Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheLeagueofExtraordinaryGentlemen

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AntiHero: Skinner, Hyde and Nemo
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**[[MoulinRouge That Duke]] also has the distinction of playing both Moriarty and his own [[SherlockHolmes nemesis]] in the same year.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HulkingOut: Dr. Jekyll when he turns into Hyde.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He never says that in the original release.


** Or, you know, when he drops the "You killed Huckleberry Finn" line.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Or, you know, when he drops the "You killed Huckleberry Finn" line.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnemyRisingBehind: Mina during her fight with Dorian.

to:

* EnemyRisingBehind: Mina during her fight with Dorian.[[spoiler:Dorian Gray]].



* [[{{GroinAttack/Film}} Groin Attack]]: Mina to Dorian during their fight.

to:

* [[{{GroinAttack/Film}} Groin Attack]]: Mina to Dorian [[spoiler:Dorian Gray]] during their fight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnemyRisingBehind: Mina during her fight with Dorian.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[GroinAttack/Film Groin Attack]]: Mina to Dorian during their fight.

to:

* [[GroinAttack/Film [[{{GroinAttack/Film}} Groin Attack]]: Mina to Dorian during their fight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[GroinAttack/Film Groin Attack]]: Mina to Dorian during their fight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Roger Moore was offered a cameo as Campion Bond, a part that was ultimately a cut from the script, and would've been the first time two actors to have played James Bond shared the screen.

to:

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Roger Moore was offered a cameo as Campion Bond, a part that was ultimately a cut from the script, and would've been the first time two actors to have played James Bond shared the screen.

Added: 116

Changed: 186

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In 2003, Fox Studios released a film version of the graphic novel...er, sort of. It had the same basic premise and about half of the same characters, but was otherwise rather a departure from Moore's original. Joining the League in the film are Dorian Gray (as in ''[[ThePictureOfDorianGray The Picture of]]'') and TomSawyer, who is all grown up and a member of the American Secret Service. Due to the film character of the invisible man not being public domain, the screenwriters invented Rodney Skinner, who stole the invisibility formula and turned himself transparent in order to become a criminal mastermind. Quatermain is recruited out of retirement in Africa, where he relocated after the death of his son, to lead the current generation of the League; Mina, Jekyll, Nemo, Skinner and Gray are likewise recruited, while Sawyer joins voluntarily. Jekyll and Hyde are a little different; Jekyll gets more screentime than Hyde and he has to ingest a secret formula to release the monster. Oh, and Mina is now a widowed vampire instead of a divorced BadassNormal. The League believes themselves to be in a race against time to stop terrorists from destroying a peace conference, but the reality is a little different.

to:

In 2003, Fox Studios released a film version of the AlanMoore's popular graphic novel...novel ''TheLeagueOfExtraordinaryGentlemen''...er, sort of. It had the same basic premise and about half of the same characters, but was otherwise rather a departure from Moore's original. Joining the League in the film are Dorian Gray (as in ''[[ThePictureOfDorianGray The Picture of]]'') and TomSawyer, who is all grown up and a member of the American Secret Service. Due to the film character of the invisible man not being public domain, the screenwriters invented Rodney Skinner, who stole the invisibility formula and turned himself transparent in order to become a criminal mastermind. Quatermain is recruited out of retirement in Africa, where he relocated after the death of his son, to lead the current generation of the League; Mina, Jekyll, Nemo, Skinner and Gray are likewise recruited, while Sawyer joins voluntarily. Jekyll and Hyde are a little different; Jekyll gets more screentime than Hyde and he has to ingest a secret formula to release the monster. Oh, and Mina is now a widowed vampire instead of a divorced BadassNormal. The League believes themselves to be in a race against time to stop terrorists from destroying a peace conference, but the reality is a little different.




!!In addition to many of the above, the film version includes examples of:

to:

\n----
!!In addition to many of the above, tropes found in the graphic novel, the film version includes examples of:



* ChuckCunninghamSyndrome: Campion Bond does not appear or even get mentioned.

to:

* ChuckCunninghamSyndrome: Campion Bond does not appear or even get mentioned.mentioned; neither does Mycroft Holmes.



*** {{Handwave}}d by the idea that the film takes place in an AlternateUniverse where these characters really exist.



* GoodGunsBadGuns: You know [[spoiler:Grey]] is a rotter when he shoots Ishmael...using a Luger! Also the villains' automatic rifles resemble SteamPunk [=AK47s=] while those carried by Nemo's men look like Sten guns.

to:

* GoodGunsBadGuns: You know [[spoiler:Grey]] is a rotter when he shoots Ishmael...using a Luger! Also Also, the villains' automatic rifles resemble SteamPunk [=AK47s=] [=AK47s=], while those carried by Nemo's men look like Sten guns.



