Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Flight2012

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AluminumChristmasTrees: Most viewers are understandably convinced that flying a passenger plane upside down to level out a nosedive is Hollywood impossibility. There's still a bit of ArtisticLicensePhysics at play, but it ''could'' work for the short amount of time it's in the film. Such a feat has never occurred in real life before, but the film does include some RealityEnsues consequences, like the oil pressure dropping due to the plane being inverted.

to:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: Most viewers are understandably convinced that flying a passenger plane upside down to level out a nosedive is Hollywood impossibility. There's still a bit of ArtisticLicensePhysics at play, but it ''could'' work for the short amount of time it's in the film. Such a feat has never occurred in real life before, but the film does include some RealityEnsues realistic consequences, like the oil pressure dropping due to the plane being inverted.

Added: 405

Changed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustPlaneWrong: [[https://askthepilot.com/denzel-washington-flight-movie/ Several]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKzbrfTj76s professional]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETxDqojmAIo airline]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y5qjj9618zE pilots]] have pointed out the many unrealistic aspects of this movie, both in terms of the pilots' conduct, and the technical aspects of the flight & crash.



** While extremely dramatic, two errors that didn't appear all that necessary crop up. First, Whitaker narrates dramatically to Air Traffic Control when the aircraft was uncontrollable; real-life pilots know that communicating their issue to ATC just wastes valuable headspace, speech, and time that simply can't be spared when dealing with an extremely dangerous control malfunction; a pilot calls Mayday only when the situation has somewhat stabilized. Second, each engine gives a fire warning, and the First Officer correctly activates the fire handles on each engine (which cuts off all fuel to the engine, then sprays the engine down with fire retardant, i.e., shutting down the engine permanently so that it does not destroy the airframe) and yet, after deliberately shutting down each engine, the First Officer seems surprised when each engine spins down and loses power.

to:

** While extremely dramatic, two errors that didn't appear all that necessary crop up. First, Whitaker narrates dramatically to Air Traffic Control when the aircraft was uncontrollable; real-life pilots know that communicating their issue to ATC just wastes valuable headspace, speech, and time that simply can't be spared when dealing with an extremely dangerous control malfunction; a pilot calls Mayday only when the situation has somewhat stabilized. Second, each engine gives a fire warning, and the First Officer correctly activates the fire handles on each engine (which cuts off all fuel to the engine, then sprays the engine down with fire retardant, i.e., shutting down the engine permanently so that it does not destroy the airframe) and yet, after deliberately shutting down each engine, the First Officer seems surprised when each engine spins down and loses power.power; the error is compounded when Whitaker calls for (and gets) full power ''after'' the engines have been permanently shut down.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBadGuyWins: While only hinted in the movie, the conclusion of the whole story is [[spoiler: the company responsible for the faulty plane getting away scot-free, because [[TheScapegoat they can shift all the blame on a drunk pilot]], rather than anything wrong with the plane]]. That despite the fact the plane had a structural failure that lead to the crash.

to:

* TheBadGuyWins: While only hinted in the movie, the conclusion of the whole story is [[spoiler: the company responsible for the faulty plane getting away scot-free, because [[TheScapegoat they can shift all the blame on a drunk pilot]], rather than anything wrong with the plane]]. That despite the fact the plane had a structural failure that lead to the crash.crash and the pilot being the only reason why almost everyone survived.

Added: 952

Changed: 412

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheBadGuyWins: While only hinted in the movie, the conclusion of the whole story is [[spoiler: the company responsible for the faulty plane getting away scot-free, because [[TheScapegoat they can shift all the blame on a drunk pilot]], rather than anything wrong with the plane]]. That despite the fact the plane had a structural failure that lead to the crash.



