Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Luther

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2003 period drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.

to:

A 2003 period drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.
UsefulNotes/TheProtestantReformation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: The scene with Luther defending a church may be a reference to a similar scene from the 1953 film ''Martin Luther.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2003 drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.

to:

A 2003 period drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\nNeedsWikiMagicLove


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther bases his arguments on references to the Bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, emphasizing his role as a scholar.)

to:

* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther bases his arguments on references to the Bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote quotes a lot of other sources, emphasizing his role as a scholar.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luther_(2003_film)#Film_inaccuracies Quite a bit]]. For example, the Golden Rose is given to Frederick of Saxony to entice to hand Luther over to Rome, whereas in reality the motives behind his receiving the Rose were not related to Luther.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luther_(2003_film)#Film_inaccuracies Quite a bit]]. For example, the Golden Rose is given to Frederick of Saxony to entice him to hand Luther over to Rome, whereas in reality the motives behind his receiving the Rose were not related to Luther.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CorruptChurch: The film's portrayal of the Catholic Church at this time, with its use of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence indulgences]].

to:

* CorruptChurch: The film's portrayal of the Catholic Church at this time, with mainly through its use of [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence indulgences]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luther_(2003_film)#Film_inaccuracies Quite a bit]].

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luther_(2003_film)#Film_inaccuracies Quite a bit]]. For example, the Golden Rose is given to Frederick of Saxony to entice to hand Luther over to Rome, whereas in reality the motives behind his receiving the Rose were not related to Luther.



* FireAndBrimstoneHell: Johann Tetzel is shown preaching [[LargeHam dramatically]] about this subject.

to:

* FireAndBrimstoneHell: Johann Tetzel is shown preaching [[LargeHam dramatically]] about this subject.subject, frightening crowds of ordinary people into buying indulgences.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FireAndBrimstoneHell: Johann Tetzel is shown preaching [[LargeHam dramatically]] about this subject.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* LargeHam: Alfred Molina as Johan Tetzel.

to:

* LargeHam: Alfred Molina as Johan Johann Tetzel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* LargeHam: Alfred Molina as Johan Tetzel.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawLoser: Most characters who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic Church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

Added: 109

Changed: 139

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther bases his arguments on references to the Bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him a cool scholar.)
* ActionizedSequel: Well, actionized remake. As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.

to:

* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther bases his arguments on references to the Bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him emphasizing his role as a cool scholar.)
* ActionizedSequel: Well, actionized remake. As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, other scenes where Martin is physically in danger, and peasants threatening [[ArsonMurderAndJaywalking boar-hunting]].
* ArtisticLicenseHistory: [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luther_(2003_film)#Film_inaccuracies Quite
a church.bit]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[Actionized Remake ActionizedSequel]]: As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.

to:

* [[Actionized Remake ActionizedSequel]]: ActionizedSequel: Well, actionized remake. As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[ActionizedRemake ActionizedSequel]]: As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.

to:

* [[ActionizedRemake [[Actionized Remake ActionizedSequel]]: As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2003 Drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.



to:

A 2003 Drama drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.





* [[Actionized Remake Acionized Sequel]]: As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.

to:

* [[Actionized Remake Acionized Sequel]]: [[ActionizedRemake ActionizedSequel]]: As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.

Added: 323

Changed: 1114

Removed: 98

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.



to:

A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Drama starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.





* BadassPreacher:In the movie, this is Luther heroically standing with a flaming torch in his hand. Literally defending the church from a horde of evil peasants, holding them back with his words. In history, he only published writings against peasant violence.
* CorruptChurch: The Catholic church, portrayed as being all about power and money. All characters who discuss the church seem to agree on this conclusion, including those who support it anyway.
* CreepyCatholicism: ...Versus the pure and noble faith of Luther and his followers.

to:

* BadassPreacher:In [[Actionized Remake Acionized Sequel]]: As discussed [[http://www.patheos.com/blogs/filmchat/2004/11/luther-luther-luther.html here]] the film is more fast-paced and visually dynamic than previous films about Martin Luther, with scenes like an opening where Luther dodges lightning, boar-hunting, and peasants threatening a church.
* BadassPreacher: In
the movie, this there is a scene where Luther heroically standing stands with a flaming torch in his hand. Literally hand, literally defending the church from a horde of evil peasants, holding them back with his words. In history, he only published writings against peasant violence.
* CorruptChurch: The film's portrayal of the Catholic church, portrayed as being all about power and money. All characters who discuss the church seem to agree on Church at this conclusion, including those who support it anyway.
* CreepyCatholicism: ...Versus the pure and noble faith
time, with its use of Luther and his followers.[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indulgence indulgences]].



* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The movie avoids depicting Martin's real-life fondness for crude and scatological comments, the anti-Semitic writings he produced in the later part of his life, and his infamous claim that the authorities should "smite, stab, and strangle, as you would a mad dog" the peasants in the peasants' war.



* ScamReligion: The Catholic Church, portrayed as being little more than a money-grabbing scheme.




to:

* TokenRomance: Martin's courtship of, and marriage to, Katherina von Bora comes very late in the film and has little effect on the main plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther base his arguments on references to the bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him a cool scholar.)

to:

* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther base bases his arguments on references to the bible.Bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him a cool scholar.)



* CorruptChurch: The Catholic church, portrayed as being all about power and money. All characters who discuss the church seem to agree on this conclusion, including those who supports it anyway.
* CreepyCatholicism: ...versus the pure and noble faith of Luther and his followers.
* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: Joseph Fiennes as Martin Luther is much better-looking than the overweight, hideous Martin Luther from real life.

to:

* CorruptChurch: The Catholic church, portrayed as being all about power and money. All characters who discuss the church seem to agree on this conclusion, including those who supports support it anyway.
* CreepyCatholicism: ...versus Versus the pure and noble faith of Luther and his followers.
* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: Joseph Fiennes as Martin Luther is much better-looking than the overweight, hideous overweight and unattractive Martin Luther from real life.



* StrawLoser: Most characters who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

to:

* StrawLoser: Most characters who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church Church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ProtagonistTitle: The title is Martin Luther's surname.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalBeautyUpgrade: Joseph Fiennes as Martin Luther is much better-looking than the overweight, hideous Martin Luther from real life.

Added: 4

Changed: 26

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of the titular character Martin Luther, father of Protestant Christianity.



to:

A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of the titular character Martin Luther, the father of Protestant Christianity.





* StrawLoser: Most characters who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

to:

* StrawLoser: Most characters who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.default.

----

Changed: 889

Removed: 500

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Portraying history from an unambiguously protestant perspective, the film gives us a version of history where all Protestants are heroic while all Catholics are either nefarious villains or at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

to:

Portraying history from an unambiguously protestant perspective, the film gives us a version of history where all Protestants are heroic while all Catholics are either nefarious villains or at the edge of converting to Protestantism.




* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther base his arguments on references to the bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him a cool scholar.) None of his opponents ever make any argument for why Catholicism isn't cool with taking the bible so literally or for why they consider their traditions important. Thus making themselves come across as if the difference between them and Luther would be simply that they have failed to read the Buble. They even get their final word in the movie to gush about how Luther is so much smarter than them and how he should have been their Pope.

* BadassPreacher: That part of actual history where Luther was in favor of the nobles slaughtering uppity peasants? In the movie, this is Luther heroically standing with a flaming torch in his hand. Literally defending the church from a horde of evil peasants, holding them back with his words. (And then in the next scene angsting over the nobles taking their revenge too far.)

* BlackAndWhiteMorality: In this story, Protestants are good and Catholics are bad. Sure, some catholics are bad at being bad... but that's simply because they are at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

* BookBurning: Evil, petty and futile when Catholics do it against Luther. Cool when Luther does it against Catholic decrees.

to:

* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther base his arguments on references to the bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him a cool scholar.) None of his opponents ever make any argument for why Catholicism isn't cool with taking the bible so literally or for why they consider their traditions important. Thus making themselves come across as if the difference between them and Luther would be simply that they have failed to read the Buble. They even get their final word in the movie to gush about how Luther is so much smarter than them and how he should have been their Pope.

)

* BadassPreacher: That part of actual history where Luther was in favor of the nobles slaughtering uppity peasants? In BadassPreacher:In the movie, this is Luther heroically standing with a flaming torch in his hand. Literally defending the church from a horde of evil peasants, holding them back with his words. (And then in the next scene angsting over the nobles taking their revenge too far.)