* [[HeyItsThatGuy Hey, It's That Guy!]]: SeanConnery is acting as a ParentalSubstitute to [[AWalkToRemember Landon Carter]], as they join forces with [[TheCuriousCaseOfBenjaminButton Thomas Button]], [[LaFemmeNikita Nikita]], [[QueenOfTheDamned Lestat de Lioncourt]], [[ThePillarsOfTheEarth King Stephen]], and [[{{Bollywood}} Naseeruddin Shah]]. Oh, and the guy who hired them is [[VanHelsing Count Dracula]].

to:

* [[HeyItsThatGuy Hey, It's That Guy!]]: SeanConnery is acting as a ParentalSubstitute to [[AWalkToRemember Landon Carter]], as they join forces with [[TheCuriousCaseOfBenjaminButton Thomas Button]], [[LaFemmeNikita Nikita]], [[QueenOfTheDamned Lestat de Lioncourt]], [[ThePillarsOfTheEarth King Stephen]], [[DoctorWho Vincent Van Gogh]], and [[{{Bollywood}} Naseeruddin Shah]]. Oh, and the guy who hired them is [[VanHelsing Count Dracula]].



-->'''Moriarty:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? [[spoiler:It is over -- for you. Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard -- audible only to dogs, lower animals -- is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]
-->[[spoiler:'''Grey:''' "Sensors attached to bombs. Bomb voyage!"]]

to:

-->'''Moriarty:''' -->'''BigBad:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? [[spoiler:It is over -- for you. Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard -- audible only to dogs, lower animals -- is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]
-->[[spoiler:'''Grey:''' -->[[spoiler:'''Gray:''' "Sensors attached to bombs. Bomb voyage!"]]



* TakeTheWheel: While the protagonists are driving in Nemo's car in Venice, Sawyer does this to Quartermaine--who promptly tells Sawyer he has no idea how to drive the bloody car.

to:

* TakeTheWheel: While the protagonists are driving in Nemo's car in Venice, Sawyer does this to Quartermaine--who Quatermain -- who promptly tells Sawyer he has no idea how to drive the bloody car.



Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeTheWheel: While the protagonists are driving in Nemo's car in Venice, Sawyer and Quartermaine do this.

to:

* TakeTheWheel: While the protagonists are driving in Nemo's car in Venice, Sawyer and Quartermaine do this.does this to Quartermaine--who promptly tells Sawyer he has no idea how to drive the bloody car.

Added: 145

Changed: 1

Removed: 37

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AFatherToHisMen: Nemo and his crew.



* AFatherToHisMen: Nemo and his crew.



---> '''Quatermain:''' The Fantom? Very operatic.

to:

---> --> '''Quatermain:''' The Fantom? Very operatic.


Added DiffLines:

* TakeTheWheel: While the protagonists are driving in Nemo's car in Venice, Sawyer and Quartermaine do this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LocalReference: The inclusion of an American (Sawyer).

Changed: 6

Removed: 393

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Yeah, those guys with advanced weapons and armor are soooooo helpless.


* QuicklyDemotedWoman: Mina's position as leader of the League in the comics is handed off to Quatermain instead. A possible subversion, however; she becomes the most powerful member of the cast, an immortal elder vampire.
** "Elder" may be something of a misnomer because Mina ''should'' be one of the more recently empowered characters (''Dracula'' being contemporaneously set and published in 1897; the movie takes place in 1899). Her use of her powers and general [[ImmortalityImmorality complete disregard]] for helpless enemy [[WhatMeasureIsAMook mooks]] don't fit anyone who still identifies as human, though.

to:

* QuicklyDemotedWoman: Mina's position as leader of the League in the comics is handed off to Quatermain instead. A possible subversion, however; she becomes the most powerful member of the cast, an immortal elder vampire.
** "Elder" may be something of a misnomer because Mina ''should'' be one of the more recently empowered characters (''Dracula'' being contemporaneously set and published in 1897; the movie takes place in 1899). Her use of her powers and general [[ImmortalityImmorality complete disregard]] for helpless enemy [[WhatMeasureIsAMook mooks]] don't fit anyone who still identifies as human, though.
vampire.

Changed: 1

Removed: 74

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not really, no.