* TheScapegoat: Katerina becomes one for Whitaker's defenders, as a way of pinning the blame for the two used vodka bottles in the airplane's trash. Whitaker initially balks at scapegoating a dead woman, especially one he was both romantically involved with and who died while rescuing a child, but eventually agrees to go along with the plan. When asked under oath, he denies drinking the vodka bottles. [[spoiler: At first]].

to:

* TheScapegoat: TheScapegoat:
**
Katerina becomes one for Whitaker's defenders, as a way of pinning the blame for the two used vodka bottles in the airplane's trash. Whitaker initially balks at scapegoating a dead woman, especially one he was both romantically involved with and who died while rescuing a child, but eventually agrees to go along with the plan. When asked under oath, he denies drinking the vodka bottles. [[spoiler: At first]].first]].
** The logic of the investigation is to find a scapegoat to blame for the plane crash, rather than the company building the plane facing any sort of legal or PR repercussions.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2012 live-action film directed and co-produced by Creator/RobertZemeckis. ''Flight'' features an ensemble cast including Creator/DenzelWashington, Creator/DonCheadle, Melissa Leo, Creator/BruceGreenwood, Creator/KellyReilly, and Creator/JohnGoodman.

to:

A 2012 live-action film directed and co-produced by Creator/RobertZemeckis. ''Flight'' features an ensemble cast including Creator/DenzelWashington, Creator/DonCheadle, Melissa Leo, Creator/MelissaLeo, Creator/BruceGreenwood, Creator/KellyReilly, and Creator/JohnGoodman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BrokenAce: Whip's actions during the plane crash and the subsequent inability of other pilots to save passengers in recreated simulations of the event make him stand out as a brilliant and talented pilot without equal. He's also a cocaine-snorting alcoholic who has no problem flying while both drunk and high and his relationship with his ex-wife and son is a mess.


Added DiffLines:

* NervesOfSteel: Whip's ability to remain cool and in control even as the plane begins to go into a nosedive is something to behold. It becomes even more impressive when at the NTSB hearing we learn that ten pilots weren't able to save the plane in the way that Whip despite being in far less stressful simulations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DangerDeadpan: Whitaker barely changes the tone of his voice while trying to save the plane while everyone else is panicking for their lives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OhCrap: When Hugh reveals to Whip that the investigators drew a blood sample from him while he was unconscious in the hospital he immediately realizes how much trouble he's in since he was intoxicated on the flight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything: Harling is introduced with [[{{Satan}} "Sympathy for the Devil"]] and is a bad influence upon Whitaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImprobablePilotingSkills / AcePilot: To drive the point, the airline had ''eleven'' other pilots attempt to save the plane as Whitaker did in simulations. ''All failed.''

to:

* ImprobablePilotingSkills / AcePilot: ImprobablePilotingSkills[=/=]AcePilot: To drive the point, the airline had ''eleven'' other pilots attempt to save the plane as Whitaker did in simulations. ''All failed.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Whip confesses he was intoxicated during the flight and is sent to jail, but in doing so he is freed of his addictions and guilt, permitting him to reconcile with his friends and family]].

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Whip confesses he was intoxicated during the flight and flight, is sent to jail, but in doing so and may never fly a plane again. But by telling the truth, he is freed of his addictions and guilt, permitting him to reconcile with his friends and family]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AliminumChristmasTrees: Most viewers are understandably convinced that flying a passenger plane upside down to level out a nosedive is Hollywood impossibility. There's still a bit of ArtisticLicensePhysics at play, but it ''could'' work for the short amount of time it's in the film. Such a feat has never occurred in real life before, but the film does include some RealityEnsues consequences, like the oil pressure dropping due to the plane being inverted.

to:

* AliminumChristmasTrees: AluminumChristmasTrees: Most viewers are understandably convinced that flying a passenger plane upside down to level out a nosedive is Hollywood impossibility. There's still a bit of ArtisticLicensePhysics at play, but it ''could'' work for the short amount of time it's in the film. Such a feat has never occurred in real life before, but the film does include some RealityEnsues consequences, like the oil pressure dropping due to the plane being inverted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AliminumChristmasTrees: Most viewers are understandably convinced that flying a passenger plane upside down to level out a nosedive is Hollywood impossibility. There's still a bit of ArtisticLicensePhysics at play, but it ''could'' work for the short amount of time it's in the film. Such a feat has never occurred in real life before, but the film does include some RealityEnsues consequences, like the oil pressure dropping due to the plane being inverted.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BellyScrapingFlight: Moments before its crash landing, the airliner's right wing cuts the top off a church steeple.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2012 live-action film directed and co-produced by Creator/RobertZemeckis. ''Flight'' features an ensemble cast including Creator/DenzelWashington, Creator/DonCheadle, Melissa Leo, Creator/BruceGreenwood, Kelly Reilly, and Creator/JohnGoodman.

