henry are ''the same name''. Keep in mind Henry ''died''.
** Except for the fact that Col. Potter's name is ''Sherman...'' :P



*** Not all wartime injuries are life-threatening. They probably had a ''lot'' of lesser injuries and illnesses to treat, that would account for most of that 97%; we just don't see these less-serious cases very often because they're less dramatic than the life-or-death ones.

to:

*** Not all wartime injuries are life-threatening. They probably had a ''lot'' of lesser injuries and illnesses to treat, that would account for most of that 97%; we just don't see these less-serious cases very often because they're less dramatic than the life-or-death ones.ones.

* One story has Potter and Klinger bartering with a Canadian unit for curare, an anesthetic banned by US officials. The unit they dealt with was the Princess Patricia's Light Infantry, an Alberta regiment. So what was an infantry regiment doing with surgical anesthetic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Not all wartime injuries are life-threatening. They probably had a ''lot'' of lesser injuries and illnesses to treat, we just don't see these very often because they're less dramatic than the life-or-death ones.

to:

*** Not all wartime injuries are life-threatening. They probably had a ''lot'' of lesser injuries and illnesses to treat, that would account for most of that 97%; we just don't see these less-serious cases very often because they're less dramatic than the life-or-death ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** But not every time. Throughout Frank's stay, all four doctors are shown in the [=OR=] at once the majority of the time, with Frank rarely doing triage.

to:

*** But not every time. Throughout Frank's stay, all four doctors are shown in the [=OR=] at once the majority of the time, with Frank rarely doing triage.triage.
*** Not all wartime injuries are life-threatening. They probably had a ''lot'' of lesser injuries and illnesses to treat, we just don't see these very often because they're less dramatic than the life-or-death ones.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding additional information.


* A rather sad one, but all the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her.

to:

* A rather sad one, but all the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her.
her, and Hanry dying was so much of a shock that they couldn't help but think of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correcting an error I made.


*** But not every time. Throughout Frank's stay, all four doctors are shown in the [[=OR=]] at once the majority of the time, with Frank rarely doing triage.

to:

*** But not every time. Throughout Frank's stay, all four doctors are shown in the [[=OR=]] [=OR=] at once the majority of the time, with Frank rarely doing triage.

Added: 1777

Changed: 715

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding additional information.


* FridgeHorror: In "The Novocaine Mutiny", Frank says that he's aware that the hearing he brought against Hawkeye will result in Hawk's death "or [[FateWorseThanDeath worse]]", which is followed by a joke about wanting virginity. So Frank, who has entries in UnintentionallySympathetic, was willing to see Hawkeye raped? Huh.
* FridgeLogic: If one of the camp's four doctors was hopelessly incompetent, how did they have a 97% survival rate?

to:

* FridgeHorror: A rather sad one, but all the characters who [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome disappear without explaination]] were in a frontline unit in a war zone, with a mine field nearby. In fact, one nurse near the end of the series dies after stepping on a mine while on a walk. These characters could have died, and it was too depressing for the main characters to mention close friends and collegues dying. The nurse late in the series had only been there about a month, and no one had gotten to know her.

[[AC:FridgeHorror]]
*
In "The Novocaine Mutiny", Frank says that he's aware that the hearing he brought against Hawkeye will result in Hawk's death "or [[FateWorseThanDeath worse]]", which is followed by a joke about wanting virginity. So Frank, who has entries in UnintentionallySympathetic, was willing to see Hawkeye raped? Huh.
Huh.

* FridgeLogic: Whenever Hawkeye replaces Frank's gun with a toy or a gun shaped lighter, he immediately pulls the trigger when unholstering it, thinking it is a real gun. We all know Frank [[YouFailGunSafetyForever failed gun safety]] and RuleOfFunny notwithstanding, he's pointing it at someone '''every''' time. In ''Five O'Clock Charlie'', when he 'arrests' Henry and Pierce for sabotaging his [=AA=] gun, he points the toy popgun at Pierce and pulls the trigger, [[RuleOfFunny if only done for the 'bang' flag to pop out]]. When he builds a small sandbag bunker in the Swamp and is woken up in the middle of the night, he points the lighter in Hawkeye and [=BJ=]'s direction. Again, this was done so the lighter would light, but still. In either time, had he had a real gun and done that, he would have killed Pierce.