* OffstageVillainy: Nemo and Hyde. The movie doesn't have KickTheDog moments for either of them like the comics. They come across as relatively decent people with no qualms about killing their enemies and, in the case of Hyde, a lust for violence that still doesn't stop him from doing the right thing - in fact, he's the one suggesting plans to save everyone - despite characters often talking about how detestable they are.
** Mina, as essentially Countess Dracula, also can be presumed to qualify.

to:

* OffstageVillainy: Nemo and Hyde. The movie doesn't have KickTheDog moments for either of them like the comics. They come across as relatively decent people with no qualms about killing their enemies and, in the case of Hyde, a lust for violence that still doesn't stop him from doing the right thing - in fact, he's the one suggesting plans to save everyone - despite characters often talking about how detestable they are.
** Mina, as essentially Countess Dracula, also can be presumed to qualify.
are.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mina also can be presumed to qualify. For being the one member of the cast who can kill arbitrarily, she doesn't seem very restrained about it.

to:

** Mina Mina, as essentially Countess Dracula, also can be presumed to qualify. For being the one member of the cast who can kill arbitrarily, she doesn't seem very restrained about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Mina also can be presumed to qualify. For being the one member of the cast who can kill arbitrarily, she doesn't seem very restrained about it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Much more pointedly on the subject of the car, Venice ''does not have streets.''


Added DiffLines:

** "Elder" may be something of a misnomer because Mina ''should'' be one of the more recently empowered characters (''Dracula'' being contemporaneously set and published in 1897; the movie takes place in 1899). Her use of her powers and general [[ImmortalityImmorality complete disregard]] for helpless enemy [[WhatMeasureIsAMook mooks]] don't fit anyone who still identifies as human, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* QuicklyDemotedWoman: Mina's position as leader of the League in the comics is handed off to Quatermain instead.

to:

* QuicklyDemotedWoman: Mina's position as leader of the League in the comics is handed off to Quatermain instead. A possible subversion, however; she becomes the most powerful member of the cast, an immortal elder vampire.

Added: 4

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Which makes no sense; Tom Sawyer was a twelve-year old in the pre-civil-war era. If anything, he should be ''older'' than Quatermain.

to:

** Which makes no sense; Tom Sawyer was a twelve-year old in the pre-civil-war pre-Civil War era. If anything, he should be ''older'' than Quatermain.Quatermain.

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Sean Connery's line "All the time in the world." May not be intentional, as he wasn't actually in OHMSS.

to:

** Sean Connery's line "All the time in the world." world" from ''OnHerMajestysSecretService''. May not be intentional, as he wasn't actually in OHMSS.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SequelHook: The MeaningfulFuneral ends with [[spoiler:a native wiseman doing...something that makes the ground shake, lighting crash across the sky, and the clouds to turn dark. This was probably meant to be Quatermain coming back from the dead.]]

to:

* SequelHook: The MeaningfulFuneral ends with [[spoiler:a native wiseman witch doctor doing...something that makes the ground shake, lighting lightning crash across the sky, and the clouds to turn dark. This was probably meant to be Quatermain coming back from the dead.]]

Added: 61

Changed: 61

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FinalSpeech: Ishmael manages to live long enough after being shot to reveal [[spoiler:Dorian]] as the traitor.* FunPersonified: Skinner gives the impression of being this.

to:

* FinalSpeech: Ishmael manages to live long enough after being shot to reveal [[spoiler:Dorian]] as the traitor.traitor.
* FunPersonified: Skinner gives the impression of being this.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrappedInContainment

Changed: 192

Removed: 1755

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Taking out some subjectives and misused tropes.


* CanonForeigner: Skinner is the only member of the League who is not directly imported from a Victorian-era novel.

to:

* CanonForeigner: Skinner is the only member of the League who is not directly imported from a Victorian-era novel. This is because Griffin isn't in the public domain, at least as far as movie rights goes, unlike the rest of the League's members.