to:

A 2012 live-action film directed and co-produced by Creator/RobertZemeckis. ''Flight'' features an ensemble cast including Creator/DenzelWashington, Creator/DonCheadle, Melissa Leo, Creator/BruceGreenwood, Kelly Reilly, Creator/KellyReilly, and Creator/JohnGoodman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The story revolves around Captain William "Whip" Whitaker (DenzelWashington), a pilot who pulls off a miraculous crash landing after his commercial airliner plunges out of the sky due to a catastrophic mechanical failure. Hailed as a hero in the press, trouble arises behind the scenes due to Whitaker being both drunk and high on cocaine during the flight, facts which could result in serious prison time and even manslaughter charges. Further complicating matters for both him and his legal defenders is Whitaker's losing battle with alcoholism.

to:

The story revolves around Captain William "Whip" Whitaker (DenzelWashington), (Denzel Washington), a pilot who pulls off a miraculous crash landing after his commercial airliner plunges out of the sky due to a catastrophic mechanical failure. Hailed as a hero in the press, trouble arises behind the scenes due to Whitaker being both drunk and high on cocaine during the flight, facts which could result in serious prison time and even manslaughter charges. Further complicating matters for both him and his legal defenders is Whitaker's losing battle with alcoholism.

Added: 88

Changed: 8

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Zero context entries


%%
%%
%%Please add context to zero context entries before removing their comment tags.
%%
%%



* DrugsAreBad

to:

* %%* DrugsAreBad



* HeroesWantRedHeads

to:

* %%* HeroesWantRedHeads



* OscarBait

to:

* %%* OscarBait



* TropaholicsAnonymous

to:

* %%* TropaholicsAnonymous
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Batman Gambit

Added DiffLines:

* BatmanGambit: [[spoiler: It's implied that the lead NTSB investigator pulls one during the hearing to get Whitaker to admit that he was drunk during the flight. Notable in that it was clearly not out of malice but simply that the whole truth would come out.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShellShockedSilence: When the plane crashes, Whip hits his head on his control yoke, knocking him out cold. From that moment until he's loaded into the ambulance, the sound of ringing ears can be heard and all other sounds are muffled or distorted to varying degrees.

to:

* ShellShockedSilence: ShellShockSilence: When the plane crashes, Whip hits his head on his control yoke, knocking him out cold. From that moment until he's loaded into the ambulance, the sound of ringing ears can be heard and all other sounds are muffled or distorted to varying degrees.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShellShockedSilence: When the plane crashes, Whip hits his head on his control yoke, knocking him out cold. From that moment until he's loaded into the ambulance, the sound of ringing ears can be heard and all other sounds are muffled or distorted to varying degrees.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* StukaScream: Can be heard briefly when [=SouthJet=] 227 resumes diving after the First Officer deploys flaps to try to curtail the initial dive. This is noticeably out of place considering there's no possible way for an MD-80 airliner to make this sound.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EvenEvilHasStandards: Hugh Lang may be ruthless about winning Whip's case, down to discrediting legitimate evidence and falsely blaming dead coworkers, but when [[spoiler:hiring Harling to give Whip a wake-up cocaine snort from a hangover, he noticeably avoids handing Harling money directly, instead making Anderson give Harling the cash.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WorstAid: Whip twice uses cocaine as a hangover cure after heavy nights of drinking. The health hazards of putting so many substances into your body notwithstanding, [[http://www.hangoverheaven.com/blog/2015/7/16/cocaine-and-hangovers cocaine's effects on relieving a hangover are pretty short term]]. Realistically, Whip would fall back into a daze after 15 to 30 minutes, but aside from one mention of a later offscreen snort at the climax, he's sharp-minded and steady again for the rest of the day each time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GoingColdTurkey: Subverted.
* GoryDiscretionShot: After the crash, [[spoiler: Katerina's]] body is only visible below the neck, with the splash of blood hinting at what happened to the head.