* In the pilot, while trying to think of ways to raise money for Ho Jon's tuition at Hawkeye's alma mater, Hawkeye suggests selling Spearchucker Jones. [[UnfortunateImplications Spearchucker was the only black doctor.]] [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome He then disappears five episodes later with no explanation.]] So, did Hawkeye really sell Spearchucker into slavery?

[[AC:FridgeLogic]]
*
If one of the camp's four doctors was hopelessly incompetent, how did they have a 97% survival rate?



*** Not all the doctors perform ''surgery'' all the time. One has to man triage, for example.

to:

*** Not all the doctors perform ''surgery'' all the time. One has to man triage, for example.example.
*** But not every time. Throughout Frank's stay, all four doctors are shown in the [[=OR=]] at once the majority of the time, with Frank rarely doing triage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Except for the fact that Col. Potter's name is ''Sherman...'' :P
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Another reason: Harry and Henry are ''the same name''. Keep in mind Henry ''died''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** But given the volume of patients they regularly had, and only had '''four''' doctors, they could not have such a high success rate if one of those doctors, who shared in about 25% of the load, was totally incompetent, and killed more patients than he saved.

to:

*** But given the volume of patients they regularly had, and only had '''four''' doctors, they could not have such a high success rate if one of those doctors, who shared in about 25% of the load, was totally incompetent, and killed more patients than he saved.saved.
*** Not all the doctors perform ''surgery'' all the time. One has to man triage, for example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding additional information.


** I believe Hawkeye would say that Frank is responsible for the other 3%.

to:

** I believe Hawkeye would say that Frank is responsible for the other 3%.3%.
*** But given the volume of patients they regularly had, and only had '''four''' doctors, they could not have such a high success rate if one of those doctors, who shared in about 25% of the load, was totally incompetent, and killed more patients than he saved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FridgeLogic: If one of the camp's four doctors was hopelessly incompetent, how did they have a 97% survival rate?

to:

* FridgeLogic: If one of the camp's four doctors was hopelessly incompetent, how did they have a 97% survival rate?rate?
** I believe Hawkeye would say that Frank is responsible for the other 3%.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:FridgeBrilliance]]
* In ''{{MASH}}'', Hawkeye always referred to Colonel Potter by his rank or name ("Colonel, I need some help here"), while he tended to call Lt. Col. Henry Blake by his given name. At first, I thought it was primarily because Hawkeye and Blake were more friends than officers. Then it hit - Hawkeye also had far more respect for Potter than he had for Blake (probably because Potter didn't put up with much from Hawkeye). The only time Hawkeye called Potter by his given name was when he was going to ask Potter to stay in Korea... and it came out like he was asking a loved one not to leave. I have no doubt that Hawkeye loved Henry Blake, but he ''respected'' Potter - and using Potter's rank was his way of showing it. - Tropers/CaliforniaDave
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Adding additional information.


* FridgeHorror: In "The Novocaine Mutiny", Frank says that he's aware that the hearing he brought against Hawkeye will result in Hawk's death "or [[FateWorseThanDeath worse]]", which is followed by a joke about wanting virginity. So Frank, who has entries in UnintentionallySympathetic, was willing to see Hawkeye raped? Huh.

to:

* FridgeHorror: In "The Novocaine Mutiny", Frank says that he's aware that the hearing he brought against Hawkeye will result in Hawk's death "or [[FateWorseThanDeath worse]]", which is followed by a joke about wanting virginity. So Frank, who has entries in UnintentionallySympathetic, was willing to see Hawkeye raped? Huh.Huh.
* FridgeLogic: If one of the camp's four doctors was hopelessly incompetent, how did they have a 97% survival rate?

Top