* FinalSpeech: Ishmael manages to live long enough after being shot to reveal [[spoiler:Dorian]] as the traitor.
* FridgeLogic: Possibly the most glaring example is the massive ''Nautilus'' being able to cruise down a canal in Venice.
** Don't forget the [[WallBanger car chase in Venice]].
** Or the fight scene in a cemetery in Venice--it's been illegal to bury corpses in the city since 1807 and all the corpses are buried off shore on San Michele.
*** Possibly {{Justified}} (or at least HandWaved), since WordOfGod says the movie takes place in an alternate reality.
** How about this one? Right after Mina is revealed to be a vampire, she ''fixes her appearance using a compact mirror''.
*** OurVampiresAreDifferent. She's not shown not-appearing in any other reflective surface, after all.
** If Dorian's portrait will age him to death just by looking at it, ''why'' is there a blank space for it in his home? Only possible explanation is if the painting doesn't work its magic while hanging (which may be justified in the dustiness surrounding the empty space), but even then it's a ''major'' WallBanger.
*** [[IncrediblyLamePun A Wall Hanger]] WallBanger, no less.
*** Unless the picture was kept veiled.
* FunPersonified: Skinner gives the impression of being this.

to:

* FinalSpeech: Ishmael manages to live long enough after being shot to reveal [[spoiler:Dorian]] as the traitor.
* FridgeLogic: Possibly the most glaring example is the massive ''Nautilus'' being able to cruise down a canal in Venice.
** Don't forget the [[WallBanger car chase in Venice]].
** Or the fight scene in a cemetery in Venice--it's been illegal to bury corpses in the city since 1807 and all the corpses are buried off shore on San Michele.
*** Possibly {{Justified}} (or at least HandWaved), since WordOfGod says the movie takes place in an alternate reality.
** How about this one? Right after Mina is revealed to be a vampire, she ''fixes her appearance using a compact mirror''.
*** OurVampiresAreDifferent. She's not shown not-appearing in any other reflective surface, after all.
** If Dorian's portrait will age him to death just by looking at it, ''why'' is there a blank space for it in his home? Only possible explanation is if the painting doesn't work its magic while hanging (which may be justified in the dustiness surrounding the empty space), but even then it's a ''major'' WallBanger.
*** [[IncrediblyLamePun A Wall Hanger]] WallBanger, no less.
*** Unless the picture was kept veiled.
traitor.* FunPersonified: Skinner gives the impression of being this.



* TooDumbToLive: In light of the above, Sawyer, who is a very normal human, has an oddly suicidal fascination with Mina. Even after having a ringside seat for multiple people getting splattered all over her.
** Well a [[EvilIsSexy dark attraction]] to vampires is hardly unusual...



* WallBanger: As ridiculous as the movie is, it's still fun and has its fans. The novelization (of a film based on a comic book) may qualify for this, however. The ending [[spoiler:not only implies that Sawyer and Mina end up together, but reveals that Skinner has been "on Her Majesty's Secret Service" the entire time]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Moriarty:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? [[spoiler:It is over -- for you. Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard, audible only to dogs, lower animals, is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]

to:

-->'''Moriarty:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? [[spoiler:It is over -- for you. Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard, heard -- audible only to dogs, lower animals, animals -- is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoodGunsBadGuns: You know [[spoiler:Grey]] is a rotter when he shoots Ishmael...using a Luger! Also the villains' automatic rifles resemble SteamPunk AK47s while those carried by Nemo's men look like Sten guns.

to:

* GoodGunsBadGuns: You know [[spoiler:Grey]] is a rotter when he shoots Ishmael...using a Luger! Also the villains' automatic rifles resemble SteamPunk AK47s [=AK47s=] while those carried by Nemo's men look like Sten guns.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Moriarty:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? It is over -- for you. [[spoiler:Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard, audible only to dogs, lower animals, is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]

to:

-->'''Moriarty:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? It [[spoiler:It is over -- for you. [[spoiler:Because Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard, audible only to dogs, lower animals, is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Unless the picture was kept veiled.


Added DiffLines:

* GoodGunsBadGuns: You know [[spoiler:Grey]] is a rotter when he shoots Ishmael...using a Luger! Also the villains' automatic rifles resemble SteamPunk AK47s while those carried by Nemo's men look like Sten guns.


Added DiffLines:

* JustBetweenYouAndMe: Lampshaded.
-->'''Moriarty:''' "Now some of you will pause to ask; why I'm letting you know all this? What fool reveals his strategem before the game is over? It is over -- for you. [[spoiler:Because my voice isn't the only sound being made. While I've rambled on, a secondary layer of inaudible sound higher than humans can heard, audible only to dogs, lower animals, is being heard by crystal sensors dotted around your vessel."]]
-->[[spoiler:'''Grey:''' "Sensors attached to bombs. Bomb voyage!"]]


Added DiffLines:

* {{Retraux}}: The BigBad's recorded message (though only heard by the League) is seen by the audience as a scratchy B&W film.


Added DiffLines:

** Well a [[EvilIsSexy dark attraction]] to vampires is hardly unusual...

Top