to:

* GoingColdTurkey: Subverted.
After being released from the hospital, Whip goes through the house he's staying at and throws out or flushes down all the alcohol he can find. However, his sobriety only lasts for a day or so and then he's back to drinking again.
* GoryDiscretionShot: After Right after the crash, [[spoiler: Katerina's]] body is only visible below the neck, with the splash of blood hinting at what happened to the head.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HookersAndBlow: Whip's general behavior before the accident. Note, Katerina isn't a prostitute, but the promiscuity is still there.

to:

* HookersAndBlow: Whip's general behavior before the accident. Note, Note that Katerina isn't a prostitute, but the promiscuity is still there.



* ProductPlacement: Subverted, while Whitaker drinks many brands of alcoholic beverage, each only appears for single scenes and none were paid placements (for obvious reasons). [[http://www.heraldnet.com/article/20121105/BIZ/711059883 At least one complained.]]

to:

* ProductPlacement: Subverted, while {{Subverted}}. While Whitaker drinks many brands of alcoholic beverage, beverages, each only appears for single scenes and none were paid placements (for obvious reasons). [[http://www.heraldnet.com/article/20121105/BIZ/711059883 At least one complained.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DrunkenMaster: Deconstructed. Whip can pull off a maneuver to save his plane that no other pilot can do ''while drunk and high'', but his personal life suffers severely and [[spoiler:once the authorities find out about his addiction, his flight career is over]].

to:

* DrunkenMaster: Deconstructed. Whip can pull off a maneuver to save his plane that no other pilot can do ''while drunk and high'', high'' (maybe even ''because'' he was drunk and high, allowing him to stay unnaturally calm and in control), but his personal life suffers severely and [[spoiler:once the authorities find out about his addiction, his flight career is over]].

Added: 1524

Changed: 1288

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ChekhovsGun: After the plane passes through the storm, Whitaker addresses the passengers while surreptitiously filling up a small jug of orange juice with three small bottles of vodka. During this, the camera [[NoticeThis lingers on him throwing the flasks into a trashbin]]. After the crash, the discovery of the vodka bottles is what eventually leads to the inquiry and misplaced blame on Katerina until Whitaker admits to his alcoholism.



* FunctionalAddict: Whitaker and [[spoiler: Katerina]]

to:

* FunctionalAddict: Whitaker and [[spoiler: Katerina]]Katerina]].



* HeroicSacrifice: [[spoiler:When the plane inverts, Katerina unbuckles her restraints to help lift a child who fell down to the ceiling-turned-floor back into his seat. Unfortunately, she's unable to secure herself again before the crash [[{{Squick}} and is pile-drivered into the cabin floor on impact]]]].

to:

* HeroicSacrifice: [[spoiler:When [[spoiler: When the plane inverts, Katerina unbuckles her restraints to help lift a child who fell down to the ceiling-turned-floor back into his seat. Unfortunately, she's unable to secure herself again before the crash [[{{Squick}} and is pile-drivered into the cabin floor on impact]]]].



* ImpairmentShot: Whip when taken out of the plane and again when waking up in the hospital.

to:

* ImpairmentShot: Whip Whip, when he's taken out of the plane and again when waking up in the hospital.



* NailedToTheWagon: The night before the NTSB public hearing, his layer and union rep check Whitaker into a hotel room with a guard outside the door, and whose mini-bar has been stripped of alcohol. [[spoiler: Too bad that the interior door to the next room over was accidentally left unlocked]].

to:

* NailedToTheWagon: The night before the NTSB public hearing, his layer lawyer and union rep check Whitaker into a hotel room with a guard outside the door, and whose mini-bar has been stripped of alcohol. [[spoiler: Too bad that the interior door to the next room over was accidentally left unlocked]].