* BlackAndWhiteMorality:
In this story, Protestants are good and Catholics are bad. Sure, some catholics are bad at being bad... but that's simply because they are at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

* BookBurning: Evil, petty and futile when Catholics do it
history, he only published writings against Luther. Cool when Luther does it against Catholic decrees.
peasant violence.



* TheFundamentalist: Just another way for Luther to be Awesome and totally justified in everything he's doing, given that this is a setting with BlackAndWhiteMorality.



* StrawLoser: Every character who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

to:

* StrawLoser: Every character Most characters who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.
default.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Joseph Fiennes in the role of the titular character Martin Luther, father of Protestant Christianity.

to:

A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Joseph Fiennes Creator/JosephFiennes in the role of the titular character Martin Luther, father of Protestant Christianity.

Added: 812

Changed: 158

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AsTheGoodBookSays: Luther base his arguments on references to the bible. (In counter-arguments to things other people say, he also quote a lot of other sources, making him a cool scholar.) None of his opponents ever make any argument for why Catholicism isn't cool with taking the bible so literally or for why they consider their traditions important. Thus making themselves come across as if the difference between them and Luther would be simply that they have failed to read the Buble. They even get their final word in the movie to gush about how Luther is so much smarter than them and how he should have been their Pope.



* CorruptChurch: The Catholic church.

to:

* CorruptChurch: The Catholic church.
church, portrayed as being all about power and money. All characters who discuss the church seem to agree on this conclusion, including those who supports it anyway.

* CreepyCatholicism: ...versus the pure and noble faith of Luther and his followers.


Added DiffLines:

* ScamReligion: The Catholic Church, portrayed as being little more than a money-grabbing scheme.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ugh, what was the command for \"hidden text\" again? I don\'t remember. :-/


§§Note: Feel free to index this page if you feel like it, but please note that the reason why I haven't indexed it myself yet is that I want to get around to add more tropes first. If you index it and have also seen the movie, please consider adding a few more tropes while yo are at it.

Added: 1031

Changed: 301

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadassPreacher: That part of actual history where Luther was in favor of the nobles slaughtering uppity peasants? In the movie, this is Luther heroically standing with a flaming torch in his hand. Literally defending the church from a horde of evil peasants, holding them back with his words. (And then in the next scene angsting over the nobles taking their revenge too far.)



* BookBurning: Evil, petty and futile when Catholics do it against Luther. Cool when Luther does it against Catholic decrees.



* StrawLoser: Every character who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

to:

* TheFundamentalist: Just another way for Luther to be Awesome and totally justified in everything he's doing, given that this is a setting with BlackAndWhiteMorality.

* StrawLoser: Every character who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.default.

§§Note: Feel free to index this page if you feel like it, but please note that the reason why I haven't indexed it myself yet is that I want to get around to add more tropes first. If you index it and have also seen the movie, please consider adding a few more tropes while yo are at it.

Added: 237

Changed: 786

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This film contains examples of...

BlackAndWhiteMorality: In this story, Protestants are good and Catholics are bad. Sure, some catholics are bad at being bad... but that's simply because they are at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

CorruptChurch: The Catholic church.

StrawLoser: Every character who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

to:

This film contains ----
!!The movie has
examples of...

of:

*
BlackAndWhiteMorality: In this story, Protestants are good and Catholics are bad. Sure, some catholics are bad at being bad... but that's simply because they are at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

* CorruptChurch: The Catholic church.

* StrawLoser: Every character who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

A 2003 Drama, VeryLooselyBasedOnATrueStory. Starring Joseph Fiennes in the role of the titular character Martin Luther, father of Protestant Christianity.

Portraying history from an unambiguously protestant perspective, the film gives us a version of history where all Protestants are heroic while all Catholics are either nefarious villains or at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

This film contains examples of...

BlackAndWhiteMorality: In this story, Protestants are good and Catholics are bad. Sure, some catholics are bad at being bad... but that's simply because they are at the edge of converting to Protestantism.

CorruptChurch: The Catholic church.

StrawLoser: Every character who ever try to argue against Luther and his teachings. Even the highest of Catholic church officials will fail to deliver any actual argument for Catholicism, letting Luther win every discussion by default.

Top