* NeverMyFault: Whip insists through the majority of the movie, that it's all the defected plane's fault for the crash and the death of some of the passengers and crew.

to:

* NeverMyFault: Whip insists this through the majority of the movie, that it's all the defected plane's fault for the crash and the death of some of the passengers and crew.



* OnlySaneMan: It's almost comical watching Whip remain utterly calm and collected whilst everyone else freaks out when the plane goes into a nosedive toward a seemingly certain crash landing.
** TruthInTelevision as many pilots have failed to save the plane/passengers because they panicked. As a result, they couldn't think clearly enough to perform the tasks needed to save the plane. However, pilots that have remained calm and collected throughout the situation were able to act rationally, and save most (if not all) of the passengers. The plane however is usually written off for... obvious reasons.

to:

* OnlySaneMan: OnlySaneMan:
**
It's almost comical watching Whip remain utterly calm and collected whilst everyone else freaks out when the plane goes into a nosedive toward a seemingly certain crash landing.
** TruthInTelevision It's also TruthInTelevision, as many pilots have failed to save the plane/passengers because they panicked. As a result, they couldn't think clearly enough to perform the tasks needed to save the plane. However, pilots that have remained calm and collected throughout the situation were able to act rationally, and save most (if not all) of the passengers. The plane however is usually written off for... obvious reasons.



* ShownTheirWork: The physics of Whitaker's fatal flight are fairly well done, though some ArtisticLicensePhysics was taken to amp up the drama. With his elevators jammed nose-down, vertical flight controls broken, he did pretty much the ONLY thing that would have had a [[StealthPun prayer]] of keeping that plane in the air a short time - ''inverting the plane'', turning nose-down into nose-up. The stuff that should fail in an inverted jumbo jet - like the gravity-assisted oil pumps - indeed fail, causing the engines to overheat and catch fire. Why did the plane not explode on impact? He dumped almost all the fuel and ran the remaining fuel out the burning engines.

to:

* ShownTheirWork: ShownTheirWork:
**
The physics of Whitaker's fatal flight are fairly well done, though some ArtisticLicensePhysics was taken to amp up the drama. With his elevators jammed nose-down, vertical flight controls broken, he did pretty much the ONLY thing that would have had a [[StealthPun prayer]] of keeping that plane in the air a short time - ''inverting the plane'', turning nose-down into nose-up. The stuff that should fail in an inverted jumbo jet - like the gravity-assisted oil pumps - indeed fail, causing the engines to overheat and catch fire. Why did the plane not explode on impact? He dumped almost all the fuel and ran the remaining fuel out the burning engines.



* VomitIndiscretionShot: A flight attendant quite understandably vomits during the crash sequence.

to:

* VomitIndiscretionShot: A flight attendant passenger quite understandably vomits during the crash sequence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2012 live-action film directed and co-produced by Creator/RobertZemeckis. ''Flight'' features an ensemble cast including DenzelWashington, Don Cheadle, Melissa Leo, Bruce Greenwood, Kelly Reilly, and John Goodman.

to:

A 2012 live-action film directed and co-produced by Creator/RobertZemeckis. ''Flight'' features an ensemble cast including DenzelWashington, Don Cheadle, Creator/DenzelWashington, Creator/DonCheadle, Melissa Leo, Bruce Greenwood, Creator/BruceGreenwood, Kelly Reilly, and John Goodman.
Creator/JohnGoodman.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BeliefMakesYouStupid: Averted. Although the more intense Christian believers (like Evans and his wife) may come across as eccentric at first, they all show genuine courage in the face of life-changing disaster.

to:

* BeliefMakesYouStupid: Averted. Although the more intense Christian believers (like Evans and his wife) may come across as eccentric at first, they all show genuine courage in the face of life-changing disaster. The fact that Denzel Washington is a Christian in real life probably had something to do with this.

Top